5 ms·
The Hypocrisy of Mandatory Diversity Statements
- bell-cot 3y agoSubtitle: "Demanding that everyone embrace the same values will inevitably narrow the pool of applicants who work and get hired in higher education." Better subtitle: "The academic workforce's skills and values will shift yet further toward ideological argument, posturing and correctness. And willingness to lie about their values."
- RobotToaster 3y agoTherefore discriminating against people with autism and other social disabilities that find lying difficult or impossible.
- onos 3y agoOr believe it’s important to be true to themselves…
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoA DEI statement can instead be about costing a lab environment compatible with people who have autism and other social disabilities. Especially as a professor who will be expected to mentor other students and conduct research, the professor can say they have first hand knowledge on how to foster a space friendly to the neurodivergent.
- Pannoniae 3y agoI'm not sure how much you know about this, but some neurodivergent/autism-friendly places absolutely shit on neurodivergent people. Especially when it involves not following unwritten rules, sadly. Expecting an autistic person to implicitly understand what not to say or what topics not to talk about is like expecting women not to be afraid at night. It is just very out of touch.
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoWell, that’s what the professor with autism can do though: in a statement establish that they will create a mentorship environment with explicit rule and clear boundaries such that will foster an environment for other autistics to succeed in the field.
- Pannoniae 3y agoYes, but compulsory DEI statements achieve the opposite effect sadly - they water down true commitment to the issue by making everyone make them, which has the effect of making the pledge worthless. This again disadvantages neurodivergent people because they often can't effectively filter between mandatory bullshit and genuine commitments, so they might be abused by people who were just forced to sign the DEI pledge but do not actually care about it to make proper accommodations like explicit rules and the such.
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoThere’s no proof that making everyone make such statements waters them down. It might also just make everyone actually think about ways their labs and mentorship style might exclude people and adjust accordingly. I think an autistic professor who writes about making a genuine commitment into supporting other autistic students and actually following through with that is just as competitive as other professors who may lie about it, because autistic people are just as capable of success as neurotypical. In fact I’m willing to be that autistic professor will be even more so, because they are going to foster amazing students that other ableist professors overlook.
- Pannoniae 3y agoIt creates pushback though... even when some people are generally sympathetic to inclusion and those general goals, a forced statement might make them push back and say "fuck it I hate this and I won't be taking it seriously". I think the best way of promoting inclusivity is offering incentives for doing so (not necessarily financial by the way - even small things like events or postcards help!) and creating a healthy atmosphere. Trying to make a polarised and generally toxic atmosphere inclusive only furthers the divide and the polarisation.
- TheFreim 3y agoI don't appreciate this reasoning. Promotion of lying isn't wrong because of some strained "discrimination" connection, it's wrong because lying is immoral and deteriorates trust.
- RobotToaster 3y agoI agree, but I was pointing out the hypocrisy/irony of it.
- bell-cot 3y agoCould you tell us about the job where difficulties with discerning the lies that the boss currently wants to hear, or in telling him those lies, is not discriminated against?
- Pannoniae 3y agoDEI is mainly a tool for wage suppression, not sure why many people fall for it...
- Cymrukicks 3y agoI haven't seen this angle discussed, could you explain further?
- Pannoniae 3y agoWell first off, the focus shifts on identity, not productivity or merit. This "justifies" lower salaries based on equal pay. Most of DEI means equity (of outcome), not equality, which is often achieved by pushing higher-achievers down, not lifting everyone up. Needless to say how this affects compensation. Second, if you are a DEI hire, you are made to feel that you only got the role for who you are, so you will most likely not ask for a raise due to the fear of reprisal or dismissal. Third, weakens the belonging amongst coworkers since everyone is really careful in social interactions to not give the leadership a (mostly fabricated) opportunity to fire them for breaching DEI policies. Obviously, when coworkers are suspicious of each other, it's much easier to use divide-and-conquer tactics and underpay everyone. Fourth, those companies recruit immigrants specifically, so they can underpay them under the threat of firing them (and making them lose their visa).
- Fluid_Mechanics 3y ago[flagged]
- Pannoniae 3y agoPlease don't assume unnecessarily hostile intents from my part, it's not very polite or friendly.
