8 ms·
So where are we all supposed to go now?
- f0ld 3y agoSome kind of wikipedia(for dummies) centric forum + news would be great. Nowadays I just browse wikipedia but it’s a bit verbose for my taste.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoHaving been a vigorous Discord user for years: Discord sucks. Its so time inefficient (yet engaging) that I had to delete the apps from my phone and desktop for my own sake. And don't even get me started on the difficulty of actually finding niche information.
- 23B1 3y agoThe Discord UX alone keeps me off it. Slack has the superior interface but with the Salesforce acquisition, I doubt it'll last for long. They've already snuffed out several communities' utility with their pricing plans.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoActually I think the UI is pretty good compared to, say, modern Reddit. The usage patterns are the problem.
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoHah, while I find Discord UI quite awful, Reddit is worse. People keep telling me Reddit is this fantastic resource, but every time I look I find things with just a few trivial or wrong answers. Maybe I'm holding it wrong.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoYeah I feel the same way about Reddit. Most of the comments are not helpful, many are straight up incorrect, and I don't get the "Google is a Reddit search engine" meme at all. There are some niches that consolidate useful info there, like fandoms or weird topics/frameworks that are discussed nowhere else, but sadly that is largely moving to Discord.
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoMaybe I'm just getting old, but I find Discord to be utterly confusing. I use it reluctantly when there's a community that uses it, but I don't enjoy using it.
- draw_down 3y agoI still enjoy twitter, I find its death greatly exaggerated.
- PointThink 3y agoI could say the same about reddit except for the "enjoy" part. I imagine that in a while people will give up on finding alternatives and go back to reddit. Unless reddit keeps doing more stupid stuff it's not going away anytime soon.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoThis is the story of Reddit for years. The best case trajectory for Reddit is Facebook's: a highly populated corporate cesspool of low quality leftovers. But that really is the best case, as Reddit doesn't have the "my family and my boss are on Facebook, so I have to be there" effect that Facebook has. It really does rely on some threshold of quality posts.
- draw_down 3y ago[dead]
- spike021 3y agoOther than the rate limit issue this past Saturday I haven't really had any problems with it. I still self-curate who I follow with follow lists. I still get to be involved in baseball discussions with friends who have stuck it out there. I'm also able to continue following a large Japanese car community, especially friends I've made when visiting for that hobby. It's still a very useful place to be. You just have to do some work sometimes (follow lists, mute/blocklist words/phrases, etc.) to keep yourself more isolated from things you don't want to see.
- hospitalJail 3y agoIf you want to follow domestic US politics/rage bait, I imagine you are having a good time. After the facebook stuff of 2016-2020, I went to twitter trying to avoid ragebait, it was there too. Its not dead, its just not helpful. You get way better stuff from individual subreddits. You get even better stuff reading a non-fiction book. Reddit's app suggests rage-bait which is why its become so bad.
- skilled 3y agoSomeone maintains a list on Gist, https://gist.github.com/zpangwin/8be46c8314d3288504f13863d9fbae1b https://gist.github.com/zpangwin/8be46c8314d3288504f13863d9f... It's quite a bit of federated stuff in there, but some "decent" links too. The problem is that I can spin up a phpBB instance and create an IRC channel, but are you going to come? It's a rhetorical question. For it to even work there needs to be a cause, otherwise you're sitting like ducks waiting for some cool shit to happen. And the new generation has no idea what those two social platforms even are... good luck onboarding a zoomer on a phpBB forum to "socialize". But I'd love to see where else people are hanging out outside of HN, maybe there are some hidden gems out there that I could consider joining. Fediverse/Discord/Slack are a no go for me, don't enjoy them at all.
- EA-3167 3y agoTo be honest, the ability to effortlessly repel Zoomers strikes me as a feature, not a bug.
- spike021 3y agoI don't see what this has to do with Zoomers, to be honest. If we're going to bring up generations, I'm a millennial who basically grew up on IRC and vBulletin forums. In fact, I'm still a fairly active participant in IRC, and I am definitely one in a vBulletin based board for a certain car. But I vastly prefer the experience of having a central place of communities like Reddit for all its problems. Moderation system tends to be consistent, you don't get random changes by negligent administrators adding full screen ads that can get past ad blockers, knowledge/discussion isn't ephemeral like it is on IRC (sure you can log but not everyone likes or wants to for various reasons).
- hospitalJail 3y agoWe are already doing it. We are becoming the old dudes making fun of the next generation. Right on time. Better to say things like: Young people are too idealistic or have a different sense of humor. They learn from us, not the other way around.
