7 ms·
Extreme heat means 2/3 of North America could suffer blackouts this summer
- maerF0x0 3y agoOr put another way -- power utilities and grid failing to keep up with consumer demand.
- ceejayoz 3y agoNot necessarily for lack of trying. > The power grid is also grappling with supply chain and worker shortage problems that have cause some power facilities to delay or cancel maintenance aimed at getting the system primed for summer. Specifically, NERC warned that low inventories of replacement transformers could derail efforts to restart power facilities following hurricanes and severe storms.
- maerF0x0 3y ago> “The intermittent nature of wind power (wind turbines only generate electricity if the wind is blowing, and how much electricity they generate depends on how windy it is) present operational challenges for grid operators,” analysts from the US Energy Information Administration wrote in a report on Monday. “Low wind and high demand periods could result in energy emergencies.” > Wind plays a central role in meeting demand in Texas as well as the two power grid regions that cover most of the central part of the United States. Drought conditions and low levels of major reservoirs could also hurt hydro power generation. > NERC also flagged concerns about new environmental rules that restrict power plant emissions, warning these regulations will limit the operation of coal-fired generators in 23 states, including Nevada, Utah and states along the Gulf Coast, mid-Atlantic and Midwest. This is the first summer since the implementation of the EPA’s Good Neighbor Plan, which aims to reduce cross-state smog from power plants and other industrial sites. This is pretty clearly regulation/environmentalist caused. Not that we shouldn't pursue a climate friendly grid, but we're not there yet and forcing the timeline is causing creaks and issues.
- lovich 3y agoWould we ever move if we weren’t forced or would we just get to a different emergency after putting off necessary changes? My point being is that the other option wasn’t to do a gradual, planned rollout, given the political realities
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoWe could still go nuclear, which gives power 24/7 no matter if it's windy, sunny, cloudy or raining. But nope...
- bryanlarsen 3y agoNuclear is great for steady state power demand, but isn't a good match for peaky power demands, like air conditioning demand during heat waves.
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoYou can use the excess power (during low loads at night) to generate hydrogen fuel, pump water uphill to use hydro during the day, etc.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoIf you've got a way of storing power, why would you use expensive nuclear power rather than cheap renewable power?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lovich 3y agoAgain, political realities don’t allow for nuclear in the US. The best that could get accomplished is that we start regulating how much pollution you spit out like in the above referenced “Good Neighbor” plan because all but the craziest libertarian types at least begrudgingly acknowledge that you shouldn’t be able to throw trash on someone else’s lawn
- ajsnigrutin 3y ago> worker shortage Are there no workers? Or no money? So a lack of educated people (electricians, electrical engineers) in the country? Or do those people get paid more to flip burgers and do other stuff?
- smileysteve 3y agoThere are no workers for the the desired amount of money (and a lack in the trades). The US has - The Baby Boomers reaching Medicare + Social Security eligibility age. - An Intransitive stance on immigration, leading to fewer workers, and especially an inability to hire trained workers - Migrated from trades education ~30 years ago in favor of college preparatory - Historically low unemployment (likely from the other factors) - A very difficult to navigate minimum wage, costs of goods trap; where the dog food store near me is hiring at $15/hr; while a nearby alterations place was looking for a trained head seamstress for $10/hr, and grocery chains and Amazon are offering $30/hr warehouse jobs, while waitresses make $2.25 with little enforcement on tipped wages.
- maerF0x0 3y agoBoomers are going to have to suck it up and pay more taxes, or leave at which point we should exit tax them. They soaked up all the opportunities, and voted themselves no taxes, and promised themselves trillions of dollars their grandkids productivity. It's time to start hunting and punishing those who pay illegal immigrants less than minimum wage (I dont think we should bother trying to fight illegal immigration against the immigrants, punish the citizens who are breaking their local laws ie paying too little) >Historically low unemployment (likely from the other factors) I actually think this is more about the historically low amount of folks participating in the economy. A lot of these bureau stats only consider folks who want a job. But what is also really eye opening is the percent of the population who does some work. That number is hitting 40yr lows, and approaching numbers seen in 50/60s when it was far less common for women to work. Why does this matter? Imagine society has N hours of labor required to keep it functioning? If fewer people are willing to work, then the remaining worker pool must do more hours of work (or become far more productive).
- dylan604 3y ago>Not necessarily for lack of trying. Personally, I would disagree. The utility companies have had notice for quite some time that they are have very real capacity issues. However, the cost of bringing new generation on line is not worth it to them. They would rather keep things as is, and then ask customers to cut back, or issue rolling outages if they don't. Take the infamous Texas freeze as example where the utilities were recommended to take steps to protect against freezes, but they decided it was not worth the expense. There's a difference between equipment and generating capabilities. Failed transformers are an issue, but it's not new. Not being able to meet demand is also not new, but it's only going to continue to be an increasing problem
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoYep, and regulators demanding even more demand with their policies (eg. ban on ICE cars coming soon, random bans on non-electric heating, cooking, etc.). edit: sure, downvote, but mandated increased demand without infrastructure first is a recipe for failure.
- black6 3y agoYou are not wrong. Mandated shifts away from carbon-based energy systems always seem to fail to take into account the inherent increased demand on the power grid.