- the_solenoid 3y agothats not how it works at all. You dont hire someone unqualified just because they tick a box, what kind of insane would that be?
- DeathArrow 3y agohttps://archive.fo/aAhKO https://archive.fo/aAhKO
- tjpnz 3y ago>UC Santa Cruz publishes online to help guide prospective applicants. >“To receive a high score under the terms set by the rubric,” the complaint alleges, “an applicant must express agreement with specific socio-political ideas, including the view that treating individuals differently based on their race or sex is desirable.” In what universe is being patronising desirable?
- soco 3y agoOn the other hand it's much cheaper for an employer to filter candidates early, instead of firing them later for inappropriate behaviour.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- readthenotes1 3y agowho defines inappropiate? _animal farm_ novel is how old??
- 111111IIIIIII 3y ago> Who defines inappropriate? The boss.
- water9 3y agowho employs the boss? The Investor. Who's the biggest investors? blackrock fidelity vanguard and state street use our pensions and 401ks to influence companies to do their bidding.
- 111111IIIIIII 3y agoThe boss is always whoever controls the capital, hence why it's called capitalism.
- hourago 3y ago
- zarathustreal 3y agoI've noticed this trend of changing the meaning of words in recent decades. How do we prevent corruption of meaning? I hear "language evolves over time!" quite a lot, as if it's a law of nature, but I've never heard anyone question the statement to determine whether it's true or why it would be true. "Diversity" is a good example but there are numerous ("racism", "bigotry", etc). I suspect the reasons for change would be insufficient to sway a majority. I suspect this is why the reasons aren't examined. Originally there was an idea that a group with completely homogenous thoughts and opinions would lack innovation and problem solving ability. Ironically, the meaning of "diversity" has been corrupted to the point that it now requires homogenous thoughts and opinions.
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoI think it doesn’t require homogenous thoughts and opinions, that’s rather bad faith and obviously untrue on its face: you cannot have homogenous thoughts and opinions with a diverse background of people. However it does limit what kind of diversity is acceptable: an opinion that gay people should be given the death penalty might definitely be unique in the workplace but also I would argue not beneficial to a workplace setting.
- zarathustreal 3y agoOne's background does not dictate one's thoughts and opinions, that's an argument for predestination and I reject it outright. Hiring practices are not, cannot, be based on background, due to time constraints of the hiring process. It is not possible to know a person's background, though you could certainly get some idea of it given enough time, perspective alone would prevent you from understanding it as they do. In fact, hiring is based almost entirely on the prejudices of the person(s) making the hiring decision. These days, publicly traded companies are incentivized through market forces (blackrock, ESG scoring) to be prejudiced against certain groups. If you're looking for a faith-based interpretation of the meaning of words, good, bad, or otherwise, you'll need to extend some faith in the existing meaning first. I'm not going to defend an opinion that I haven't given, such as that the death penalty should be given to a person based on their sexual orientation. I will, however, defend the notion that every person's opinion holds valuable information and perspective. You cannot argue on principle that diversity is a good thing while simultaneously arguing that it can be a bad thing. This is an obvious contradiction. It changes the meaning of the argument from "we've discovered a fundamental truth" to "we'd like you to act a certain way" and that glosses over the outstanding implicit request, by the existence of a status quo, for you to act a certain way.
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoBasically this is about a professor who believes in meritocracy and race blindness, and is angry that this isn’t considered acceptable for professorship. It doesn’t really go into whether or not the professors opinion is a valid opinion based on factual evidence for the existence of meritocracy and the benefits of race-blindness. But he could also have gone into a statement advocating for accessibility or veterans access instead, such as saying he would ensure his lab and research location will be wheelchair accessible and that any trials component of his research will be available in formats compatible with deafness or blindness. Or does he not believe in those either? What about having flexible work hours so parents can raise children, or older students can live their adult lives (which will benefit veterans)? This article is myopic and implies that DEI is thing. I actually think that belief is just as lacking in diverse thinking as it is accusing DEI to be.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> doesn’t really go into whether or not the professors opinion is a valid opinion based on factual evidence It doesn’t matter. If everyone is required to sign a statement saying the sky is blue, it is meaningless if there is “a valid opinion based on factual evidence” to the contrary. That there is a mandated view suppresses the inquiry that might generate factual evidence, whether in favour of the hypothesis or not.
