4 ms·
It's not due to apathy, it's due to economics. Emotions or willpower don't factor in here at all, just pure costs. The alternative is to raise taxes or tariffs
by crazygringo 3y ago
It's not due to apathy, it's due to economics. Emotions or willpower don't factor in here at all, just pure costs.
The alternative is to raise taxes or tariffs to pay for keeping unneeded production lines active, which means hardworking Americans in the rest of the country take home or keep less money. Which might sometimes be the right tradeoff for national security, but you only ever really know in hindsight.
Nobody was predicting a major European land war.
- throwaway894345 3y agoPresumably the parent meant “atrophy” and not “apathy”. Seems like the kind of shit my phone’s autocorrect is likely to pull. > The alternative is to raise taxes or tariffs to pay for keeping unneeded production lines active, which means hardworking Americans in the rest of the country take home or keep less money. Which might sometimes be the right tradeoff for national security, but you only ever really know in hindsight. The parent wasn’t talking narrowly about keeping defense supply chains maintained (although that’s probably a good idea) but about maintaining our manufacturing industry in general so we have the equipment and experience to build. This requires a policy shift, but an eminently sensible one for reasons besides military policy: we (the US) should reduce our dependence on a reliably oppressive dictatorship (particularly with respect to critical supply chains like defense) and bring those jobs and ingenuity back home (or at least to friendly shores). To wit, middle class Americans would bring home more money (although not so much for the American managerial class, which has enriched itself by outsourcing American middle class jobs), but there would be less cheap, disposable plastic junk on our shelves—things would cost more but they would last longer and we would repair our goods rather than disposing of them. Apart from reasons of global and national security, economy, etc, why should we allow products on American markets that were made with labor and environmental conditions that we would never tolerate here? Why should we be complicit?
- inetknght 3y ago> The alternative is to raise taxes or tariffs to pay for keeping unneeded production lines active, which means hardworking Americans in the rest of the country take home or keep less money If taxes are raised then yes hardworking Americans in the rest of the country take home or keep less money. If tariffs are raised then it's not hardworking Americans that take home or keep less money. It's people who import things that can and should be built locally instead. Better to keep the money in the USA instead of sending it overseas; better to pay Americans to build the things instead of paying people who are already rich to get richer.
- dukeyukey 3y ago> If tariffs are raised then it's not hardworking Americans that take home or keep less money. It's people who import things that can and should be built locally instead. Well, it's the customers that suffer due to higher tariff-induced prices. And if prices are kept the same and the company takes the hit, workers get hit by the lack of new investment the company now can't afford to make.
- inetknght 3y ago> Well, it's the customers that suffer due to higher tariff-induced prices. Indeed? Except the customers are also getting paid better because they now have jobs instead of shipping those jobs overseas.
- dukeyukey 3y agoWhich are artificially-supported jobs that soak up labor that could be used in a more productive way. Trade restrictions destroy economies of scale by breaking up markets and make us all poorer.
- voakbasda 3y agoIt’s not just economics. Manual labor and trade work are generally looked down upon by our culture; there is a misguided belief that white collar is better than blue collar. This has steered many people away from keeping these skills even as hobbies.
- aardvarkr 3y agoNo, it’s purely economics. Manufacturing is really tough to get right and producing at scale is a monstrous problem. There is no hobby that teaches you the exact process for creating a stinger missile using 247 custom parts assembled in 36 steps in a highly choreographed process of man and machine. To build even the most basic thing you need a team of highly experienced people who have been doing that job for a decade. Keeping those production line active while producing no parts is a crazy expensive proposition. There was a post that hit the front page recently about how the us airforce paid $50k for an airplane trashcan. It costs that much not because the raw materials + direct labor to create it cost that much, but instead because you have to pay for the 30+ people involved to restart that product line again for a super small batch.
- gaze 3y agoNo, it costs $50k because they can charge that much. Just like the way everything else is priced.
- vajrabum 3y agoI don't know about the trashcan but I do know about Lockheed's infamous $500 toilet seat. In that case it was hand fabricated fibreglass that fit over the top of the tank where waste was held and what you would call the seat was attached to it. It actually cost more than $500 to manufacture but they got so much bad publicity that they dropped the price.
- adhesive_wombat 3y ago> instead because you have to pay This is the thing, you don't actually have to pay to get "a" suitable trashcan. You do have to pay to get that exact one and be able to prove it. Certifications, approvals and so on carry significant costs. And significant benefits, like making aviation extremely safe, and standardisation allowing interchangeability and cooperation. When the system ossifies over time, plenty of people are more than happy to simply follow the rules in their silos rather than think about whether there's a better way. And, indeed, this sometimes is the best way rather than doing something clever, expedient and inventive that gets your name included in a NTSB report in 15 years' time.
