3 ms·
There are at least two observable things: 1. you have consciousness 2. people are speaking about consciousness The second point makes it likely that consciou
by amelius 3y ago
There are at least two observable things:
1. you have consciousness
2. people are speaking about consciousness
The second point makes it likely that consciousness is not simply a consequence of physics, but e.g. that it loops back into it; or perhaps it is more likely (because simpler) that physics is a consequence of consciousness.
- Aardwolf 3y agoCan you please elaborate why point 2 does that? You can never prove others have consciousness, no matter what they say (I'm not saying they don't).
- amelius 3y agoNote that I carefully used the word "likely". There is no proof. Simply Occam's razor. Why would something that has no consciousness make up that it has consciousness?
- Aardwolf 3y ago> Why would something that has no consciousness make up that it has consciousness? You can make a computer program `printf("I have consciousness\n");` But I actually also didn't follow the rest of the argument. How does whether other people say they have consciousness or not, tell anything about whether it's physics based or not? If it's physics based, people could say they have consciousness. If it's not physics based, they could also say that?
- amelius 3y agoThe argument goes as follows: 1. People are talking about consciousness. 2. This talking happens in the physical world (soundwaves are being produced, etc.) 3. We assume that other people have consciousness since they talk about it. As you say, there is no absolute proof of this, but Occam's razor makes it silly to assume otherwise. 4. So, the soundwaves (physics) are happening because of consciousness. There is a causal link from consciousness to physics. This means that consciousness is not simply the observation of physics. It actually loops back into it, or physics is an emergent property of consciousness.
- Aardwolf 3y agoNot all sound is created that way, e.g. rain falling from the sky is not, do you intent to mean all physics, including rain, originate from consciousness in some way (such as in theories that everything is an illusion, ...), or rather, that consciousness can affect physics in some way, e.g. because you can choose to speak and produce sound waves
- amelius 3y agoYes, the second option is the one used in the argument. This shows that consciousness is not just qualia, i.e. the observation of physics.
- atlantic 3y agoYou can never prove that there are others. Neither can you prove that there is a self. There is just consciousness, overlaid by various experiences, which we tend to attribute to a substantial self. So it doesn't make sense to ask for a proof that others have consciousness, until you can define self/others properly.
- aatd86 3y agoUnless consciousness is a property of matter at a certain point and then its physics that loops back into itself and consciousness is just a physical phenomenon. Just the same way existence is self-referential.