5 ms·
Slim people have a genetic advantage when it comes to maintaining their weight
- xeonmc 3y ago...They have found that the genetic dice are loaded in favor of thin people and against those at the obese end of the spectrum Now, was it Einstein who said "Intelligent Creators do not play dice"?
- xyzelement 3y agoCan you explain a bit the point you are making?
- imtringued 3y agoThe aesthetic beauty of nature is usually used as an argument in favour of intelligent designers. Obesity does not fit in with that aesthetic beauty. If there was an intelligent designer then it is clear that he left a lot of bugs in the design. The design appears to be highly adapted to a certain environment and now that humans have left that environment the intelligent design starts to fall apart. The design needs to be adapted to the new environment.
- xyzelement 3y agoI believe the religious reply to this would be that G-d created us as unique individuals, with our own ways to contribute and our own unique growth path that requires overcoming unique challenges. Eg - your unique path in life maybe unlocked by figuring out how to handle your predisposition to obesity, while mine may require working through emotional baggage or whatever. If we persevere, we not only avoid the problem but level up in our development.
- INGSOCIALITE 3y agoUnique individuals , yes. But we all function the same way. This is why calories in / calories out is a constant among all unique individuals.
- xyzelement 3y agoCorrect. But we differ in how hard it easy maintaining that balance is for someone.
- AnonC 3y agoThe title needs to have (2019) in it.
- eyelidlessness 3y agoCue the “calories in, calories out” chorus in 3, 2,
- jabradoodle 3y agoUnless your body breaks the first law of thermodynamics then yes, you loose weight when eating less calories than you burn.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- somenameforme 3y agoThe article [1] (which is not paywalled) does not challenge that. It specifically excluded the very small percent of people with genetic disorders, like leptin deficiency, which can genuinely directly drive obesity. If you look at e.g. compulsive gamblers, you're going to find substantial genetic differences in these individuals relative to those who do not find themselves addicted to gambling. This obviously doesn't mean that genetics are making them bet their house on black. But if there's any genetic component to factors like self discipline, impulsiveness, and other factors then these would show up when you look at differences between people where those sort of characteristics can work as a driving (or mediating) factor. [1] - https://journals.plos.org/plosgenetics/article?id=10.1371/journal.pgen.1007603 https://journals.plos.org/plosgenetics/article?id=10.1371/jo...
- SkyPuncher 3y agoIt doesn’t really seem relevant to this conversation. CICO can be true while also having genetic play a role.
- monkeycantype 3y agoThe relevance is that the most important contribution genetics seems to make to obesity is the effect on the drive to eat. I learned a lot from this summary of obesity genetics: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41576-021-00414-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41576-021-00414-z
- Out_of_Characte 3y agoIsn't this stating the obvious? It also does not solve the problem or explains why people have gotten obese over the last few years.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- blitzar 3y ago> people have gotten obese over the last few years Selective breeding?
- redroyal 3y agoI’ve been running an experiment on myself. For reasons I won’t get into I take a great deal of antibiotics. Kills off the gut bacteria enough that I can introduce a new dominant type. Lost 40lbs in the last two months and I’m never hungry or tired. Indeed I can fast for weeks without the slightest discomfort or temptation. I simply burn my reserves, where before I was constantly craving more food. Every hour at least. Now I often just take a multivitamin and a glass of milk and I’m good for the day
- OccamsMirror 3y agoHow did you introduce a new dominant gut flora and what was it?
- blitzar 3y agofaecal transplant is the usual method
- bbotond 3y agoOkay, you can’t just leave us hanging and not tell us what exactly you have done
- 3y ago
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- sacnoradhq 3y agoThere's another factor: hunger is proportional to weight via leptin resistance. If you have normal genes and can get to a slightly underweight state, then you should have improved leptin sensitivity and eat slightly less. I noticed this factor as my grandfather lost weight, ate less, and it became a vicious cycle where he struggled to maintain weight. Also as I gained weight, I became hungrier and hungrier. I'm on Wegovy now.
- pier25 3y agoDoes Wegovy work?
- sacnoradhq 3y agoOh yeah it works. Take 4 bites and feel full. Hunger is normal/slightly reduced but satiation is rapidly reached. There is an echo of hunger when actual satiation isn't achieved about 20-30 minutes later because the body is operating more on the side of keto and anaerobic. Another downside to the semiglutide autoinjector is it requires cold chain refrigeration. While the autoinjector is damn overengineered and barely noticeable, oral semiglutide should be available around 2024. If that doesn't require a cold chain, that would be a massive improvement.
