7 ms·
How to foster shoshin
- ulfbert_inc 3y ago>His German compatriots referred to his ‘delirious ravings’ while experts in the United States accused him of peddling pseudoscience. Many such cases!
- Archelaos 3y agoThis narrative is way too simple. The US-American Frank Bursley Taylor proposed something like condinental drift even before Wegener. One of Wegeners early opponents, Hans Cloos, nevertheless held him in high regard. Despite his dissent from the mainstream, he received a professorship in Graz. The opposition against him at the time was well justified. His theory lacked a convincing explanation about the driving force of plate tectonics, which he identified as tidal and centrifugal forces in his early theory. (The extent to which these forces contribute to plate tectonics is still disputed today.) It was only later (after he had drawn the harsh criticism quoted in the article) that he considered convection currents as the main driving force.
- kazinator 3y agoShoshin and shoshinsha (beginner) are everyday words in Japanese, not special Zen terms.
- pzel_ 3y agoYes, in the same way as "evangelist" and "novice" are everyday words in English. This does not invalidate their original religious meaning. Daisetz Suzuki I'm sure was quite aware of both the everyday usage and the Buddhist origins.
- sctb 3y agoNitpick, but this article quotes Shunryu Suzuki—the other Suzuki—not D.T.
- pzel_ 3y agoBeginner's mistake!
- kazinator 3y ago"Novice" doesn't originally have religious roots; in the story of its etymology, it got sidetracked into religion. Quite likely because the only dudes who knew Latin in the Middle Ages were in monasteries, and so they applied Latin words they learned to their circumstances. "Hey, it says here that when Romans brought in a new imported, inexperienced slave, they called them novicus. Let's use that for our newcomers! After all, we make them do chores, like slaves, LOLZ!"
- pzel_ 3y agoI'm going off of this entry: https://www.etymonline.com/word/novice https://www.etymonline.com/word/novice Sure the root word might be Latin, (and so is a majority of European vocabulary), but the specific usage of "novice" meaning "newbie" in English, comes from the monastic orders, via French. Monastic orders, which, in fact, did not "do stuff, like slaves, LOLZ", but were instrumental in preserving (or rediscovering) knowledge and technology from the imperial era.
- thrdbndndn 3y agoSo are lots of other words. Really hate this trend.
- pzel_ 3y agoAre you referring to the trend of desacralization or resacralization of religious terms? This is the dictionary definition of shoshin from kotobank.jp: > ② (「しょほっしん(初発心)」の略) 初めて悟りを求める心を起こすこと。仏道にはいったばかりのこと。また、その人。〔法華義疏(7C前)〕 ※正法眼蔵随聞記(1235‐38)一「或は初心未入(みにふ)の人意得(こころう)
- chimpanzee 3y agoUh oh, sounds like somebody could use some shoshin!
- sctb 3y agoAnd this article is mostly talking about everyday concepts like learning. But there's no denying that the idea of beginner's mind is used within Zen in a special sense. From Dogen's essay On the Endeavour of the Way: > Because practice within realization occurs at the moment of practice, the practice of beginner's mind is itself the entire original realization.
- lanstin 3y agono special sense here, just experiencing things without the sense of knowing the outcomes to expect. just sit and see.
- hooverd 3y agoDoes Japan have articles like "Top 10 English concepts to live by" where they're all just regular words?
- lanstin 3y agoas a Zen trainee, i am pretty sure there is no secret meaning to the otherwise normal words. beginer's mind is just that mind when you have no experience to predict what is expected next.
