14 ms·
Oregon County Sues BP, Chevron, Shell, Exxon for $51B Climate Damages
- nullc 3y agoPerhaps they should adopt contract terms to prevent their products from being sold or used in Multnomah county, it's only reasonable that they should seek to mitigate the risk of the plaintiffs claiming an ever increasing amount of damages.
- di456 3y ago“We are confident that, once we show what the fossil fuel companies knew about global warming and when, and what they did to deny, delay and deceive the public, the jury will not let the fossil fuel companies get away with their reckless misconduct.”
- nroets 3y agoOil companies also know that their products are critical to the production and distribution of food and a long list of other modern day necessities. Should they cease operation and let us starve ?
- d4mi3n 3y agoI think the argument here is that they shouldn’t deceive the public about the realities of their operations in order to raise or sustain their profits. If the service is essential, the consumers of said goods can make their own decisions about how essential they are without all the smoke and mirrors.
- nroets 3y ago"An inconvenient truth" and Greta Thunberg hardly had any effect in changing policy. So don't tell me the lies of the oil companies had any effect on policy. Congress saw the conflict of interest, but didn't want to do anything that raise gas prices.
- tfourb 3y agoyou can’t definitively prove or disprove that. What you can prove is that oil companies actively deceived consumers about negative externalities associated with their product.
- d4mi3n 3y agoI don’t disagree with you, but I also don’t believe allowing or continuing to normalize deception of the general public is an acceptable status quo. Congress and the public may decide what level of non-renewable energy sources is acceptable to them. But they should not need to do so while being burdened by deliberate campaigns to misinform them or muddy the waters.
- matzab 3y agoThat's a brilliant excuse: Lie about the effects of emissions, lobby (and pay) Congress to not do anything about it (or change incentives to maybe use less gas rather than more) and then, when you are getting sued, just argue that the lying didn't affect policy, so it was perfectly fine.
- tzs 3y agoHave you considered the possibility that Gore and Thunberg have had little success in changing policy because of things like the lies of oil companies?
- elchief 3y agoYa we didn't have food before oil...
- Rodeoclash 3y agoI would normally take the effort to explain this but I don't think you'd get it.
- adastra22 3y agoWe didn’t. Not at the scale seen in the 20th and 21st centuries. You could use every acre of land to produce food for humans using the best traditional farming techniques, and only feed 4 billion people. There literally wasn’t enough biomass and replenishing reactions. The other half would have to starve. What feeds the world today? Fixed nitrogen fertilizers made out of the combination of air and fossil fuels.
- zelphirkalt 3y agoIf only we had never increased in population count that much. We would have spared the planet from many ecological disasters. A population of 4 billion sounds like a dream right now.
- adastra22 3y agoAre you really saying the universe would be better off without 4 billion people? Each with their own hopes, dreams, families, and hobbies. Whatever value you ascribe to nature only exists because we people are here to witness it. Doubling the number of people doubles the number of sentient beings bringing light and value to the world. I seriously cannot fathom how someone could say that the world is better off if people didn't exist. What value system justifies that mass murder through erasure?
- acdha 3y agoI agree with the value of people but would factor quality of life in. We’re currently projected to have something like a billion people seriously disrupted by climate change and all of us noticeably worse off which puts you in questions like how much human misery undercuts that. Obviously the solution isn’t “kill 4B” and especially because the climate impacts and causes are very unevenly impacted - 300M Americans have generated more greenhouse gases than the billions in Africa or Asia who are being impacted first.
- whatever1 3y agoNo but they should at least not do buybacks and pay dividends, before cleaning up the mess that their production & product causes. This way an even competition field would form. Oil drilling is not a ludicrous business if you consider the actual costs for production (aka capturing carbon, decommissioning rigs, cleaning up production sites).
- bruce511 3y agoThen surely you must blame investors? Let's say Shell suspended all dividends indefinitely. What would your advice to your pension fund be? Sell Shell and buy BP? Would Shell's ability to function exist if they became a non-profit and a share price of 0? Does Saudia-Arabia pay for the clean-up of say Australia? Does the US pay for the clean-up of Uraguay? Does the explorer, producer or consumer bear the clean-up responsibility?
