5 ms·
The Central Bank of Brazil (Bacen) Opens Up GitHub for the Digital Real Industry
- mighmi 3y agoJust a month ago, a friend told me about serious efforts in Brazil in this direction. The larger institutional banks have been adjusting their business models to survive CBDC's implementation (e.g losing out on transfer fees, a loss in deposits etc.) which invites lively discussion on the philosophy of loan origination. It sounded a bit airy fairy to me until seeing this just now. Another guy (a Lisp-Haskell friend) runs a low level programming outfit which was implementing some interesting proofs of concept (they had no bandwidth for a collaboration a few months ago), I wonder if this has any relation. Taking rumors at face value, this puts introduction 2-3 years away. Does anyone have any insights? ------- I'm surprised by the inclusion of smart contracts. Perhaps the term just seems dirty to me due to crypto, but with central bank backing this could actually go somewhere.
- cyberax 3y ago> could actually go somewhere. Into a deeper ditch
- marcosdumay 3y agoSo, if I'm reading it right, it's a cryptocoin for interbank settlements? It's interesting that the local press isn't talking about this. But then, I guess the hype on cryptocoins died completely by now. I wonder if systems like that can be federated to create bridges so that PIX-like systems over the world talk to each other.
- H8crilA 3y agoInterbank settlements are fully digital for decades, there's one system per central bank. There is a federated system that works world over (SWIFT). It is also decades old.
- marcosdumay 3y agoIt is digital but it's not very open. That one system that works is expensive, slow, and not very secure. The fact that it's still there, and it still have those features is a clear reason why something different is needed.
- H8crilA 3y agoTypical rates: $0.3 per payment within a country $5.0 per international payment I don't think that's expensive. And it is open to all banks and certain other financial institution.
- rafaelturk 3y agoI love BACEN. Best central bank in the world. That's why we've built openpix.com
- major505 3y agoI still have to read a lot to make my mind about that, but if the mission objectives in the website are anything to go, this is kind of bullshit. The mission statement in the website: " As CBDCs podem melhorar a eficiência do mercado de pagamentos de varejo e promover a competição e a inclusão financeira para a população com pouco ou nenhum acesso a serviços bancários. " translating: CBDCs can imporive eficiency in retail payment market and inclusion of population of none of little access to bank services. But Brazil alread gave a big step a few years with the pix. This days anyone can open a free bank acccount in 10 minutes via their phones, and pay everything ditaglly. Your just scan a QR code, or send money using the person phone number as a key. To mee, this seens like a attempt to remove paper money from the market and increase tax collection.
- alephnerd 3y ago> To mee, this seens like a attempt to remove paper money from the market and increase tax collection. That's not a bad goal tbh, but why couldn't they continue to support the Digital Wallet/e-Banking industry instead then? Would CBDCs compete with NuBank? What differentiates it from Pix?
- major505 3y agoIt is to me. It means mor control of the goverment over its people. Like I said in other comment. Its a precursor to the comeback of the CPMF. Also it had the potential to deanonimize all transactiosn you make. I dont wanna the goverment knowing everywhere I spend my money.
- alephnerd 3y agoTrue, but you could still do all that without a CBDC (eg. India w/ UPI and China w/ UnionPay). What value add does a CBDC provide if you want surveillance capabilities on a consumer's transactions and assets? Heck, Pix seems to have your CPF number so doesn't that mean any transaction over Pix (aka most digital transactions I assume) can be traced back to the individual?
- fb03 3y agoI'm unsure of what to make of this effort by Bacen. Seems to be more of the same unnecessary/mindless/exploratory churn that they love to do to waste taxpayer money while there are way bigger fish to fry being left to the side.
- ke88y 3y agoI never really understood central bank currencies... it always felt like the government jumping on a hype train. The fact that the primary criticism against central bank currencies comes almost unanimously from people who consider straight up tax evasion a good thing is starting to change my mind.
- carlosjobim 3y agoIf you take away the possibility of tax evasion, what options are then left to protect yourself against an oppressor? For most of people living right now, their government is not much more than that. Taxation is human farming, and it has been going on since the dawn of civilization.
- ke88y 3y agoBrazil is not an authoritarian state.
- carlosjobim 3y agoWho ever claimed that? Look to China instead.
- ke88y 3y agoThe article is about Brazil... what are you talking about? What does China have to do with anything? Evading taxes levied by legitimate and democratically elected governments is unjust.
- carlosjobim 3y agoThere's nothing unjust in evading taxes. It's an individual choice, nobody is born into servitude. The discussion is hypothetical about an all-encompassing CBDC, which could take away the gray market and hinder tax evasion. Brazil is not in that situation, since the CBDC is just another payment method among others, most importantly physical cash. If you want to see an authoritarian society you should rather look to China, where they are developing their social credit system.