- yetanotherloser 3y agoOutside. There's even a nice blue ceiling (or, for British users, a nice grey ceiling)
- 23B1 3y agoOutside has a killer graphics card and zero lag.
- function_seven 3y agoYeah, but the settings are almost non-existent, and the NPCs constantly ignore them anyway. Also, no respawn. Lame.
- npsimons 3y ago> zero lag. Obviously you aren't drinking enough.
- spacemadness 3y agoNobody will listen to ones unhinged rants outside though. Instead of being upvoted people just look at them funny.
- yetanotherloser 3y agoI thought that was a plus?
- qbrass 3y agoWhere do you even get a soapbox sturdy enough to stand on these days?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jareklupinski 3y agomaybe i'll even buy a newspaper while I'm out there! they still make those right?
- oidar 3y agoI've been enjoying Metafilter again after many years, and also Tildes. There are well established forums for my interests that were always bigger than they were on reddit. I have some Tildes invites if anyone wants them.
- byronvickers 3y agoI'm very much a lurker in online spaces (this is the first comment I've ever made in HN!) but I've found the atmosphere on tiles very appealing. I'd love an invite if you'd be willing to share. You can contact me at <my username> at gmail.
- icebergonfire 3y ago> I have some Tildes invites if anyone wants them. I'd love a Tildes invite if you still have one to share. My email is on my HN profile.
- Backing5890 3y agoIf you have any extras I would love one! - tildesinvite.yx13z@simplelogin.com
- baumandm 3y agoI'd appreciate an invite if you have any left, my email is on my HN profile.
- mandmandam 3y agoI'd love one, please. Can be reached at mtiga at duck.icom, without both of the i's.
- rapid_onset 3y agoI would love to have an invite! I love the feel of tildes.net; feels like the old internet. Email: myalias.quickstep124@silomails.com
- shaunkoh 3y agoAlso looking for Tildes invites, if anyone has one!
- dimmke 3y agoSometimes I think about Gravatar. Like it was such a simple concept but made sense and saw huge adoption. It seems like the main bottleneck all new platforms face is getting people to sign up. That’s why OAuth is so popular. It makes me wonder if Gravatar had not been acquired and had expanded into being a service where the whole point is that you have an account that you can expand and withdrawal from various services, it would have been so much better positioned than more recent attempts or what became OAuth.
- DHPersonal 3y agoThat’s what I hoped the fediverse was promising to users: one account, cross-instance.
- didntcheck 3y agoAnd this is why IMO Lemmy is overcomplicating things. People are conflating single sign on (easy, relatively) with server-to-server federation (hard and resource intensive. Jumping straight into fairly deep waters of distributed systems) Federation makes sense for Mastodon, since you boost (retweet) other people and reply to them, but Reddit communities are not linked like that. The only way they're connected is by hyperlinking, an aggregated front page, consistent UX or API, and shared user accounts. All of which can be done with entirely independent servers and OpenID/OAuth
- gremlinsinc 3y agoI'm building a new protocol that adds a centralized DAO server for essentially auth, and name reservations for different taxonomies or purposes like subreddits, usernames, tags, anything really you'd be able to create unique taxonomies that could be tied to your apps. I want essentially to allow federation but with a single archival source of truth. Just in beginning stages though.
- jFriedensreich 3y agoRushkoff would say well social media is like the missionaries, when they leave, next comes AI, the conquistadors for the kill. https://youtu.be/RCVXaqSEqmI?t=676 https://youtu.be/RCVXaqSEqmI?t=676
- ix-ix 3y agoI have been browsing Tiles a lot and love it. Anyone got an invite?
- tacker2000 3y agoSince Apollo shut down ive been checking out lemmy.world (via wefwef.app[1], a web client app thats almost a carbon copy clone of Apollo) and I guess im slowly getting how the whole thing works, and into this whole fediverse thing. Whilst there it not much content right now, you can experience first hand how the old communities you had on Reddit are being recreated there. It’s kind of fascinating to watch and you also slowly realze that maybe it might be actually a great thing if the content is not going owned by any single company and that what happened with reddit could never happen here. But who knows? [1] http://wefwef.app http://wefwef.app
- hashtag-til 3y agowefwef.app are going to realise they have a real naming issue if it ever make into some relevant user base.
- standardUser 3y agoThe article is supposed to be about the "downfall of social networks" but somehow manages to ignore the fact that Facebook, Instagram and Tik Tok are all still thriving with no end in sight. It's basically trying to say that because Reddit is struggling with profitability and Twitter is struggling with being bought by a petty jackass, social networks are in precipitous decline? But I barely think of Reddit or Twitter as social networks. I use the former as a resource for niche topics and I avoid the latter at all costs because it's full of bots and repetitive political crybabies. Yet me and everyone I know engages with some combo of FB/Insta/TikTok several times every day, just like we have for years and years.
