4 ms·
When someone says, "certain topics will get you banned" that doesn't make me judge the platform, that makes me judge the person. People are going to assume it'
by hinkley 3y ago
When someone says, "certain topics will get you banned" that doesn't make me judge the platform, that makes me judge the person.
People are going to assume it's something you don't want to name, if you won't name it.
- sourcecodeplz 3y agoWhy would you judge the person because some kid somewhere is a trigger happy moderator? What happened to thinking for yourself?
- hinkley 3y ago> What happened to thinking for yourself? What do you think I'm doing, right now? Someone is invoking censorship as a reason not to adopt a new platform. No specifics, just rabble rousing. That's manipulation. Pushing back is thinking for yourself. Or, they are being imprecise and undermining their position, in which case what I said works as advice on further conversations. Either way is thinking.
- pessimizer 3y agoOr they're assuming good faith in their opponents. To not know what has been censored on twitter, and that the recent interest in mastodon was a reaction to the lifting of some of that censorship, is either to be playing stupid or to actually not have the background to discuss the subject usefully.
- hinkley 3y agoWe weren't talking about twitter. We were talking about one Mastodon server defederating another for hate speech. That's not 'some topics'. That's hate speech. If they're talking about some other kind of speech that I might actually care about, they should have mentioned it. Because the next bad one I can think of is even worse than hate speech.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- screye 3y agoCome on, in a lot coastal discourse it is practically taboo to mention vanilla opinions that are held by 70+% of the population. Mastodon instances are largely moderated by people from the other 30%. You are free to judge if you want. But don't pretend this is a violation of publicly accepted morals in the 1st world.
- antiframe 3y agoI am having trouble imagining what you mean. Can you illustrate your point with an example opinion that is held by 70% of the population but is taboo to discuss?
- ploum 3y agoIt is funny how, in their own bubble, people assume that their opinion is held by 70% of the population while it is often the opposite (fun fact: more people voter for Hillary Clinton that Trump yet Trump voters believe that they are the majority. Same for abortion where polls showed that a clear majority of the US was pro-choice yet a very loud minority has a lot of political power)
- murderfs 3y ago86% of Americans think that police funding should increase or stay the same: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/02/03/before-release-of-video-showing-tyre-nichols-beating-public-views-of-police-conduct-had-improved-modestly/ft_2023-02-03_police-conduct_03/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/02/03/before-re... 80% of Americans think that the southern border should have increased security: https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2022/09/08/republicans-and-democrats-have-different-top-priorities-for-u-s-immigration-policy/ft_2022-09-08_immigration_01/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2022/09/08/republica... 50% of Americans oppose affirmative action (with 33% approving, 16% not sure): https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2023/06/08/more-americans-disapprove-than-approve-of-colleges-considering-race-ethnicity-in-admissions-decisions/pp_2023-06-08_college-admissions_00-01/ https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2023/06/08/more-america...
- 3y ago
- redox99 3y agoWhen you name something, then it becomes a flamewar about that something. But generally speaking, anything that the US/"San Francisco" left wing ideology deems "bad" is generally unwelcome.
- echelon 3y agoI'm LGBT and my spouse is trans. I don't believe you should silence anti-trans rhetoric. I believe you should engage it. The ability for /r/conservative to ban my counter arguments is just as harmful as Mastodon shutting down the anti-trans positions. Conversation is what moves us forward and is how we find commonality. I grew up religious and conservative. I changed a lot of my viewpoints through friendly conversations in the internet of 2000-2010, before tumblrism, cancel culture, and censorship took hold. If I grew up in today's world or internet, I might never have been exposed to different opinions in a non-hostile, no-judgment environment. By trying to segregate, censor, and ban we're only leading to intractable polarization. Never giving folks an opportunity to change. Never accepting that people are capable of growth. Please let's talk with each other. Even if we disagree. You'd be surprised how effective that can be. We're all suffering though this world together. Laugh away our differences and find the ways and the things that we share. We all hold more in common than you might think. Love your enemy, even if they don't love you (yet). If I could have one lasting impact on this world, it would be this message.
- egypturnash 3y agoI'm a fifty-something trans lady and I am just fucking tired of trying to change viewpoints. I just want to live my life and talk with my friends without some butthead coming in and telling me I shouldn't exist, I get enough of that by checking the news lately. If you have the energy to politely engage people who think of you as a child molester who should be shot on sight, great! Go for it! But I have done that, and I am tired, and I do not want to do it any more. I run a Mastodon and I just want it to be a space to talk to my friends and maybe make some new ones, and thus, I block the fuck out of places I do not expect to get anything but hate from.
- hinkley 3y agoCommon rhetoric among PoC even twenty years ago was essentially, "We're tired of being spokespeople and tutors for your problems." Not everyone is cut out to be an educator, and I think you should have the option not to be voluntold for the job. Not just because it should be your right, but because insisting that everyone in a group can speak for that group is itself stereotyping. I think once you see that it's really hard to be patient with people who don't.