9 ms·
Generative AI Could Add $4.4T a Year to the Global Economy, McKinsey Finds
- johnea 3y agoSo, Elon and Bozo are going to be able to screw us for $4.4T more than before! This IS the greatest threat of "AI"
- jqpabc123 3y agoAnd how will it achieve this? By eliminating jobs of course. McKinsey’s study found that generative AI and other technologies could automate work activities that currently take up 60 to 70 percent of employees’ time. Who knew that 60 to 70 percent of employee's time was mostly just BS that could be easily automated by a BS generator?
- BugsJustFindMe 3y agoI did? A lot of people did? David Graeber (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_Jobs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_Jobs) did?
- 2devnull 3y agoWriting books that mean nothing to anyone of import; the ultimate bullshit job!
- mo_42 3y ago> And how will it achieve this? By eliminating jobs of course. For now, probably only white collar workers. It’s probably good if those jobs go away. Then, we need to think how to compensate those people. Capital is not evenly distributed so no compensation will just drive profits and this will not end up in the pockets of most people. I'd say the employer has to keep paying salaries for some time to let people acquire new skills.
- adventured 3y agoCompensate white collar workers? I don't think so. They get the same tough love that blue collar workers have been getting for over a century with each machine innovation that upended their lives. Learn to do plumbing.
- 2devnull 3y ago“Learn to do plumbing.” No. There’s a union to prevent that thankfully. Don’t make this the problem of plumbers or other high paid tradespeople. Become a cop. They get high pay and they need more people desperately.
- seydor 3y agoTBF it is true. but that doesnt mean that those employees will be fired, hopefully they will be assigned to something less bullshitty. E.g. for people in academia i am sure it has removed a lot of 'bs job time' already
- nathan_compton 3y agoI'm in academia and the fact is that for anything not well represented in its training data, even GPT4 is next to useless.
- seydor 3y agoit s been great for formatting reports etc. i find it very useful
- nathan_compton 3y agoI've tried using it for correcting drafts but I've caught it not faithfully reproducing text too many times to trust it.
- seydor 3y agocorrecting things is obviously not it strength. but it can easily convert a bullet list to an article
- AlexandrB 3y agoOr maybe they'll be assigned to something even more bullshitty or just more menial.
- yieldcrv 3y ago> TBF it is true. but that doesnt mean that those employees will be fired, hopefully they will be assigned to something less bullshitty. I think that people miss that headcount will just stop increasing first, everyone is looking for mass layoffs and miss that other component. I don't have a problem with that. Just find it interesting that people who would have a problem with it aren't considering it.
- idopmstuff 3y agoI don't think it's reasonable to say that just because something can be automated via AI that it's BS. I've used AI to write some scripts that automate a bunch of tasks that involve pulling data from different sources and putting them into a Google Sheet for reporting purposes for an ecommerce business I own. Is reporting on the financial reporting of my business BS? Also, this study is about future gains coming from AI, so even if you take the very cynical position that LLMs/generative AI are nothing but "BS generators" today, unless you have good reason to believe that they will not improve in quality, that's not really a good basis on which to judge their future applications.
- jqpabc123 3y agounless you have good reason to believe that they will not improve in quality I do. These LLMs can't tell facts from BS now. With LLMs starting to generate ever more BS, going forward it will only become harder to tell the difference --- for both them and us. What do you think will happen when LLMs start sucking in each others BS from the internet? I don't think it's possible for this sort of global BS feedback loop to produce an improvement in quality.
- idopmstuff 3y ago> These LLMs can't tell facts from BS now. I think this is severely overstated as a problem that would prevent LLMs from being useful. LLMs generate BS if you use them like a search engine, but there are lots of use cases where they don't. Need to summarize a document or rephrase something in a different tone? Hallucination is really a non-issue. I've used LLMs to write scripts - while hallucination does happen, it's a situation where I can easily validate that the scripts are doing what I would expect, so hallucination isn't a serious issue.
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoExactly. There are many, many cases where AI significantly speeds up doing something. I've already used it productively for writing code, understanding how to set up new tech, summarising documents and academic papers, and writing clearer text. And I'm not a power user at all. So this will result in fewer existing jobs, and the productivity of the remaining jobs must increase. And some new jobs will be created along the way.
- furyofantares 3y ago> Who knew that 60 to 70 percent of employee's time was mostly just BS that could be easily automated by a BS generator? I feel like most office work being BS has been in the zeitgeist since before Dilbert was popular for sure. And part of why The Office works so well as a sitcom environment is we don't expect anyone to do any work there.
