11 ms·
Hunter-gatherer lifestyle fosters thriving gut microbiome
- hirundo 3y agoThis gives them an advantage in the supply of material for fecal microbiota transplant bacteriotherapy. Unless they use the proceeds to stop eating like hunger-gatherers, which seems to be the usual path. I know some modern Californians who eat like hunter-gatherers. I wonder if they might be able to monetize their gut flora.
- Y_Y 3y agoI hope the trade-off is worth it for them
- OldManRyan 3y agoWhat trade-off specifically?
- ramesh31 3y ago>What trade-off specifically? Not starving to death when there's a drought
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoYet another unambiguous data point that modern life is measurably worse for your body, and with less diversity, than tens of thousands of years ago.
- r3trohack3r 3y ago> Yet another unambiguous data point that modern life is measurably worse for your body I’m not sure this is the takeaway. I feel there are many unambiguous data points that modern life is measurably better for your body. Infant mortality rate. Average life expectancy. The mortality rate for mothers during pregnancy. The mortality rate for random injuries (cuts, breaks, etc.). Death by food poisoning. Quality of life, and mortality rates, for mental and physical disabilities. It seems like, in nearly any circumstance, the modern human body is at considerably less risk than our ancestors. But there are trade-offs and missteps. It seems we’ve tossed the baby with the bath water in some cases. And getting the baby back further improves modern life.
- martythemaniak 3y agoAll right, but apart from the sanitation, the medicine, education, wine, public order, irrigation, roads, a fresh water system, and public health, what have the Romans ever done for us?
- asdff 3y agoJokes aside but ancient rome was probably a disgusting place where setting foot into it put you at severe health risk compared to a quaint village. There's a reason why the rich rich of rome lived in villas outside of town.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoObviously we don’t have records for the majority cause of death in 100,000BC, however I see no reason to believe that compared to Paleolithic man there are fewer risks now. Consider the top youth killers today: drug overdoses, automobile accidents, firearms, household accidents. These were just not possible ways that people could die in 100,000BC. Yet heart attack and cancer have always led death rates for as long as humans have been counting. My hunch is that people for the most part have always mostly died of “old age” (cancer, heart attack, pneumonia, infection) for all of human history and while overall rate had dropped - the type has changed to be less random biology and more social-cultural (which is worse IMO)
- AntiRemote 3y ago[dead]
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 3y agoPeople have used drugs since time immemorial and even "natural" drugs can kill you. For example dying from esophogeal rupture during those purging ceremonies where toxins are ingested to induce profuse vomiting. Though there were no firearms, there certainly were weapons and murder. Even human sacrifice. Before there were cars, being kicked by a horse was a significant risk. Or being killed by the animals you hunt, like mammoths and other large mammals. And I'm not sure what you mean by suggesting "household accidents". Accidents were possible before too. And way probably more lethal on average because there were no antibiotics, soap, or blood transfusions.
- chomp 3y agoI don't think this is right, hunter-gather diets were largely restricted to the area they lived, you can't across the board call them diverse. It depends if you lived in an area that was blessed with diversity, or if you were forced to eat the same seeds/nuts constantly. Malnutrition plagued the Neanderthals by the way. We have skeletons and teeth that show disruption to growth. There's evidence of some groups of gatherers that subsisted on local flora that caused excessive amounts of tooth decay. Modern living results in way healthier people (for the most part).
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoPoint is well taken that I shouldn’t generalize and that it’s likely been a trade off. I suppose my rebut would claim that the diet of the average US adult today is worse than the average Paleolithic person, but that the healthiest US adult would be healthier than the healthiest Paleolithic person.
- mlyle 3y ago> I suppose my rebut would claim that the diet of the average US adult today is worse than the average Paleolithic person Worse in some aspects. But the leading cause of death in paleolithic times is thought to be diarrhea from foodborne illness causing dehydration and starvation, which is not such a killer today. Is that included in "diet"? (It would seem to be, because we're talking about effects on gut biome...)
