6 ms·
How the Y chromosome makes some cancers more deadly for men
- lr4444lr 3y ago[flagged]
- vore 3y agoI understand this comment is poo-pooing the idea of gender being separate from biological sex, but even biological sex is not as straightforward as having a Y chromosome meaning you're a man, such as women with Swyer syndrome...
- dvt 3y agoWittgenstein would have such a field day with the semantic games we're playing these days. The disclaimer basically says: "man" has a purely subjective meaning, but we're going to keep using the word anyway because we know you know what we mean objectively. Kind of funny if you think about it. I think that's what the (̶n̶o̶w̶ ̶n̶u̶k̶e̶d̶) comment was pointing out.
- amluto 3y agoIt’s a wee bit silly given that the article has “Y chromosome” all over it. But this is an article about cancer, and one could just as easily imagine that testosterone levels, or estrogen levels, or amounts of various types of tissue, etc could affect incidence of various types of cancer. For example, brief searching found: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complete_androgen_insensitivity_syndrome https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complete_androgen_insensitiv... XY people with this condition have rather different cancer risk profiles than the general population of XX cis females or XY cis males.
- lr4444lr 3y agoI'm not poo-pooing that idea. The issue is the political (mis/dis/ab)use of language in all contexts. This is Nature journal, for goddakes, using the term "man" in a completely obvious biological convention to discuss chromsomal effects on cancer prognosis. They have no reason to latently apologize for that by acknowledging gender sex disparity in this piece.
- kanbara 3y agonot all men have xy-chromosomes and not all xy-chromosome bearing people are men. it’s really simple, tbh
- z3c0 3y agoI get what you're saying, but do you feel that you require that nuance to be acknowledged to understand what the article is getting at with the word "man"? I miss elegant, succinct language. George Carlin's point about "shellshock" vs "posttraumatic stress disorder" deserves mention here.
- vGPU 3y ago[flagged]
- eozoon 3y agoThink of it as men = "people with y chromosome" varible setting, or a "People with y chromosome (hereinafter referred to as men)" in a contract. The scientifically accurate way to describe the subject of the article is "people with y chromosome" but that is clunky to repeat so they want to designate a shorthand for it, while acknowledging that without proper definition the shorthand would be vague and not accurate description. I'd think defining your terms clearly is perfectly suitable for a scientific journal.
- NhanH 3y agoDefining unusual term is perfectly suitable for scientific journal. Men == people with y chromosome is something that has been used for thousands of year (in the context of scientific writing), and if you have to define it, you might as well define the term “define”. In the context of this paper, no one is gonna ask “what do you mean by men” if you remove that disclaimer. Sure, another paper that discuss some social issues with men might have to clarify whether it is the y-chromosome men or all men, but this isn’t the case here
- haldujai 3y ago
- ozr 3y agoIf it's so rare that it needs to be explicit defined as a medical syndrome, a disclaimer should be unneeded.
- coredog64 3y agoSwyer syndrome is exceedingly rare. Where else do we muddy the waters of understanding for a 1 in 100,000 exception?
- davidmurdoch 3y agoSome people are born with only one arm. It is for this reason that we can no longer describe humans as having two arms. /s
- cocochanel 3y agoI will steal this one.
- _thisdot 3y agoReminds me of Steve Jobs unveiling the first iPhone. He mentioned it doesn’t need a stylus, but something all of us are born with!
- fzeroracer 3y agoHowever, if it turned out that having two arms meant you were at a higher risk for a specific cancer, you would probably describe it as 'two arms leads to higher rate of X cancer' rather than 'all humans are at higher risk of X cancer' because it's burying the lede.
- yarg 3y agoSure, but their gonads don't produce eggs. They're socially female and in many ways physically female, but from a reproductive perspective (the reason for sexual dimorphism in the first place) they're not female. They're males with transformative hormonal disorders. Also, arguments regarding legitimate medical issues like this and CAIS are completely orthogonal to the ideological reason behind the caveat on the article.