- whatever1 3y agoInvestors do whatever is optimal for them. The duty of the market regulators is to ensure an even playing field, so that the investors are not deceived about the profitability of businesses. Thankfully the US has a lot of say in the global oil supply and demand market. We already have rules & taxes in place for all the producers and importers of oil in the US (aka they need to buy certificates for blending renewable fuels mostly from US produced corn). So yes, it is feasible, it is done already.
- mbgerring 3y agoThe word “critical” used in this sentence suggests there is no way to produce or distribute food or other commodities without fossil fuels, which is plainly, obviously false.
- andsoitis 3y agoTo produce and distribute food for the world’s population without fossil fuels, would not be practical. Should we halt all space exploration and aviation until neither require fossil fuels? Perhaps someday in the future it would be, and we should work towards it, but note that oil bootstrapped a lot of modern way of life.
- throwaway69123 3y agoIf it’s plainly false you’ll have no trouble explaining how, plainly. How do we feed the worlds population without fossil fuel produced fertilisers and fossil fuel distribution
- tfourb 3y agoBy that logic everything that has any positive externality at all would be legal. The plaintiffs specifically argue that the companies behaved recklessly motivated by profit seeking. They actively misled the public about a negative externality associated with their product. That is basically the same argument that plaintiffs made against tobacco companies. Cigarettes were legal, they brought satisfaction to consumers, but the producers actively misled their customers about negative side effects in a reckless manner.
- andsoitis 3y ago> By that logic everything that has any positive externality at all would be legal. It sounds like you’re arguing that products made by oil companies should be outlawed? So no more petroleum and petroleum products? Or am I misconstruing the implication of your argument?
- tfourb 3y agoCigarettes are still legal and oil should remain so but the price of oil should include its cost to society, not only profit maximization considerations.
- outside1234 3y agoThe argument should be that these externalities get priced into oil to help with climate change effects and transitioning to clean energy. The analog I think are cigarettes and how we have taxed them out of existence
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoSadly, the solution we adopted for cigarettes, namely letting them still profit by poisoning the children of the developing world, won't work for climate change as we share the same atmosphere with them.
- swader999 3y ago[flagged]
- onion2k 3y agoUnless they gave their oil away for free, they already did.
- flanked-evergl 3y agoNo they did not, they invoiced for the oil, not the externalities of its use. Saving a life is an externality just as someone dying from a heat wave.
- onion2k 3y agoSaving a life isn't an externality though. It's very much an 'internality' - it's the reason why people use oil for heating when it's extremely cold. You can't claim people used oil to keep warm and then claim 'not dying from cold' is an external benefit of the product. Edit: Actually you can claim that but only if Exxon weren't aware that not dying from cold is a benefit of heating, like they claim they weren't aware that climate change is a downside of their products. Are you saying people who work in the oil industry are really that stupid?
- imtringued 3y agoYou are aware that in economics, prices are supposed to reflect differences in utility and marginal costs, right? If there is an overproduction of a given product then prices tend toward marginal costs, if there is a shortage they tend towards marginal utility. Oil companies tend to be very profitable because they get to monetize their land usage rights over oil bearing land. Their marginal costs are very low, basically just the cost of extraction of what was already there. They don't have to pay the plants. The marginal utility is defined by the best possible uses and guess what, saving a live is one of the best possible uses for a resource so people are willing to pay for it, possibly up to everything they have. Your objection is that the price is somewhere between what the marginal cost and utilities dictate. There is a consumer and a producer surplus and you argue that oil is cheap in comparison to how much people are willing to pay to save a life and this must be some huge consumer surplus that the oil company is responsible for. Except the company isn't responsible for its low marginal costs, it didn't pay the plants it is digging up. The market for life saving oil is oversaturated because there is not much oil that is directly allocated toward saving lives. Burning oil to keep yourself warm on an especially cold day isn't the same as heating your home every winter day so it is as comfortable as the summer. Nor is heating an overly large house life saving. You could have used an electric blanket instead to save your life. Since you only need to heat your own body, the amount of energy is insignificant. So the price of oil is mostly reflecting its low utility (compared to saving a life) and low marginal costs. So it appears that in very specific circumstances the consumer surplus is really high. An objection against consumer surpluses isn't an argument against carbon taxes because they tax the usage, aka the burning, of fossil fuels and not its production. For taxing production you would need a land value tax or a resource extraction tax. Carbon taxes reduce globally harmful uses of fossil fuel at the expense of reducing individual consumer surpluses.
