4 ms·
From what I have seen so far Threads seems to have been an incredibly rushed and premature launch, done directly to counter Twitter's missteps from the last few
by paxys 3y ago
From what I have seen so far Threads seems to have been an incredibly rushed and premature launch, done directly to counter Twitter's missteps from the last few weeks. And the decision is proving to be the absolute correct one.
What I don't understand is why Bluesky didn't seize the opportunity first. People were literally banging on their doors begging to be let in and they continued to go "sorry we are exclusive, invites only". Now no one gives a shit.
- fullshark 3y agoWe'll never know if Elon would have shot himself more in the foot though without a clear competitive threat. Maybe some more time would have paid off? Though I agree that rate limiting + need to be signed in catastrophe over July 4 weekend seemed to be the sweet spot.
- dmonitor 3y agoIt’s actually crazy how slow bluesky’s rollout has been. I can see why they want some level of exclusivity (so that people want to join, and when they join can immediately hook up with their friend who invited them), but they really need to open the faucet a bit.
- gonzo41 3y agoSurprise! 30 million people wanted to join BlueSky because they wanted a twitter alternative that wasn't filled with hate fill toxic weirdo's. Now Meta's got em. 4D chess move there guys.
- bonestamp2 3y agoI'm not sure if this is the reason, but BlueSky doesn't appear to have a trust/safety moderation team that can operate at full scale. I mean, neither does twitter, but Jack understands that some people do want that. On the other hand, it's much easier for Meta to launch since they already have those people in place for Instagram and Facebook.
- threeseed 3y agoAlso given Jack's behaviour recently not sure how committed he is to trust/safety. He is definitely sympathetic to unfettered free speech and allowing misinformation to proliferate.
- paxys 3y agoNo one cares. Seriously. The order should be: 1. Generate hype 2. Launch the MVP 3. Focus on growth and scaling 4. Add new features 5. Figure out trust & safety and the rest of the long tail of problems Diverting resources to focus on problems before they become problems is the #1 recipe for failure for startups, and bluesky seems hell bent on it.
- alphager 3y agoModeration is a key feature of the MVP. If a horde of n-word spewing, cp posting spambots is the image that gets shared on newssites, it's dead in the water.
- tentacleuno 3y agoAgreed. Bluesky had a tone of hype back in its infancy, and now you never hear about it. They definitely missed their opportunity.
- dragonwriter 3y agoStill hear about it, but its either “No one is there” from people on it or “I can’t get an invite” from people not.
- hyperhopper 3y agoMind boggling how even with prior knowledge and multiple opportunities, they replicated the Google plus mistake to the minutiae.
- cmcaleer 3y agoI actually don’t hate the idea but it’s the rigid sticking to it that’s the dumb part. The rate limiting clusterfuck was such a perfect opportunity to go “OK everyone here’s a hundred invites valid for the next 48 hours go wild”. Still feels like a club since you have to get an invite and creates an impetus on users to get these invites sent out ASAP. I actually figured that this was the strategy, but now that they let that golden moment pass them by I now realise that nobody there has any idea what the fuck they’re doing. Guess Jack just wants it to be a haven for all the worst blue checkmark behaviour of Twitter, in which case I commend him for creating a containment website.
- paxys 3y agoBluesky actually closed registrations even with invites during the Twitter debacle. It's like they desperately want to fail.
- nwienert 3y agoBlueSky never had a chance, same goes for Threads. It's not some mistake in strategy, it just turns out you can't launch a copycat social network no matter how good your marketing/funding... network effects are tough. They aren't failing due to privacy, or invite strategy, or anything else. They are failing because there's no differentiation whatsoever. It's so simple, and it's been true since forever. The meme that Twitter is burning down is cope. The only people for whom it's burning down are extremely online liberals. And even they are not leaving Twitter. They are the only ones praying for these alternatives to succeed, or in recent HN threads asserting the downfall is assured and imminent. The actual ground truth of using Twitter if you aren't extremely online and praying on political rivals' downfall is that it basically hasn't changed much at all. You need to differentiate, be cool, and be fun in some new way to leap past immense network effects. And probably also guarantee revenue share through a sort of decentralized network.
