7 ms·
Ways to say no with grace and style (2021)
- yamrzou 3y agoI wonder why is it that a simple “No” is vexing, that it requires ways to say it with grace and style?
- eur0pa 3y agoThis is an all-American problem; the rest of the world says «no» just fine
- wenc 3y agoI think the Brits and the Japanese rarely say an outright no too.
- dijksterhuis 3y agoIn Britain we often just pretend we didn’t hear them and hope they leave. A problem ignored is a problem solved.
- fullspectrumdev 3y agoI almost miss working in the UK, because you could just fuck off a problem you didn’t want to deal with and nobody would call you out on it
- balder1991 3y agoI wouldn’t generalize it like this. Each culture has a lot of subtleties that make certain responses rude.
- nordsieck 3y ago> This is an all-American problem; the rest of the world says «no» just fine Obviously, you've never been to Japan.
- danielscrubs 3y agoWay easier to understand in Japan because of how it is delivered (body language, lived there for years). Americans can sometimes deliver a yes/no with a non confrontal, energetic go getter smile which makes it very puzzling to outsiders. To believe an American I really have to look for commitment details delivered unprompted, otherwise it’s just hot air. Very anecdotal data because I haven’t been there much though.
- pgwhalen 3y agoIn my (admittedly limited) experience, American corporate culture is stronger than most with respect to encouraging people to say no.
- stcroixx 3y agoI don’t think an Indian coworker has told me no in 25 years. So much waste and stress can be avoided with simple accurate communication.
- cobertos 3y agoUnrelated, but did anyone notice how the 'ff' ligature in "Warren Buffett" overrode the capitalization. What a weird edge case I've never thought of. EDIT: Ahh, it looks like it uses a font-variant: all-small-caps without setting font-ligatures: none
- ranting-moth 3y agoI hope you list "extraordinary attention to detail" on your CV! Nice find. I'm guessing it's a bug in the font?
- jfk13 3y agoYes, a well-engineered font should handle the interaction better -- probably the easiest approach would be to ensure that case-substitution subtables are ordered ahead of ligature subtables. (Though as cobertos noted, the author could have worked around the font issue by more careful use of font variant properties in their CSS.)
- wahahah 3y agoIt's not plain to me that ligatures might conflict with smallcaps. Certainly feels there's no good reason for that to be the case.
- flangola7 3y ago"No." is a complete sentence.
- justin_oaks 3y agoIt might need an awkward silence thereafter to be truly complete.
- tgv 3y agoDepends a bit on your definition of a sentence, but "no" is only an interjection. The sentence lacks a verb and a subject, so some might not consider it complete. In case of a yes/no question, the rest of the sentence can be thought elided, which would make it complete. It is, however, perfectly clear.
- ranting-moth 3y agoIt entirely depends on who you're talking to if they are entitled to grace and style. Although I would like to think that I treat everyone with grace and style. If I'm polite with my "no", and it still doesn't work and the person isn't entitled to grace and style then I make it very clear and abrupt. "I said no, do you understand what that means?"
- stcroixx 3y agoSome may not even be interested in or want your grace and style. A simple no would be far preferred.
- behnamoh 3y agoIn academia, it’s almost impossible to say “no” to a senior faculty. I’ve had situations where a coauthor requested something that was just infeasible, but pushing back against that made them not trust me with future projects because they thought I was justifying my incompetence, whereas they were the ones who wouldn’t even listen to my detailed reasoning. This environment forces you to just give them the results that they like to see, even if the results are not scientifically accurate. It’s as if the goal is not to do science, but to publish and tell an interesting story in your papers. You might say: “well, just ignore them and do your own thing”, but unfortunately in academia so much depends on how people like you. Without good recommendation letters, citations, and networking, you can’t really go far in your academic career. I’ve seen people who couldn’t get their tenure after several years because of this. It makes me sad but unfortunately this is the truth I discovered only recently. Had I had known about it, I’d stick to industry jobs. I can remind myself that almost no one will ever read academic papers in my field, but at the end of the day, I’m still struggling with this dilemma: do the right and scientific thing and ruin my future in academia, or do what my peers are doing and make senior faculty like me.
- CapitalistCartr 3y agoAny chance you have to get out of academia, go. Anyone competent should avoid that life. Society is better off with good people in academia, but an individual is better off out.