- aliasxneo 3y agoIt was a crazy day for sure, my city was the hottest place on planet Earth for that one day.
- nosefurhairdo 3y agoCold-related deaths may outnumber heat-related deaths by a factor of 20. Source: https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(15)60897-2/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...
- tfourb 3y agoWhat are you even attempting to argue? From your source: "However, if—as the data seem to show—extreme cold is relatively unimportant, then a few degrees of warming will not yield a large reduction in cold-related mortality. Moreover, if extreme heat is important, then the same few additional degrees might cause a substantial increase in heat-related mortality."
- nosefurhairdo 3y agoMy point is if you want damages from energy companies for deaths from warming then they should bill you for deaths prevented from cold. It's preposterous to think humans would be better off with less or more expensive energy. In a broader historical context, the only people who believe this are the most privileged people to have ever lived.
- tfourb 3y agoAnd maybe the people who never had reliable access to energy but suffer the consequences of excessive CO2 emissions? There are quite a few of them. As is argued elsewhere in this topic, energy companies already have billed everyone for the benefits provided by their product. What the lawsuit is alleging is that they haven't taken responsibility for recklessly misleading the public about negative externalities associated with their product and that they should be punished for it.
- nosefurhairdo 3y agoWhy stop at suing energy producers? Let's sue energy consumers too! Everyone knows their energy consumption contributes to emissions contributes to warming, so aren't consumers similarly liable? Utterly asinine. One of few legitimate roles of government regulation is to address issues of externalities. This is an issue to address with regulation, not litigation.
- oh_sigh 3y agoI can see the evidence that some parts of the oil companies tried to hide the concept of global warming and oil's impact on it. However, considering the fact that global warming has been well known to the public for decades, and we still haven't taken any kind of drastic action to prevent it, can any damage really be attributable to the oil companies? Should the oil companies have hid the data on global warming? No. Would the world be any different if they didn't try to hide the data? Also no.
- hunson_abadeer 3y agoThe usual rule of civil lawsuits is that you sue whoever has the money.
- pjmlp 3y agoThe wonders of US legal system. Most of the lawsuits would be laugh out of court in most jurisdictions across the globe.
- xapata 3y ago> Would the world be any different if they didn't try to hide the data? Also no. I think they're asserting that the world would have been different. I find it plausible, if not certain.
- zelphirkalt 3y agoThe point is that they systematically tried and succeeded to create doubt about climate change, when they knew well, that climate heating is happening. They actively mislead many people, who would rather grasp for the comfortable alternative lies than face the reality. They actively spent and did spend huge amounts of money to influence politicians to tell their "there is no climate change" or " it is all natural and normal" or "this would have happened even without humans" naratives.
- tppiotrowski 3y agoI'd be very interested in the testimony in this case as it seems that the plaintiffs argue that 100+ deaths during 2021 PNW heatwave were caused by global warming. I'm not sure what argument you make. Climate is different from weather and there have been extreme temperature events throughout history. Furthermore, how do you account for natural releases of methane or the whole cow farting angle? How do you establish responsibility, etc.
- tfourb 3y agoClimate change increases the number and severity of extreme weather events in a given year. That is well documented by now. So you can’t attribute all heat wave deaths to climate change, but you you can have a high confidence in attributing some of them. You can also quantify the contribution of individual companies to historical CO2 emissions. As long as the court follows that basic logic (and courts in other countries have done so) I don’t see a problem.