- o0banky0o 3y agoFacebook instagram and tiktok, as you say, do not have the same searchable level of useful information in super niche subjects, which turns out to be the crucial difference afaic, the rest is noise.
- ulfw 3y agoI don't see Facebook (the core, original product) thriving. At least when it comes to actual engagement, I haven't seen any in years. None of my hundreds of "friends" posts anything anymore and we've been there since the Stanford days.
- standardUser 3y ago
- weevil 3y agoThe decline of social network monopolies will also see a decline in mass political influence in the form of international content farms pumping out propaganda, and grassroots organisations trying to save us from burning down the planet. It feels like the balance of political discourse and its capacity for abuse wobbles and wavers over time, but ultimately they cancel each other out. I'm looking forward to a world beyond parallel societies operating on the internet for the profit of one or two companies.
- rchaud 3y agoI wouldn't hold out too much hope. The most egregious propaganda has long since shifted to non-clearweb channels like Telegram and Whatsapp groups.
- pessimizer 3y agoThe decline of individual social networks leads to social network monopolies, it doesn't damage them.
- satvikpendem 3y agoI've been enjoying tildes.net a lot, especially after the Reddit debacle. It's more like HN in that there are much fewer jokes and pun threads than reddit.
- rapid_onset 3y agoYes
- dtx1 3y agoNerds screaming for decades: The lock-in effect of the big companies will bite you in the ass. Normies: But it's so easy and i can't be bothered to understand what i am doing anyway. Go away ...The inevitable happens... Normies: Where are we all supposed to go now? Rinse and Repeat.
- filoleg 3y ago> Normies: But it's so easy and i can't be bothered to understand what i am doing anyway. Go away An alternative reading: Nerds screaming for decades: why make things easy for normies, they just need to git good. Poor UX is a feature, not a bug, and it doesn't matter anyway. Normies: lol ok sure. P.S. To add to the horse that is already beaten to death many times over: "just set up a cron job to rsync your files to a remote linux storage server, who needs a cloud storage solution with simple and easy to understand UX anyway, anyone can (and cares to) do it, just git good".
- dtx1 3y agoI read that as > The Free shit they make for us must be trivial to use and for free and i wont give them any money to develop it to solve the problem. I'd rather get exploited by megacorps for free and complain that they treat me like cattle hope they like to grass they get fed
- filoleg 3y agoHow does poor UX and difficulty of use have anything to do with free vs paid? That's an entirely orthogonal problem. I, personally, am in the camp of people willing to pay for non-shit services that let me avoid ads and other annoyances coming from something being "free". And I vote with my wallet too, which is why I pay for YT Premium and never have to think about the whole ad debacle with YT. Because yeah, "free" tends to come at a cost.
- dtx1 3y agoBecause Good UX cost development time that has to be paid by someone. Nothing can compete with the lock-in and network effect these megacorps have. We have four choices to deal with that: * Close your eyes, cry about bad UX and continue to be treated like literal cattle by them. * Push for legislation that forces these services to be paid only thus making competition on the grounds of how they treat their users possible again * Collectively decide to use and finance free, federated, semi-selfhosted open alternatives (see crying about bad UX on that front) * Stop using them at all And even youtube premium is just paying to be a cattle. Youtube has enormous lock-in power already and I can't even count the amount of fuckups, anti-consumer features and violations of their users and "partners" they have commited. I am done regarding the petty complaints of the cattle users that don't want to understand, can't be bothered to consider the effects they have.
- gochi 3y agoThis article was a culture shock. Did people actually used to believe places like Reddit or Twitter were "healthy good places" to spend your time? I thought we were all on the same page for once, in recognizing that while social networks have some benefits for the most part they are deeply unhealthy places due to how every one of them is built around ad views or subscriptions. This is partially why I don't really care about the downfall of any of these platforms, they were always replaceable and never all that beneficial. Rather than tightly weave my identity to a platform, I'll just do what I've been doing which is browsing different platforms and posting what I want to them. More should adopt this viewpoint, so the next time a platform collapses on itself as they usually do they don't feel so... lost.