- freeAgent 3y agoI think OP meant to say atrophy, not apathy.
- mensetmanusman 3y agohttps://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2022/02/22/politics/mitt-romney-russia-ukraine/index.html https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2022/02/22/politics/mitt-romney-russ...
- tehjoker 3y agocould have been avoided so easily with diplomacy. neocons were jonesing for it.
- nradov 3y agoDiplomacy was tried and didn't work.
- tehjoker 3y agoNATO could simply have promised that Ukraine would never be a NATO member or shadow NATO member, but instead they entertained it and organized a coup in 2014. Just backing off any time over the previous decade would have resulted in hundreds of thousands of fewer dead young men. This isn't to say that Ukraine can't defend itself from Russia, or that the invasion was good, but a simple recognition that there were things that led to this situation that were unforced. The point of NATO has been said to "Keep the Americans in, the Germans down, and the Soviets out" [of Europe]. Post-1991, there is no need for it and it has mainly been used to provoke and bomb other countries such as Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Yugoslavia, and now Ukraine/Russia. Arms manufacturers are kissing their freshly printed dollar bills and thanking our economic system for their great fortune.
- skeletal88 3y agoYou are just spewing russian propaganda talking points. Russia requested that nato would leave all the eastern european countries that had joined, Poland, Baltics, Czechia, etc. Then russia could also start invading us after it had taken Ukraine. Russia was mot interested in diplomacy, they just wanted Ukraine one way or other.
- throwaway894345 3y agoSheesh this is a wildly misinformed post (or rather, informed exclusively by baseless Russian propaganda). 1. There was no 2014 coup in Ukraine, there was a change in president (ratified by parliament) because the first guy (Putin's stooge) had the police kill protestors. This predictably provoked riots, but a riot isn't a coup and indeed the government wasn't overthrown. 2. The invasion was never about NATO; this was just one in a litany of obvious propagandist justifications and it has no more credibility than any of the others ("de-Nazifying Ukraine" and "defending ethnic Russians against genocide"). To wit, if Russia was genuinely motivated by NATO encroachment why would he, after years of NATO weapons, personnel, and doctrine being turned away from Russia and toward the middle east, would it do the very fucking thing designed to flood Russia's doorstep with NATO weapons, personnel, and member states? 3. The idea that there has been no need for NATO since 1991 (because Russia hasn't been particularly aggressive) is a non-sequitur--Russia hasn't been particularly aggressive since 1991 because of NATO. 4. NATO has not been used to provoke conflicts with anyone. 5. NATO didn't provoke an attack in Afghanistan; Afghanistan aided and abetted an attack on a NATO member state. Recall NATO is a defensive alliance. 6. NATO wasn't involved in Iraq; various member states were involved. 7. NATO bombing in Libya was implementing a UN Security Council resolution (recall that China and Russia have UNSC veto rights which they declined to exercise). 8. NATO did intervene to halt an ethnic cleansing campaign in Yugoslavia. They found a loophole in International Law that allowed them to intervene legally. 9. NATO had no role in the Ukraine/Russia conflict except to provide Ukraine with the weapons, training, intelligence, etc necessary to defend itself. Russia is the unambiguous aggressor. 10. "The point of NATO has been said to..." this is not evidence, it's baseless rhetoric. I promise
- 2devnull 3y ago“Nobody was predicting a major European land war.” I don’t think that entirely accurate. Mearshiemer is one prominent example. Nuland being another.
- 0xDEF 3y agoMearsheimer is a Putin fanboy who expected Russia would win the war in a month.
- ImHereToVote 3y agoWould you want the Russians to go nuclear like Mearsheimer anticipated of them? Perhaps the reason he is wrong is because he doesn't think of them in the best possible light.
- greesil 3y agoTo be fair almost everyone in the west thought the Russians would win in a short amount of time at the beginning of the war.
- hackandthink 3y agoMearsheimer was right predicting the war. Let's hope he is not right again: https://mearsheimer.substack.com/p/the-darkness-ahead-where-the-ukraine https://mearsheimer.substack.com/p/the-darkness-ahead-where-...
- greesil 3y agoSkimmed it. Yikes. I can't believe in the analytical ability of someone who thinks the invasion happened because of rational Russian security concerns as opposed to the fever dreams of an unhinged kleptocrat.
- hackandthink 3y agoAdam Tooze acknowledges Mearsheimer's analysis. His criticism of Mearsheimer is more subtle. My take is that Mearsheimer triggers cognitive dissonance. https://adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-95-is-ukraine-the-wests https://adamtooze.substack.com/p/chartbook-95-is-ukraine-the...