8 ms·
EU Advocate General: Technical Standards must be freely available [pdf]
- soulbadguy 3y agoof course they should be. The fact there aren't currently, and we need to even discuss it is so strange. I am happy that EU exists and is forcing some sanity in the tech world.
- westurner 3y agoIIUC this means that EU government standards must be public domain? Or, preexisting paywalled / committee_attendance_required standards are now conveniently by decree public domain? What are some good examples of Open Standards and Open Web Standards for EU and other world regions?
- layer8 3y agoETSI standards, for example, are already freely available. But if they reference and normatively rely on ISO standards, it might mean that the EU will have to somehow arrange for those ISO standards to be made freely available as well.
- tialaramex 3y agoISO spends about $45M per year. That's not chicken feed, but it's scarcely unaffordable at a national scale.
- CodesInChaos 3y agoPublic domain content is available without any copyright restrictions. While making it available under restrictive rules/licenses could be enough to achieve the "no secret laws" requirement.
- tgv 3y agoPublic domain (in its normal interpretation) might even have adverse effects. It would allow sites/books to publish the standards with (un)intentional errors. Copying them as is should be free though, IMO.
- peoplearepeople 3y agoFree redistribution without modification, is likely a better model
- westurner 3y agoWhat does it cost to license non- free and open specs that way; is this notice a notice of intent to pay to release such specifications for all somehow?
- westurner 3y agoWe all benefit from Open Standards; but in a competitive market specifying any particular standard - open or not - may be disadvantageous for the market. Open Standards: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_standard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_standard Open Standards > Specific definitions of an open standard: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_standard#Specific_definitions_of_an_open_standard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_standard#Specific_definit... Web Standards: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_standards https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_standards E.g. W3C, IETF, WHATWG, and ECMA develop open standards.
- westurner 3y agoW3C Web Monetization: https://webmonetization.org/ https://webmonetization.org/ : > The Web Monetization API allows websites to automatically and passively receive payments from Web Monetization-enabled visitors. From https://interledger.org/faq/ https://interledger.org/faq/ : > Web Monetization is being proposed as a W3C standard. Using the Interledger Protocol, the Web Monetization proposed standard aims to make it easier for web creators to generate income from their work without relying on advertising, site-by-site subscriptions or tracking models. IIUC, ILP messages would help financial regulators - such as FTC CAT Consolidated Audit Trail - audit traditional ledgers and cryptoassets? Interledger was contributed to W3C and has undergone significant major revision; including packetization of liquidity into many small transactions. FWIU, W3C Interledger Protocol is a W3C spec but by producing IETF-style numbered RFCs, their process slightly differs from the W3C WG Working Group model (with a page, a mailing list; and one or more git Repositories with Issues: github.com/orgname, github.com/orgname/readme, github.com/orgname/orgname.github.io, ).
- userbinator 3y agoI wouldn't call the "web standards" actual standards in any meaningful sense; real standards change slowly, while web "standards" churn routinely according to the whims of Big Tech.
- westurner 3y agoAll standards development groups have to deal with people that don't help; that just complain and diminish the work of others.
- diogocp 3y agoThe submission title is misleading. This is an opinion of an Advocate General, not a decision of the court. > The Advocate General’s Opinion is not binding on the Court of Justice. It is the role of the Advocates General to propose to the Court, in complete independence, a legal solution to the cases for which they are responsible. The Judges of the Court are now beginning their deliberations in this case. Judgment will be given at a later date.
- layer8 3y agoI now updated the title. It's not a decision of the Court, but the Advocates General are part of the Court, along with the judges, and their opinion is followed in most cases.
- anotherhue 3y agoSecret laws are generally considered bad. It's going to be for something dumb like the exact dimensions of a fire safety tag, but if you don't tell me the law then it's a secret law.
- miga 3y agoI think "bad" is understatement: the secrecy of the law undermines the principle of transparency that makes law work.
- layer8 3y agoThe standards are not secret, they are merely behind a paywall. The assumption has always been that the companies who have to (or want to) implement those standards can afford the expense. However, one point addressed by the Advocate General’s present Opinion is that it should be possible for citizens to check whether the relevant standards are being obeyed, which means that citizens need to have access to those standards, not just the entities implementing the standards. In addition, an important part of the current court case is about whether copyright (the basis on which fees are charged) can apply to standards that are effectively part of the law.
- konschubert 3y agoNot all companies are big, old industry dinosaurs. Sometimes people try to start new companies, and they don't have a lot of money. Charging for standards is a way to prevent competition.
