5 ms·
I keep on reading that electric vehicles require less maintenance, but they still require some maintenance, and lots of things continue to break. how much main
by m463 3y ago
I keep on reading that electric vehicles require less maintenance, but they still require some maintenance, and lots of things continue to break.
how much maintenance does a honda ice car really require? Most of them run flawlessly for years and years, almost without opening the hood at all.
I wonder how the numbers break down?
- soperj 3y agoYou seriously don't change the oil?
- delfinom 3y agoI change out my Honda's oil once a year (10k miles per year), so what, $60? Heh, in my case, I would go bankrupt owning a EV because of tires. My god roads are so fucking bad in NYS that I replaced 3 tires this year alone due to massive gashes in the sidewalls. EVs being so fucking overweight do not have cheap tires, RIP.
- m463 3y agoalso in my experience tesla has terrible inside edge tire wear.
- starttoaster 3y agoI could be mistaken, but I think they're mostly not counting a procedure that basically amounts to loosening up a bolt that makes oil come out the bottom, tightening it back up again, and then adding new oil from the top side. I think the kind of maintenance they're thinking of is more like "replace the serpentine belt."
- pengaru 3y agoTiming belt is a big one for ICEs, valve adjustment if it's something racy. There's also just so many moving parts there's far more opportunity for engine failures, especially in the face of neglect/deferred maintenance. I don't think there's an EV equivalent for needing an engine rebuild/replace because you ignored the timing belt for too long on an interference motor. It's worse on newer ICEs that have to meet modern fuel economy and emissions standards too. Very high compression-ratios have become commonplace, making the consequences for neglect much more severe. You'd be hard-pressed to find a non-interference design in something modern. And turbo motors are much harder on their oil... Newer ICEs are tantamount to yesteryears high-strung race engines, too bad the chassis are so heavy.
- sokoloff 3y agoMany serpentine belts are a sub-10-minute job. Put a wrench on the tensioner, take the tension off it, slip old belt off, put the new belt on, release the wrench tension. It’s literally faster than any oil change (engine, diff, or transfer case).
- rascul 3y agoCan change the serpentine belt while waiting for the oil to drain.
- soperj 3y agoThey said they don't lift the hood.
- stbenjam 3y agoThere’s no oil to change. It doesn’t have a combustion engine.
- mulmen 3y agoIt has a differential and gearbox so it has oil.
- soperj 3y agoAre you even reading what I'm replying to? > how much maintenance does a honda ice car really require? Most of them run flawlessly for years and years, almost without opening the hood at all.
- stbenjam 3y agoMy bad
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- NikolaNovak 3y agoIt's weird. Two decades ago I had a 2004 subaru that needed nothing first years. Then We got a 2015 Toyota rav 4 and every maintenance there was some up sell. Change a filter check the brakes resurface rotors change the atf or differential oil etc. We actually got into a dispute with dealer after third consecutive $300brakes maintenance. Thought maybe that was lemon car or bad dealer but now we have a honda odyssey and same thing. My bill last week was $900 for a car that nothing was wrong with, just "regular maintenance". Due to our schedules my wife usually takes the car in ; I can see the bill is inflated in terms of labour and parts but I already know they'll tell me that's the book value. So for today's ice cars, they do get a lot of revenue from regular maintenance and may even be more profitable for them than actual fixes. I wonder about Ev - do they not have brakes, Cv joints, bearings, differentials (I know there's no transmission), et cetera?
- danans 3y ago>U wonder about Ev - do they not have brakes, Cv joints, bearings, differentials (I know there's no transmission), et cetera? They have all those, but at least for brakes, they last much longer due to regen braking.
- mulmen 3y agoMy brakes are serviced on a time interval. Brake fluid is hydrophilic. You replace it based on age to prevent corrosion of brake components. If brakes are used less and don't get as hot I would expect EV brakes to need more preventative maintenance, not less. Pads and rotors may last longer, but fluid will be the same or worse.
- sokoloff 3y agoAny water vapor that gets into the fluid won’t be removed by brake application, so your flush interval will be no different.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI think on a Tesla you should use your brakes once a month or so, just so they don’t get rusty. If you live in a place where they salt the roads in the winter, you need to clean and lube your breaks once a year.
- pengaru 3y agoIf Tesla is any indication, they'll be chock full of unnecessary complex gimmicks that will constantly break and need servicing. I once helped someone with a flat tire in a Model S who had zip ties dangling from every door handle. The "present mechanism" had failed in every door, look it up, it's a known problem of wire fatigue caused by the present mechanism's repetitive movement breaking the door handle. Imagine owning a Model X at 150,000 miles. I watched kids have to crawl under the rear "gullwing" door of a fresh one last month. It refused to open beyond a small gap, despite there being no obstructions. Impatient parent in the driver's seat just shouted in frustration for them to crawl in after throwing his hands up at the steering wheel. Trash needs lots of maintenance to keep on the road... those things are like Homer Simpson mobiles.
- panick21_ 3y agoYes a Tesla takes more maintenance then a stock Honda Civic. But if you actually compare like for like in terms of vehicle size and price, its quite different. People hear act like Tesla are full of gimmicks and the cars it competes with are cars from the 1970s. But also you are just mostly wrong, actual data simply says something different. I don't have the links, but there have been studies on the this and Tesla comes out looking pretty good.
- jefft255 3y agoLooking forward to an electric car that’s not a gadget on wheels. Oh well that’s probably never going to happen
- m463 3y agoThought I should mention my experience: - 2 door handles broken. - the door panels have been opened so many times, now they are perpetually loose and the door closes with a weird sound. - driver floor mats came loose multiple times. - one rear drive motor failure. (note that apart from tesla claims, two drive motors does NOT mean you can continue the trip on the remaining one) - 4 flat tires - no spare, so each one ended up requiring a flatbed. Tesla's roadside assistance is rarely timely. Actually any roadside assitance. (I'm ordering a cheater spare) - rear defrost wires most don't heat. - touchscreen developed bubbles - front spoiler broke - rear ultrasonic sensor fell inside bumper now the warranty expired, and of course a third door handle broke. Also, be careful of what you wish for. they seem to minimize "unnecessary complex gimmicks" by removing controls. That means everything goes on the touchscreen and you become a terrible driver because you cannot control your car easily. Really, tesla needs decent dedicated controls with honda attention to detail and reliability.
- jayd16 3y agoFans, belts, radiator, oil, (ironically) battery, (oil, fuel and intake) filters are eliminated. Bulbs, tires, alignment, washer fluid, cabin filters, and brake pads remain.
- stbenjam 3y agoI’ve owned a few EV’s and they all have 12V batteries. The traction battery charges the 12V and it powers all the typical car power systems.
- jayd16 3y agoAh hmm, I guess you're right. So just the alternator and starter are gone.
- asynchronous 3y agoWhile Teslas are required to have a 12v due to federal regulation they do not to my knowledge require any checking or maintenance. They’re basically unused in the car, you can’t even get to them without removing stuff.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoTesla uses a lithium 12V now due to problems with the leas acid one they used previously. So they are definitely used, most of the electronics outside of the power train are 12V.
- panick21_ 3y agoTrue for now. Next generation architecture seems to be moving to 48V. This is expected with the Cybertruck and all following architectures.
- mulmen 3y agoBrake fluid also needs serviced. And EVs still have suspension so you'll eventually need new shocks. You also have power steering. And Air conditioning, including the condenser. (Some?) EVs also have radiators for heat management of the battery which includes a water pump.