- haswell 3y ago> A final, more pleasurable step you can take to increase your intellectual humility comes in the form of deliberately invoking in oneself the emotion of awe. Several studies have shown that awe quietens the ego and prompts epistemological openness – that is, a greater willingness to look at things differently and to recognise the gaps in one’s knowledge. If you cannot remember the last time you experienced awe, I highly recommend seeking it out. It may be important for fostering intellectual humility, but it seems just as important for fostering a better outlook/framing on life in general and brings with it a sense of wellbeing. After burning out and starting a sabbatical last year, I went on a road trip that provided many moments of awe: a snowy mountain sunrise in the Rockies, the Milky Way in one of the darkest spots in Utah, long hikes through the redwoods, etc. What struck me was that I had forgotten what these feelings felt like, and that I hadn’t felt them since I was a kid. Glimpsing them reminded me how important they are, and I’m convinced that sustainability in future work endeavors (and life in general) involves an appropriate dose of awe and wonder on an ongoing basis. Road trips into the desert aren’t necessary to experience this either (for me anyway) - just a very effective way to guarantee the experience (again, for me). But I can find it by pondering the bigger questions about life and the sheer improbability of our existence. Dedicating some regular time to this kind of reflection has been beneficial. And I do find that I’m more open to possibilities. But that seems like just one of the outcomes from the “nourishment” of these experiences.
- mikrl 3y agoI took a walk last night to look at the sunset, and felt a strong feeling of both awe and melancholy as I did so. Is it really so rare to be awed by natural beauty, or just humbled by where one is in life relative to oneself in the past, and others (both more and less fortunate) in the present? When I think of friends made, friends not present, and all of the life trajectories that I can keep track of, I feel it’s all just a long and strange trip, man.
- vmoore 3y ago> If you cannot remember the last time you experienced awe, I highly recommend seeking it out The older I get, the more I appreciate the sheer vastness of space and the amount of stuff in it, and contrasting the size of it to our little pale blue dot. The Nihilists will say our time here is all meaningless and we'll eventually be swallowed by the Sun if we don't go star faring. We better get our act together in terms of space travel before it's too late. We need to think long-term and occupy Mars, then taken to its logical conclusion: Von Neumann machines which populate our galaxy. That's if we're not sucked into the black hole in the center of our galaxy. But at least we gave it a shot. We outsmarted the natural cycles of the solar system and transcended it, possibly building a Dyson sphere around the Sun and then hopped to other star systems and built Dyson spheres around them. When I was young, I knew the Universe was very big. But over the years, helped by various documentaries, YouTube videos, and various psychedelics, I surmised we are destined for something much more than mere Earth. Our spirit cries for space travel, yet at the same time it's hampered by the rape of the planet and late-stage capitalism and 'infinite growth' at all costs.
- debacle 3y agoAre people "intellectually humble" or just more humble in general? Many intellectual people use their intelligence and authority as a coping mechanism for poor social skills or low self esteem. As a manager + systems architect, I've worked with a lot of people who almost have PTSD from dealing with the petty tyrants in our industry, and I've been told that academia is much worse. If you want to foster shoshin, just listen more than you speak. I've got two decades of experience and my third year interns teach me cool things all the time.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ncr100 3y agoPractically this is an excellent point. I want people to listen more than they do, myself as well.
- photochemsyn 3y agoThis author's example does not inspire confidence in the rest of the article: > "Take the matter of genetically modified (GM) foods, which are overwhelmingly considered to be safe based on current scientific knowledge. Research has shown that people who hold the strongest anti-GM views, believing that they are harmful, are the most inclined to overestimate their relevant knowledge." If I insert the genes coding the enzymatic pathway for production of a virulent mammalian toxin into a maize plant, that's going to be very unsafe, particularly if pollen from that plant can carry those genes into someone's non-GMO cornfield. On the other hand, if I make a minor specific edit to the regulatory region upstream from a gene that controls the onset of flowering in a tomato plant, with the idea of producing an early-flowering varietal for northern climates, that's entirely safe (assuming no other accidental changes were made). Claiming that GMO foods are 'universally acknowledged to be safe' is like claiming metallurgy is universally acknowledged to be safe. It all depends on the specific application and how it's done, e.g. heavy metal pollution is a major issue in many places because of lack of pollution controls. Placing blind faith in governmental and corporate scientists because they wear the white coats of authority is not that different from blind obedience to the priestly caste of prior centuries. If they can't provide explanations that the educated layperson can understand, and if they can't respond to detailed criticisms of their claims, then they should not be trusted.
