6 ms·
Teflon Aka Polytetrafluoroethylene cookware represents a health hazard. The stuff contains a great deal of Florine and breaks down at 300C, but that’s not pure
by Retric 3y ago
Teflon Aka Polytetrafluoroethylene cookware represents a health hazard. The stuff contains a great deal of Florine and breaks down at 300C, but that’s not purely binary instead it becomes increasingly unstable as your approach the temperature. Further no manufacturing process is perfect, I wouldn’t therefore assume eating significant quantities would be safe.
That said, it’s generally used as a coating rather than a structural element so there’s less of it in the environment.
PS: Toothpaste which you should mostly spit out generally contains less than 0.5% fluoride compounds such as sodium fluoride NaF or tin fluoride SnF2, the F in both being Florine.
- jansan 3y agoIs "Florine" the same as "Flourine", and isn't that what they give children so they get healtheir teeth? I am a bit confused here to be honest. Edit: Sorry, stupid question, was thinking of Fluoride.
- iso1631 3y agoYou're thinking of fluoride
- taneq 3y agoDoes it contain Fluorine (a dangerous halogen gas) or does it contain Fluoride (the ion of that gas, commonly added to toothpaste and drinking water).
- deelowe 3y agoFlourine...
- oasisbob 3y ago"Fluorine" is also the terminology used for covalently bonded Fl moieties, not just difluorine, the gas. Fluoride is the ion, but if you want to get pedantic, you're not adding the ion to toothpaste and drinking water - you're adding another fluorine compound which is dissociating in solution. Ie, when you salt your food, you're not tossing in Cl- ions directly.
- oezi 3y agoI understand that Teflon might be a hazard in pans but feel like it reduces the amount of burned food in contrast to steel/iron pans so much for me that I hope it is a net gain. (sorry in advance for all who want to suggest iron skillets. I can't make them work in daily use.)
- grimgoldgo 3y agoIf you are regularly burning food in steel or iron pans, maybe it's time to understand why? I cook in exclusively iron and steel cookware and I cannot remember the last time something got burned (excepting when I deliberately charred something.)
- hirundo 3y agoPlease don't take your skill in this for granted. It's a gift. I've been using cast iron pans sporadically for four decades, following all of the common advice, and failing magnificently every time. I still use one occasionally to put a crust on a steak ... and then use a small piece of chainmail[1] to defeat the klingons. It's not that I don't believe you. It just doesn't work that way in my pan on my stove with my food at my skill level, at all. I gave up and buy nonstick pans and replace them every other year or so. [1] https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0087UYR1S https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0087UYR1S
- abathur 3y agoI don't cook enough (and never steak) for you to assign me much weight, but FWIW I've had a (lighter, spun) cast iron skillet for 8ish years. I followed a seasoning procedure available online that involves (IIRC) 3 rounds of applying thin coats of flaxseed oil and leaving it in an oven at a fairly high temp. This process went fine, but I always had to baby the pan (had to be very careful cleaning it with said chainmail, very careful with what/how I cooked in it) and had to re-do the initial seasoning several times when it got too troublesome. This process would leave the pan at a dark brown, and for a while I blamed this on not removing rust well enough before seasoning or not babying it well enough for it to build up to a ~normal black coat. At some point during the early pandemic I tired of this. I decided to do something similar on the stovetop where I could observe/iterate better. Apply a coat, wait for it to stop smoking, and repeat until it was black. (plus a few for good luck; I didn't keep track; this took maybe dozens of rounds?) I've had a much better time since then. The most ~babying I've done is applying a few fresh coats if I don't use it for a while or water doesn't bead when I rinse it.
- SapporoChris 3y ago300 C is typically the highest setting on a stovetop. I never go above medium when using Teflon cookware. I've not used a cooking thermometer yet, but https://homebli.com/stove-top-temperature-knobs-what-the-numbers-mean/ https://homebli.com/stove-top-temperature-knobs-what-the-num... gives a good general guide line under a section labelled Stove Top Numbers to Degrees. Also, I only use 'plastic' utensils with the pan. The result, not a single scratch on the pan. The surface looks brand new, I've been using it over a year.
- blueprint 3y ago[flagged]
- tomjakubowski 3y agoI would guess GP meant silicone tools, silicone being a kind of plastic.
- blueprint 3y ago[flagged]
- hombre_fatal 3y ago[flagged]
- blueprint 3y ago[flagged]
- SapporoChris 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.