- behnamoh 3y agoTrust me, I've thought about it for long. Unfortunately, the main obstacle is visa issues. I've heard stories about international PhD students who left academia to work in the industry, only to be treated like slaves because the employer knew the person couldn't just switch jobs while on H1B visa (no other company would hire them). Then there's the greencard issues (easier to get approved if you're an academic).
- totallywrong 3y agoI'd say don't be miserable for a visa. If you are at PhD level, there are many great countries that will be happy to have you.
- SmoothBrain12 3y ago[dead]
- robwwilliams 3y agoHere in Memphis Tennessee (and perhaps more widely in the South) the following response to a request is equivalent to a hard no: “Let me get back to you on that.”
- OldGuyInTheClub 3y agoIn Los Angeles it is, "You can count on me"
- jowdones 3y agoLOL, that's good :)) I just learned a new thing, can't wait for the opportunity to use it in real life.
- shannifin 3y agoWhen the other fills in the void of an awkward pause, it tends to be to try to further convince you to say yes, which can be really annoying. I usually just say sorry, no by default, then I can change mind after if necessary.
- balder1991 3y agoNot related to the post content itself, but I really like this blog’s theme. It makes me prefer reading the actual page instead of the “reader mode” from my browser.
- shannifin 3y ago"What should I deprioritize?" I've known a couple supervisors who hate this response, effectively responding in turn "nothing!" (Fortunately I did not work for them myself, just heard them complain about it.)
- fud101 3y agothat was my immediate reaction to reading that also. It's easy for the person to say nothing and then what? You haven't got much out of that exchange at all. Now you still have to say no, which was the original problem that you tried to side-step.
- laserlight 3y ago> then what? Then, at least you know that you are dealing with a jerk.
- icegreentea2 3y agoWell, this depends. If you were saying no because you honestly believe that you cannot accommodate your manager's (or whatever) request into your current schedule/plan/loading, then you probably want to take the time to get in writing a new plan that exactly articulates what your manager believes your old plan and priorities were, and what your new plan and priorities are. You are now trying to solve a planning and communication problem. If you were just saying no because you didn't -want- to do it. Well, then your manager is calling your bluff, and ya, you need to find another way to wiggle out of it. Tough luck.
- zeteo 3y agoA useful variation is: "Where does this fit in the order of priorities? Would you put it above <most important pending task> or <most urgent pending task>?". If neither, you have some time to figure it out later, after you complete your ongoing task(s).
- paddw 3y ago> Saying no to a senior leader at work is almost unthinkable, even laughable, for many people. However, when saying yes is going to compromise your ability to make the highest level of contribution to your work, it is also your obligation. What kind of world do the people who write this stuff live in?
- Nocturium 3y ago[flagged]
- steveklabnik 3y agoFrom the FAQ: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html > Can I delete my account? > > We try not to delete entire account histories because that would gut the threads the account had participated in. However, we care about protecting individual users and take care of privacy requests every day, so if we can help, please email hn@ycombinator.com. We don't want anyone to get in trouble from anything they posted to HN. More here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23623799 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23623799
- have_faith 3y ago> because that would gut the threads the account had participated in It wouldn't if it just gutted the data and replaced the username with a generic string. This feels very "perfect being the enemy of good" teritory. Of course if HN was based in the EU this would have to have been solved by now.
- cpif 3y agoFor those situations which require neither grace nor style: http://www.textfiles.com/humor/101nos.txt http://www.textfiles.com/humor/101nos.txt
- keepamovin 3y agoThese are hilarious! Oh, the good old days of text...how I miss the internet of my youth!
- wiz21c 3y agoYou can still have grace and style by showing the finger (depending on the culture and your willingness to take some risk) :-)
- palata 3y agoI love this one (not in your list): "I wish I could, but I don't want to" :D
- agumonkey 3y agoMy next mail will be "sorry I couldn't read you, my connection dropped"
- activiation 3y agoLove the "Monk mode" but there are also a lot of other good tips in there.
