4 ms·
Are you asking why a commercial company doesn't want to give its main product away for free? I'm surprised CentOS lasted as long as it did.
by IshKebab 3y ago
Are you asking why a commercial company doesn't want to give its main product away for free? I'm surprised CentOS lasted as long as it did.
- bananapub 3y agowhat do you feel RH's main product is? is it: 1. a collection of very old binaries of software with lots of testing done, or 2. a linux distribution that happens to have a very good support contract and a web of agreements with other vendors ?
- steve1977 3y agoBased on the experience I had with their support (covered by a support contract), it must be 1.
- ahoka 3y agoSo the value is having to live with the same bugs for 10 years?
- ElectricalUnion 3y agoThe value is not having to reverse-engineer, rewrite and recompile software every week because some random library changed in a non-compatible way.
- somerandomqaguy 3y agoFor some people yes. The bugs you know about usually will have a workaround that minimizes it's impacts. It's the bugs you don't know about that are typically most difficult to deal with.
- jrochkind1 3y agoI guess the question that would lead to is why a company that didn't want to give it's main product away for free would have had a main product that was licensed as open source for so many years. We all know that an open source license means people can use it, copy it, modify it, and run it where they want, without paying anyone, right? (Is it even legally possible to have a linux distribution that isn't open source? I'm not sure?)
- arp242 3y ago> Is it even legally possible to have a linux distribution that isn't open source? I'm not sure? For the GPL parts? No. But that doesn't mean "you must make it the source code publicly available at https://example.com/source-code.tar.gz https://example.com/source-code.tar.gz". GPL 2 and 3 differ a little bit in the exact terms for this, but both are essentially the same: you only need to ship source code to the people you distribute the software to, not to the general public at large.
- aidenn0 3y agoYou need to ship the source code to the people you distribute the software to and you need to do so under a license that allows them to modify and redistribute this. So if any of your licensees wants to make a 100% copy of what you shipped, then you need to allow them to.
- arp242 3y agoKind of, but also no. As I understand it, RedHat customers are forbidden to redistribute the source code by the RedHat EULA. While they can't legally sue you for breaking the GPL, they can sue you or just drop you as a customer for breaching the EULA. I'm not entirely sure how this interacts with the GPL's "no additional restrictions" clause in a legal sense, although it clearly isn't in the spirit of it. Either way, the net effect is the same: no one is going to risk the wrath of IBM's lawyers, and any avenue of "source leaks" can be closed off. It's not a functional mechanism for RHEL derivates.
- jrochkind1 3y agoI'm not sure that is accurate about the EULA? The EULA I find googling (this is not something I am previously acquainted with) says: > With the exception of certain image files identified in Section 1.3 below, the license terms for the components permit User to copy, modify, and redistribute the component, in both source code and binary code forms. This EULA does not limit User's rights under, or grant User rights that supersede, the license terms of any particular component. — https://www.redhat.com/en/about/licenses/rhds-rhcs-eula https://www.redhat.com/en/about/licenses/rhds-rhcs-eula I may not be interpreting that correctly or what it means practically, I'm not really familiar with what's going on here. If you definitely know better than me, I'm happy to hear it (cites to other informed authors explaining it would be great!), but I don't want to go down a long thread accidentally discussing things based on a misunderstanding of the EULA... I do get that Red Hat is trying to somehow add value to open source software (linux), have it's software be understood as being open source itself (for the marketing value), while also trying to get people to pay to use it. They are trying to have their cake and eat it too, I get it. And maybe they have enough lawyers to make it work somehow, or can just make it so inconvenient practically to use the rights the open source license grants to make it work somehow. But yeah, if you "don't want to give your main product away for free", and your "main product" is licensed with an open source license... you are in a pretty difficult spot. Which is, I guess, where Red Hat finds themselves.
- arp242 3y agoThe thing is, I'm not so sure RedHat actually lost revenue over CentOS. The people who want to use CentOS is a very different type of userbase than the people who would use RedHat/RHEL, and the CentOS people would simply choose Debian or something else over RedHat. From purely a business perspective I think the entire thing naïvely makes sense, from a far-away view without much knowledge of the business space. But once you look a bit closer I don't think it does.
- eYrKEC2 3y agoBut, sometimes the people that use CentOS get hired by Mega-Corp and when their CTO requires a support contract with contracted SLA's, they choose RHEL instead of Ubuntu One, because they're way more familiar with RHEL'like systems instead of Debian systems. Yes, cheap/free people will be cheap/free, but sometimes they're not the decider.
- IshKebab 3y agoThey definitely lost revenue. People use RHEL/CentOS because a load of software only officially supports Enterprise Linux. But why would they pay for RHEL if CentOS works fine?
- arp242 3y ago> a load of software only officially supports Enterprise Linux Which software is that?
- IshKebab 3y agoBasically all commercial EDA software. E.g. https://www.synopsys.com/support/licensing-installation-computeplatforms/compute-platforms/compute-platforms-roadmap.html https://www.synopsys.com/support/licensing-installation-comp...
- wingmanjd 3y agoThe database engine IBM DB2 didn't (doesn't?) officially support Centos. It had to be RHEL.
- ozr 3y agoThe product is open source. They chose to make a linux distribution.
- mindcrime 3y agoThe code and bits aren't Red Hat's main product. Red Hat's main product is the "warm fuzzies" that large enterprises get from knowing that somebody is "on the hook" to provide support if there's a SHTF outage or other incident, and somebody to sue in the unlikely chance that they lose serious $$$ as a result of a technical problem. In many ways Red Hat is closer to a company that sells insurance than a company that sells software.