- olieidel 3y agoThis is very interesting. One data point for this are the standards for medical device compliance (e.g. for medical software). You can buy them from different institutions, the content is the same, but the price varies from anywhere between 30€ to 500€. Yep, for a PDF file. It's an unholy mess and literally every person I've encountered in the system, even auditors, think that it's ridiculous. The PDF-selling companies argue that they need that money to organize committee meetings for developing further versions of standards etc., but that leaves me wondering - we have so many other standards-setting institutions which don't rely on shady PDF sales, so why not take that model instead? [1] https://openregulatory.com/accessing-standards/ https://openregulatory.com/accessing-standards/ (Disclaimer: My company)
- jtwaleson 3y agoDon’t forget the mandatory mention of evs.ee where you can buy standards way cheaper thanks to the Estonian government.
- jaybeavers 3y agoThank you from someone begrudgingly paying thousands of Euros for IEC medical device standards pdfs!!!!
- immibis 3y agoMost standards organizations have SOME way of making money, because we live in capitalism. Some of them take hefty fees for membership; some of them take hefty fees for compliance certification; some of them take hefty fees to use their trademarks (as in putting the USB logo next to the USB port); and some of them take hefty fees to see the standards.
- robomartin 3y ago> because we live in capitalism No. Because it costs money to run these organizations. They are either funded by the government (which means taxes, which means us), membership fees or other activities. Last I checked everyone needs to feed themselves or their family. This "it's because it's capitalism" thing gets old pretty quickly. What should be objectionable is precisely when organizations are government (taxes, us) funded and they sell us standards you are supposed to work and test against for, well, government-mandated certification requirements. So...we pay for their work through taxation...for them to sell us the products they create...and then we pay for the testing services against documents we cannot freely access even though we paid for their development. That's just messed-up. This is where it gets complicated. If USA or European taxpayers fund the development of these standards, should others outside of those regions have to pay or contribute in any way? China is no-longer a poor agrarian society. And yet they benefit from work done in the EU and USA for decades at great cost to taxpayers. Not sure what the answer to this is other than to point out these things are not simple. There's the "well, it benefits everyone" angle, which brings us back to "Why are these organizations charging for PDF's at all?".
- SNosTrAnDbLe 3y agoI realized this once when I went down the rabbit hole of SQL standards. ISO SQL standard - 187 CHF https://www.iso.org/standard/76583.html https://www.iso.org/standard/76583.html ANSI SQL standard - 237 USD for non members https://webstore.ansi.org/standards/iso/isoiec90752016 https://webstore.ansi.org/standards/iso/isoiec90752016
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoYeah, sux to not have the SQL standard. Flipside, allegedly it is nearly undecipherable (on hearsay, not IME)
- DaiPlusPlus 3y ago> Flipside, allegedly it is nearly undecipherable It's readable - though obviously you're going to need experience in RDBMS theory (Codd's paper, etc) to grok it. It is very verbose, though. Fortunately, the only people who need the ISO SQL spec are the vendors: the people writing SQL engines and tooling: it's next-to-useless for people who are designing databases or writing queries against them, chiefly because no RDBMS implementation, ever, has come close to implementing the full specification, and everyone has their own extensions to SQL - so all the vendors put out their own documentation and the world's largely been happy with that for the past ~40 years that SQL's been relevant. It's not too hard to find the standards in PDF form if you know where to look - and as someone who does a fair bit of SQL, I'll say I've only ever referred to the standards to back-up my more controversial posts on StackOverflow.
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoI'm heading in the direction which is engines/tooling and I'm amazed at the number of corners of SQL that I have discovered that I don't know properly. You can use it fine for decades but when you need to know precisely what is acceptable to the GROUP BY/HAVING clauseS... then you suddenly realise you don't. It's quite surprising. it would be useful to have that standard. Thanks, will have a hunt.
- amelius 3y agoI always wondered why they weren't for technical safety standards. By the way, there should be a special place in hell for the people who designed this EU standards website: https://standards.cencenelec.eu https://standards.cencenelec.eu You can search for standards, then you can pay for them in a webshop, but you can't link to the main page for each standard as there is some kind of URL-cookie mechanism that works hand-in-hand with state on the server that will break down as soon as you start using the URLs elsewhere.
- miga 3y agoThe standards are often referred to by the law and public institutions. This means that they become de facto law, even if they do not adhere to fundamental principles of the law: transparency, and fairness. Standard paywalls thus should be seen as a barrier for the rule of law, not just barrier for innovation. The prices for access to standards made sense in the era, when every document had to be printed instead of downloading as PDF.
- mozman 3y agoPeople want to get paid for their work, and we need rigorous authors and vetting. Who will pay?
- explaininjs 3y agoCommercial enterprises could pay a licensing/verification fee that gets split between the spec authors and third party verifiers. After all, isn’t the entire value of a spec in the verification that it is correctly implemented?
