5 ms·
This notably surround James O'Keefe's Project Veritas recording people, as the plaintiff suing the state. The dissenting opinion here is somewhat long to repos
by jauntywundrkind 3y ago
This notably surround James O'Keefe's Project Veritas recording people, as the plaintiff suing the state.
The dissenting opinion here is somewhat long to reposte, but seems worthy, in my view:
> Dissenting, Judge Christen stated that because the majority does not dispute that the State has a significant interest in protecting the privacy of Oregonians who engage in conversations without notice that their comments are being recorded, the court’s analysis should be straightforward. First, principles of federalism require that the panel begin from a premise of reluctance to strike down a state statute. Next, following Supreme Court precedent, the panel should sever the two statutory exceptions [ed: felony endangering human lives, activities of police officers] that Project Veritas challenges, apply intermediate scrutiny to the content-neutral remainder, recognize that the statute is well- tailored to meet Oregon’s significant interest, and uphold section 165.540(1)(c) as a reasonable time, place, or manner restriction. Judge Christen stated that the purpose Oregon advances is its significant interest in protecting participants from having their oral conversations recorded without their knowledge. The majority recasts the State’s interest as one in “protecting people’s conversational privacy from the speech of other individuals.” That reframing of the legislature’s purpose serves as the springboard for the majority’s reliance on an inapplicable line of Supreme Court authority that pertains to state action aimed at protecting people from unwanted commercial or political speech, not protection from speech-gathering activities like Project Veritas’s, which are qualitatively different because they appropriate the speech of others.
I wonder to what extent repeal might happen. Do the judges who struck this down intend to, in the absence of law, now allow 0 party consent recording? Can I just go around planting bugs around the city & start recording as many people as I can, unbeknownst to them?
- gjsman-1000 3y agoThat already exists - it’s called a video camera on almost every public area. Recording in public areas, unless the owner prohibits it, is almost always legal. This primarily concerned individuals. Two people couldn’t meet and secretly record a conversation with the other without consent. Recording a private conversation you are personally involved in, without notification, is legal in almost all states.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- GloomyBoots 3y agoEdit: I misread “legal” as “illegal” in the last sentence. Aren’t most states single-party consent? I know mine is, for which I’m grateful. I regularly record “private conversations” with state officials after having had incidents with them.
- gjsman-1000 3y agoThese are the states generally requiring the consent of all parties: California, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Montana, Nevada, New Hampshire, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Vermont, and Washington. 15 states. Everyone else is single-party consent.
- haroldp 3y agoNevada is a single-party consent state.
- EricE 3y agoTwo party consent only protects the politicians - frankly I'm shocked it hasn't been forced in more states.
- rootusrootus 3y agoThis needs to be clarified as I think some people will misunderstand. Oregon is a one party consent state for phone conversations. The all-party consent only applies to in person.
- loeg 3y agoIn Washington you don't need the other parties' consent (in the lay sense of the word) if you announce that you are recording and they continue talking. RCW 9.73.030 (3): > Where consent by all parties is needed pursuant to this chapter, consent shall be considered obtained whenever one party has announced to all other parties engaged in the communication or conversation, in any reasonably effective manner, that such communication or conversation is about to be recorded or transmitted
- Dalewyn 3y agoJames O'Keefe was removed from Project Veritas earlier this year. Make of that what you will, just putting it out there so you and anyone passing by aren't using outdated information.
- RajT88 3y agoTo be honest, I do not see the issues with allowing Veritas to record under existing 1 party consent state laws. Their behavior amounts to various other crimes such as libel, fraud, etc. Use those laws to punish their bad behavior.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoI'd forgotten that Federal law's 1 party consent is as extensive as it is, & hadn't included that above. That is an important consideration. To be honest, I'm not sure how I feel about states creating their own privacy laws. Part of me agrees, that 1 party consent is probably all that's required, and to do more creates a danger that criminal activity can use the law to protect itself. Oregon did exempt two specific classes of speech: any speech talking about a felony that endangers human life, and any speech by police officers. This gives the public some right to 1 party record really bad things. What's so weird here is that the court used those exemptions to strike down the entire law. They said that since the law discriminates, since these people aren't protected, it jeopardizes their right to speech. And they used that to invalidate all of the state's attempt to create additional privacy for citizens. I'm not sure how I feel on 2 party consent entirely, but this seemed like an attempt to create a somewhat balanced, privacy-sensitive approach, and seeing it taken down like this makes me feel embarrassed for the courts, that the federal courts would so brazenly & broadly undo the state legislature. I'm undecided about 2 part consent, but this feels like a vicious stroke by the courts.
- tohnjitor 3y agoWhich crimes are they committing specifically?
- RajT88 3y agoRead the wiki and tell me in detail how all this is OK.