3 ms·
"That commentary rule would hold up if someone posted entire movies and then left comments or groupings attached to them. I don't expect that to work for still
by Alex3917 15y ago
"That commentary rule would hold up if someone posted entire movies and then left comments or groupings attached to them. I don't expect that to work for still pictures either."
The fair use rules are completely different for movies, so it's not really analogous.
- petegrif 15y agoIn what way are they different in law? Because surely that's the point, isn't it?
- Alex3917 15y agoIt's a lot more difficult to claim fair use for movies. I don't know the exact laws offhand.
- nagrom 15y agoIt's re-publishing the entire creative work by a for-profit corporation and its users. If it's not possible to infringe copyright by re-publishing the entire work in this way, then copyright means nothing.
- Dylan16807 15y agoOn the one hand, yes in technical terms it is republishing. On the other hand, they could deep-link the photo. The intent is to cache the photo. Pinterest could disable caching and still work. But a standard hollywood movie is not already available online to be linked to. If you upload it you become primary hosting, not a caching layer.