6 ms·
NASA’s Mars Sample Return has a new price tag–and it’s colossal
- anonymous_12321 3y agoyeah maybe Musk should pay for it
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cubefox 3y agoAs the article says, contracting a private company like SpaceX or Lockheed Martin for the lander would likely be much cheaper than letting JPL do it. We already see massive cost differences between public and private institutions in related areas, e.g. for new rockets and space suits.
- Shawnj2 3y agoContracting Lockheed would not be cheaper lmao
- wand3r 3y agoI wish the US government wasn't the worst steward of capital on the planet. If objectives actually mattered instead of a combo of jobs programs and bribery/influence laundering so much could get done. Im all for science funding but its looking increasingly likely you could just pay spaceX to do this research while they are literally on the planet. Further, you could basically solve homelessness in CA or build a vast network of public light rail for $10B. Obviously you couldn't do any of that because you need 1-3 layers of consultants and 10 layers of subcontractors to do anything. These stories frustrate me. Heres a link to Patrick Collison's blog section fast[1] so we can review what it was like when we could build things and do science in this country. [1] https://patrickcollison.com/fast https://patrickcollison.com/fast
- mozman 3y agoI'd much rather have my tax dollars go to science and space exploration rather than giving away free stuff to people.
- rscho 3y agoI'd much rather give free stuff to people. Given those people are citizens and it allows their reinsertion into society. Space exploration supposed benefits are far more remote and as of now, not very useful.
- nunobrito 3y agoI'd rather invest in space to live there one day than staying on this floating rock with people that give stuff for free. I
- ddingus 3y agoNone of us alive today will be living in space one day. All of us alive today can benefit from assistance given to the least of us. I want the space future too. However, I also want my time here to be better. I won't see the space future. Sadly. I could easily see a cleaner, more harmonious world. Being human can suck. These discussions are one of the ways it does.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- barbazoo 3y agoIgnoring the "free stuff" straw man but it's fascinating how someone can be so cruel to not want society to solve the homelessness problem. If this becomes a "mainstream" opinion, we've truly failed as homo sapiens.
- randallsquared 3y agoAdding more money to "the homelessness problem" seems unlikely to actually solve the problem. It's (politically) difficult to address the underlying root causes, but easy to show how compassionate we are while subsidizing homelessness, and you get more of what you pay for, so.
- mabbo 3y agoThis is the ultimate form of the "tyranny of rocketry" equation. Imagine the smallest possible rocket that can take off from Mars with samples aboard. How much does it and it's fuel weigh? Now imagine how big of a craft you'll need to slow that rocket down from interplanetary speeds and land on a target on Mars. How much does it weigh? And how much fuel will it need to accelerate to interplanetary speed after lifting off from earth? And how big will the rocket need to be to lift all of that into orbit? The answer to all of this is making fuel on Mars. SpaceX called this it over a decade ago, and they aren't wrong. For ten billion dollars, you could just pay SpaceX to send a Starship to Mars and have a human on board grab your samples directly.
- phkahler 3y agoAgree 100 percent. But also why return the samples at all? Just send automated lab equipment to analyze it.
- dotnet00 3y agoNo amount of automated lab equipment is as flexible to work with as samples on Earth, for obvious reasons.
- cubefox 3y agoThe article says the utility from sending the samples back is indeed limited, at least compared to the cost, which would likely exceed the (already astronomical) JWST cost substantially.
- idlewords 3y agoThere's no such thing as automated lab equipment that can analyze it. Even the space station has to send air and water samples down to Earth for anything beyond very rough analysis. You need technicians and a cleanroom environment to do this work.
- Larrikin 3y agoHow about 10 billion to NASA instead of privatizing research with public money.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoAnd yet, if extra terrestrial life sits in one of those, it would trigger a geometric spending frenzy in biology. The key to pulling this trigger is confidence in the samples. Nobody wants to bring back "just dirt".
- munchler 3y agoThe chance that any of those samples contains evidence of extraterrestrial life is quite low. No one is betting this much money on those kind of odds. The samples are scientifically valuable even if they are “just dirt”.
- 1970-01-01 3y agoThis is essentially the issue. Nobody expects life in these tubes. The project was designed to find it, and the assumption was made that a high confidence sample would fuel and expedite a return mission. With a very high price tag and a very low chance of finding life, it's better to spend money elsewhere.
- bannedbybros 3y ago[dead]
- rafaelturk 3y agoI wonder how much this cost will be reduced if the project was managed by NASA but open source, with feedback from a tech, science community. As opposed with the current model that relies on deals with companies such as Lockheed Martin.
- GartzenDeHaes 3y agoIs that a sustainable profit model? Lockheed Martin is barely staying alive making new engines for 5 year old jets. Two trillion dollars doesn't go as far as it used to you know.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- properparity 3y agoWhat exactly is it that costs so much money when it comes to space stuff? Is the materials, exotic and rare stuff? Do you need custom microchips/fabs or something? Is it the engineer salaries, thousands of highly paid people times N years?
- dotnet00 3y agoIt's largely down to NASA's "waterfall" development approach. Everything must be custom designed from the ground up, all things made sure to be correct and safe before the first bolt is installed. That's why a lot of the "new space" oriented programs emphasize "commercial-off-the-shelf" solutions so much. They're only just barely catching on to the relatively obvious bit that costs can be reduced a lot by relying more heavily on existing commercial solutions. Space isn't the most extreme environment compared to what a lot of industrial gear has to be able to deal with. Some examples which come to mind are the cameras which were used to record video of Perseverance's landing, as well as most of the Ingenuity copter itself, were COTS parts. IIRC as a result Ingenuity has more processing power on board than Perseverance's main computers. These were all low cost lower priority components, but they did a great job of showcasing the usability of COTS parts.
