5 ms·
When wealthy adventurers take risks,who foots the bill for rescue attempts?
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoToday I heard about Julian Sands. I wonder if his decision to go solo hiking would be considered a risk.
- wavefunction 3y agoEverything is a risk, at least in terms of probabilities. Is it a reasonable risk is a more interesting and open-ended consideration. A solo day-hike is a reasonable risk in my estimation, but not when you add the issue of inclement weather. In the US Rocky Mountains prudent hiking culture urges hikers to descend below tree-line by "afternoon" as inclement weather is likely to occur after then in the day and trees can provide some protection. Descending far below rated depths in a carbon-fiber single-hulled "submarine" operated by a lunatic seems to the average person to be a simple reckoning of supreme foolishness or gullibility on the parts of the victims of the Titan implosion.
- dinkblam 3y agoit doesn't matter if the adventurer is wealthy or not, people why take extraordinary risks, should pay their rescue themselves (or have special insurance covering that stuff). why does the public have to pay for all those extreme sports people who need rescuing? they obviously should be required to have additional insurance...
- wyager 3y agoPeople can and do object on ethical and sometimes religious bases when they are forced to buy insurance against their will. An approach that wouldn't force anyone to buy anything and would be socially efficient is to just not send a rescue for people who haven't bought rescue insurance (effectively privatizing rescue, most likely) but this is politically unpalatable for most western cultures - you see the same with medicine. Also, how would requiring insurance for this even work logistically? Do we station cops anywhere a risky activity could conceivably happen? Do we arrest people if we think, post facto, they did something with a risk of rescue (like go on a hike) and didn't buy insurance for it?
- watwut 3y agoIn general, those sports do require special insurance. Includes rock climbing in alps - rescue gets really expensive if you do not have it. And second, these rescues are typically cheaper then searching bottom of the sea or moving massive military equipment half the world around without advanced warning. Rescures in these situations simply do not have infinite resources and work with what they have. And third, climbers typically do not try to use the situation to launder liberarian "public sector bad" while being actively rescued by damm military. The company called for help 10 hours after loss of contact, the company made whole series of "yolo" decisions too and then tried to turn the situation against their political enemies... who were just paying their customers rescue.
- tim333 3y ago>Includes rock climbing in alps - rescue gets really expensive if you do not have it. Not in France. Not sure which alps are expensive?
- watwut 3y agoAustria, Switzerland, same rules apply for mountains in Slovak Republic. The mountains themselves are not expensive. The expensive part happen when you need rescue after your climbing and don't have insurance. The insurance itself is not expensive and is super easy to get.
- teeray 3y agoNH Fish & Game offers a “Hike Safe” card [0] for $25 ($35 for family) which is approximately an insurance program offered by the state. It acts like a “get out of jail free” card if you need a rescue and are adequately prepared. The funds contribute to the search and rescue fund (along with hunting / fishing licenses / OHRV registrations, which receive the same benefits). [0] http://www.hikesafe.com/ http://www.hikesafe.com/
- wyager 3y agoWe do this to some degree already, but it would be nice if rescues could be repurposed as military training. The cost of a rescue is small compared to baseline military burn rate, and it's good training. Someone gets lost in the forest? Pretend the person who got lost is a high value military asset and bust out those fancy thermal camera drones for some practice. (Civilian departments in wealthier/larger areas have those now too, but less expensive ones.)
- watwut 3y agoWith added bonus of "when they try to shill 'public sector bad' political point as public sector is working overtime to save them". That was particularly distasteful of that company.
- luma 3y agoPoor person gets cancer? Well we don’t have enough money to treat them, sorry but they have to die a preventable death through no fault of their own. Rich person does stupid, risky things? We have millions to spend on search and rescue efforts.
- wyager 3y agoHow many times a year do you think people get cancer vs get lost at sea?
- azinman2 3y agoNot to mention that if a poor person does something stupid and gets lost, millions could still be spent in their rescue. Search and rescue isn’t the same thing as health care.
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoDoes it make any difference?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wyager 3y agoYes, since the structure of OP's complaint was whether or not we have "enough money" to do things. I'm not advocating for any particular expense policy here, just pointing out that we can easily afford to fund all rescue missions, while paying for all cancer treatment is a much larger expense, so it's not unreasonable that people don't funge those two categories.