- FooBarBizBazz 3y agoI'd have thought that fluorine, like oxygen, is a strong oxidizer (fluorine being even stronger), and so fluorides, like oxides (e.g. rust) would be extremely stable, among the most stable compounds possible. Unless I'm forgetting the other side: Maybe the other half of the compound is not a strong enough reducer? It's a hydrocarbon though, it burns well in oxygen... That said, even oxides do break down when heated. Like, that's what smelting is... Hm...
- Retric 3y agoCarbon Florine bonds are some of the strongest you will find. Carbon tetrafluoride CF4 is almost as safe as nitrogen at room temperature. Tetrafluoroethylene C2F4 is actually explosive on the other hand because of it’s carbon carbon bond, the stuff is happy to spit out the carbon and get CF4. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetrafluoroethylene https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetrafluoroethylene
- __alexs 3y agoCarbon tetrafluoride and Carbon tetrachloride are the two "carbon tets" you never want to mix up.
- marcosdumay 3y ago> Maybe the other half of the compound is not a strong enough reducer? It's about as strong as most of the molecules on your body. But I don't think that fluoride moving around is the problem. Looks like the problem is exactly the stability, and some long foreign molecules installing themselves in your body.
- jader201 3y ago> Teflon Aka Polytetrafluoroethylene cookware represents a health hazard. Are you saying, then, that this claim [1] is false? It states that PTFE is safe, whereas PFOA — what Teflon used to contain — was the component that made Teflon unsafe. [1] https://www.webmd.com/food-recipes/is-teflon-coating-safe https://www.webmd.com/food-recipes/is-teflon-coating-safe
- brnt 3y agoPTFE is a PFAS, as is PFOA. > Now, since PFOA belongs to a large group of chemicals called PFAS, consisting of 4,700 similar substances, it might be tempting to just switch to one of the other PFAS chemicals that hasn’t been restricted yet. But that wouldn´t solve the problem, it would only postpone and perpetuate it. [1] [1] https://marketplace.chemsec.org/articles/news/2020/04/01/the-dos-and-donts-of-replacing-pfoa/ https://marketplace.chemsec.org/articles/news/2020/04/01/the... I.e. there's a whole zoo of similar compounds, and all those type specific safety claims are all at room temperature. The whole point of their use is often on heated surfaces, getting near and over the safety limit.
- kurthr 3y agoSorry, but PTFE (polytetrafluoroethylene) may be a PFAS (per-and polyfluoroalkyl substances but not a Perfluorooctane Sulfonate PFOAS) however, it is definitely not a PFOA (perfluorooctanoic acid). Your link does not contain a reference to PTFE and looking at the meaning of the acronyms should provide evidence fluorethylene is not a sulfonate or an octanoic acid. The manufacture of PTFE may involve generating these as bio-hazardous byproducts and PTFE could be contaminated or even break down into them, but they are chemically not the same.
- crznp 3y agoI think you misread: GP claimed that PTFE is a type of PFAS, and separately: PFOA is also a type of PFAS. And if PFAS is the problem, it wouldn't be useful to ban specific classes like PFOA if they are just replaced by different classes of PFAS. I'm not sure about the last claim: it isn't clear that all PFAS are equally bad, so replacing PFOA with a different PFAS might be worthwhile. It seems hard to study, but with Europe banning PFOA, perhaps we'll get some more insight.
- nameless_prole 3y agoHeating up Teflon straight up kills birds if they're in the same room.
- colordrops 3y agoSource?
- katbyte 3y agohttps://vcacanada.com/know-your-pet/teflon-polytetrafluoroethylene-poisoning-in-birds https://vcacanada.com/know-your-pet/teflon-polytetrafluoroet... https://www.teflon.com/en/consumers/teflon-coatings-cookware-bakeware/safety/bird-safety https://www.teflon.com/en/consumers/teflon-coatings-cookware... its a thing
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vkou 3y ago> PS: Toothpaste which you should mostly spit out generally contains less than 0.5% fluoride compounds such as sodium fluoride NaF or tin fluoride SnF2, the F in both being Florine. And table salt is made out of Sodium and Chlorine, one of which is explosive when mixed with water, and the other is used to gas soldiers in trenches if you're into committing war crimes. What matters is what effect the particular chemical has when you put it through common household uses, not the effect of its constituent parts.
- Retric 3y agoI added that because the first two responses seemed to be confused. Anyway, uncommon household uses can also be a safety concern. People still do occasionally get poisoned by mixing ammonia and bleach even despite the repeated warnings. Talking about the constituent parts is similarly relevant when you’re heating something to significant temperatures. Many reasonably safe substances really shouldn’t be tossed on a bond fire etc. For other things it’s not the substance itself that’s a concern but impurities from the manufacturing process. People often think of past recalls as companies doing something dumb, but I think we underestimate how difficult it is to get this stuff right.