- dmbche 3y agoI think it has more to do with sanitation than diet directly, many illnesses that kill that way (cholera, for one) flourish to this day in unclean areas, where excrement contaminates the water/food. Not eating rotting food as well, which was normal for a very long time. Pretty certain that that accounts for a whole lot of diarhea and death. It does make me think of how little soil we are in contact with compared to paleolithic persons - I know that B12 is sourced from the soil in our alimentation, but since we wash our produce we don't get any, and if you don't eat meat you need to supplement. I wonder if there are not other bacterium that we are washing away. Also remember hearing that it could be picked up on your skin on contact, which is also not something most people do daily.
- jandrese 3y agoI'm not sure "diversity of gut flora" is a good indicator of quality of life. It might just mean you have less dirt in your diet.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 1970-01-01 3y ago>Yet another unambiguous data point I checked. It's ambiguous: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleolithic_diet#Health_effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleolithic_diet#Health_effect...
- myshpa 3y agoI don't think a modern paleo "fad" diet has anything to do with the real diet of that times. Anthropologist Debunks the Paleo Diet https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FNIoKmMq6cs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FNIoKmMq6cs
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoTo be clear I think there’s a significant difference between “What people ate in the Paleolithic“ and “The Paleo Diet” TM
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fasterik 3y agoI doubt this is true if you factor in the positive effects of medical care, safer living conditions, sanitation, etc. that are available in modern developed countries.
- xenonite 3y ago> The analysis suggests that the average Hadza adult gut microbiome contains 730 species (standard error [SE] of 14.5 species), compared with 277 species (SE of 32 species) in the average adult Californian gut microbiome, 317 species (SE of 32 species) for the Nepali foragers, and 436 species (SE of 106 species) for the Nepali agrarians.
- beezlebroxxxxxx 3y agoIn what sense are hunter-gatherer diets "more diverse"? Are they eating a lot of different things? Is the food they're eating simply better on a microbiome improving level regardless of whether they have more variation or less, or is it more to do with preparation/cooking?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoExercise, lots of plants, variety.
- neves 3y agoprobably eating more dirt
- mstipetic 3y agoIf you look at any modern supermarket and strip out all the processed junk, you’re left with a few types of meat, few types of vegetables and maybe some mushrooms. Most of our dishes are a combination of maybe 25 items of which 6,7 are heavily used.
- GordonS 3y agoWould your typical hunter-gatherer have more than 25 edible items regularly around them? I'm not so sure.
- rdevsrex 3y agoYes. I can't cite it, but I remember seeing a study that said hunter gatherers in warmer climates can have up to 200 different food sources. Of course I'm sure it's highly dependent on season and region.
- mastazi 3y ago> hunter-gatherer You don't even need to go that far - my Italian grandma who was born in a farming village in the early 1900s, knew dozens of herbs, how you would go about finding them, and how could you use them for this or that other purpose. You can't find any of those herbs in a modern supermarket except maybe for a couple of them.
- pj_mukh 3y agoDumb question: After the 8473628484th study confirming how important the gut micro biome is, why isn’t there a pill to build it up? Like a multi-vitamin that just boosts the diversity in the gut? Are processed diets changing the physical makeup (thermal?, acidic?) of the gut as well and therefore a pill won’t work?
- edgyquant 3y agoIsn’t this exactly what a probiotic is?
- jjtheblunt 3y agoI think this is an example of such probiotic pills. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B002NL165W https://www.amazon.com/dp/B002NL165W
- HumanOstrich 3y agoNot exactly. Probiotics tend to have transitory effects, so you have to keep taking them to see the benefits. You'd need to significantly change your diet and lifestyle to have a chance at generating any positive changes to your gut microbiome that will persist. Even then, it seems to be much more difficult to change things after an early age. Unless you get some magic fecal pills.
- notaustinpowers 3y agoWe all have a different micro biome. While humans are only .01% different from each other, our micro biomes can vary wildly based on diet, lifestyle, environment, etc. There's no one size fits all pill we could take.
- blacksmith_tb 3y agoTrue, though it might be possible to make a more one-size-fits-all pill that targeted species which correlate with worse health (say, a bunch of bacteriophages).