- layer8 3y agoThe Opinion argues that those affected by the standards, for example citizens buying products subject to the standards, should be able to know what those standards are, and at least in principle be enabled to verify if the standards are met. Requiring third-party verifiers would be a way to deny ordinary citizens free access to the standards.
- explaininjs 3y agoAs a consume I might be able to read the standard freely, but I have no interest in buying all the electronic test bench equipment necessary to, for instance, verify that the USB-C charger I bought is fully compliant. However I’d be happy to pay an extra dollar or so to have a trusted third party do so. To put my money where my mouth is, I only buy certified “made for iPhone”/“certified Magsafe compatible” accessories now and have had a much better experience than I did before.
- codedokode 3y agoShould we make ordinary laws also paid? The lawyers earn ridiculous profits so it is only fair that they share some of it with law authors.
- dwheeler 3y agoThe people who will pay will be the same people who currently pay.The authors of standards are usually not paid by the standards bodies and get no royalties. They and their companies even have to pay for the travel required. The technical reviewers are also often not paid by the standards bodies. The purpose of the current system is to defray the costs of the printing press, since there was no other way to disseminate information 100 years ago. Now that we have the Internet, paying for individual standards is unjustifiable and should be ended. This is made worse because of the increasing number of standards that effect anything useful. Countless problems have happened because people cannot affordably access the hundreds of standards they are supposed to be using.
- diego_sandoval 3y agoYes, but the lawmakers are the ones that should abstain from referencing closed standards in the law, not the standard the one that has to open itself because the law references it. Or maybe the law could create its own official standard that simply paraphrases what the closed standard says, effectively making it open.
- csense 3y agoI figure this should be a straightforward case of eminent domain. Say you own a house. The government needs to take your house to demolish it to build a road. The government is within its rights to just take it (after due process and fair payment). Now say you own a document that you make people pay to read. The government needs to take your document to make it part of the law to build a building code. Why doesn't the government exercise same kind of rights to just take it (after due process and fair payment)?
- rat9988 3y agoBecause nobody will make the effort afterwards to make good standards. Fair payment is in most countries quiet unfair in fact.
- csense 3y ago> nobody will make the effort afterwards to make good standards That's not true. If 3000 people a year would have paid you $100 for access over the next 20 years, that's $300,000, which as a future income stream has some PV X. You'll be indifferent [1] between collecting the trickle of revenue from customers paying the paywall, and a one-time lump sum from the government of X [2]. [1] You'll be indifferent by definition. Because you'd say "Yes please" to a lump sum of $1 trillion, "No thanks" to a lump sum of $1, and PV is defined to be the crossover point where your answer changes. [2] If you have a discount rate of 5%, then X ~= $300,000 / 1.05^10 or so, depending on how front-loaded the payments are and how much you care about payments more than 20 years in the future. > quite unfair in fact If the government pays you less than X, in theory it's unconstitutional, plain and simple. If the legal system doesn't accept your projected revenue, or discount rate, or you have to pay the lawyers and expert witnesses too much to legally establish the basis for those calculations...well then, the problem isn't the government taking your document to make it part of the law. The problem is the legal system is too inefficient or unreasonable, which has a different set of fixes (e.g. make laws about what calculations the government has to use in this situation, and make the government pay the plaintiff's attorney fees if the case is sufficiently clear-cut instance of "the government didn't follow its own official rules and this should never have gotten to court in the first place")
- CrimsonCape 3y agoIt's time for a ruling like this to apply to construction related codes. You need code books such as IBC, IRC, IECC, NFPA, ANSI in multiple year editions (depending on jurisdiction) and then whole new batches of books when jurisdictions adopt new codes. Then, the IBC allows you to claim fire ratings if you match an Underwriter's Laboratory tested assembly (for example, a fire-rated wall) which buying PDFs from UL is another additional expense. Point being, there's a rabbit hole of paywalled technical standards in construction.
- wolverine876 3y ago[PDF]
- userbinator 3y agoReading the title as "Technical Standards must be freely available PDF" also makes sense.
- gerdesj 3y agoISO 9000 + 14000 + 21000 (Quality, Enviro, IS Security) cost a bloody fortune for a small business and they get updated every few years. That lot is nearly compulsory in some markets. You still have to shell out for at least a day per standard per year for auditing but it would be nice if the standards themselves were free. Every little helps as Mr Tesco is fond of saying. (EDIT - speling)
- javajosh 3y agoIt's so strange when a government agency seems to actually advocate for people rather than for special interests.
