3 ms·
Ponzi scheme? Yes. Lots of major players who really don't want the Ponzi pyramid to collapse? Yes. But, long-term, no Ponzi pyramid can avoid collapse. Bla
by bell-cot 3y ago
Ponzi scheme? Yes.
Lots of major players who really don't want the Ponzi pyramid to collapse? Yes.
But, long-term, no Ponzi pyramid can avoid collapse. Black money is not infinite, and can get skittish when the music starts fading. A central bank printing money can prop the pyramid up...for a while. But that only makes the collapse bigger, and takes more of the central bank's economy down with it when it finally does go.
- ChuckNorris89 3y ago>But, long-term, no Ponzi pyramid can avoid collapse. Both politicians and industry leaders know it will inevitably pop at some point, but since they have short terms while they're in charge and won't be accountable for long term consequences of their actions, they just want to make sure it doesn't collapse while they're in power, so they keep kicking the can down the road as long as their short tenure last, then it becomes the next guy's problem, rinse and repeat. They're hopeful they can make the problem big enough that the government will have to bail them out when it crashes. It's a result of chasing maximized short term returns at the expense of long term consequences in a zero accountability system. Basically, it's what our system rewards.
- kryogen1c 3y ago>> Current market prices for a lot of commercial real estate seems to be a ponzi scheme > Ponzi scheme? Yes. How in the world are these the top comment and top reply? Commercial real estate isn't a ponzi scheme. Like, at all. In any way, shape, or form. There are disparate actors making separate, uncoordinated decisions. There are single transactions being made delivering real value. There's no long term holdings falsely being promised under the guise of stealing short term value by adding more customers. The commercial real estate market changed. Money is going to be lost. There are bad contracts on the books. Correlated markets are going to suffer. Leveraged losses are going to exponentiate. None of this has anything to do with a ponzi scheme.
- simple-thoughts 3y agoIn common parlance, an asset bubble is called a Ponzi scheme. Actual Ponzi schemes should be referred to as “rob peter to pay Paul” scams to prevent confusion.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CydeWeys 3y agoOr we could just use the actual definitions of words rather than make everything worse and harder to follow along with.
- yazaddaruvala 3y agoOr we could just be flexible and evolve with any reasonable colloquialisms of the time.
- Atheros 3y agoIn a ponzi scheme, some actors go to jail for the rest of their lives and in a speculative bubble they do not. There are good reasons to have separate words for these separate concepts. Dishonest people will always use hyperbole when describing the world. That hyperbole is not justification for honest people to abandon technical definitions. And that is what you are proposing. Having everyone "evolve" on the definition of 'ponzi scheme' means that the current definition is erased. But the current definition is still in use!
- yazaddaruvala 3y agoIf a speculative bubble was later found to be a victim of pump and dump, then people also can go to jail. At that point did it stop being a speculative bubble? The reality is, reality doesn't have such distinct boundaries as you are trying to enforce. At the end of the day, what is the point of a word's definition? To help communicate an idea to other people and society. The US financial and legal systems are intentionally designed to segregate the less educated. Confusion is their primary strategy to make more money! You can either choose to help them continue the segregation, or you can chose to liberate financial and legal concepts to everyone. How can you help? By understanding what parts of the concept were easy to understand, what colloquial language is most used to describe it, and then realizing the gaps between the coloquial and technical definitions. Trying to resolve those gaps with "you're using ponzi wrong" continues the segregation and confusion. Trying to resolve the gaps with "Oh.. you think a ponzi scheme is any scam using obfuscated financial instruments. Ok fair enough lets start the conversation there." you would then continue and say "A typical ponzi schema has a single power structure with a single voice and name e.g. Bernie Madoff. However, in this case it is a ponzi scheme with a distributed set of actors i.e. no one is working together, but still there is large scale issue occurring - we typically call this a speculative bubble / coordinated pump and dump - its not always easy to know what exactly is going on". You could even continue "Realestate in general has actually been a generational pump and dump scheme. Its not that grandma's everywhere meant to harm anyone, but the common advise to 'buy a hose at any cost' is in favor of the realestate owning elderly (i.e. most of them) and as such is difficult for them to say anything else. Additionally, because its been generational, it seems to have been working for quite some time giving it even more credence. At the end of the day tho, it is a distributed ponzi scheme - if you go to withdraw your money and no one is willing to add even more money (i.e. how much you want, and the "processing fees" around it) - you will not get your money."
- salawat 3y ago>There are disparate actors making separate, uncoordinated decisions. You sure about that? https://www.propublica.org/article/yieldstar-rent-increase-realpage-rent https://www.propublica.org/article/yieldstar-rent-increase-r... Would not completely write out the possibility of collusion, even if non-Ponzi in nature. DoJ has been sniffing around various actors that have been increasingly found to be acting in a cartel-like manner to keep rents high.
- cpuguy83 3y agoTell that to Seattle and Amazon. I have little doubt that Amazon's back to work is about real estate and tax revenue for the city.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI doubt it: Amazon isn’t on good terms with Seattle’s city government. They wouldn’t mandate RTO if it wasn’t in their self interest, Amazon isn’t one for needless charity.