4 ms·
> they just wanted a quick fix, not spend $$$. > Then I bought macs for everyone I bet you would've gotten similar results if you spent the same amount of mone
by jeroenhd 3y ago
> they just wanted a quick fix, not spend $$$.
> Then I bought macs for everyone
I bet you would've gotten similar results if you spent the same amount of money on Windows computers.
For example, my dad is using an 8 year old Windows computer that he got second hand. It works absolutely fine because it wasn't underspecced at the time it was produced.
People underestimate the difference investing in good hardware makes. They see $300 computers and expect them to work just as well as a $1200 top of the line machine, and then get frustrated at how slow their Celeron machine gets after getting their expectations crushed. Getting mad at a "broken" computer is easier than admitting you messed up and made a terrible investment.
- tenebrisalietum 3y ago> People underestimate the difference investing in good hardware makes. Yes, but ... > Getting mad at a "broken" computer is easier than admitting you messed up and made a terrible investment. Mid take. Windows still sucks on $1200 hardware, just faster. You still get the same crappy UI that shuffles around every couple of updates just because, dangerous legacy stuff like ActiveX, SMB1, and IE lurking just beneath the surface, ads in the Start Menu, random updates, forced reboots, etc.
- skeaker 3y agoThat's beside the point, isn't it? I don't think anybody is arguing that Windows doesn't have issues
- tenebrisalietum 3y agoNo, it's definitely within the point.
- jeroenhd 3y agoI agree that Windows sucks. I also think it sucks less than macOS, but Microsoft is working hard to change that. Linux sucks less in some ways but sucks a lot more in many others. None of the operating systems seem to want to support you as the user anymore, they're all part of a ploy to buy more hardware, rent more software, and move everything to some kind of cloud solution you'll never be able to get rid of. However, ActiveX, SMB1, and IE11 haven't been an issue since Windows 11, and you need to go out of your way to find them in Windows 10. IE has been dead for over a year. Even before that, Microsoft received widespread criticism when they hid IE11 by default, because users didn't want to change away from IE for some godforsaken reason. The Windows kernel is a software engineering marvel and Windows has become incredibly stable on modern hardware. The shell on top of it has become a victim of terrible enshittification that started in Windows 8, or maybe 10.
- Etheryte 3y agoThe question in my opinion is not really about specs — no matter how much you spend on your hardware, you can't, pardon my French, take the shitbox out of Windows. Device manager and registry still being a thing, reboots to install software, ads in the start menu, etc are a good example of how Windows is not a system for human users. It's amazing how much backwards compatibility they've offered over the decades, yes, but it's also got them holding a lot of smelly baggage.
- Dylan16807 3y agoHow often do you have to touch the device manager? Registry is fine. It's not a very big fraction of software that needs a reboot. It's much more common to have an OS update need one, and that's pretty universal across desktop OSes. The ads are bad. Though interestingly those are relatively new, not baggage.
- AlotOfReading 3y agoDevice manager is usually step 2 or 3 when something is going wrong. When you're fixing someone else's computer, you'll probably spend a lot of time there. Windows also tends to break in mysterious ways after applying OS updates which need to reboot. The observable symptoms are things like network timeouts, performance drops, and random application crashes, but the people you're providing tech support to usually don't have the knowledge to recognize when those are justified problems or windows itself being silly.
- flashback2199 3y agoYou don't get it. It doesn't matter how many times you have to do X, Y, or Z in Windows. The first time any one of them is needed the entire "non tech savvy person using their computer to get things done" program comes to a complete halt.
- white_dragon88 3y ago[dead]
- figassis 3y ago
- kortilla 3y agoThis is incorrect. I had the same issue supporting my family members on good hardware with windows. It was just too common that software updates broke things, random adware would get installed when they clicked on things, etc. This was windows vista/7 era and when I made them switch to macOS the problems just went away. I think apple seems to be better about making it so non power users can’t accidentally mess things up so much. It doesn’t help that the windows install for a printer includes some huge print center bloatware if you accept defaults and for Mac it didn’t prompt for anything like that (same printer plugged in with usb). I can’t even imagine trying to support them on the new windows with the advertisements and changing stuff in the start menu…
- Dylan16807 3y ago>I had the same issue supporting my family members on good hardware with windows. It was just too common that software updates broke things, random adware would get installed when they clicked on things, etc. Those weren't the issues that needed money. The issue that needed money was "sometimes their machines just needed to be upgraded because they were running the new office, and the new skype and the new chrome, antivirus, etc, and the 3yo system could barely keep up".
