3 ms·
I often wished universities (and other organizations) would use a scoresheet-like "matrix of oppression" to determine someone's background difficulties. Like o
by solardev 3y ago
I often wished universities (and other organizations) would use a scoresheet-like "matrix of oppression" to determine someone's background difficulties.
Like okay, you get X points if you're this race, Y points for that. Z points if your parents were poor. Or if you grew up in these bad zip codes. Or if your dad was gone and mom was an addict. Whatever.
As an Asian American of relatively privileged (middle class) upbringing who went to a state college, I often found it unfair that many of my desperately poor white peers worked their asses off their whole lives, despite minimal support from their parents, to get into college on merit alone. Meanwhile for me, my admissions counselor handwaved away all the entrance requirements (my GPA was low, I didn't have the pre reqs done, etc.) and admitted me on the spot. Years later I'd find out that I was part of their zip code based recruiting program designed to get non whites into the school for the benefit of their diversity quotas. In California they already weren't allowed to use affirmative action due to Prop 209, so they just used a geographical proxy for race (finding zip codes with high non white ratios to recruit from).
I didn't deserve that spot at all. I never worked for it, I never suffered for it, my parents didn't much either. I just happened to benefit from policies meant to protect Black and Hispanic people, at their expense, while simultaneously throwing white people under the bus. It was pretty unfair all around.
I get that as a society we want to help give people a chance to escape the circumstances of their birth. But skin color alone is an awfully broad brush that paints only a vague picture of who that person is and what kind of adversity they may or may not have overcome. I wish we looked at it with more nuance is all I'm saying.
- zmgsabst 3y agoInstitutional racism is highly corrosive to society. All we’ve done is create new grievances among poor whites to justify the guilt of upper class whites about things their grandparents did. Those people are rightly upset that the government has been openly racist to them their entire lives. How did that help? — I mean, besides soothing the feelings of elites that they’re not bigots, even though they made 1950s style racist policies about “too many” Jews and Asians in their universities. (Which is what triggered this lawsuit…)
- solardev 3y agoYeah. There's nobody really fighting for poor white men, except maybe Bernie? But it's all too easy to capitalize on their grief and anger and redirect it into cultural wars instead. That anger is politically more potent left unchecked and weaponized than actually addressed. Some of the most down to earth, hardworking people I knew were poor white men with a dream: teachers, farmers, builders, activists, lawyers. They weren't interested in going into tech or finance or getting rich and retiring early or whatever, just to pursue their dreams and some semblance of happiness. Reminds me of old homesteaders. Same with the Black and Hispanic folks I knew at the same time, many of whom got support or scholarships of one kind or the other. On the ground, we were all just peers and friends and supported each other however we could. But officially the poor whites had no formal support network at all, while diversity programs had special buildings, funding, time, and labor devoted to the rest of us. My white peers never held that against me, as far as I know, but they did comment about how unfair it was to them to be punished for the sins of their (great grand) fathers. And I can't say they're wrong...
- zmgsabst 3y agoI find it interesting that certain people seem unable to comprehend that Donald Trump is the result of that racism by Democrats: Not because his supporters are racists, but because they’re done with an establishment openly bigoted towards them — and pathologically unwilling to address their needs.
- solardev 3y agoOur politics are really, really ugly these days, with no room for this sort of nuance anymore. It's really sad. Talking one on one with people though, it's easier to find common ground. And sometimes make a new friend. But it's hard for sure when the elites are so insistent on a divide and conquer strategy.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dahwolf 3y ago
- everdrive 3y agoI don’t think this is a bad idea conceptually, but I worry that the implementation would be a race to the bottom. Who gets to decide who’s been the “most oppressed?” It seems like nearly anyone could feel slighted by this.