- qayxc 3y agoCareful, careful. The COTS part is a bit misleading as a great part of the total cost is in testing and certification. Some might be under the impression that JPL just took some COTS parts, stuck them on Ingenuity and that's that. This is not the case. Of course every component had to be tested for space worthiness and possible interference with other systems. All that takes time, money, and specialised facilities. It's also important to keep in mind that the helicopter was a technology demonstrator, a proof-of-concept that played no critical part in the overall mission. Its job was to perform one flight to show it can be done. It's a big difference if your components only need to do their job once, or if you have to have a guaranteed minimum endurance and the entire mission depends on them.
- melling 3y agoCancel the project. Do it in 15 years when the cost drops dramatically. SpaceX, AI, robotics, etc will make significant improvements over that time. “If NASA manages to develop and launch the Sample Retriever Lander by 2028, the samples could be returned to Earth in 2033” NASA developing these one-off projects is expensive and time consuming. We need most of the technology to develop commercially.
- sho_hn 3y agoCommercial will benefit massively from the R&D results of this mission, which is attempting many engineering firsts and enablers. SpaceX is standing on the shoulders of past giants, too. The thing is, companies fail more easily financially than governments do. It's a good use of gov funds to minimize risks of productization for the private sector, to give them a competitive leg up. This is how the US space industry is winning, imho - spoken as a European.
- melling 3y agoYes, companies usually don’t have unlimited funds. Shareholders start complaining (e.g Metaverse). It’s quite simple. The budget doubled to $10 billion. Cancel the project. We’ve been promoting a faster, better, cheaper NASA for 3 decades. It’s not working. Let’s find a better way to increase innovation. https://www.upi.com/amp/Archives/2000/03/15/NASA-study-faster-better-cheaper-fails/3418953096400/ https://www.upi.com/amp/Archives/2000/03/15/NASA-study-faste...
- andrepd 3y ago>It's a good use of gov funds to minimize risks of productization for the private sector, to give them a competitive leg up. It's a good use to spend public funds to boost private profit? Well it certainly is a good use, but only for one of those parties.
- lloydatkinson 3y agoSo let me get this straight, for the (relatively) low cost of only 9 billion they could return materials from Mars? That’s a steal. The entire US Department of Defence spends 800 billion. The fact some of that can’t be shared for a one off project is deeply frustrating.
- jvanderbot 3y agoWait until you see how much it costs to build and run a single offshore drilling platform or prospecting well in the ocean. Then think how many there are.
- guraf 3y agoAn offshore drilling platform costs about 250M to build and deploy. It is not funded by tax payers and it starts paying for itself after a few years (they extract $250,000 worth of oil per day on average, up to double that). I don't understand your comparison?
- ornornor 3y agoMaybe parent was hinting at the astronomical numbers and the relative futility of spending this amount on this vs that.
- jvanderbot 3y agoI was saying that in the scale of human enterprises, the cost of returning soil from another planet is a rounding error. 9 billion over a decade vs the operating cost of O&G industry as an example, isn't even close. Soil from Mars vs oil from earth. Both are an amazing scientific and technological accomplishment, but one is also historic.
- Fezzik 3y agoNot directly funded by tax payers… the exceptional tax breaks that oil companies have received from our shat government are astronomical.
- 3y ago
- idlewords 3y agoA little bit on what makes the sample return mission so hard: The crux of the matter is getting a fueled rocket onto Mars that can launch back into low Mars orbit and rendezvous there with a waiting satellite. The size and weight of this return rocket is itself constrained by its ability to fit into an aeroshell and survive entry and landing without breaking. You quickly get into a regime where you're trying to land the heaviest thing ever attempted on Mars, which makes the landing conditions harder so the rocket has to be sturdier, which makes the landing vehicle heavier, and so on. The Martian atmosphere gets you both coming and going. On the descent, it is thick enough to make supersonic retropropulsion very complicated and potentially unstable, but too thin to slow a really massive re-entry vehicle down sufficiently with parachutes. You end up having to fire rockets that kick up a lot of rocks and dust during the very last seconds of the landing, while at the same time relying on your onboard computer to find a safe landing spot. On the ascent, the atmosphere is thick enough that you have to deviate from the most efficient launch trajectory and worry about aerodynamic forces on the ascent rocket. Because of the atmosphere, the launch rocket has to be staged, which makes it bigger and heavier than you'd ideally want. And you can't use the most efficient cryogenic fuel, because there's no way to keep it from boiling off on the long trip over to Mars and down. There are also non-obvious couplings between the lander and the ascent rocket, like center of gravity issues when you pack the rocket into the aeroshell, the question of how to get the samples into the rocket and point it up, and constraints on the design imposed by the hard conditions of atmospheric entry (15G acceleration) and the low surface temperatures. None of these problems are insurmountable, but they are thorny enough and interwoven enough that it's very easy to see how the price tag climbs into the billions, even before you factor in organizational dysfunction and inefficiencies at NASA. The fact that it has to work on the first try (since political factors rule out trying it piecemeal) is also a huge cost driver. There's a great paper that goes into some of these challenges in detail: "Drivers, developments and options under consideration for a Mars ascent vehicle", DOI 10.1109/AERO.2016.7500822
- Veedrac 3y agoMass to space is a little expensive but not that expensive. NASA's refusal to just fly more payloads and join or coordinate them in space is a political one moreso than technical, and if they took the opportunity to get more payload mass they could stop worrying about minor mass margin issues. The very obvious price comparison here is that Mars Sample Return has a price tag meaningfully bigger than the two winning HLS bids combined, including demonstration missions. Yes, the moon is closer, but also HLS is moving living humans, not small rocks.
- MengerSponge 3y agoThey could probably open a credit card and get a free checked bag.