- jeroenhd 3y agoVista/7 was definitely an era filled with questionable choices from both Microsoft and computer manufacturers. Vista was plainly unfinished when it came out (and driver vendors put in 0 effort to update their drivers for a completely revamped driver architecture). 7 was basically what Vista should've been and it was very solid on hardware designed to run it (on hardware released for Vista or even XP, you were still stuck with the terrible drivers from the Vista era). The instability and bloat have changed significantly in the 17 years since Vista came out. The Windows kernel itself is rock solid, most drivers run in user mode so BSODs are extremely rare. There is bloatware, for Windows and for macOS, for all the terrible hardware vendors out there. I remember plugging in my Logitech mouse into a Mac and finding out I need a separate app to configure it properly because various OS mouse settings only apply to Apple hardware for some reason. Printers Just Work these days, unless you buy one of those awful models that requires an app to set up, and then it doesn't matter what desktop OS you use. Microsoft did add ridiculous Microsoft ads and a scummy account requirement to Windows 10 and 11. However, these aren't visible for most users, because most users are already logged in to a Microsoft account. When people talk about "ads" in Windows, they don't mean banner ads, they mean "click here to connect to Microsoft Onedrive with your MS account", not too different from various iCloud related menus I've seen. The way they mess with Edge, that is plain awful. I'm astonished with how much effort Microsoft is putting into shoving Edge down everyone's throats. Edge is the biggest reason not to use Windows in existence. I'm not sure what you mean by "changing stuff in the start menu" so I can't comment on that. However, I'd recommend trying out a Windows VM some time (you can download them from the MS website for free!), because I get the feeling your experiences with Windows are quite outdated.
- manicennui 3y agoWho exactly sells Windows machines with good hardware?
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 3y agoYou can get ok hardware for a reasonable price. My LG 'gram' seems fine. $800, very lightweight. Came with Windows home. Upgraded to pro for $6. If you want 'good' some of the Alienware laptops will be more beefy. Or the $5000 desktop PC I got off Newegg had top of the line specs and came with Windows.. Not sure what you're talking about really. You can get crap, medium or best with Windows.
- manicennui 3y agoI have an Alienware Ryzen 9 machine. I'm not at all impressed. I only have it for games. The Intel 4790k machine that I built around 2015 with Windows 10 is more responsive. I'm not convinced that any hardware runs Windows 11 well.
- pokerface_86 3y agomy 12600k+3080 has no issues with windows 11
- figassis 3y agoAre you suggesting I buy $5k windows desktops when I can get $1000 macs that I know will be easier to use long term. Also, I used to buy top of the line Sony VAIOs, that was my go to brand. They were robust, many were had sturdy aluminum bodies (not unibody but close), and the base models were often very performant (specs, cooling, etc). Usually they all started at roughly $800, I used to buy the $1000 ones, so moving to macs did not start suddenly costing more, same average price, better quality of life.
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 3y agoI'm not claiming it's the best bang per buck, just saying you can get good hardware with Windows preinstalled. Or just reformat to Linux if you think Windows is sluggish.
- ilyt 3y agoThat's more to your dad not managing to install any crapware many computer-clueless users get baited into rather than hardware itself. Even the bottom line machines nowadays are perfectly fine for "living" (internet, multimedia, office apps etc.).
- figassis 3y agoSorry, I'm a software engineer, I never installed crapware, ever, and I moved off of windows (long before I moved my family). The amount of time spent troubleshooting issues was always non negligible. Today, on Mac I wan wake up, open the lid and start coding. With windows, I used to be afraid of even closing the lid the night before. The amount of peace of mind I get today, and the time I save? Macs could cost 2x more and I still would be saving money. Funny thing is, before I moved to macs, I used to not like them at al, mainly because the entire UI/UX was different. But then I got used to it, and huge productivity boosts like spotlight (don't get me started on windows search + all the indexing while searching), silent almost never activating fans, like confidently leaving the house for 5 hours without having to carry a charger (try that with a powerful windows laptop), being able to drop the thing without having to worry about buying a new one, and a 1000 other little things that really add up. My point is, the reason there are apple fanboys is not because they're a great company, or they pretend to want to save the planet, or because of "one last thing" or whatever, it's because of all these small things that add up to just letting you do your work and forget about the machine. I'm an engineer and I don't want to think about my machine. Imagine what my mother feels.
- figassis 3y agoI would not. I never bought laptops under $1000. I know what to buy and I'd almost always customize specs for the person that needed it (spend more on ram, graphics, cpu, cooling for my architect sibling). Still, 3 year expiration. Starts with fragmentation (you end up having to defrag more and more frequently), every app you install makes the system less stable (messes up the registry, add/removes some random and critical .DLL), uninstalling doesn't necessarily fix. There's this accelerated entropy on windows PCs that I had just had enough of. Don't get me started on the update reboots when you really need to get work done. On the long startup times even when you clear out the startup items, the never knowing if a reboot will actually be that or a BSOD. If you're helping someone remotely and they say "It's asking me to reboot", you know you'll have to drive to them to help it back up.
- the_overseer 3y agoDefrag in 2023? On a SSD? Really?
- figassis 3y agoI moved off of windows a while ago, last windows I seriously worked on was 7. When the metro stuff started coming around I was on my way out. I never really used 10 (did that exist, was it skipped?) or 11, only set it up for others, very quickly so I didn't have to spend any more time on it, and the dark patterns regarding online accounts as well as the start menu ads just reassured me I'd made the right decision.
- jeroenhd 3y agoYour experiences sound like they were based on Windows 7. Defragmentation hasn't been an issue in at least a decade unless you bought real cheap hardware. The DLL issues bring back memories of Windows XP and Vista, even Windows 7 had SFC and other proactive system protection mechanisms. Windows 10 came out with a task manager that shows you exactly what's slowing down startup. I don't know what hardware you bought, but BSODs have become so rare that I don't even remember what Windows 11's BSOD screen looks like, and I'm pretty sure Windows 10's changed since I last saw it. From what you're describing, I doubt your experiences were with modern releases of Windows.