- nqwiudhnoaq73 3y ago[flagged]
- swelteringhot 3y ago[flagged]
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> just hope that the public anger gets directed at the people and corporations trying to enforce ideology, as opposed to ideology itself Why not both?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- swelteringhot 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- onos 3y agoIt’s stunning that the left fought for decades for racial equality and free speech, only to do an abrupt about face. But to stick to the current topic: these required dei statements are definitely ideological litmus tests, and the people promoting these are not “on the right side of history”, but authoritarians.
- snapplebobapple 3y agoIt makes more sense when you realize it's not the same left. The old left was much more on the hopeful/practical side of marxist thought focused on the economy as the alleged pathway of oppression, which gave them a focus on unionization and equal rights. The new left is much more influenced by the butt hurt, due to the utter failure of the system in the face of free market, decedents of old school marxism that has generalized marxist thought processes (i.e. critical theory) to all sorts of different alleged pathways of oppression. The new left comes much more out of the university and the legal profession and many of the different versions don't really like each other because critical theory doesn't give you coherent results and as such things that form the foundation of one version are considered abhorrent in another (i.e. put a critical race theorist and a queer theorist in a room and compare and contrast what the same base idea and reasoning system manifests as). The moderate center left is much more alienated under the new regime and is increasingly homeless as well because the new left isn't as willing to compromise its vision in return for incremental improvement (I think that's because it's not as unified a thought process as it was when it wasn't generalized but that's just my opinion)
- TheFreim 3y agoIt was never about "free speech" but rather "how can we justify what we say to gain influence". Once sufficient influence has been acquired it is necessary to prevent opposition from wielding the same tool that gave you power. The common man may have been convinced that "free speech" was an ideal but ultimately they were being used or manipulated.
- john0015 3y ago[dead]
- quickcheque 3y agoAs a prof, I use GPT for any boilerplate statements such as DEI required as part of grant/fellowship/scholarship applications.
- red-iron-pine 3y agoshow us the prompt
- Viliam1234 3y agoIf GPT isn't trained on the latest Twitter data, this can backfire. Yesterday's political correctness can get you fired today.
- biimugan 3y agoI would love everyone to just examine the specific situations as they arise instead of immediately jumping to Platonic discussions of merit and race and gender. Otherwise you're falling into a culture war trap that's completely unproductive. The first problem is there's actually no injury here as far as I can tell. This person did not even submit the paperwork, and thus did not get scored, and thus did not get rejected. The entire thing is based around the assumption that he would get rejected. But why would he assume that? Maybe it has less to do with his paperwork and more to do with his public activity. For example, in this case, you have an individual who either tweets or retweets dozens of times daily (DAILY), frequently getting into online arguments. He's active in the conservative online outrage machine, retweeting and interacting with conservative personalities. He has a paid Substack where he opines about the cultural revolution ("Marxist" left unsaid, but obviously present), whether COVID was real, how "the Left" destabilizes society, and other conservative culture war issues. By any stretch of the imagination, this isn't a normal person. This is someone who is loud, addicted to Online Discourse, and who seems like they're looking to make trouble. If someone like this was a colleague, regardless of their political persuasion, I would steer clear of them. This type of person is often not pleasant to be around, and often fails to properly do their job.
- swelteringhot 3y ago[flagged]
- hourago 3y agoAll the argument is "do not judge people by their politics", and then it dedicates a lot of words to judge people by their politics. It is not just ironic but nonsensical. A political biased piece that tries to hide behind a wall of very faulty reasoning.
- hourago 3y agoA lot of people angry here because they are not allowed to discriminate based in actually protected classes like gender. It seems that the hiring manager just wants to make sure that the potential employee is not going to discriminate against other employees. A very reasonable position. I see many people arguing "to include racists is also diversity" a sentence that may be grammatically correct but it is meaningless when it comes to semantics.
- hsjqllzlfkf 3y ago> Demanding that everyone embrace the same values will inevitably narrow the pool of applicants who work and get hired in higher education. True diversity comes from people who look different.