4 ms·

LLM doesn't know stuff, it has few models beyond an extremely deep association between (in this case) descriptions and pictures. Humans have shitty models for

LLM doesn't know stuff, it has few models beyond an extremely deep association between (in this case) descriptions and pictures. Humans have shitty models for stuff, but we have them. We lack the massively deep numerical associations. It can't be that long before someone makes an AI that says knows a few common models like "stuff made of steel is rigid, stuff made of cloth is soft, etc". Along with "If someone keeps emphasizing a number, that's the number of things he wants".

im3w1l 3y ago
Me: A designer has created two artpieces. The first one "The gattoya" is made of steel bars welded into a spiral shape. The second "Misiblur" is made of cloth and somewhat resembles a butterfly. Which is most comfortable to rest your head on and why? Chatgpt: Based on the description provided, it is likely that "Misiblur," the art piece made of cloth resembling a butterfly, would be more comfortable to rest your head on compared to "The gattoya," which is made of steel bars welded into a spiral shape. The reason for this is that cloth generally has a softer and more cushioned surface compared to steel bars. When resting your head on Misiblur, the fabric would provide a certain level of support and padding, which could make it more comfortable for resting your head. On the other hand, resting your head on steel bars, as in the case of The gattoya, would likely be less comfortable due to the hardness and lack of cushioning provided by the material. Steel bars are not designed to be soft or ergonomic for resting purposes, so it may not provide the desired comfort. It's important to note that the comfort level can vary depending on individual preferences and the specific design and construction of the art pieces. However, based on the given materials and descriptions, Misiblur made of cloth would generally be the more comfortable option for resting your head.
- lordnacho 3y ago
  Yes but that's text, and there's plenty of text that will tell you that steel is rigid, and rigid is uncomfortable. Also you gave it an A/B choice, random chance is 50%. Does it insist it's right if you prompt it the other way? Does it make pictures of people who are comfortable in one but not the other? Most of the time when I see something funny in LLMs it's in the images. People with 8 fingers, elbows bent backwards, that kind of thing. Spatial models.
  - im3w1l 3y ago
    You are partly right, but I asked it to motivate its answer and it was able to do that in a coherent way. I quite intentionally didn't ask it which was rigid or soft, that's a connection it made itself. (edited to remove incorrect info)
deleted 3y ago
[deleted]

im3w1l 3y ago

Me: A designer has created two artpieces. The first one "The gattoya" is made of steel bars welded into a spiral shape. The second "Misiblur" is made of cloth and somewhat resembles a butterfly. Which is most comfortable to rest your head on and why? Chatgpt: Based on the description provided, it is likely that "Misiblur," the art piece made of cloth resembling a butterfly, would be more comfortable to rest your head on compared to "The gattoya," which is made of steel bars welded into a spiral shape. The reason for this is that cloth generally has a softer and more cushioned surface compared to steel bars. When resting your head on Misiblur, the fabric would provide a certain level of support and padding, which could make it more comfortable for resting your head. On the other hand, resting your head on steel bars, as in the case of The gattoya, would likely be less comfortable due to the hardness and lack of cushioning provided by the material. Steel bars are not designed to be soft or ergonomic for resting purposes, so it may not provide the desired comfort. It's important to note that the comfort level can vary depending on individual preferences and the specific design and construction of the art pieces. However, based on the given materials and descriptions, Misiblur made of cloth would generally be the more comfortable option for resting your head.

lordnacho 3y ago
Yes but that's text, and there's plenty of text that will tell you that steel is rigid, and rigid is uncomfortable. Also you gave it an A/B choice, random chance is 50%. Does it insist it's right if you prompt it the other way? Does it make pictures of people who are comfortable in one but not the other? Most of the time when I see something funny in LLMs it's in the images. People with 8 fingers, elbows bent backwards, that kind of thing. Spatial models.
- im3w1l 3y ago
  You are partly right, but I asked it to motivate its answer and it was able to do that in a coherent way. I quite intentionally didn't ask it which was rigid or soft, that's a connection it made itself. (edited to remove incorrect info)

deleted 3y ago

[deleted]