3 ms·
Whose else? - x86 and x64 are too power-hungry for small systems. - Power is still up and running, but also on the high end, too (see Power 8 and 9). - MIPS3
by nine_k 3y ago
Whose else?
- x86 and x64 are too power-hungry for small systems.
- Power is still up and running, but also on the high end, too (see Power 8 and 9).
- MIPS32 cores are found in lower-end MCUs. AFIACT MIPS actively offers their cores for embedding in MCUs, like ARM.
- You can still buy MCUs with Atmel AVR and 8051 8-bit architectures on the lowest end.
What's lost? SPARC and Motorola 680x0, I presume. I frankly wonder what prevented 680x0 from getting into widespread MCUs. Apparently Phillips used it their custom controllers for some time.
- qbasic_forever 3y agoZ80 and PIC were pretty popular in the hobbyist embedded space before Arduino and Atmel AVR really took over in the 2000s.
- megous 3y ago8-bit PICs are still quite nice. All of them up to 40-pin variants are made in DIP package, so I can put a bare package into a breadboard and have a ton of features out of the box in the right pin number configuration for the job. People should just select modern ones, and not the same old 16F84/877 or something legacy like that, that's been obsolete for like 25 years already. All of the modern ones have very uniform programming interface, nicely configurable I/O and a lot of analog features.
- Koshkin 3y agoATTiny85, too, is amazing, having only 8 pins.
- crote 3y agoPIC used to have a terrible architecture, and was barely supported by open source tooling. Heck, GCC still doesn't have PIC support, and an experimental backend was dropped from LLVM! I'm not surprised AVR ate its lunch in the hobbyist space.
- duskwuff 3y ago> AFIACT MIPS actively offers their cores for embedding in MCUs, like ARM. Not anymore that I'm aware of. They laid off most (possibly all?) of their architectural engineers around 2020 and sold off the remaining rights to a Chinese firm. There's still a few MIPS-based MCUs out there, like PIC32, but they're a dying breed. ARM Cortex-M is much better suited to these applications. > I frankly wonder what prevented 680x0 from getting into widespread MCUs. Poor IPC, high interrupt latency. The weird mixed 16/32-bit nature of the 68000 made it easier to implement a microcomputer with (since you only needed 16-bit RAM/ROM), but would only get in the way in a microcontroller (where memory would mostly, if not entirely, be internal). It's a shame; I liked the ISA, but the performance just isn't there.
- withinboredom 3y ago> ARM Cortex-M I almost did a prank post when Apple came out with/announced the M1. I had recently had tore down my broken PSVR which has the very nicely stamped ARM M1 in it. I wanted to post something like "Apple didn't invent it, Sony did!" Regretfully, I did not.
- duskwuff 3y ago> I had recently had tore down my broken PSVR which has the very nicely stamped ARM M1 in it. I don't think that's correct. The Cortex-M1 is an soft-core-only design; there's no hardware implementation. (And moreover, the ARM cores used aren't usually part of the external markings on a chip.) What chip were you looking at? I don't see anything which looks like that in the iFixit teardown: https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/PlayStation+VR+Teardown/69341 https://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/PlayStation+VR+Teardown/6934...
- withinboredom 3y agoI was really hoping to still have the boards, or at least a picture. I could find neither. It was a gen1 model, so it didn't look anything like those photos on that teardown.