3 ms·
If you don’t want to be tracked then you have to make sacrifices on the scale of not carrying around a cellphone. But that really doesn’t scale. Handing out y
by Retric 3y ago
If you don’t want to be tracked then you have to make sacrifices on the scale of not carrying around a cellphone. But that really doesn’t scale.
Handing out your customers secrets doesn’t have a big red flag that automatically tells them you’re selling them out. That’s the core issue which has nothing to do with customer choices and why regulation is one of the few ways to give customers informed choices.
- hsbauauvhabzb 3y agoName any major organisation that’s not selling data excluding companies such as signal and (presumably) apple…
- Obscurity4340 3y agoThat's ok, but there should always be transparency in who is collecting the data and the chain-of-custody of data collected. The ad agencies and everyone affilliated thrive in the current darkness...
- hsbauauvhabzb 3y agoSorry that’s a valid point, my point is that I’d like to not have my data sold in the first place,
- xnx 3y agoGoogle, Facebook, Microsoft
- hsbauauvhabzb 3y agoYou don’t think they’re selling the data to other departments internally?
- ethbr0 3y agoThe only reason those 3 aren't selling data is that they have the vertical integration to launder and monetize it themselves. They don't have to sell it, because they can keep it, productize it, and then sell the targeting information to advertisers, without revealing the underlying data. -- Imagine a Google, Facebook, or Microsoft without an ad network and devices/apps to serve it on. Then tell me they wouldn't immediately be selling their tracking data to anyone who would buy.
- JohnFen 3y agoYes, but that's because they do the dirty work themselves. The dirty work is still being done. It's marginally better that they don't "sell" the data, but their collection and use of it is still horrible.
- soupfordummies 3y agoNot carrying a cell phone is a pretty huge sacrifice now—it’s almost to the point where you have to have one in order to participate in society.
- Retric 3y agoGiving up cellphones isn’t as big deal as you’re suggesting. At work and at home you can call or email em, they’re only out of contract for a few hours a day. Being required to hand over cellphones when entering a secure facility makes them far less appealing.
- soupfordummies 3y agoI actually disagree -- it's sneakily become a BIG deal to fully participate in society (esp post covid). Here's three real-world examples in a row: Took my partner out on a date downtown last Saturday night. Dinner and a show. Gotta have an app or at the least mobile browser to pay to park. No parking meters or out of order. Gotta have a camera/mobile browser to scan the menu at the restaurant. No more paper menus. Gotta have a phone to show your ticket to get into the theater. No more paper tickets. Just got bounced back and forth between staff when I tried. It's so many little things like this that have crept up -- especially in the last couple years. It's just assumed that everyone has a working charged phone in their pocket at all times now. Sure, can you get by and survive? Of course! But it's gonna be a giant pain in the ass and you're gonna be "that guy" to the people around you. Which again... pretty big sacrifice.
- ethbr0 3y agoParent was likely talking about activities for which there is only a "mobile app" solution, with no fall-back human option. The usual pattern is: 1. Company releases mobile app 2. Company directs users to mobile app, for data collection purposes, and releases new physical activities app-first. Backup, non-app methods are an afterthought 3. At some point, the non-app methods are so broken, under/unstaffed, that they're functionally useless Consequently, you now can't do the thing without a device.
- JohnFen 3y ago> If you don’t want to be tracked then you have to make sacrifices on the scale of not carrying around a cellphone. If that's all that was required, I'd be thrilled.