3 ms·
That's correct, but it's still clear that the bet is lost. We do not understand in 2023 how neurons give rise to consciousness. Maybe there will come a point w
by jfengel 3y ago
That's correct, but it's still clear that the bet is lost. We do not understand in 2023 how neurons give rise to consciousness.
Maybe there will come a point where it's in the gray area but not today. We know that people act in ways that we cannot explain even a little bit.
Also, the bet is friendly. It's just a way to express their different underlying opinions. Neither one is put out by it. They will likely enjoy some of the wine together.
- sabellito 3y agoDidn't you just agree that "consciousness" is not defined? Then how can you follow that with "... it's still clear that the bet is lost. We do not understand in 2023 how neurons give rise to consciousness"?
- ttctciyf 3y agoIn order to understand, then we'd have to have a good definition, no?
- imtringued 3y agoYou don't understand how bets work. The parties involved decide the conditions, not you or me. The neuroscientist wagered that he or other neuroscientists will achieve something in 25 years. They did not. If the goal was poorly specified or impossible to achieve, that is on the person starting and accepting the bet.
- jfengel 3y agoThey started with a hazy idea of what consciousness is. They bet that they'd have a better definition. There was certainly the possibility that they could have disagreed on the outcome. But there is really no dispute. The possibility of disagreement would have mattered if the bet itself were significant, but it wasn't. It was always a tiny stake.
- mannykannot 3y agoThe article says the bet is this: "Christof Koch bet philosopher David Chalmers that the mechanism by which the brain’s neurons produce consciousness would be discovered by 2023." It is a straightforward fact that no such mechanism has been discovered, and that is all we need to show that Koch has lost the bet.
- 0xEF 3y agoPersonally, I wish scientist made more of these public friendly bets. I feel they really help promote the discussion to a wider audience abd brings a bit of spirited competition to the matter rather than the capitalist motives we normally see with research. Something like The Long Now's Long Bets but with your average scientists where us regular folk can throw our two cents in (without the membership fee).
- jfengel 3y agoI'm a big fan of public engagement with science, but it's a double edged sword. A lot of people get the impression that they have a good handle on it and an opinion that demands attention. I cannot tell you how tired I am of people arguing about the merits of string theory, where effectively none of the people involved know even the first thing about it. It's not that people shouldn't get involved, but involvement should be more than just cheerleading as if it were a sports game. Maybe that's inevitable. Maybe the public engagement will always produce 99 dunces shouting and one young scientist who goes on to study it for real. But it can be disheartening when it looks as if 100% of the public discussion is both ignorant and mean.