- negative_zero 3y agoFYI for all: the cheapest source of standards available in English (that I have found) is the Estonian Centre for Standardisation and Accreditation: https://www.evs.ee/en https://www.evs.ee/en Prices are generally single to low double-digit Euros (even for standards that are hundreds or 1000+ dollars). If you are a solo contractor like me (and hence only need one copy), DON'T get the single licence copies. You need to use some BS DRM software that binds the file to your computer and is a PITA. Get the organisation one, pay for two licenses, and you'll be given a regular PDF instead (and still save hundreds of dollars). You obviously will only get the Estonian specific annexes, but those are normally optional anyway, and generally available for free when downloading the "free sample" of a standard for a specific country.
- reaperman 3y agoThank you! The availability here looks like it greatly exceeds that of http://libgen.rs http://libgen.rs
- justinclift 3y agoThe ISO SQL standards docs are still ridiculously expensive :( https://www.evs.ee/en/search?query=SQL&organisations=2 https://www.evs.ee/en/search?query=SQL&organisations=2
- negative_zero 3y agoDamn :( That's very unfortunate (and I am sorry if I got your hopes up). I should have specified that I've only searched for and purchased hardware specific standards not software ones.
- justinclift 3y agoNo worries, it was worth checking just in case. :)
- slim 3y agocheapest source is libgen. I recommend it for education. You'll always have the means to pay for a copy if you implement the standard for $$$
- mhh__ 3y agoDealing with IEEE standards reminds me of a movie script company that sent me a pdf via a mail company on the internet (not an email!)
- sizzle 3y agoDoes this include ISO standards? Those things are so expensive and sometimes I just want to skim through certain subjects for fun
- s1artibartfast 3y agoTo add my two cents, government required standards should be freely available. If Bob and Joe want to make a proprietary standard, that's fine. If their standard is generally viewed as a sign of good workmanship, that's fine. It's only when a government says that anyone building widgets must follow the standard that it becomes a problem. If a government wants to write compliance with a proprietary standard into a law, then they should be required to buy or license that standard
- samtho 3y agoThis is very prevalent in the US with regards to building codes especially. The laws themselves are technically not locked behind lock and key, but they directly reference them. This shouldn’t be allowed, for which I agree that if they (a government organization) wishes to use one of these proprietary standards, they should license the parts they use. It’s unconscionable that we have laws that must be followed (or face repercussions) that are locked behind a paywall. Any tax payer should have free and open access to any law they are subject to or it simply shouldn’t be a law.
- tannhaeuser 3y agoBefore the discussion degenerates into general capitalism critique as usual, it should be noted that copies of those ISO standards that aren't free to download are "expensive" (though still in the range of obtaining a single academic fulltext paper for non-institutional use) because the authors of said standards have reserved special republishing rights for the material. In other words, the copies are expensive because the authors need to make money off their books published in parallel, with the book text also containing much needed commentary. At least it used to be like that years ago. If you want "free" standards, look what happened to so-called web standards dominated financially by FAANG, and the catastrophic results to the extant web. Might as well say the web as such doesn't exist anymore.
- DropInIn 3y agoSeems to me your saying the problem is that independents and corporations make the standards rather than governments and nonprofits...
- layer8 3y agoIt’s usually not the actual authors who get the money from selling copies of the standards, it's the standards organizations, who finance part of their operations from it.
- tannhaeuser 3y agoAs I said, the incentive for authors is thus to make the standard incomprehensible, hard to navigate, voluminous, ... and sell a book about it the profit of which goes to the author(s) and publisher. The authors and potential sponsors also negotiate the selling price of the standard or whether it can be downloaded for free, thus can inflate the price. That kind of deal is how experts in the field get even involved - otherwise what would the incentive be for an editor when the process of establishing consensus is extremely long (multiple years), tedious, and expensive.
- layer8 3y agoAt least in the fields I’m working in, the incentive is interoperability, and the authors are payed by the companies that are members of the standards organization, and/or are academics that are payed for consulting work. The incentives are really the same as for “open” standards like IETF, WhatWG, etc. The fact that standards are often difficult to parse is more a side-effect of compromise wording, non-English authors, and technical terseness, and that they effectively act more as a contract between the member companies, which already have the institutional knowledge to interpret the wording.
- lakomen 3y agoSince AI is all the rage, I wonder if one could feed a standards document or RFC to AI and it would output the implementation in whatever language you like... But then again with how wrong it is usually...
- Woodi 3y agoWhat about requirement to making standards simple and resonable as possible ? You know, like they did to standards about phys laws... What about prohibiting standarization for easily outdatable things ? Like for example not using RSA anymore ? Some big government could finally propose something better for their peoples without backdoring it ? Look it is like with carring gun - you really want to sabbotage ammo your people are using to defend ??