- bruce511 3y agoAh, but do you ascribe blame to the fuel producers? Or the fuel burners? As a liquid it's not a problem. Burning it is the problem. Therefore should it not be the burners who are responsible? Perhaps the county should just ban the burning of fool fuels. If its causing do many local deaths then surely that's the logical first step? Or would that just be political suicide?
- tfourb 3y agoThe plaintiffs in this case do not argue that one or another party is responsible for the ultimate emission of CO2. They argue that the oil companies recklessly and with the aim of increasing their profits deceived the public about negative externalities associated with burning oil/diesel/gasoline/etc. And that this reckless behavior led to certain damages for which the companies should now be punished both to help pay for consequences and to deter similar behavior by these and other companies in the future. I am not a lawyer so I don't know if this legal theory will hold up in court or if a jury will follow these arguments. But on a personal and moral level it makes sense to me.
- dudeinjapan 3y agoThey should sue everyone who drives a car. They are the ones who are combusting the oil and releasing CO2.
- legitster 3y agoPresident Biden literally just gave a speech months ago demanding oil companies increase production and lower prices. Energy companies would have been happy to push solar or nuclear everywhere if there was any market/regulatory demand that justified the effort. Even if oil companies decided that "oops, we shouldn't exist" and decided to cut production to zero and give back their shares to everyone (which is arguably what they have been trying to do until the current administration began threatening them), that vacuum would have to be filled with something. And it would probably be filled with a nationalized oil company that is un-sue-able like most of the rest of the world has.
- elchief 3y agoThat argument worked great at Nuremberg
- legitster 3y ago???? To the best of my mind there is not a developmental need or even a market demand for war crimes and genocide. I really have no idea what kind of equivocation you are trying to make.
- mcpackieh 3y agoIt isn't illegal for oil companies to produce oil, so they have no legal obligation to refuse such a demand from the POTUS. The superior orders defense for producing oil isn't relevant because producing oil isn't an offense in the first place. Maybe it should be illegal to produce oil, but even if such laws are eventually passe they won't be retroactive. Ex post facto laws are unconstitutional for good reason.
- KingLancelot 3y ago[dead]
- dehrmann 3y agoI'm somewhat sympathetic to this because oil companies suppressed research, but society has known about this risk for a long time and benefited from oil. I put more of the fault with consumers, voters, and lawmakers. Oil companies just produced when they asked for.
- tfourb 3y agoThere is enough blame to go around but simply ignoring the responsibility of oil companies doesn't serve the debate, either. By that logic, the producers of Zyklon-B should have been cleared of any wrongdoing because they simply satisfied the Nazi regime's demand for a nerve agent to kill people in concentration camps. Simply ignoring severe known negative externalities associated with your product should always come with legal liability.
- sBqQu3U0wH 3y agoZyklon-B is not a "nerve agent" and was primarily used as a pesticide.
- tfourb 3y agoYou are correct sorry for the mixup (I guess "blood agent" would be more correct). Its primary use is of no consequence for this analogy, though. The company that manufactured Zyklon-B did provide it to concentration camps knowing it would be used to harm people and the executives responsible for this decision were sentenced by allied justices to death and prison terms as a consequence.
- footlose_3815 3y agoThose poor oil companies and their windfall profits somebody should help them out
- mattm 3y agoThe makers of opioids are just producing what they asked for too. Companies should be expected to pay the true cost of what they produce and not have it be borne by the rest of society.