- woeirua 3y agoHow long before we see a SaaS (s*t-as-a-service) startup where you can get fecal transplants sourced from people who only forage for their food?
- eganist 3y agohttps://www.google.com/search?q=fecal+transplant+as+a+service https://www.google.com/search?q=fecal+transplant+as+a+servic... halfway there
- blitzar 3y ago> Donors needed A call to action, just the kind I have been looking for. It is my duty to give a shit.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoLast I checked, the FDA approved fecal transplant pills so you can swallow capsules of verified safe poop instead of having to inject poo up your bum.
- yCombLinks 3y agoWhy skip the good part
- dheera 3y agoThat sounds more disgusting, not less. The mouth is for clean stuff. The bum is for dirty stuff.
- cesarvarela 3y agoAgriculture was a mistake.
- myshpa 3y agoOur biggest mistake.
- anthk 3y agoThe big three religions of Middle East were built around praising sun and wheat harvesting.
- aitchnyu 3y agoTuber farmers who can't do anything but eat the day's harvest get by on much simpler culture than grain farmers. Landlords with granaries? Tubers can't be stored, so the idiot building palaces is wasting time. Kings and armies marching to claim faraway fertile lands? Rich city ruling over neglected grain basket region? They can't eat anything from faraway land. Festivals, astrology? Those won't help for perennial crops. Accounting? Not helpful for food.
- anthk 3y agoAnd that's how religions got spreaded over. Also, I think as bread was taken as "sacred", at least in Christianism, I think that could be related to the fungus (or mold) in some cereal/bread such as ergotism releasing hallucinations and "visions" of virgins/daemons and so on.
- Barrin92 3y agoYuval Noah Harari had a good quote on wheat farming in Sapiens Think for a moment about the Agricultural Revolution from the viewpoint of wheat. Ten thousand years ago wheat was just a wild grass, one of many, confined to a small range in the Middle East. Suddenly, within just a few short millennia, it was growing all over the world. According to the basic evolutionary criteria of survival and reproduction, wheat has become one of the most successful plants in the history of the earth. In areas such as the Great Plains of North America, where not a single wheat stalk grew 10,000 years ago, you can today walk for hundreds upon hundreds of miles without encountering any other plant. Worldwide, wheat covers about 870,000 square miles of the globe’s surface, almost ten times the size of Britain. How did this grass turn from insignificant to ubiquitous? Wheat did it by manipulating Homo sapiens to its advantage. This ape had been living a fairly comfortable life hunting and gathering until about 10,000 years ago, but then began to invest more and more effort in cultivating wheat. Within a couple of millennia, humans in many parts of the world were doing little from dawn to dusk other than taking care of wheat plants. It wasn’t easy. Wheat demanded a lot of them. Wheat didn’t like rocks and pebbles, so Sapiens broke their backs clearing fields. Wheat didn’t like sharing its space, water and nutrients with other plants, so men and women laboured long days weeding under the scorching sun. Wheat got sick, so Sapiens had to keep a watch out for worms and blight. Wheat was attacked by rabbits and locust swarms, so the farmers built fences and stood guard over the fields. Wheat was thirsty, so humans dug irrigation canals or lugged heavy buckets from the well to water it. Sapiens even collected animal faeces to nourish the ground in which wheat grew.
- n8henrie 3y agoAll of the commenters so far (and the article's title) seem to assume that this is causative of good health. Why is that? I'm aware that fecal transplants can help cure C diff infections. Do we have randomized, placebo-controlled evidence that suggests that gut biodiversity is causative of (and not just associated with other lifestyle features causing) good health? It's hard for me to imagine a good way to design such a study. I thought the rigorously performed research regarding eg probiotics had mostly been disappointing. Is there any reason to think that food that is good for human health would not also be good for gut flora health, thus heavily confounding much of the non-interventional research?
- CrHn3 3y agoThe IMPRINT study has given us a lot of information using shotgun metagenomic sequencing of longitudinal fecal samples: https://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(21)00660-7 https://www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(21)00660-7 There seem to be windows where bacterial populations are in flux until the microbiome stabilizes around 3 years of age. It is difficult to modify the microbiome after that. I think our models have to shift so that we prioritize early intervention, especially for those at risk for dysbiosis (like premature and c-section babies).