- _thisdot 3y agoI’m sorry, it’s not clear to me who you’re talking about
- yarg 3y agoThen we both get to be confused by each other's comments.
- eozoon 3y agoThe article is talking about colorectal cancer and bladder cancer, y chromosome owners can get those cancers too whether or not they have female phenotype or not.
- yarg 3y agoI was replying to a subject forked sub-thread, so what I said isn't directly applicable to the article.
- fzeroracer 3y agoSo by your own argument, are men that are infertile not men, then? If so, then I believe we have quite the reckoning with how many people think they're men when they're not.
- yarg 3y agoThey're not complete men. They're the whimper at the end of a 4,000,000,000 year long bloodline (I say blood). Our ability to replicate is and ever has been and will remain the primary guiding factor of our evolution. The meek be damned, it's the fertile who shall inherit the earth.
- mjfl 3y agoI think the issue is that men can clearly observe people in public these days, saying that they are men, when they are clearly not men, and are women, without ambiguity or any intersex condition. You are not able to say this to them without offense and thus... tension right?
- idlewords 3y agoBiological sex is a pretty clear and straightforward concept if you don't happen to be girded up for ideological battle around it. The idea that clear semantic categories somehow lose validity if they're fuzzy at the edges is unique to the gender wars; no one seems to find it problematic to talk about sandwiches, or childhood, or the fruit/vegetable binary, all of which are way muddier categories than sex.
- haldujai 3y agoIs anyone seriously debating that sex isn't binary? Gender being different from sex is not a new concept, from the 2001 IOM report (predating the "gender wars"): The committee defines sex as the classification of living things, generally as male or female according to their reproductive organs and functions assigned by the chromosomal complement, and gender as a person’s self-representation as male or female, or how that person is responded to by social institutions on the basis of the individual’s gender presen- tation. Gender is shaped by environment and experience. Not much has changed regarding sex from 2001, we've expanded the definition of gender which is clearly much more complicated. http://elibrary.pcu.edu.ph:9000/digi/NA02/2001/10028.pdf http://elibrary.pcu.edu.ph:9000/digi/NA02/2001/10028.pdf
- spinach 3y agoThere indeed are many people pushing the idea that sex isn't binary using things like Disorders of Sexual Development (intersex), other species that can change sex like clownfish (pretending this says something about humans), and also creating confusion between sex and gender and conflating them (such as how your sex is listed on ID, but people claim a gender, such as the opposite sex or non-binary, and have that gender listed as their sex).
- haldujai 3y agoI should have been clearer, sex is generally binary there are obviously rare exceptions like chromosomal abnormalities. Who's making these arguments? A quick Google scholar was not fruitful, do you have any sources or is this a fringe minority? > such as how your sex is listed on ID This presupposes that sex be listed on ID rather than gender. I don't follow this in the news so I'm not sure what the arguments are but at face value using the IOM definition from 2001 ("how that person is responded to by social institutions on the basis of the individual’s gender presentation.") gender seems like the more appropriate choice for identification.
- vGPU 3y ago> Fewer than 100 cases have been reported as of 2018. Irrelevant.
- acomjean 3y agoThey explicitly say that men=people with Y chromosomes in this article. Then they talks about “men” loosing the Y chromosome in some cells. “As men age, the proportion of Y-less blood cells increases, and an abundance of such cells has been linked to conditions including heart disease, neurodegenerative conditions and some cancers.” Sex and gender are lumped together in English and this creates some vagueness. Especially in the paragraph where they’re indicating that “lifestyle” plays a role in those differences in cancer rates.
- reaperman 3y agoIt makes sense to differentiate gender from sex for many scientific studies. There are many other studies where I could see it being entirely valid to bin AFAB men with all men. It's good for studies to specify how they define their bins.
- throwaway22032 3y agoThe commenters below seem to be missing the point entirely. When interpreting a study like this, the results should not be taken to be to be reliable when applied to trans men, to intersex individuals, or to anyone that exists with other rare conditions. A study dealing in averages cannot describe those edge cases by definition. That's why it's amusing to have it be pointed out, as it's self evident.