- Solvency 3y agoWhy has everyone on here been comparing Threads to Twitter when threads.com literally says its a Slack alternative for makers? The product has absolutely nothing to do with a Twitter style social network. Edit: lol so FAANG just steals any and all actively used product names now. Got it.
- shmde 3y agoThreads.com != Threads( twitter clone ) by meta
- ianburrell 3y agoI think it is branded as Threads by Instagram. One Google Play Store, Threads the chat app has "not affiliated with Threads by Instagram" in their listing. I wonder if they are getting lots of downloads by confused people.
- cmcaleer 3y agoA company the size of Facebook can release a new product that they’re trying to eat Twitter’s lunch with and not even buy the dot-com? Crazy.
- amosliberal 3y agoMark zuckerberg has literally built a monopoly of social media, lmao. At this point, since they've acquired such a large amount of users (2 billion), they can release anything and people will use it.
- delive 3y agoThe social app uses .net - Threads.net
- ipsum2 3y agoInstagram Threads was a (different) thing back in 2019: https://www.theverge.com/2019/8/26/20833903/facebook-instagram-threads-messaging-app-close-friends-snapchat https://www.theverge.com/2019/8/26/20833903/facebook-instagr.... Threads.com looks like it came out in 2022?
- ipsum2 3y agoGoogle Plus (invite only) failed in a similar way.
- lakomen 3y agoGoogle+ was excellent until they started to copy Facebook and be Postcentric vs Commentcentric
- iamacyborg 3y agoDid it? I’ve not seen any updates on the lawsuits that claim that Facebook and Google colluded but I could have easily missed something.
- Pufferbo 3y agoI feel the same way. I read one thread where someone was praising the app’s “refined” design. My first thought was, “What are they talking about. The UX is refined because there’s literally nothing here”. It’s just one feature, the MVP, posts/replies. It would not surprise me if two weeks ago they were not planning on this release and t was only the recent drama that influenced them to release.
- xwdv 3y agoI finally got an invite code to Bluesky the other day. There is absolutely no content. Not as in “blank page nothing here” type of no content, I mean as in the “open the fridge, look around, and decide there’s nothing to eat” type of no content. Meanwhile, Threads is content rich and there’s already people I know posting cool stuff to see and interact with. The result, is that I don’t give a fuck about Bluesky, and I’m not going to bother spreading invite codes. If I get at least 20 upvotes on this comment though maybe I’ll consider it since it means the interest is there.
- tshaddox 3y agoA social network being invite-only is such an obvious non-starter that I genuinely can't imagine the conversation that went into that decision. Assuming the basic underlying tech works more often that not (and ideally some story for community moderation), there's literally nothing I want from a Twitter competitor other than having everyone on it. My interest in a Twitter competitor that is invite-only is and will always be exactly zero.
- jrussino 3y agoI don't know about this. I got onto Facebook circa 2007 when it expanded from Harvard to other universities and man did I love it for a few years. Facebook really ended up being a major extension of my college experience. That was when it was just students, and it really had that new freshman undergrad social feel to it where it was all about linking up with new people you just met and seeing what they're up to and flirting and sharing pics and planning events. I kind of feel like Google was onto something with the "circles" idea and it's not clear to me why something like that didn't catch on. I don't want to share everything with the whole world. My college friends, my professional contacts, my family - these are all social circles that I'd want to be connected to with a service like this, but in separate buckets that don't overlap (or only somewhat overlap). So from a user's point of view, exclusive/invite-only can be really appealing. But if you're thinking from a "make as much money for the company as possible" point of view then yeah anything that limits the number of potential customers you can attract is going to hurt.
- DonsDiscountGas 3y agoFacebook was never exactly "invite only" but when they started it was limited to certain universities, and they expanded gradually. If a social network is only going to have a few user it can still provide value if they all have something in common; better 1,000 users all in the same city/university than 10,000 users scattered across the globe. Threads doesn't have this problem since they can just do a full-court-press immediately and get 30M users in a few days. I dunno how bluesky works but if they are reasonably generous with the invites you can get your friends on it (who are interested) pretty quickly.