- nmcfarl 3y agoThese are all fairly obvious sadly. And as such are lacking in style, and grace is much harder with angry people who know what is up. These days when I say I need to check my calendar people are instantly disappointed, everyone knows it’s beyond full. And I can memorably remember being screamed at extensively (by a higher up outside of my chain) in a meeting 20 years ago, for asking what needed to be deprioritized. I mean I use these all, but if people are going to be emotional about a no, they will see right through these, and you will have the same problems.
- ericbarrett 3y ago> And I can memorably remember being screamed at extensively (by a higher up outside of my chain) in a meeting 20 years ago, for asking what needed to be deprioritized. I think the list assumes you aren't being abused :( Screaming at a subordinate like that is abuse, full stop. If that's what one is dealing with, nothing on this list is going to help. I had a similar experience, in about the same era, and nothing on this list would have helped me, either. But it's still good advice! Some people just don't know how to say no, and it's tough watching them bury themselves with stress handling tasks that could have been deflected with no loss to the company, or even the one who asked.
- swayvil 3y agoHow is screaming at your coworkers a thing? Doesn't that instantly disqualify you from the sane adults club?
- Calamitous 3y agoYou would think. But while it’s not common, in my experience, it does happen. I recall one job I had in a startup where the CTO was a screamer; he’d literally storm around the programming pit shouting at everyone when he was in a mood.
- watwut 3y agoIt obviously does. But, it will not harm your management career at all, so we get managers that verbally abuse people.
- activiation 3y agoA lot of times, i don't say no but I explain why I can't say yes.
- justin_oaks 3y agoI'm not saying this is you, but many people explain too much. Either the explanation ends up being lies to weasel out of something, or it's unnecessarily long explanation that the other person doesn't want to hear. I prefer to both give and hear a simple no. People who seek explanations aren't always entitled to them (i.e. they're not your boss). Some people feel rude not giving explanations when asked. I feel people are rude for expecting me to give an explanation when I've said no.
- activiation 3y agoLast time I gave an explanation, it was to someone who thought he was my "boss"... Instead of telling him no, i told him why he had no reason to tell me what to do... I probably should have told him no or fuck you like you suggested
- Nocturium 3y ago[flagged]
- om154 3y agoThis seems particularly relevant for work - if you work with reasonable people, that don’t expect you to deliver 2 weeks of work in one. As for personal commitments (or “yes”) find it easier to say “let me think on it” or “that’s a great idea. Let me get back to you.” Life is busy and it’s hard to commit in the moment anyway amongst whatever your existing commitments are.
- palata 3y ago> if you work with reasonable people, that don’t expect you to deliver 2 weeks of work in one. Which is by far not the norm with managers I've had.
- FpUser 3y agoI had big cultural shock when I came to Canada just because of that. You talk to a person (especially in business environment) and you have no fucking idea what are they saying. Dealing with muricans was a breath of fresh air. They mean what they say and if they say something it is as good as on paper (at least this was my experience). It is my impression that in Canada many are pathologically incapable of giving straight answers (there are pleasant exceptions here and there). I was told many times that I am "too direct". Well for some reason I prefer it this way and refuse to bend. Maybe it hurt me few times but I think it had also paid back.
- justin_oaks 3y agoI'm wondering if there are any advantages to having a culture of indirectness, where instead of "no" you say something like "That would be very difficult" or some other code language for "no". Thus far, I've only been able to see downsides to not being direct in communication.
- snovv_crash 3y agoIf they're being weasely with you it's probably to avoid giving offence. A lot of people don't react well to "You have no idea what you're talking about, please be quiet while the rest of us discuss what needs to happen." or similar, so instead some platitudes get mentioned and the topics move on.
- FpUser 3y agoNope. Nothing of that nature. If "I have no idea" what I am talking about I freely admit to it and do not mind asking an explanation. It was mostly business dealing with various subcontractors including factories. Q. Can you make this and that by 11 xteenth? And how much A. Eh, meh followed by the story of their life. Q. Ok let's try the other way. Give me a terms you are comfortable with A. Blah, blah, blah ... Yap, yap, yap ... No real answer Finally found somebody from whom I was able to extract X pesos Y months. Deposited retainer. Y month passed Q. A we ready. A. Oh this part did not come. That material is not available. Q. Why the fuck did not you say so before? You have assured me that there will be no hold ups of that nature. A. Blah, blah, blah ... Yap, yap, yap ... No real answer
- kleiba 3y agoOf course, there is a cultural bias to be recognized as well. In the country I currently live in, I notice that it is way more common to give a blunt "no" to some request than it would be in the states, where we would (at least on the surface) try to be more accommodating. Even if we don't want to say yes :)
- tempodox 3y ago> “The difference between successful people and very successful people is that very successful people say ‘no’ to almost everything.” Which is false if you're not a decider to begin with. Otherwise, saying “no” to almost everything lands you somewhere between ‘uncooperative’ and ‘insubordination’. The majority of people are not the target audience for this article.
