3 ms·
I'm not here to make assumptions. I'm here to point out "being able to open a web page in a context like that is not necessarily a security problem", and I'm s
by Dylan16807 3y ago
I'm not here to make assumptions. I'm here to point out "being able to open a web page in a context like that is not necessarily a security problem", and I'm sure you can think of an example if you don't like my example.
With an existence proof, you only have to worry about the narrowest possible interpretation. The skill of considering what an exploit could lead to is very important, but it fits oddly into such a hypothetical. Finding a possible flaw doesn't invalidate an existence proof unless you also can't think of a way to mitigate it.
Also if the video is small and says youtube and tricks a user I'm not sure I would call that a security problem. You can trick users with a post-it note, and that doesn't mean there's anything wrong on a technical level.
- nomel 3y ago> You can trick users with a post-it note, and that doesn't mean there's anything wrong on a technical level. Sure, but something present on the screen of a trusted system is very very different than a post it note. This claim is why I'm sticking strong by my assertion that this is why red teams exist. That's a really baffling view of security, to me.
- Dylan16807 3y agoYou're still not listening to my real point. Pretend it can only play a rickroll, no other videos. Or I could come up with something more reasonable like "it only does top trending and you need to hold keys down so if you don't have skimmer-level tech to shove in you can't persist the exploit" or whatever. I'm saying there's some scenario where it's not a security issue. You don't need to prove that there are scenarios that are security issues. That's obvious.