4 ms·
How's this better than Matrix? (Not a leading question. I haven't used Discord/Matrix/etc. more than a handful of times and don't know what I don't know.)
by kstrauser 3y ago
How's this better than Matrix?
(Not a leading question. I haven't used Discord/Matrix/etc. more than a handful of times and don't know what I don't know.)
- muzzio 3y agoDoes Matrix have the equivalent of voice chat rooms that Discord has? I find as a user of Discord that being able to see who's just hanging out is the killer feature there. (As are things like game streaming and bots, ofc)
- dingusdew 3y ago[dead]
- Arathorn 3y agoyes, albeit in beta in Element: https://element.io/blog/drop-in-drop-out-chats-with-video-rooms-and-a-new-search-experience/ https://element.io/blog/drop-in-drop-out-chats-with-video-ro...
- moojd 3y agoI saw this and got excited but no, this isn't discord voice channels. This is an integrated jitsi meet call. It looks like some sort of prototype has been merged to develop though: https://github.com/vector-im/element-web/pull/21476 https://github.com/vector-im/element-web/pull/21476
- prophesi 3y agoWhat do you mean it's not discord voice channels? Looking at the screenshot[0] their Jitsi Meet integration is identical, because discord voice channels are essentially voice conference calls. [0] https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/48614497/159062202-a7f8d8b2-ff39-4576-b398-cc3b526864f9.png https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/48614497/159062202...
- solarkraft 3y agoThere's still a "join" page every time before you can actually enter a room. And the participants in the room aren't shown as nicely when you're not in it. Both are very important for replicating Discord's low friction. Opening a full window when it's just a voice channel anyway is also distracting and increases friction.
- barbariangrunge 3y ago$5/user/month = no way in hell I can get all my friends on board to use it. Impossible to get network effects going like that, as much as I wanted to try it. It looks like it's a b2b app anyway
- lannisterstark 3y agoIt's $0/user/infinity if you host your own Matrix server[0]. You don't have that option with Discord. Your data will remain with discord servers. Element is hardly b2b lol. --- [0]: https://matrix.org/ https://matrix.org/ A good starting point if you're tech literate is this: https://github.com/spantaleev/matrix-docker-ansible-deploy https://github.com/spantaleev/matrix-docker-ansible-deploy
- celdon25 3y agoMatrix feels a bit monocultural for my taste. Perhaps Revolt can do better, we'll see.
- staunton 3y agoCan you explain what you mean? Is it due to the technology or an accidental adoption pattern that's independent of the technology?
- pndy 3y agoIIRC it doesn't feature encryption and there's no pairing devices via QR or emotes chain as in Element client. Last time I played around Revolt it was very Discord-alike
- logicprog 3y agoWhat made me choose Revolt over Matrix is the user interface and structure. I vastly prefer the server-with-multiple-chatrooms paradigm that Discord (and by extension Revolt) use, it's a much nicer way to host a hangout with your friends if you have more than a few, so conversations about different things can happen in different places and people can avoid stuff they're not interested in. Matrix kinda has this in that you can group groupchats, but the UI is a lot more awkward. Additionally, Revolt has custom emoji, and you would not believe how reliant you can get on custom emoji if you and your friend group have gotten used to using the samw set for years.
- 3np 3y agoMatrix is a protocol. It doesn't have a UI as such. I guess a more useful question could be "why isn't Revolt using Matrix?"
- neltnerb 3y agoYes, that was what came to mind for me. My Element UI has organizations (servers) and rooms and people in them, surely Matrix would support all the features this has as well? Perhaps you used it before this was supported. Or maybe Matrix has some issue I don't know about, which is a more interesting question. Element seems to have both video and audio chat, but leaves a lot to be desired on the UI side sometimes. I can definitely imagine the more the merrier when it comes to open source UIs for open protocols.
- sureglymop 3y agoI can say a few things as someone who has been running a matrix server as a slack alternative in a company for a while now. Element does not have an "administration" ui. Synapse has an extensive admin API, but element so far has not created a ui for it. This can make it hard to use for example in a business because a lot of compliance and security related aspects are hard to control and dial in. Another thing is that quite often, users don't familiarize themselves with the encryption model. They create a key but then lose it and all their chat histories with it (especially non technical users). Well, because everything is encrypted, a server admin can't see or recover their messages when that happens. There may be some privacy concerns when federation is turned on, such as user profiles leaking or unwanted users joining rooms they shouldn't be able to in a server. Again, these things are all addressed by Matrix/Element but they are an issue because users don't familiarize themselves with it enough. Element are developing something new called Element Call, which is a Jitsi alternative that uses the Matrix protocol. So far it's in early development and not very usable for self hosted servers yet. There is not a lot of administrative control really. If two users just spam each other in a room it will fill up storage and of course the server admin can't check what these people are writing. Another thing that can trip people up or make Element hard to use in a company is that the Element clients have certain defaults. For example, the video calls by default use a pre-defined Jitsi instance. Other aspects also use external service by default, even if connected to a self-hosted server. That is pretty much a nightmare if there are compliance/privacy concerns and a company wants to host everything in house. What's really pleasant is how verbose and easy to understand the matrix protocol is. It's quite easy to create bots, send messages over the API etc. So it can be easily integrated into other business processes.
- justaj 3y agoYou're trying to compare a web app to a protocol. Better question would be: Why is this not powered by Matrix?
- gaws 3y agoHow's this better than IRC?