- solardev 3y agoIt's not really about "who is the MOST oppressed" but rather that there are many oppressed peoples who are right now slipping through the cracks altogether. Probably we need to support all of them, at the expense of people who could afford it (the upper middle class and up), not make them fight for scraps against each other. I think the likely outcome of such a system (my hypothesis only, untested in reality) is that we'll find that yes, believe it or not, life is harder for Black people in general, especially in some areas, but that there are also rich Latinos, poor whites, cis men who've been abused, Asians who grew up in the hood, whatever. Our society is too heterogeneous to neatly segregate us by any one line alone, whether that line is race or class or sex oe whatever. Our backgrounds are a complex mix of variables that each have an impact and shouldn't be ignored.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 3y agoI think the qualification of how to label the matrix parent mentions is irrelevant. The chart clearly exists and has been used. Whether we call it something like 'race conscious equity generator' or 'oppressed totem pole' is just a way to polarize each side of the spectrum ( and adds to the point GP made about whether it is just a play for making people fight over relatively stupid stuff ). The point is that points for being $race and $class exists. As a society, do we want to fine tune everything to ensure that our individual mix of variables are accounted for or do we want individual to adjust to societal mold? It is a real question. For school, that clearly values obedience to the mold and passivity ( for better or worse ), I would assume the latter.
- solardev 3y agoAre you talking about assimilation vs maintaining cultural heterogeneity (like "melting pot" vs "salad bowl" models)? (Sorry, it's a bit hard to keep track of which post/point is a parent or GP or such. Not sure if I understood your point correctly.) I think this is more about opportunities than conforming, like whether we could have a system that provides supplemental resources (whether it's tuition or teaching aid or job opportunities or whatever) to people who have the same drive and merit as anyone else, but for whatever reason was given a significant handicap early on. That just lets them get into an organization to begin with. What they do with their participation, whether it's to conform or rebel or something else, is a separate (but still fascinating) question, I think? There is this idea that diversity will automatically lead to change. Sometimes it does, but yeah, sometimes people just choose to assimilate and stay quiet instead.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoYou're worried about skin color being used as a determining factor, but you were admitted based on zip code. That's trying to admit disadvantaged people, but not doing so based on skin color. So maybe in this specific case, they're already looking at it with more nuance? Or at least a different axis than skin color?
- solardev 3y agoWhile a charitable view, my impression is that was unlikely. The school itself was already located in an impoverished area. They didn't need to recruit from the other side of the state to find disadvantaged students. And their materials said nothing public about special admissions for disadvantaged people. It wasn't until I met face to face with a counselor that they let me in. My guess -- it's only a guess, I can't prove this -- is that the counselor had some leeway to determine whether to admit me, and that there was an unwritten mandate to prioritize candidates of color. I don't know if whites from those same zip codes would've gotten the same treatment. It seemed to me like the face time was a possible way for the university to hide race quotas behind judgment calls. I don't have the numbers for this though, just a hunch. And to their credit, we did have poor white applicants who did get in, obviously, or I wouldn't have gotten to know them. It wasn't an especially selective school to begin with. But it did seem like zip code recruiting was a proxy for race based recruiting. If they wanted income based recruiting they could've done that from anywhere without geography as a constraint.
- Bo0kerDeWitt 3y agoThis idea of a "matrix" often occurs to me when such topics are discussed. What attributes would you add to the matrix? You've suggested race, family wealth, zip code, whether a parent was an addict. You could also have height, physical beauty, IQ, degree of disability, sporting aptitude. Perhaps even degree of neuroticism or autism. The problem is, the matrix quickly gets bigger and bigger. The number of unique matrices starts to increase exponentially. What you end up with is a unique matrix for each individual. So why not do away with the matrix altogether, and just treat people as individuals, without fetishizing one or a couple of the attributes? Also the weight you assign each attribute is a subjective judgement. Who do you trust to make such a judgement? For example, what bestows more "privilege", having a pretty face, or being from the middle class? And by how much? I don't know.
- solardev 3y agoI think there are two questions here, both of which are totally valid, difficult, and important. One, how do you quantify "oppression" or "deservedness". My honest answer to that is I don't know. I wonder if a statistical model of demographics vs lifetime earnings can help, at a first estimation, by it wouldn't be simple at all and would probably be even more controversial than gerrymandering. But the other side of the question: the "why" should we do this at all, I think there is a clearer answer for that. Because if we don't, power and wealth quickly entrenches and polarizes society. Those with existing privileges share them with their offspring, and in so doing create dynasties of power that are counterproductive to the dream of an equitable democracy (which isn't a dream everyone shares). Those dynasties can arise from race, but also class, family name, legacy admissions, etc. People aren't just blank slate individuals but also very much the product of their environments. I think the goal isn't to wash away individual performance but to give people the chance to actually discover, express, and utilize their individual ability despite handicaps of circumstance -- at its core, the basic idea is that there are people who are richly deserving of aid and recognition because they could be great, "if only" something. It's the "if only what" that isn't easy to agree on. We don't want to exclude someone just because they had poor parents. Or because they're neurodivergent. Or white. In an ideal society there would just be ample opportunities for everyone. We don't live in such a society, so as long as there are limited resources and opportunities, we have to either fight over them or try to share them. I prefer the sharing model, but not everyone does.
