3 ms·

My Cousin Vinny did it. Honestly I don't think VFX has ever truly helped a comedy. Imagine what that movie could have been with cheap gratuitous CGI. Instead

My Cousin Vinny did it. Honestly I don't think VFX has ever truly helped a comedy. Imagine what that movie could have been with cheap gratuitous CGI. Instead of Vinny getting covered in real mud, you could have slow motion closeups of glossy mud drops with fluid simulation flying through the air, the camera spinning around the mud in three dimensions before it cakes Vinny. But would such a visual spectacle make the movie funnier? I don't think so. And quite frankly, She Hulk would look a lot better if they simply found a buff actress and painted her green.

jncfhnb 3y ago
Not in general. In the context of modern tv, particularly on the marvel side. The finale is she hulk complaining to marvel / Disney that the show was becoming a heap of generic spectacle garbage with a big superhero fight even though the premise of the show was light legal comedy. It’s a good observation. Marvel has flubbed the landing on almost every tv series even if the original premises and pilots were good. I don’t think they executed on the bit very well, but props for trying I guess. Edit: I don’t agree with it being better with a green woman though. It did benefit a lot from it clearly being the same actress in both forms. There’s a time and a place for practical effects. That wasn’t it.
- mcpackieh 3y ago
  > Edit: I don’t agree with it being better with a green woman though. It did benefit a lot from it clearly being the same actress in both forms. I think it should have been done with the same actress. A buff actress can be made to appear more or less buff with clever wardrobe, camera angles, lighting, etc. In some scenes you hide her muscles under loose clothing or flat lighting, and in other scenes you emphasize them. Forced perspective can make her look taller or shorter when needed. Playing with the focal length could change the apparent shape of her face as well. CGI muscles completely ruins the whole deal for me. At the very least they should have done the opposite; hired a buff actress and slimmed down her muscles with CGI when necessary; I think that would look less fake than what they did.
  - jncfhnb 3y ago
    Idk man I’m trying to imagine photo realistic she hulk and it doesn’t seem like it would work. There was a hulk tv series a long time ago that was just a green painted dude and it was very silly
    - mixmastamyk 3y ago
      TIH was a really good show, relatively realistic, and Bill Bixby/Lou Ferrigno yet to be topped. :-p
wink 3y ago
Maybe not the best example and maybe I was misinterpreting it, but Doctor Strange In the Multiverse of Madness was VFX-heavy and it was the funniest movie I'd seen in a while when it came out. Not strictly a comedy and maybe I am too easily amused.

jncfhnb 3y ago

Not in general. In the context of modern tv, particularly on the marvel side. The finale is she hulk complaining to marvel / Disney that the show was becoming a heap of generic spectacle garbage with a big superhero fight even though the premise of the show was light legal comedy. It’s a good observation. Marvel has flubbed the landing on almost every tv series even if the original premises and pilots were good. I don’t think they executed on the bit very well, but props for trying I guess. Edit: I don’t agree with it being better with a green woman though. It did benefit a lot from it clearly being the same actress in both forms. There’s a time and a place for practical effects. That wasn’t it.

mcpackieh 3y ago
> Edit: I don’t agree with it being better with a green woman though. It did benefit a lot from it clearly being the same actress in both forms. I think it should have been done with the same actress. A buff actress can be made to appear more or less buff with clever wardrobe, camera angles, lighting, etc. In some scenes you hide her muscles under loose clothing or flat lighting, and in other scenes you emphasize them. Forced perspective can make her look taller or shorter when needed. Playing with the focal length could change the apparent shape of her face as well. CGI muscles completely ruins the whole deal for me. At the very least they should have done the opposite; hired a buff actress and slimmed down her muscles with CGI when necessary; I think that would look less fake than what they did.
- jncfhnb 3y ago
  Idk man I’m trying to imagine photo realistic she hulk and it doesn’t seem like it would work. There was a hulk tv series a long time ago that was just a green painted dude and it was very silly
  - mixmastamyk 3y ago
    TIH was a really good show, relatively realistic, and Bill Bixby/Lou Ferrigno yet to be topped. :-p

wink 3y ago

Maybe not the best example and maybe I was misinterpreting it, but Doctor Strange In the Multiverse of Madness was VFX-heavy and it was the funniest movie I'd seen in a while when it came out. Not strictly a comedy and maybe I am too easily amused.