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> Who knew that 60 to 70 percent of employee's time was mostly just BS A lot of it is software industry's fault. Think back to all those office jobs that got eliminated by software in the past 50 years. Like secretaries, in-house art departments, ${whatever the people distributing internal memos around the office were called}, etc. The jobs may be gone, but their tasks didn't disappear. Instead, they were smeared out over the remaining workforce. How much time a week each of us spends on trying to sync up meetings with different teams, writing reports, preparing slides, managing our mailbox and calendar - or all the other tasks that are not the actual thing we are specialized in? All those things were done by in-house specialists, and like with all specialized jobs, those people were much more efficient at it. Now, they're gone, while we're left doing their jobs on top of our own, and suffering a huge context-switching penalty on top of it. I'm increasingly convinced that most of the savings software brought to office work is just an accounting trick. The secretaries, in-house graphics teams, etc. all took salaries, which were clearly visible on company balance sheets. In comes the software, out these people go, their responsibilities get distributed between all the remaining employees - suddenly, the salaries for those specialists disappear from the balance sheets, while the company... it feels like it experiences an unexplained, broad productivity drop. A great mystery. Is it because Feds are messing with interest rates? Is it because some "cost diseases"? Who knows? Doesn't matter - it looks like a global thing, so it doesn't show on the balance sheets. If Large Language Models are going to automate away all those BS tasks we've been doing, what's really happening is that they're finally materializing the gains that regular office software promised to deliver, while it in fact made things worse. (Exercise for the reader: based on the above, think about websites and apps enabling "self-service", and consider if, as individuals, we're really gaining much by being made to do for free the work that used to be someone else's job.)
- pydry 3y ago* McKinsey told AT&T that cellphones would be a niche market in the year 2000 with only 900,000 subscribers. The firm’s estimations were off by 108 million. * In the 1990s McKinsey advised SwissAir on the controversial “hunter strategy”. The major expansion program failed miserably and the airline was forced to declare bankruptcy in 2001. Other notable clients who ended up bankrupt include Kmart and General Motors. * McKinsey & Company gave the go-ahead for the infamous $350 billion merger between Time Warner (TWX) and AOL. Looking back, the merger is viewed as one of the greatest company disasters of all time. https://www.equities.com/news/a-look-at-mckinsey-company-s-biggest-mistakes/ https://www.equities.com/news/a-look-at-mckinsey-company-s-b... Not that I want this to prevent them from whipping up some serious executive FOMO over AI. Ive got bills to pay.
- drawkbox 3y agoMcKinsey has many controversies. [1] McKinsey and Jeff Skilling used Enron as a "sandbox". [2] McKinsey is somewhat a consult cult that ruined agility with "Agile" which goes against everything agile was supposed to be. [3] Real agile and agility is now crushed due to them turning it into a micromanagement always on critical path. [4] McKinsey margin cutting has killed off lots of research and development and innovation. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McKinsey_%26_Company#Controversies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McKinsey_%26_Company#Controver... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McKinsey_%26_Company#Enron https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McKinsey_%26_Company#Enron [3] http://agilemanifesto.org/ http://agilemanifesto.org/ [4] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-BOSpxYJ9M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-BOSpxYJ9M
- innagadadavida 3y agoFundamentally I don’t understand how a new technology can claim to make everything more efficient but at the same time grow the economy. Shouldn’t we have loss of jobs and reduction in consumption and GDP if we become way more efficient?
- nine_zeros 3y agoBecause a lot of jobs are ridiculously inefficient. The efficiency gains make things (and money) move faster. Faster movement of goods, services, and money makes GDP grow.
- mo_42 3y agoIf you can get done twice as much because you have a robot assistant, then, your basically producing twice the amount of goods or services. So, people can consume more. To be able to produce or consume more the abstractly growth GDP. I guess an important assumption here is that people get payed according to productivity. Otherwise this would go into the profit of the company. But still the increase in wealth would end up somewhere.
- wintogreen74 3y agoThe funny part to me is that they assume this journey to uber-efficient utilization of labour will be super... efficient? How many decades will it take us to unlock the potential of all this displaced BS work?
- wintogreen74 3y agoThey come up with a hypothesis like "Every hour of labor shaved off a job by AI gets converted to an hour at the highest value measure". Then they produce very complicated spreadsheets that show how many hours will be saved and multiply this by a very big per unit number. Then they report on the results with very little scrutiny of the methodology. The huge dollar $ign$ blind executive thought leaders, who will rush to adopt - at least for the next 6-9 months. source: former management consultant
- ArekDymalski 3y ago
- bubblehack3r 3y agoSounds like they have an interest in the market.