- npsimons 3y ago> Did people actually used to believe places like Reddit or Twitter were "healthy good places" to spend your time? If you never curated your reddit experience, I could see how you might have this attitude. I won't deny that /r/popular and /r/all are rage inducing dumpster fires. But if you create an account and join subreddits, just going to https://www.reddit.com/ https://www.reddit.com/ takes you to a selection just from those subreddits. And there are a large number of wholesome, nurturing, even useful subreddits. In some respects, it is like Usenet used to be. > never all that beneficial. Google would disagree, after the recent blackouts. There's a lot of useful information going on in various subreddits - to the point that some posts on specific topics compete for stack answers in search rankings! Hell, I've found more useful Common Lisp resources in the Lisp subreddits than I ever found on HN, and better solutions to (some) problems than on stack.
- gochi 3y agoI have curated my experience. Including tiny subs dedicated to niches. I still don't see it as a healthy good place to spend my time. What's worse, is the platform encourages these subs to spread, become unmaintainable to the core moderation group, and eventually becomes yet another dumpster fire. Everyone always loves to believe their sub won't change. Why are we bothering wasting resources on reddit, when what we actually want is a maintained wiki page? >Google would disagree Only because Google has ignored their search engine problem for years before Reddit existed, and sees absolutely no problem in promoting the most random of sites as long as the content technically exists on the page. At this point, I'm not sure they want to solve the problem, due to the revenue gained by encouraging prioritized ad placements. Don't even get me started on the absurd levels of misinformation. Not even related to politics, it's everything. The posturing as experts when they're 15 year olds. The encouraging of buying this over that, without letting others know they work for that company. So much of the "useful information" on reddit is misjudged that way because of the pseudo-anonymous structure that encourages people to turn off their brain and believe everything they read. By the way this isn't an argument in support of non-anonymous platforms, only that the way people interact with Reddit is quite harmful and not sure many recognize that.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- floren 3y agoUsenet. What's that, nobody's posting? Well... post something. Yes, spam, but it turns out to be trivial to filter.
- bane 3y agoThe lesson I'm taking from this is that companies are good at building a public commons, but absolutely terrible stewards of it over the long run. It sort of makes sense, if a local government, or a university wants to build a physical commons, they hire out to companies to design, build, etc. the space, but then ownership transfers over to the organizer of interest such as the government who then manage it in perpetuity.
- datavirtue 3y agoI'm all for everyone going private. You can bounce from black-hole to black-hole and talk to people you want to talk to. The problem has been mass, public adoption. We learned our lesson. Bring on the invite-only revolution.
- rchaud 3y agoHow about websites try cultivating their own audiences in the comments section and messageboards, which was the default until these sites decided that getting traffic from social was all that mattered? 10 years ago The Verge had a thriving comments section, with an audience that migrated from Engadget and Gizmodo. There was even a messageboard to discuss topics in more detail. It ended up getting closed. These days the comments sections on Verge stories are largely dead.
- tacker2000 3y agoA lot of sites have big comments sections with high quality answers, like the FT. But of course you are always posting at the behest of their mods and on some stories you cant post at all.
- rchaud 3y agoThat's better than nothing. Hopefully it's better than the WSJ's, which appears to be restricted to subscribers yet is still pretty toxic.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bediger4000 3y ago> it’s shifting from growth and engagement, which broadly involves building good products that people like, to increasing revenue no matter the tradeoff; In short, shifting to Doctorow's "enshittification".
- dahwolf 3y ago"So where are we all supposed to go now?" Important to understand that the word "we" in this article means chronically online tech journalists angry at Twitter.
- BasedAnon 3y agoback in the olden days we had a thing called a forum, they were much better
- tb_technical 3y ago4chan
- rsynnott 3y ago[The monkey's paw curls, and another social network from Facebook appears] (This seems to have been written shortly before Threads showed up)
- sotajensede 3y agoIn the 5th paragraph and in the title subtext, the author bemoans the fact that all of the other for-profit social media websites are for entertainment. This reeks of echo chamber nonsense to me. ALL social media is essentially entertainment for ~98% of users if they are honest with themselves. There are absolutely cases where Facebook is used to keep in touch and keep track of family and friends, certain Reddit communities can be a resource for hobbyists and professionals, Twitter contains breaking news. But the majority of page views on all of these platforms are for entertainment and always have been. If you consider these platforms to be important professional and/or technical tools, you probably aren't a frequent user and only go there via Google search or you are a writer for the Verge or some other publication that takes itself too seriously.
- kgwxd 3y agoLemmy has been great. Only been on about a week, haven't missed Reddit even a litte, and I was a friggin' addict. Mastodon too, been on there for a few years but I don't use it much, I was off Twitter long before that even came around and I wasn't really looking for a replacement. Watching all the various types of assholes fail to gain any foothold in the fediverse, while simultaneously watching them implode the current mainstream platforms, is very refreshing.