- CSMastermind 3y agoThis is an emotionally and politically charged topic that can be hard to discuss with any clarity. The Skeptoid episode What the Oil Companies Really Knew, part 2 of which can be found here: https://skeptoid.com/episodes/4877 https://skeptoid.com/episodes/4877, can be a good starting point because it is at least an attempt to try and provide a fair and factual overview. I think this passage is particularly relevant: > The message received from actually reading all of these documents is not — as is commonly reported — that oil executives' own scientists were warning them of the true nature of climate change. Instead, what they indicate is a broad pattern of scientists who were either outside their discipline or among the outliers who were unconcerned with the anthropogenic portion of CO2 buildup, advising those executives that no action was currently warranted. They were wrong, make no mistake; but that's what they were saying, and that's the information the oil companies were acting upon, at least through the end of the 20th century. > There's a point I've tried to make any number of times on Skeptoid, and that's if you want your argument to be robust and persuasive, don't include any bad evidence. Include only strong evidence that has been proven to survive scrutiny. If you present cherrypicked quotes, like the authors of so many of these articles have been doing, it is very easy for your opponents to discover that; and when they do, the only point you will have made is that your argument is weak and easily countered — and thus probably false. It's a bad time in human history to harm the cause of educating people about global warming.
- zackees 3y ago[flagged]
- 411111111111111 3y agoLiterally all of your links are dead. Is this an LLM hallucinating non-existing evidence?
- NavinF 3y agoFirst link is dead, but the two Twitter links work if you're logged in
- 3y ago
- thedaly 3y agoBetter be careful or the attorneys could end up like Steven Donziger, an attorney who won a huge settlement from Cheveron, and has been fighting them in court ever since.
- jcranmer 3y agoSigh. Journalists who discuss a lawsuit without linking to the actual lawsuit in question... The lawsuit appears to be available at https://multco-web7-psh-files-usw2.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/s3fs-public/Complaint_0.pdf https://multco-web7-psh-files-usw2.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.co.... Heading straight for end and looking at the causes of action: 1. Intentional and negligent creation of public nuisance. The nuisance appears to be extreme climate events, and I'm doubtful that you could actually show sufficient action on the part of the oil companies to link them to the extreme climate events (the standard is probably that you need to show that but for the actions of the companies, those events wouldn't have happened and... yeah, that kind of direct attribution isn't possible). 2. Negligence. I mean, this section is a mere page long, and doesn't go into any detail whatsoever, so it's hard to even figure out what is the supposed duty that wasn't done. So... almost certainly going to die on a motion for dismissal. 3. Fraud and deceit, in that they covered up the effects of climate change. Except that's not fraud--fraud requires that someone be reliant on the lie to do something. So you'd need to show that, e.g., someone only bought a tank from gas from Exxon because Exxon said climate change didn't exist. I suppose it's possible that's true--there's millions of people in the country after all--but... that's not really something that happens (least of all, anything actually alleged in the complaint, so far as I can thing). 4. Trespass. Wildfires caused by climate change constituted trespass. Cute legal theory, but cute legal theories are almost always tossed out of court quickly. So out of four claims, three of them are dead on arrival, and the first one has an uphill fight. And even if they win, the $50 billion for "abate the nuisance" definitely isn't going to happen, and you're looking more at the actual damages which is apparently around $50 million.
- gnz11 3y ago> Journalists who discuss a lawsuit without linking to the actual lawsuit in question... The website seems like a PR dumping ground. Given the incomplete byline I would highly doubt they are an actual journalist —- more likely a freelance blogger.
- tinco 3y agoWith regards to 1, I think these companies are the wrong ones to target. Oil companies are not the ones who are emitting CO2, they just bring the hydrocarbons to the surface and put it in containers. It's the big buyers of those containers that make the decision to burn the hydrocarbons. Targets of these lawsuits should be energy companies, trucking, shipping, flying, transporting companies. As to 2 it certainly seems like a hard one, but not entirely without merit. Wouldn't it be negligence if you sell a product knowing that your customers are going to use that product to hurt the environment? It's not like a hazardous chemical where you can assume the buyer has processes in place to deal with the results. These companies did the research and they know their product negatively affects the environment when burned, they know the government is not enforcing any checks and balances and still they sell the product to customers who 100% are going to burn the product. In my opinion it's for sure the government and the customers themselves who bear the greatest blame, there's some negligence there. I'm not sure why you're going back on your own argument in 3. I'm sure you could find people whose belief that their buying of oil doesn't affect the climate was cemented by the deceit of those companies. And if someone would start suing companies for negligent burning of hydrocarbons, I'm sure there would be CEO's that would happily point their fingers at the oil companies in accusation of deceit. The trespass one seems ridiculous, I guess because a judge isn't supposed to let frivolous things affect their judgement it's a freebie to throw in? Anyway, 2 and 3 seem to at least have some merit to my untrained eyes. Maybe it's more about sending a message than actually winning a lawsuit? If a judge takes the suit seriously and the oil companies are forced to publicly weasel out of these charges, wouldn't that be some sort of a win for the movement?