- Supermancho 3y ago> while paying for all cancer treatment is a much larger expense Not all. Additional. No moving the goalposts.
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoI have another concern - if I am lost in the atlantic, will half the US and canadian navy mobilise to save me, like they did for these guys? I don't have the confidence that they will.
- AwaAwa 3y agoIt's a big club and we ain't in it.
- wyager 3y agoIf you can get yourself lost in an equally attention-grabbing way, they probably will.
- expertentipp 3y agoWithout internet in the open sea to stream it, would be very difficult...
- gautamdivgi 3y agoI think world navies and coast guard collaborate on high seas rescue and recovery [0]. 0. https://www.sail-world.com/Australia/Unsinkable-A-Young-Womans-Courageous-Battle-on-the-High-Seas/-82756?source=google https://www.sail-world.com/Australia/Unsinkable-A-Young-Woma...
- silverquiet 3y agoStartup idea - specialized EPIRBs that cost $10 million dollars so the rescuers know you're rich and can prioritize you over the huddled masses.
- Tarq0n 3y agoEmergency position-indicating radiobeacon for others that were also wondering.
- silverquiet 3y ago
- deltree7 3y agoEvery rescue attempt is a practice run for something more important in the future. Whether it's a cat stuck in a tree or a Billionaire in the bottom of the ocean, first responders must attempt rescue for the benefit of humanity. Explorers always make plenty of rookie mistakes. I'm sure there are plenty of lessons for future explorers, first respondents, regular people from these events.
- PeterStuer 3y agoWhere these 'explorers' or 'tourists'?
- deltree7 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vxNsr 3y agoIsn't this similar to the type of thing we see here on hn all the time... some journalist, or person with a big following does something (sometimes semi-stupid) that runs afoul of big tech's automated policies and loses access to their account, they use their influence to pressure real eyes on the thing to fix it. While there are of course major differences, I think the point is that public opinion would dictate that if we know about something like this people would want a search are rescue mission launched. The only reason it wouldn't be launched for someone with less money is because that person's family/friends wouldn't have the PR team to tell everyone about it. I don't want to live in a world were if we know someone is lost at sea we just sit back and say, "well they made their bed." That's a pretty callous world to live in, where we see someone in trouble and turn our backs... and by the way there is a parallel for poor people, just ask Italy/Spain, they're constantly dealing with migrants trying and failing to come across the Mediterranean in boats not built for that, as soon as they see it's not gonna work, they do launch rescue missions.
- arp242 3y agoOwning a car comes with the obligation to get insurance in most jurisdiction, so it's not that outlandish to require insurance for these types of things too. The question is what exactly "huge risks" are; I've been hiking on my own and sometimes didn't see anyone for days; is that a "huge risk" or just a "risk"? Do I need an evaluation to see how "prepared" I was? In the end everyone takes some amount of "risk" at times, so how do you define "exceptional" risk and codify that in law? I'm certainly not looking forward to a future where everything that could possibly perhaps be risky are regulated to the microscopic level. And if we look at the overall costs, are we really talking about that much money? Is it unreasonable for the public to carry these costs? Personally I'd say yes. But is it enough money to act upon, considering any legislation will also restrict normal people? A lot less sure about that.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Owning a car comes with the obligation to get insurance in most jurisdiction, so it's not that outlandish to require insurance for these types of things Arizon’s stupid motorist law “states that any motorist who becomes stranded after driving around barricades to enter a flooded stretch of roadway may be charged for the cost of their rescue” [1]. This transfer of liability is simpler than insurance requirements. And it doesn’t strike me as callous when dealing with wealthy people voluntarily engaging in risky activities within a jurisdiction that has the capability to save them. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stupid_motorist_law https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stupid_motorist_law
- arp242 3y agoThis is extremely narrowly defined and doesn't really translate to generic "huge risks". This is really the problem, because you can narrowly define specific situations like "drive around barricade to enter a flooded road" or "go on a deep-sea dive in an uncertified experimental sub built by some cowboys", but the list is basically infinite so it's not really practical to codify all of those situations, except those that occur frequently enough that it's a structural issue (which I presume is the case with this specific law).