- TheAceOfHearts 3y agoMaybe this will have positive long-term outcomes, if it results in more people taking climate change seriously and it leads to investing in alternative forms of energy generation? Spending a few days suffering in the sweltering heat really makes you appreciate the magic of the AC and reliable access to power. The biggest concern is whether people will end up dying because of this. I know there's places in the US where the heat is legitimately lethal.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jimbob45 3y agoif it results in more people taking climate change seriously and it leads to investing in alternative forms of energy generation We're reaching breast cancer levels of awareness here. At this point, we're all aware of the issue and are actively voting to invest money in solving the problem. Awareness is no longer the problem.
- alexb_ 3y agoI don't see a large chunk of the voter base pretending that breast cancer is a myth invented by the chinese to slow down America.
- JimtheCoder 3y ago"large chunk of the voter base" I'm not sure how large it is...loud, maybe...
- Timon3 3y agoSize doesn't matter, only political power. The chunk of the voter base that believes that stuff is also the chunk that currently plays kingmaker for half the american government. Their last president was literally a proponent of this idea.
- tivert 3y ago
- pstuart 3y agoThe best way to deal with this: install solar power on site to power the AC. Make zero (or low) interest loans available to pay for it; the power companies could originate the loans and pay them back through the existing monthly payment system. Everybody wins: people get cheaper/sustainable power, the grid load is eased, and the utilities can make money handling the money.
- JimtheCoder 3y agoDo we have the materials and manufacturing capacity for a massive amount of solar panels right now? Installers?
- maerF0x0 3y ago> Installers I've long held that, at least in developed countries, we should be ending unemployment insurance and moving to guaranteed employment and utilizing unemployed folks for public service projects such as solar installs. Yes, of course not for disabled or high skilled folks who just need to transition. But for many many cases there's little reason to give someone hundreds per week for no work.
- JimtheCoder 3y ago"we should be ending unemployment insurance and moving to guaranteed employment and utilizing unemployed folks for public service projects such as solar installs." While I agree with that, it seems the implementation of a program like that would be quite difficult...especially considering how difficult it is to get pretty much anything done. Are these new workers doing things that other union workers could be doing? Would they have to join the union? Those two simple things would derail any plan like that for one side of the isle in the US, at least.
- maerF0x0 3y agoI agree politically it's a hard change. I'm just speaking about ideal policies at this point. Perhaps a wide retraining program offering. Something like "Hey you've been unemployed for 2 years, you're losing benefits starting (sometime). To help you along you can take a free solar installer course paid by the tax payer."
- jzellis 3y agoMy long term goal is to eventually be able to mostly run my house off DC solar. Considering that I moved to London from Las Vegas three years ago, it might not be the most realistic goal anymore, I grant you. ¦-D
- oh_sigh 3y agoI live in a place with similar temperatures to Las Vegas, and, I think the trick might be to have a very sealed up house, with very good insulation. And then, suck in as much cold nighttime air as you can, perhaps even running the AC at night since it is more efficient, and then try to ride that cold air through the day.
- Arrath 3y agoI do this as much as possible and it generally works fairly well. Less so now that the power company cut down a tree that helped shade my roof, but I can usually make it into mid-afternoon before having to kick the AC on during the summer highs. High Desert in SoCal for reference.
- wizofaus 3y agoGP was suggesting it's far more realistic in Vegas than London, where they moved to.
- zombielinux 3y agoThats how lots of large commercial buildings do it. Make huge blocks of ice in the middle of the night when energy is cheap and the building's heat load is at a minimum, then melt the ice and use the phase change of water to absorb as much heat as possible. Also why its colder in the morning and it feels like the building is a bit too warm to be comfortable if you stay late. This, of course, varies from building to building.
- leashless 3y agoSomething to note. If you put solar panels on the roof of a building, and plug them directly at 12V or 24V into an appropriate air conditioner (no batteries, inverters etc) the efficiency gains can be startling. Potentially useful for a lot of work places. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/323883629_DC_Appliances_and_DC_Power_Distribution_A_bridge_to_the_Future_Net_Zero_Energy_Homes https://www.researchgate.net/publication/323883629_DC_Applia... for example The match between daytime AC loads in workplaces and the output from solar panels is close enough to work in many areas.
- candiddevmike 3y agoI wonder how much residential energy usage ends up being DC vs AC these days, with computers, USB devices, LEDs, etc. I remember reading something about converting homes to have DC outlets, wonder if that's not too far away.
- sidewndr46 3y agoWhat would be magical about 12 or 24 volts that leads to an efficiency gain?
- tenacious_tuna 3y agoI think it's less that 12 or 24 is more efficient than mains, but rather that not having to convert DC -> AC -> DC and also not having to step the voltage up and back down is more efficient. That's 2x 'rounds' of conversion you don't have to do anymore. (though I'm not an electrician, I'm just guessing)
- sidewndr46 3y agodoes someone actually make an compressor that runs off DC directly? It'd have to be a universal motor from what I understand. That seems really unreliable.
- fencepost 3y ago
- gmuslera 3y agoSo, the Ministry for the Future will be funded after this year's event?