- zeteo 3y agoExactly. This is like saying the difference between sick and healthy people is that healthy people almost never go to a hospital. It's true, but saying no to almost everything is more useful as a way of recognizing a very successful person than becoming one.
- fma 3y agoI have no clue who the target audience is for this article... The "advice" ranges from saying no to coffee to saying no to your boss. Then the advice on "checking my calendar"...uh if I'm your boss, I would have checked your calendar already and see where you have timeslots. Article seems like the author asked ChatGPT for ways to say no and then added their examples to shoehorn to one article.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rcme 3y agoSaying ‘no’ to almost everything is the difference between successful people and very successful people. It’s not the difference between very successful people and unsuccessful people.
- classified 3y agoThat's just saying "beggars can't be choosers" in a way that flatters the powerful. If you're "successful" and need Warren Buffet to tell you that, you might as well let it be.
- 3y ago
- usrbinbash 3y agoI have found that "No problem, which of your projects may I put on hold for that?" is a pretty effective way of saying "No". Doubly useful, because if they actually want it enough to have it done anyway, they will free up the time required for it by themselves. The important thing here is to memorize another phrase: "Certainly. Could you send me a quick email about that reprioritization?" Which is just a very graceful and stylish way of saying: "Can I have that in writing?"
- DangitBobby 3y agoAnd if you have to deal with someone who can't be bothered to write an email for you, you can just agree verbally and send them a summary email afterwards. Either they respond or they accept the summary implicitly.
- whall6 3y agoMaybe we have different goals, but if you want to grow in your career this is terrible advice. I get it, we can’t do everything, but surely there’s something you can put to the side.
- jakewins 3y agoI’ve found the opposite FWIW - in many orgs you get rewarded for getting stuff built, and a powerful tool for that is to show product and upper management the tradeoffs of their requests, to counter scope creep. “I can move the team off what they are doing to accommodate this request, but we will need to deprioritise <thing you asked for last week> if we want to stay on schedule”
- usrbinbash 3y agoI am not putting anything aside. My employer is. My time is a resource my employer has at his disposal. He pays me and in exchange gets to decide how he wants to allocate my time. My job includes giving realistic estimates on how long things take to accomplish. When asked to do something that I know cannot be done due to resource and time constraints, I's my duty to tell my employer as much, so he can make a strategic decision. And in my experience, employers value that input.
- douglee650 3y agoAuthor seems to have missed "ghosting" .. perhaps it lacks the grace and style.
- tgv 3y agoDo people not understand that tactic, or don't they want to understand it? Perhaps it's a bit of both, but it is not a sure-fire way of denying a request.
- mosselman 3y agoAbout 80% of these are pretty cowardly and the others overly verbose. Saying “sure I’ll meet you later this year” is not saying no. It is either lying or just a yes. Ignoring people with bounces is also lying and cowardly. Just say no. The one with the priorities is too long and vague. It is also known as “yes, and” as in “yes and which thing should I not do?” Much more to the point. People will respect you more if you literally say “no”. If you start saying things like “I can’t right now because …” that just invites people to do problem solving like “ok so what if I write the blog post, then can you do the job interview?”. A more direct variation is “no. I can explain to you why if you want”. Then the answer is clear and it signals there is no room for negotiation. That is a real no. Or just “no”
- thyrox 3y agoYes they are mostly weasel ways of saying No. But humans are strange irrational creatures and for some reason even when you know what the other is doing it's still better to hear I would love to help you but.. phrase. I've tried the downright No after getting advice it's just better to say No directly, and I can tell you from experience that there is no better way to burn bridges and get people to dislike you when you do that. People seldom respect you for doing that. I think it's some strange disconnect from the theoretical and practical.