- nathan_compton 3y agoMcKinsey also worked on that line city in the desert and a bunch of other incredibly stupid shit. I don't know why people take them seriously.
- seydor 3y agoSounds like they got that number from chatGPT
- sparker72678 3y ago"Fires good for the economy, Arsonist Promises."
- bourneavent 3y agoThese studies aren't done wholistically and only done from a business perspective. That's why these studies are garbage they fail to account for the feedback effect. Employers pay money to workers so that workers in turn can buy products from employers. These studies only account for how much money Employers save when they get rid of workers and pay less money to workers. Well when you get rid of workers or pay them less there's less money going around for workers to buy things from employers. These studies fail to account for this feedback. It's the tragedy of the commons. If one company utilizes generative AI to reduce labor costs that company benefits. If all companies collectively do this, then everyone loses. It's the aggregate behavior of all companies acting in their own interest that ultimately causes them all to act against their own interests.
- scylla 3y agoHow is this any different from farm machinery 200 years ago or industrial automation 50 years ago? More production with far less people. The same concerns that tithes would lead to massive unemployment. Instead, the economy and global living standards shot up and completely new fields opened up.
- bourneavent 3y ago>How is this any different from farm machinery 200 years ago or industrial automation 50 years ago? More production with far less people. The economy will for sure eventually get into some sort of equilibrium again. Things will become normal sort of like how the giant wealth inequality gap is super normal right now (likely caused by the same automation you're describing). But there is so much different now then before. Additionally the velocity in which this replacement is occuring is much higher then industrial automation. Given the differences we cannot fully know the outcome. It's easy and convenient to allude to examples in the past to predict the future, but that is not a data driven or logical conclusion. We don't know what will happen, and to ignore the possibility of a bad outcome is folly. My wild guess is that there will be a temporary period of destabilization and this temporary period could last between one to two decades all the way to several generations. By then all the "problems" will be normalized; sort of like how the wealth inequality gap has been normalized and how it's basically become normal to see tons and tons of homeless people living in RVs in the bay area.
- swyx 3y ago"finds" = "pulled out of ass"
- nologic01 3y agoSomebody will feed all these insightful McKinsey studies into an LLM and nobody will ever know the difference
- zackmorris 3y ago*for billionaires
- Animats 3y agoIn addition to the $5 trillion McKinsey said would come from the Metaverse![1] [1] https://www.globenewswire.com/en/news-release/2022/06/15/2462945/0/en/McKinsey-Company-s-new-research-shows-the-metaverse-could-grow-up-to-5-trillion-in-value-by-2030.html https://www.globenewswire.com/en/news-release/2022/06/15/246...
- flashgordon 3y agoLooks like they have been over hyping everything after their huge dismissal of mobile in the 80s!! https://www.upf.edu/web/angel-lozano/innovation/-/asset_publisher/AZaAOTtL3c4Z/content/id/223464268/maximized#:~:text=In%201980%2C%20McKinsey%20%26%20Company%20was,the%20actual%20figure%2C%20109%20Million https://www.upf.edu/web/angel-lozano/innovation/-/asset_publ....
- hospitalJail 3y agoVRChat is similar to Metaverse and while it hasnt exploded in popularity, its growing. I could see it being a multi-trillion dollar thing. My retired dad is obsessed, he spends hours per day in it meeting new people and his friends from around the world. He even has become more open minded to Trans people(He has been socially liberal his whole life, but that topic he was resistant on). He tells me about parties at clubs, celebrating holiday's like St. Patrick's day, having birthday parties, even a wedding. Soon companies will begin monetizing it more blatantly and capitalism will feed it. Facebook failed because Facebook is creepy and we try to avoid their products.
- bagels 3y agoDid Facebook fail? It still drives a lot of profit.
- acchow 3y agoFacebook didn't fail because it's creepy. It's product just wasn't good enough to overcome its creepiness cost. (although, going by Facebook's stock price I don't think it has failed...?) TikTok is much creepier and more invasive, but people keep flocking to it.
- donohoe 3y agoI find anything McKinsey claims to be dubious by default.
- hospitalJail 3y agoAs many people here, I program. My performance directly reduces the cost of company operations. Previously I was responsible for $500k/yr in savings, but with ChatGPT aiding my coding, I can easily see that number 1.5x-ing. Not to mention, we could use local models for multi-millions in savings(we don't trust putting our data online). I think as people learn when to use LLMs, it will cause a multi-trillion dollar explosion in cost reductions.
- kneebonian 3y agoDoes it increase real wealth at all though or is this like how I'm now $100,000 richer because my house appreciated, even though it makes 0% actual impact on my situation?