- krob 3y agoCI/CO is ideal circumstances, just like falling from the sky, computing how long it takes to hit the ground is not as simple as it's 9.8ms/s^2*m, you have to build a differential equation that accounts for all the various force factors involved. Our biology are those various force factors playing on the rate of incorporation of the energy and how the system which consumes energy may alter pathways, and this is where we run into permutations of the metabolism that are not accounted for by CI/CO. We know that people with metabolic syndrome and insulin resistance cannot loose weight because their hyper sensitive to any amount of sugar, so insulin causes them to constantly store energy, but some people who eat a lot of calories get a massive energy boost like they almost got some caffeine in their system. Our biology has millions of biological permutations that ideal systems cannot account for.
- Kirby64 3y agoI'm going to disagree with you. CI/CO is absolute. The issues people get stuck on is twofold: Calories in is largely correct, however it comes with a few small cavaets. If you eat an excess amount of food (and I mean a LOT, 6000cal+), you probably cannot disgest all of it. For normal sane amounts of calories you're going to digest the vast majority of them. For certain folks, they may have trouble digesting certain types of food. This is going to impact far fewer people than most think, I believe. The much bigger one is calories out. What you burn can change a lot. Certain bodies adapt their calorie burn quite quickly to calorie reduction. Unconscious effort changes can heavily increase or reduce calorie usage. There's very little about sugar that inherently makes it "constantly store energy" for certain people. Its calories like anything else, and if you eat tons of it, it's just tons of calories. The final note is that certain people can have huge swings in water retention depending on food eaten. Salty foods do this for most people. But that isn't true weight gain, and should be largely ignored.
- daggersandscars 3y agoThe BMI they use to help define "thin but healthy" is less than 18 m^2 / kg. Some selected height / maximum weight combinations for a BMI of 18: 5' (152 cm): 93 lb (42 kg) 5.5' (168 cm): 112 lb (51 kg) 6' (183 cm): 132 lb (60 kg) 6.5' (200 cm): 159 lb (72 kg)
- ano-ther 3y agoA BMI below 18.5 is underweight according to NIH: https://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health/educational/lose_wt/BMI/bmicalc.htm https://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health/educational/lose_wt/BMI/bmi... But comparing the extremes (<18, >30) and using in-between as control probably makes statistical power easier.
- acumenical 3y agoOr, you know, just stop eating so much. It isn't hard and you can do it for free. Even if you have the genetics of a plant, you are not going to defy the laws of thermodynamics and gain weight while eating below maintenance. What is more common than genetic abnormalities causing excessive weight gain is eating calories in secret, as well as an extremely inaccurate sense of the caloric content of food.
- spokeonawheel 3y agogenerally true, but if you have a hormone imbalance this approach will not work.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoBoth of the following things can be true: 1.There are certain genetic factors where, giving the same amount of calories to one person, will have a different metabolic result than giving the same amount of calories to a different person 2.Giving either person too many calories will result in a net weight gain Given what we know about the food supply, including food deserts, education, or lack thereof, around nutrition etc. as well as average physical activity levels of modern humans, —- it is morally bankrupt to continue to try to push this idea that the majority of people who are obese is anything other than latter environmental and behavioral shaping over the last hundred years. Until the literal aisles of disgracefully cheap liters of sugar syrup and literal pounds of salted fried potatoes become a relic we will 100% continue have an obesity crisis
- arp242 3y agoThere are some people who claim some pretty questionable things, but that's a different matter altogether, and a real understanding of the differences between people is pretty important because there really are differences. I can eat pretty much anything and not gain too much weight, without paying attention to anything, while another people can't. People really do process excess calories different: some turn more of it in to fat, whereas others just excrete it or turn it in to muscle tissue. I'm also the kind of person who can not eat anything all day and basically just be fine (I don't really get hungry fast). I play the game on easy mode, whereas others play it on hard or even nightmare mode.
- throwaway22032 3y agoThe genetic advantage is just that intuitive eating works for some and not for others. If you want to achieve a goal that's different from the general public, most of us need a plan, whether it's a body transformation, financial goal, sport goal, whatever. Even people who are trying to gain weight will tell you that it's difficult to meet a calorie goal unless you actively track it and override your feelings of hunger. I personally don't really get people who struggle with making conscious food choices. For me, so many other things in life are harder. Getting up in the morning, sleeping (actually falling asleep) at the right time, staying focused at work, making sensible choices with women... all of those seem far harder than "do I put this thing in my mouth right now". That's genetics for you, I guess.