- renewiltord 3y ago> On the other hand, if I make a minor specific edit to the regulatory region upstream from a gene that controls the onset of flowering in a tomato plant, with the idea of producing an early-flowering varietal for northern climates, that's entirely safe (assuming no other accidental changes were made). No, this is not true if someone is pointing a nuclear missile at NYC and will fire it if you "make a minor specific edit to the regulatory region upstream from a gene that controls the onset of flowering in a tomato plant". It's important that you clarify the point by also adding in the caveat excluding this case. I am also told that what you propose is unsafe in the event that there is a terrorist with a bomb who will explode in Penn Station if you make that edit. It is important that we be precise with safety language since otherwise we may mislead people about the state of the field. Please be more responsible.
- giantbanana 3y ago[flagged]
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoA good way to get this mindset is to try doing things you don't know how to do. I write a bit about that, here: https://littlegreenviper.com/miscellany/thats-not-what-ships-are-built-for/ https://littlegreenviper.com/miscellany/thats-not-what-ships... Reminds me a bit of the old Stephen J. Gould quote: “The most erroneous stories are those we think we know best -and therefore never scrutinize or question.”
- wnolens 3y agoI think there's an underappreciated reason for trying to cultivate this kind of mind. > With eyes and mind wide open, it’s so much easier to enjoy the wonders of the world Never occurred to me before but by constantly learning new things (instrument, rock climbing, history of Iran, sewing..) I've been cultivating a mindset of gratitude for the world and appreciation of others' abilities. I feel it has helped bring my brain slowly back into balance from being quite depressed. Focusing on learning something new was a way out.
- kristopolous 3y agoThis can be said way more briefly: "what would teenage you be like here" Follow those instincts (presuming you weren't a slacker) and that's it.
- suction 3y ago[dead]
- astrange 3y agoThis article title is what you call Orientalism. 初心 is not a mystical ancient philosophy term unknown to the West. It's "beginner's mindset" or "openness to new concepts". Actually, knowing "openness" is more important because knowing what Big 5 personality traits are protects you from believing in MBTI.
- Dalewyn 3y ago"Shoshin" translated to English means going back to one's roots. Remembering why you're doing what you're doing, and so on. Life can get overwhelming and it's far too easy to lose track of the fundamentals.
- ftxbro 3y agothis is such a hacker news article. your autistic childishness is actually a superpower with its own japanese word.
- gjvc 3y agoposting that comment with that username is meta-ironic
- sublinear 3y agoMaybe I'm living in another world, but I think it's far more likely to find people with low self esteem than overconfidence and neither is capable of being humble. People who are proud about "staying humble" are every bit as insufferable.
- m3kw9 3y agoNot sure why low self esteem isn’t covered as a major problem if you want to learn things. It’s as bad as over confidence, you stop yourself from learning anything remotely difficult because you talk yourself down habitually
- sublinear 3y agoYep. I struggled with this a lot in high school and college. It led to poor grades and taking extra years I couldn't really afford at the time to finish college. This was a conflict between my low self esteem and modest ambition to finish school and start a career. I worried constantly if I was really going to fail at something so simple. This generated so much distracting anxiety for me until I finally upped the dose on the usual self-medication (mostly booze) to turn my brain off and just start doing things. A few years later I finally awoke from those hazier times in a much happier place making a decent living. Mine is definitely not a unique story, but I just wanted to agree that our culture largely ignores low self esteem because it's one of the hardest problems to fix.
- ptelomere 3y ago"Invoking awe" is easy, travel to places you've never been, do things you've never done, and what not. Richard Feynman once said "The easiest person to fool is yourself". The real "humility" is how you'd respond when someone tell you how wrong you are. Most people response with "fight", instead of reflecting, which is the "correct spiritual" response many people should take, because logically you never know 100% of everything to be 100% sure about anything.
- teus666666 3y ago[flagged]