- mhb 3y agoSure, but the examples given have neither grace nor style.
- rewgs 3y ago> I can tell you from experience that there is no better way to burn bridges and get people to dislike you when you do that. Agreed, with the caveat that I’ve almost always not regretted letting the bridge burn, because I dislike them for not being able to handle a simple but polite “no” as much as they dislike me for offering it.
- whall6 3y agoAgree entirely.
- alberth 3y agoThese are horrible recommendations. The article is telling you to lead people to believe you'll say yes - and when you ultimately never do - they'll hate you more for it. Or, you're simply creating more work on yourself because you're having to constantly come up with yet another excuse to kick the can down the road. If the answer is "no", just say no. People will appreciate it more than above because you're respecting them and their time.
- asylteltine 3y ago[dead]
- platz 3y agoThe author clearly has a bias towards categorizing people as Essentialist or Non-Essentialist. Exactly how in this context do those terms make sense ?
- noud 3y agoThere is absolutely no reason to have 8 cheesy indirect ways of saying no when, "I'm very sorry, but I cannot do it" (or something in these lines) is a perfectly fine way to say no in almost every case.
- noud 3y agoI once asked a girl for a date who responded with "I cannot make it, because I have to polish my nails tonight." When I asked if she could make it tomorrow, she answered that she also had to polish her nails tomorrow. I would have been fine if she just said "no".
- chx 3y agoOne thing I learned from freelancing: never say no to a new project. Quote an outrageously high price instead. What's the worst that can happen? They pay it.
- sjducb 3y agoI used to think this till I spent a family holiday working in a hotel room.
- maximilianroos 3y agoA couple of additional approaches I've had success with: - "I can (for you), but it involves me asking a few people for a big favor, so could you confirm with your (manager / colleagues / friends) that they really want this?". I've found this a) filters out most low-value requests, b) gets your own contribution recognized. - "I didn't quite understand your email. The choices are A or B or C, what works best for you?". Don't anchor on their request, don't even mention it, just restate the choices open to them and let them choose. Particularly where there's a clear external anchor it elides any contrast with their request "well you said X, I can only do A, sorry there's such a gap".
- whall6 3y agoThe best advice I’ve ever received is to treat everyone I work for like a client. In that vein, asking a senior leader what other tasks you should deprioritize is asinine.
- throwawaaarrgh 3y ago> Say, “Yes. What should I deprioritize?” Dude. That is the most savage passive-aggression I have ever heard. Is this guy a brit? > “You are welcome to borrow my car. I am willing to make sure the keys are here for you.” Who would ever say this? An asshole, that's who. Don't be a passive-aggressive asshole. Just say no. If this makes them upset, use language that expresses empathy and compassion. But don't avoid a hard fact by trying to be cute or non-confrontational.
- yCombLinks 3y agoI think you're wrong on both counts. The first example is closer to direct than passive. Passive-Aggressiveness would be saying yes, but intentionally doing a poor job without communicating. His second example was letting someone borrow his car when he couldn't drive them. I can't drive you, but you can borrow my car. I will make sure to get you the keys. Doesn't seem assholish to me.
- idk1 3y agoThe "what should I deprioritize" is a tad passive agressive for my liking. I do this but I do it in another way. My way to manage to-dos ane people has always been... I have a public visible list of all my to-dos, and I share my screen and talk through where I can put it in the list, I do most of the time want to genuinely help everyone out with everything, so I get it on the list but it could be a few months away and I let them know other people could bump it down too, if it's high priority we can get a few more people on the call and negotiate it going at the top of the list, schedule a call for later to do this. This way everyone is aware of everything and then they may find another way of getting it done, or it gets done in a month or two and everyone is happy!
- lisasays 3y agoWhen I was writing this book I set an e-mail bounceback with the subject line “In Monk Mode.” The e-mail said: “Dear Friends, I am currently working on a new book which has put enormous burdens on my time. Unfortunately, I am unable to respond in the manner I would like. For this, I apologize.—Greg.” If one of my friends did this -- actually, my real friends would never do this. But if by "friend" here is meant in the fairweather / outer social orbit sense -- I guess it could sort of work. Most of the other techniques here (like the humorous "Nope!") strike me as off-base, somehow. And a sign that that person probably isn't worth having as a high-value friend.