60 ms·
They'd prefer you stop watching. Bandwidth costs them a lot, and they have pretty much the cheapest bandwidth of any tech player. If 1% of users are freel
by londons_explore 3y ago
They'd prefer you stop watching. Bandwidth costs them a lot, and they have pretty much the cheapest bandwidth of any tech player. If 1% of users are freeloading like you and I, and they can block us and save 1% on their infrastructure bill, that's still a huge amount of money saved, and could easily turn the whole effort from a loss to a profit.
- wpietri 3y agoDo we know that bandwidth costs YouTube a lot?
- londons_explore 3y agoBandwidth costs all video sites a lot. Thats why cloudflare won't host sites with lots of video. It's why twitter doesn't do HD video. Thats why there are no startups trying to make video hosting sites. If you hosted a youtube clone on AWS with their cloudfront CDN, you'd be paying $0.085 per GB out to the internet. A youtube ad view earns perhaps $0.004. HD video is ~6GB/hour, so a 3 minute video costs $0.0255 to host (before compute and storage costs, profit and engineer time). Earning $0.004 for something that costs you $0.025 is never going to work out...
- vetinari 3y agoNot to distract from your point, but > It's why twitter doesn't do HD video. Twitter does HD video. I don't know whether it is generally available or not, but for example, Tucker Carlson's videos are 1080p.
- fomine3 3y agoInteresting description: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FpAOeoZWAAM-iHV?format=png&name=900x900 https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FpAOeoZWAAM-iHV?format=png&name=...
- psnehanshu 3y agoThis looks to me like a sane comment. No idea why this was downvoted.
- wpietri 3y agoBecause it doesn't answer the question. I was asking about YouTube, which, being part of Google, occupies a radically different position. They aren't using AWS to host their video, so the numbers are irrelevant.
- dijit 3y agoI don't like this reasoning because I've seen the inside of google. Their bandwidth is very cheap. What costs is having a CDN, a bunch of very fast servers that exist in every point-of-presence, given the load they endure CDN cache servers fail quickly when compared to others. -- along with the upkeep of their networking equipment, which is cheap but not free. But Google itself has invested wisely in how it connects to the internet, they are dark fibre all the way with many hundreds of gigabits between sites and pops. It's a huge upfront investment (the kind SV startups seem to hate) but the long tail makes bandwidth essentially free. The only cost they have is hardware and peering, and given their size I can't convince myself if they are or are not being shafted financially by big ISPs for peering - even if they are though, it's marginal compared to what GCP/AWS/etc; charge us, even Colo datacenters will charge significantly more than what it costs Google.
- wpietri 3y agoThanks, this is exactly what I was wondering about. I would expect Google's marginal cost of bandwidth to be approximately zero. What are networks going to do, not connect to Google?
- michaelt 3y ago> What are networks going to do, not connect to Google? Throttle the connection so its slow enough users get 480p video at peak viewing times. Ask google for $$$$ to stop doing that.
- tinus_hn 3y agoGoogle can just say ‘if you’re on this network, you only get poor quality video. Come to one of the networks that support YouTube properly!’. Remember that for a while they were just about the only site that could load Flash. YouTube is that important.
- gymbeaux 3y agoMost places in the US at least have two ISPs at most so it would probably not pan out so well if they tried to do that
- kbutler 3y agoKey words are "would cost _you_". The providers get much better cost per GB at scale, then sell to you at a profit. For example, transfer out from S3 gets down to $0.05 at just 150TB, including the AWS markup. (Note that CloudFront data out is not directly comparable to S3 data out!)
- wpietri 3y agoYes, I get that I have to pay a lot for bandwidth. And that you have to pay a lot for bandwidth. My question is specifically about YouTube.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- no_wizard 3y agoThough Cloudflare does have a separate product for streaming Video, it definitely doesn’t fall under the generic CDN serving files model
- bsder 3y ago> Thats why there are no startups trying to make video hosting sites. No, there are no startups in video for the same reason there were no startups in office apps or operating systems in the 2000s, a subsidized 500lb gorilla in the space. The problem with a video startup is that you have to charge for your content. And some jerk will download your video, post it to YouTube, and distribute it for free. If YouTube were forced to stand on its own instead of being subsidized by the Google advertising maw, we'd see innovation in the space. Until YouTube gets broken out from Google by anti-trust action, the video startup space will continue to remain dead.
- Dylan16807 3y agoThe big cloud providers all charge ridiculous amounts for their bandwidth. It makes your numbers completely invalid for any bandwidth-focused operation. Also youtube's bitrate usually far below that amount.
- dskrepps 3y agoI think our best bet to make a difference is to cause network effects to drive other users to take the same steps we do. In the long run that will help shrink their monopoly, and/or bring a tipping point closer to reality. Similar to voting. Yeah, I could vote for a third party candidate, but the real power I have is in how many other people I can convince to vote for someone.
- rtpg 3y agoI don't understand this. What is your principled stand? Don't charge me money and also don't put in ads? Youtube is one of the few platforms where people making content can actually survive off of it. It's not everything but it's more than ~anything else. It would be nice for there to be more platforms but personally I'm exhausted of platforms trying to race to the bottom and ultimiately squeezing people who are actually doing the "hard work". (My one big complaint is that youtube doesn't charge people for bandwidth, meaning that services like Vimeo are ... kind of DOA. I don't know how you do that and have viral stuff for normal people, but it does feel like something should be in place)
- wcarss 3y agoYouTube could play ads and let me play videos while my phone screen is locked. They could play ads like they used to: a small popup. They could play ads like they did after that: one 5 second pre-roll. Or like after that, a pre-roll with a skip call to action. But at some point it got into the ballpark of two 10-15 second ads every 5 minutes even on the channels of people who explicitly asked not to turn on monetization because they're making educational content, often for kids and schools. The mobile app nags me with a "try premium" / "skip trial" popup 5 times per week. There are consistently small bugs in the user experience of the app. Oh, and they're rich as God because they're also the people who own the operating system, browser, app store, and search engine I used to find all this stuff -- plus my email and my productivity software, all of which they will leverage to _squeeze_ every last bit the juice out of me as a user. They own all my data already. They own everything. So, what is the "principled stand"? Enough is a goddamned enough! If they were just going to show some ads, it would be fine, but like every single parasitic horror show out there, they promised they'd be good and they cannot stop getting worse. At the very least, I can choose not to pay them $12/month for the privilege.
- gymbeaux 3y agoThen I don't want to hear about dwindling YouTube revenue on their next earnings call...