- Groxx 3y ago
- mustacheemperor 3y agoI've seen the belief that Google Plus failed because of the long invite-only limited access period repeated here many times - if that theory is correct, Bluesky seems to be making the exact same mistake with their launch.
- mh- 3y agoIt's certainly why it failed within the circles I was in. People with access in the early days didn't have enough invites to migrate existing communities - even very small ones.
- londons_explore 3y agoA better solution is to require two invites to sign up. And then the service provider hands out double the number of invites. But now every new user has at least 2 existing contacts on the service - so their first experience is more than just saying "hi" to the only person they know there.
- bob-09 3y agoI think that would be impactful, but would still create barriers to entry. I'm not one to beg for invites, so I have a hard enough time casually finding one invite, let alone two. I'd imagine a good portion of invites would get stuck in purgatory waiting for a second, all while the potential user moves on to the next thing that grabs their curiosity. What about one invite to create an account, a second to participate?
- LightBug1 3y agoYou hear that sound? It's the sound of Zuckerberg whipping the carpet out from under Twitter and all the new upstart platforms. And I'm no Zuckerberg fan. The contrary. The ony plus point is seeing Elon get made. I heard he's now threatening to sue Twitter. Hey Elon, you cannot sue your way to an excellent social media platform, no matter how good your lawyers are ...
- ot1138 3y agoHuh? Are you serious? The odds are so wildly against Threads that I honestly can't tell if you're being sarcastic or not.
- rvbissell 3y agoSue himself?
- akomtu 3y agoHe can afford to sue himself, and even hire two very expensive law firms to represent both sides. He can even drag this case for decades, appealing court decisions and requesting expensive discovery, maybe even take it to supreme court.
- rvbissell 3y agoWell, that would keep him in the news...
- km3r 3y agoRushing it out the door when there is a massive Twitter (and to a lesser extent Reddit) population that is ready to jump ship now seems like the right move to me. You can always add features after, you can't ask for better timing than this.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Zetice 3y agoThreads will probably integrate with the AT Proto at some point anyway...
- Dirak 3y ago1) This is the largest launch of a social media platform this decade. Higher growth than ChatGPT, and already over 50MM signups https://www.quiverquant.com/threadstracker/ https://www.quiverquant.com/threadstracker/ 2) Zero downtime on a day 1 launch at the scale is a very impressive technical feat. If it had been rushed or released prematurely, this level of app stability would not have been the case. If I had to guess, this would be the reason why Bluesky hasn't been able to release to the general public In terms of the app being a foundation that will be built on and cannibalize Twitter, I'm very bullish on the future for Threads!
- carlossouza 3y agoMakes you wonder about Jack’s luck/skill ratio in Twitter launch. After seeing Bluesky so far, it may be higher than what most thought…
- mrkramer 3y agoKevin Systrom (Instagram founder) worked at Twitter in the early days and he said that Jack was super smart and hard working which I doubt with all respect to the Twitter. He grandiosely failed at managing Vine which was supposed to be TikTok before TikTok. Vine could've been bigger money making machine that Twitter is or was. Also If I was Twitter CEO, I would've acquired popular blog platform Medium which was founded by Twitter co-founder and then I would build massive ad-network (Twitter, Vine and Medium) which could stand up against Facebook's and Google's ad business at least in the eyes of advertisers if not investors. Also Zuckerberg wanted to acquire Twitter in the 2008 for $500m because in his paranoid head, he was scared that perhaps Twitter could overtake Facebook. Let me be clear, Zuckerberg is cutthroat competitor that doesn't care about anything except success. And looking at the Zuckerberg's track-record he won't let go this massive opportunity which is basically to kill off Twitter with Threads without much effort because Twitter is and was imploding for a very long time. One side-note about Kevin Systrom; he said that back in the day when he co-founded Instagram, he didn't hear and know about AWS. So I must come to the conclusion in this ad-hoc way that not all successful founders know what they are doing and yea there is a lot of luck involved. And btw he is a Stanford graduate?! What is Stanford teaching these "kids"?