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoStudy after study fail to disprove the hypothesis that gut microbiome diversity is a strong correlate with longevity. Here's a meta study for you: Here we introduce the MicrobiomeHD database, which includes 28 published case–control gut microbiome studies spanning ten diseases. We perform a cross-disease meta-analysis of these studies using standardized methods. We find consistent patterns characterizing disease-associated microbiome changes. What more do people want? Why is this something people fight? [1]https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-017-01973-8 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-017-01973-8
- CrHn3 3y agoI’m not sure what you take away from that meta analysis, but to me it does not seem to be about diversity as much as which groups of bacteria are associated with general improved health outcomes and disease. If you have more alpha diversity because you have more pathogenic strains, it does not necessarily mean it’s better. Some studies have found no differences in alpha diversity[1] when looking at outcomes like longevity. Maybe alpha diversity is the byproduct of healthy flora but it could be possible to engineer a microbiome that was more advantageous for a given population that was less diverse. 1. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7762384/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7762384/
- CrHn3 3y agoThis article conflates diversity with gut health. It has not been proven that more diversity is necessarily better[1]. In fact, in infants a less diverse b. infantis dominant environment is probably advantageous[2]. If you're having a baby, the best thing you can do is to supplement b. infantis, especially the robust strain from Evolve Biosystems[3]. The Hadza have more b. infantis[4] which kicks off a set of immune host interactions that have positive effects on inflammation during the critical period after birth[5]. "After around 3 years, the gut microbiota stabilises retaining relative proportions of taxa with adaptations to composition harder to impose,"[6] so I doubt it's diet as much as it is vertical transmission of the right kinds of bacteria that set the infants up for a lifetime of healthy immune response. 1. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5103657/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5103657/ 2. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6177445/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6177445/ 3. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7352178/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7352178/ 4. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9894631/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9894631/ 5. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0092867421006607 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S009286742... 6. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6950569/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6950569/
- dmbche 3y agoI'm surprised you're downvoted, you liked 6 papers and are just stating that the link is tenuous, I think that's fair.
- Fricken 3y agoThe parent opened their comment with a false claim. At no point did the article conflate gut diversity with gut health.
- FollowingTheDao 3y agoAlso, never ever ever do they mention anything about human genetics. There are people who carry more hunter-gatherer traits than others. So who is this diet really for? Genetics matter. I am a FUT2 non-secretor and this effects my gut health tremendously. I had IBD-D for years before I found this out. Before then if I took any pre or pro-biotics it was a nightmare, but that was supposed to be the healthy thing to do. So sorry, but I do not listen to any nutritional research anymore that over generalizes a genetically diverse population. https://www.nature.com/articles/ismej201464 https://www.nature.com/articles/ismej201464 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9866411/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9866411/
- lucidguppy 3y agoI think they should call them gatherer-hunter lifestyles. The bulk of calories for paleo/neo-lithic people came from stuff that didn't run away.
- bmitc 3y agoI think the left most adjective is a modifier of the right most. So hunter gatherers are primarily gatherers that also hunt.
- joker_minmax 3y agoLifestyle is more than just diet, there's the activity level, sun exposure, and different things in the water. I think we should just start saying that gray cubicles are bad for the microbiome and roll with that.
- asdff 3y agoYou'd have to uproot how the western world works to get us back to how we evolved to be healthy and survive on this planet. Finding time to get your 8 miles of walking a day in would be hard enough. We probably spend way too much time thinking a day as well with the 8 hour day. Think about how often a white collar worker does nothing but sit all day and gets home exhausted from the mental drain and stress: that can't be very healthy and is really far off from early modern human behavior as well. Stuff like a deadline you are stressing over is a very modern concept too, probably takes years off your life but what do you know we live by them and pretend like we are being productive and healthy while burning the wick at both ends. By the time you actually get the time to live like how you are supposed to live, you are old, in retirement, fragile from a lifetime of inactivity, and can't make up for your years lost of good physical health that you had to spend at a desk growing lethargic instead.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 3y ago> Finding time to get your 8 miles of walking a day in would be hard enough. I frequently do 6 mile walks with my dog, 8 miles would only be about 3 hours. Considering how much time people spend planted in front of a TV each day on average that shouldn't be that hard to hit. Tell you what, have the corpos give me an extra 1.5hrs each day and I'll give up 1.5hrs of TV and then we'll have enough for that 8 miles. We really need to take back our time from the exploitation class. A lot of problems go away if you work fewer hours a week, but there exist very few jobs that will pay anywhere near a livable wage for that. Like, I could easily survive on half my income if only someone would give me back half my time for it, but that just isn't an option.