- throwaway22032 3y agoMost of the reason why internet discourse feels weird / uncanny valley to me is that it seems to often be made up of teenage debate society level "hot takes" on the bloody obvious. Attractive, rich people get more attention. People who try and push the envelope, as misguided as it might be, get more attention than everyday human #66384385 on the street. GPT4 gets more attention than some neural net demo I make on my Raspberry Pi. Why would it ever be otherwise? A world like that would have us still in caves.
- Tarq0n 3y agoThis is an example of the is-ought fallacy [0]. Especially when it comes to the spending of public funds by a democratic government it makes sense for people to make their preferences known. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is%E2%80%93ought_problem https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Is%E2%80%93ought_problem
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throwaway22032 3y agoI don't think that human nature is a fallacy. There are evolutionary reasons behind preferring fitter members of the group.
- blacklion 3y agoFor everybody who says (quotes from different comments here): > How many times a year do you think people get cancer vs get lost at sea? > Not to mention that if a poor person does something stupid and gets lost, millions could still be spent in their rescue. > Every rescue attempt is a practice run for something more important in the future. I want to remind, that at same time about 700 refugees were lost in Mediterranean. Without any SnR, practice run or another.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> at same time about 700 refugees were lost in Mediterranean Were there Americans on board? Governments treat their citizens’ lives differently. It’s not fair, but it’s an obvious consequence of our organisation around nation states.
- AviationAtom 3y agoIf it had been in American waters, and they had been detected, then the USCG would have taken them aboard and to shelter while their status was sorted out.
- zajio1am 3y agoIt is problematic that such class/wealth-based rhetoric is used even in mainstream publication like apnews.com and not just some far-left rag. It does not matter whether adventurers are wealthy or not, there are plenty of high-risk activities that sometimes require costly rescue missions, while being affordable to middle-class people (e.g. mountaineering or caving). The mechanism to footing the bill should be the same, so there is no reason to single-out wealthy ones.
- expertentipp 3y agoDuring the same week two Pakistanis were imploded into meat cloud and probably tens of their fellows sunk in the boat on the Greek coast. From two extreme social casts, all of them paid for their trips. Both trips incurred expenses by US and EU taxpayers. Why don't they share food and get along together?!
- sergioisidoro 3y agoIf the wealthy would pay taxes proportionally to their wealth, and not evade taxes like many do, this would be an easy answer for me.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- motohagiography 3y agoI think as a species, we tend support people who we percieve could or might do something for us in the future. It's not just about rich/poor or race, it's whether you think the people being rescued could provide future opportunity for you or your group. There's also the question of whether the risk you are taking to rescue someone will be valuable to them. Are you going to risk anything to intervene in a dispute between apparent meth addicts, or move on? The calculation is based on your perception of the quality of their choices leading up to their circumstances. Like if there were the hands in the water of people drowning that you can pull into a boat, when do you grab the one with the possibly-racist tattoo? You rescue small groups of adventurers because they are engaged in a socially valuable activity. The whole point of having search and rescue helicopters to rescue skiiers and hikers is that hikers and skiiers represent people who help themselves, and they are part of the positive group we have organized our society to encourage and incentivize. Some societies encourage and incentivize corruption and exploitation, and so they don't need to rescue hikers unless they can be used to extract favours from foreign governments. There's a limited amount of effort you're going to make to rescue a narco-sub crew because they're a hostile and invasive force that is importing poison, violence, and exploitation into your society. There is a notion of "us," and "not-us," everywhere in the world, and in the case of some rich toursts in a sub, they were still "us." The sadistic glee about these rich people dying in a sub, and the fantasies some people have written about their suffering, makes me wonder who among us would be really worth saving.
- rambojohnson 3y agoit's so obnoxiously obvious: their estates, their rich families, who else should? lol
- tim333 3y agoI guess mostly either taxpayers do or they are covered by volunteers / voluntary organisations like the British lifeboat service. A problem with charging is what about the non wealthy people who need rescue attempts? I know a bit about Everest rescues. The government is pretty useless being nowhere near the action and insurance services are kind of useless on the whole too. Rescues are mostly done if at all by other climbers / sherpas on the mountain and usually free though offering the sherpas a few thousand in cash probably would help. Helicopters won't fly without credit card payment (about $15k from base camp).
- nowaternoice 3y ago[flagged]