- AlwaysRock 3y agoThe who is more privileged game is not a fun one to play. Watched a white male friend and a white passing Hispanic female friend get into this argument before. He grew up poor in a rural area, only one parent worked a low paying job and the other was the care giver. She grew up middle class in a city, parents were college professors. There are a ton of other factors but even at those basics it got complicated. Is a male always more privileged than a non male? How do you weight one point of privilege vs another? It all started to feel very subjective. I wonder if a matrix like that would even be legal.
- solardev 3y agoFor me, the goal wouldn't be to rank the oppressed against each other, but to provide resources for all those who need it. I think of it less like a tournament and more like food stamps: below a certain income, food becomes difficult to afford, and aid is helpful (I was on food stamps for a short bit and really appreciated it). It doesn't really matter WHY their income is low, just that society can help them with food. College aid is similar, except that admission seats aren't as easily fungible as tuition dollars. Same for job spots, I suppose. Let's say you have 100 openings of something. A candidate would be scored across the board, mixing demographics with performance. 10 points for an essay. -3 for bad GPA. +5 for a bad zip code. +3 for being a woman. -6 for wealthy parents. Whatever. In that way all those factors could be considered. But yes, the exact numbers would be difficult to arrive at. Maybe we could try to statistically model those based on their impact to lifetime earnings, updated every census or whatever. It wouldn't be easy. At all. Is it legal? I don't know. But the law can change. More to your point, I'm not even sure if this is a GOOD or ethical idea. Just a thought for discussion.
- AlwaysRock 3y agoWhat you are describing sounds like a more complicated version of AA.
- Balgair 3y agoEven if it did happen, it would immediately become useless. What's the old adage? Once a metric becomes a target, it ceases to be a good metric. Such a matrix would only become a goal for those wanting to get their kids into schools. I have no doubt at all, you'd get a cottage industry of counselors that would plan out how to best maximize your kids' privileged scores to get in. Sell your house to a relative at X months before admissions, find an ancestor of Y race on our special website at Z months before submission, claim a disability of ABC and take a SAT/ACT/FGH test under that disability, etc. You'll have a score of III with Stanford, a score of JJJ with Harvard, and a score of LLL with your safety school. Yadda yadda yadda, and here's the percent chances for each school. Hell, with AI and all this jazz, this won't even cost all that much and be the purview of the upper-middle class. You could likely just buy that service for under $100 by 2040.
- DonsDiscountGas 3y agoThat's what the University of Michigan used to do, it was ruled unconstitutional in Gratz v. Bollinger in 2003. It was never really clear (imho) how affirmative action (as actually practiced) could be implemented; discrimination based on race has been explicitly illegal since 1964 but somehow the courts ruled that some discrimination was legal (in Bakke v. California) but the courts can't actually provide a workable solution, they can just shoot down what people try.
- koolba 3y ago> … but the courts can't actually provide a workable solution, they can just shoot down what people try. And they do it because reverse racism is just racism. The way you truly eliminate racism from society is by eliminating all its forms. And that includes “well intentioned” racism. If there’s any metric outside of academic competence that will be a deciding factor in an admittance process, the only acceptable choices are wealth and income. Though even those have their contrarian arguments.
- glonq 3y ago> I often wished universities ... would use a scoresheet-like "matrix of oppression" Be careful what you wish for. Like most well-intentioned ideas, this would become terribly exploited/gamified.
- slt2021 3y agoit will end up being similar to Chinese "social credit" system and that score will dictate everything in your life. no, thanks
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- foogazi 3y ago> I often wished universities (and other organizations) would use a scoresheet-like "matrix of oppression" to determine someone's background difficulties. Why make it so hard ? Why not just let everyone in and end discrimination