- valval 3y ago
- Aerbil313 3y ago[flagged]
- tuukkah 3y agoI wonder what the result looks like if you test people who eat produce from a home garden or if it's typically not enough to make a difference and you'd have to live outdoors. Similarly, people still eat significant amounts of foraged berries and mushrooms in some places - it does not have to be all industrial even if you live in a city.
- chrisbuc 3y agoA forager friend of mine has just completed participating in a gut biome study (in conjunction with the UK Zoe project), where he and other foragers have been only eating wild foraged food for 3 months. A pretty good achievement for him (although he lost about 20kg over the 3 months). He blogged daily photos of what he ate on insta: https://www.instagram.com/rural_courses/ https://www.instagram.com/rural_courses/
- xenonite 3y agoSo what was the result?
- chrisbuc 3y agoHe only finished last week - all goes into the research project. More here: https://monicawilde.com/the-wildbiome-project/ https://monicawilde.com/the-wildbiome-project/
- tuukkah 3y agoI suppose it's best to start with 1 or 3 months of 100% foraged food like they are doing. If that works, later experiments can find out whether less than 100% is enough.
- tuukkah 3y agoThat would be an interesting data point in the higher end.
- DoreenMichele 3y agoPreviously: The Gut Microbes of African Hunter-Gatherers https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7599422 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7599422
- roody15 3y ago“ The team suspects chronic inflammation in the gut could trigger such damage, creating a selective pressure for those genes, says study co-author Matthew Olm, a microbiologist at Stanford. “If you have a state of chronic inflammation, it would make sense that your gut microbiome has to adapt,” he says. These genes were not detected in the Hadza microbiomes.” Think we are learning that a major key to overall health is minimizing the state of inflammation. Poor eating choices, lack of exercise, stressful job / life in general many urban environments tend to promote lifestyles where you could live in a state id constant inflammation.
- lumb63 3y agoCorrect me if I’m wrong, since I’m not an expert in this area, but I think lowering inflammation is not really the goal? Inflammation as I understand it is just a marker for stress (in the broadest sense of the word). I understand that inflammation is the body attempting to heal from said stress. So really, the goal is to remove chronic stressors, of which you listed many. I think you got most of the big ones, maybe missing toxic chemical exposure in food/air/water depending on locale, and mental stress due to a lack of societal cohesion, across a lot of the US at least.
- yeouch 3y agoFermented foods, psyllium husk, non-strict intermittent fasting and strength training will get you like 80% of the way there while still being able to enjoy sitting at your computer for 8+ hours a day.
- Aromasin 3y agoThis is the sort of advice people need to hear more of. Almost none of us are ever going to realistically adopt a hunter-gatherer lifestyle again. We need more data on how to get close to that within the confines of modern life. There's some great material out there now, but only very recently. I personally really enjoyed this discussion on this between Andrew Huberman and Justin Sonnenberg (Professor of Microbiology & Immunology at Stanford University): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ouCWNRvPk20 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ouCWNRvPk20 Huberman's prior episode is also great: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=15R2pMqU2ok https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=15R2pMqU2ok Basic takeaway was low sugar fermented food 4-6 times daily. Doable for almost everyone, palate aside.
- lkuty 3y agoThe book "Fiber Fueled" by Will Bulsiewicz is an excellent source of information regarding the gut microbiota and its importance. I highly recommend it.
- Biologist123 3y agoI know some Hadza. I told them a little while ago they’d be able to sell their bowel movements to westerners for cash. They didn’t believe me.