5 ms·

The Vatican should be able to charge a royalty on every marble sculpture currently produced, because undoubtedly the sculptor has studied The David. Yeah. Total

• gumballindie 3y ago
  The scary thing about ai is people willing to compare it to humans. They sound a bit like conspiracy theorists. While it is true that in theory ai can reach human levels of intelligence, it still is software, and software should be treated as such. Pay for the content used or dont use it all unless explicitly permitted by the authors.
  • jncfhnb 3y ago
    Telling software to pay you sounds like you’re comparing it to / treating it as humans
    • grugagag 3y ago
      But it is built from something extracted from humans and not only that but that devalues humans afterwards because it’s much cheaper to pay an LLM pennies than others humans a few dollars. The reason LLMs charge pennies is only because they don’t pay anything for the knowledge they are trained on. Seems like the most obvious outcome is for people to feel threatened, close circles and not share, perhaps run private LLMs and harvest by themselves the value they already put in.
      • chii 3y ago
        > but that devalues humans afterwards and yet you had no qualms about low pay workers in developing countries doing factory work do you? > they don’t pay anything for the knowledge they are trained on. that knowledge was disemminated for free. There cannot be a restriction on knowledge usage, as it is not a right that has been granted to the creator of said knowledge.
      • jncfhnb 3y ago
        The obvious outcome is people get over it and change nothing. Their individual sharing makes no difference.
• wwweston 3y ago
  If individual artists slowly learning from examining individual works were really much like being automated borrowing at scale, we wouldn't be having this conversation.