- Affric 3y ago> “You cannot generalize,” she says. “When people just throw all the data together, they miss the point.”
- bitcurious 3y ago> When interpreting a study like this, the results should not be taken to be to be reliable when applied to trans men They could apply to trans women, so it’s a worthwhile thing to clarify.
- throwaway22032 3y agoThey also should not be taken to be reliable when applied to trans women for the same reasons - they're outside of the normal hormonal envelope of a man and therefore an edge case.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nemo44x 3y agoThey’ve been institutionally captured for awhile. It’s just is what it is. Easier to play the word games and be polite than risk livelihoods for basically silly reasons. Eat the shame and sell out to keep the lights on.
- lr4444lr 3y agoI've heard. Just doing my small part to point out the obvious, and and melt a little snow as this ball keeps picking up mass on its downward roll.
- brickmort 3y agoIn the months leading up to the Russia's october revolution in 1917, citizens learned that it was much easier to just wear the badge of support for the revolution than be publicly harassed and ostracized by supporters. This passivity is what ultimately allowed the bolsheviks to gain power to in Russia's government and helped kick off events that plunged the country into decades of famine and misery. while the context and scenario here is different, 'eating the shame' is a very slippery slope.
- Apocryphon 3y agoWhatever one's views are on the hot button issue, it is breathtaking to watch a throwaway comment completely monopolize the discussion.
- lr4444lr 3y agoAs the OP, I agree 100%!
- bitcurious 3y agoYou ever look at a GitHub project and complain about how someone else used the same variable name as you, but had the gall to assign a different value to it? What you’re doing is the scientific literature equivalent. The term “man” is understood by a very broad swath of society, and overwhelmingly the educated class who writes for and reads these journals, to refer to the gender construct, not the biological fact. Clarity is always better.
- jeswin 3y ago> The term “man” is understood by a very broad swath of society, and overwhelmingly the educated class who writes for and reads these journals, to refer to the gender construct, not the biological fact. Clarity is always better. Are you saying that without the clarification, readers might be confused by what's implied by "man" here? Do we have to add this everywhere we use the term "man" now?
- derefr 3y ago> Do we have to add this everywhere we use the term "man" now? No; the journal article made the clarification because it was intentionally using the incorrect, not widely-understood definition ("people with a Y chromosome") for brevity. This group includes cis men, trans women, and — perhaps most surprisingly — XY people born intersex with "enough" feminine primary sexual characteristics at birth that they were then assigned to be female through genital surgery and lifelong estrogen injections. You might grow up all your life as female, and yet be more prone to these cancers, because you happen to have a Y chromosome — i.e. because you are "a man", in the chosen terminology of the paper. This is not how the word "man" is normally used!
- lr4444lr 3y ago> You ever look at a GitHub project and complain about how someone else used the same variable name as you, but had the gall to assign a different value to it? Without context? Literally, never.
- bl_valance 3y agoThe fact that this topic is so touchy, even in the tech/science circles which by far are the most "progressive", tells us that there is a lot of unresolved definitions that aren't talked about because of fearing to offend.
- DrDroop 3y agoBeing a black male athlete can gives you an increased chance of developing a certain type of kidney cancer. The full explanation is listed below, but the gist is black people have more chance to have sickle cell trait and during high intensity training your kidney starve for oxygen and this damages a certain gene that is a palindrome and thus hard to correct for the immune system and thus grows into a cancer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j7WGP6sJBLk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j7WGP6sJBLk
- reaperman 3y ago[flagged]
- acomjean 3y agoThis seems counter intuitive to me. Men having the Y chromosome, but also have and X. Women having two XX but only one is active. So unless those extra Y chromosome genes are causing issues I’m not sure why it would be different. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-inactivation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/X-inactivation I think x-inactivation is on a cell by cell level so it could be having 2 X chromosome would be an advantage, though why escapes me.
- Aleksdev 3y agoWell that sucks.