3 ms·
This is a legal fiction. Both abortion and affirmative action were legislated from the bench. That's how they came to be. It's a classic thing. Having come to t
by renewiltord 3y ago
This is a legal fiction. Both abortion and affirmative action were legislated from the bench. That's how they came to be. It's a classic thing. Having come to the conclusion that some thing should be law, the composition of the bench determines whether sufficient justification can be found. Then these decisions have the weight of law.
It is a defacto Politburo - a long lived legislative body of ultimate authority that has a rolling composition not determined by direct electoral results.
We can point to the legal fiction that the judiciary is not the legislature all we want but it walks like a duck and quacks like a duck.
- Supermancho 3y ago> the composition of the bench determines whether sufficient justification can be found. You're under the mistaken impression that justifications are a prerequisite. Any court can find justification for any ruling in whatever way they see fit. Yes, lower judges have been remove for questionable decisions. SCOTUS is above that, as a lifetime appointment. Sometimes rulings come with no justification at all. SCOTUS has been trying to explain itself via these public "opinions", but is not required to do so.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]