- junon 3y agoMan, the fact that intelligent people on HN are still defending oil companies with such fervor makes me incredibly sad.
- Nasrudith 3y agoWilliam Roper: So, now you give the Devil the benefit of law! Sir Thomas More: Yes! What would you do? Cut a great road through the law to get after the Devil? William Roper: Yes, I'd cut down every law in England to do that! Sir Thomas More: Oh? And when the last law was down, and the Devil turned 'round on you, where would you hide, Roper, the laws all being flat? This country is planted thick with laws, from coast to coast, Man's laws, not God's! And if you cut them down, and you're just the man to do it, do you really think you could stand upright in the winds that would blow then? Yes, I'd give the Devil benefit of law, for my own safety's sake!
- monsecchris 3y agoThis website defends big pharma to the death and they behave much worse with more and larger judgements against them.
- xyzelement 3y ago"makes me sad" says more about you then the topic. Clearly there's room for recognizing the value of gasoline and other fuels to our society and for trading off pros and cons of their use. Not having trucks to deliver food to my grocery store would make me "sad" personally.
- imtringued 3y agoCarbon taxes recognize the value of gasoline and other fuels. That is their entire point.
- junon 3y agoYou're putting an awful lot of words in my mouth.
- 3y ago
- mcpackieh 3y ago> Multnomah County is seeking $50 million from the defendants for actual damages from the 2021 record-breaking heat wave. Temperatures in the region reached 116°F, killing 69 people in the county. This is the hottest temperature ever recorded in the county’s history. $51B of damages for ostensibly killing 69 people in that county? This seems farcical, they're shooting for the moon to make headlines, they can't be serious with this. It's a PR/political stunt.
- runeks 3y agoAlso, surely those four companies cannot be solely responsible for the emissions that allegedly caused that heat wave — which is assuming we can even attribute that heat wave solely to global warming. Surely this isn't the first heat wave that have killed people in that area.
- DropInIn 3y agoTheres actually a whole thing in the law about who to sue and how damages are dealt with, specifically that one goes for the Big offender for the full amount and then that party can pursue the smaller offenders to repay thier share of the costs.
- x3874 3y ago[dead]
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y agoFuture headline: Supreme court decision (9-3) says Oregon County can go f*k itself. Majority opinion by Justice Thomas written after he rents his garage out to oil-execs for $10M.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Google234 3y agoOregon County increases taxes to pay for the 10 year lawsuit and everyone claps :) what’s another 0.6% am I right?
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- exabrial 3y agoHow to transfer taxpayer money to your friends: 1. Start by having an official State/County/City forcibly takes money from taxpayer. 2. Lawyer Golf Buddy of said ^ official mentions his yacht isn't new anymore. 3. Said official hires golf buddy to do the legal stuff for some frivolous lawsuit, billing at a discount rate of $750/hour. Good frivolous lawsuits are ones that get the constituents excited yet are completely hopeless. 4. Lawyer golf buddy attempts to milk the hopeless court case as long as possible, as he gets paid no matter what happens. 5. Buy new yacht. Invite government official over after he retires.
- friend_and_foe 3y agoLol good luck. The county should've done their research, that heat dome was a natural occurrence and they will become less common with climate change. But everything is climate change to some people. Perhaps the county owes the oil companies 51 billion for the heat dome that won't happen to them that otherwise would've? I actually hope more of these types of lawsuits come, so that people will begin to cite actual climate science and begin to become aware of what is the result of it and what isn't, like this heat dome.