4 ms·
IRS confirms Stanford study of racial bias in audits
- boredumb 3y ago"The researchers suggest that’s because the IRS set up systems that are more likely to flag tax returns with potential mistakes in how some tax credits, like the earned-income tax credit (EITC), are claimed. There is no evidence that Blacks cheat on their taxes, but they do file at disproportionately higher rates the kinds of returns that the IRS approach targets." So african americans take on more EITC that trips an internal system to flag for audit. What was the rate of outcomes for these cases?
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoFor the EITC audit program as a whole, about 90% of all audits result in a change to the originally-filed return.
- duxup 3y agoIs there any indication why this occurs? It’s not like someone goes to the IRS in person and they see that person and decide to audit them do they? I have had the IRS reach out to me a few times and I’ve had to deal with them. It was all via mail and felt very formal and computerized. It didn’t seem like there was much room for individual discretion.
- yieldcrv 3y agoAlgorithm searching for EITC filings Its a socioeconomic class issue, in the US thats also 99% correlated to race by half a millennium of prior design, so for anyone looking for a race explanation they will find that and often miss the socioeconomic perpetuation, which is important in patching the discovered issue
- wlesieutre 3y agoIf you read the article, yes it’s because they’re more likely to use certain tax credits that are factored into the audit selection algorithm
- JPKab 3y agoThe very top of the article stated the reason why. "The researchers suggest that’s because the IRS set up systems that are more likely to flag tax returns with potential mistakes in how some tax credits, like the earned-income tax credit (EITC), are claimed. There is no evidence that Blacks cheat on their taxes, but they do file at disproportionately higher rates the kinds of returns that the IRS approach targets."
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoThe cheese moved in the middle of that paragraph; almost to the point of non-sequitur. Audits are not done to detect cheating. They're done to make sure returns are correct; error-free. Some errors are deliberate (that's cheating), some errors are not (those are mistakes).
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoI make this comment almost every time that this comes up. The Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) is a ~$70-100bn social payments / anti-poverty program for lower-paid Americans masquerading as a refundable tax credit. So the IRS ends up running that, because the IRS is responsible for tax, despite the fact that virtually none of the recipients of EITC actually owe any income tax in the first place. Congress has made the EITC fairly complicated, specifically relating to the relationship between the person claiming the credit and their dependent children. Some of that is natural, given it's actually a anti-poverty spending program. The net result is that the EITC isn't just a simple "I made this much, and this is how much tax I owe as a result" thing. It's got eligibility requirements, it's got cross-checks to make sure that multiple returns aren't claiming the same dependent children, it's got checks to see the dependent children actually exist etc. It's not surprising that filers make errors at a higher rate for more complex filings, and it's therefore also not a surprise that the IRS automates error-checking. EITC auditing is also highly effective, with changes to returns being made in ~90% of cases where the IRS challenges the return.
- duxup 3y agoTY
- stefan_ 3y agoI think a director of a company or agency that ever blames "the algorithm" should be immediately dismissed.
- atlasunshrugged 3y agoRight? I mean "the algorithm" didn't just appear on its own? How it was developed and what it's optimized for was based on human design/development (or in the government's more likely case, procurement) choices.
- vuln 3y agoI’m sure the 87,000 new agents will add a bit of equality to these audits.
- colpabar 3y agoHey, we say equity now. Equality was too hard.
- vuln 3y agoI appreciate your correction. I apologize for my mistake and any harm caused by my lack of knowledge.
- vidarh 3y agoRecognising that "equality" is imprecise and flawed is not new. E.g. Marx, Critique of the Gotha Programme (1875) said this as part of a lengthy argument about what is now the SPD meant with "fair distribution of the proceeds of labor": > Thus, with an equal performance of labor, and hence an equal in the social consumption fund, one will in fact receive more than another, one will be richer than another, and so on. To avoid all these defects, right, instead of being equal, would have to be unequal.
- JPKab 3y ago"The researchers suggest that’s because the IRS set up systems that are more likely to flag tax returns with potential mistakes in how some tax credits, like the earned-income tax credit (EITC), are claimed. There is no evidence that Blacks cheat on their taxes, but they do file at disproportionately higher rates the kinds of returns that the IRS approach targets." Translation: Lower income taxpayers who know to take advantage of specific programs are more likely to be audited, independent of race. Black Americans are more likely to use these programs, but saying that doesn't attract clicks the same way that "The IRS is racist!" does.
- atlasunshrugged 3y agoAgreed, it's somewhat hysterical reporting (but hey, blame the consumers, they're the ones that click on those headlines). However, in the end it is still pretty interesting that they are focused on looking for fraud at the lower end of the income spectrum rather than the higher end where I imagine the risk/reward ratio is much higher... if the IRS sends a claims letter to a poor family for 1k, they'll probably pay it or not have a way to fight it. If the IRS sends a claims letter to a wealthy person for 100K, they're going up against accountants and tax lawyers who are probably better equipped than the IRS itself.
- nonethewiser 3y agoThere is real demand for racism.
- runako 3y agoThe Civil Rights Acts stipulate that it's also illegal to use proxies for race as a means of targeting members of a racial group. (This hasn't gone to court, so we don't know whether this targeting was intentional or unintentional. Under the Acts, it likely does not matter. We see suits like this all the time, and this general rule is typically upheld. For a recent example with reasoning, look at the federal appeals court ruling against a North Carolina voter ID law.) We are likely to see the Supreme Court rule as much again this summer. Key search term here is "disparate impact" if you are curious. The key takeaway here is this conduct by the IRS is possibly illegal under federal law.
- atlasunshrugged 3y agoReally interesting, I know there is a lot of hesitancy around the billions that are flowing to the IRS for modernization and more agents for enforcement but I do wonder if it'll let the IRS focus on the much more complex investigations needed to find wrongdoing from wealthy people who have probably filled out all the correct forms meticulously with an army of accountants and tax lawyers, but are doing some shady stuff nonetheless rather than going after the low hanging simple mistakes (and probably simpler fraud schemes) by low-income earners.
- mistrial9 3y agoafter a recent and publicized (post-covid 19) addition of agents to the IRS, a neighbor in California got a summary readjustment of their low-income in a high cost-of-living area; the summary adjust showed an additional $23,000 in taxable income, with no supporting documentation. After making an appointment and waiting for weeks to contact the office, the adjustment was declared "in error" and rescinded, again with no supporting documentation.
- trompetenaccoun 3y agoLove how these universities come out with ever more findings of racism in all sorts of institutions - with the one exception of their very own offices: https://padailypost.com/2022/10/29/stanford-defends-using-race-in-admissions-submits-brief-to-supreme-court-on-behalf-of-harvard/ https://padailypost.com/2022/10/29/stanford-defends-using-ra...
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoI’m not sure what you mean, academics study racism in academia all the time. Here’s just one study in 2021 about the lack of black physicians, just from googling racism academia study. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8357067/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8357067/
- trompetenaccoun 3y agoThese US universities are systematically racist in their admission practices. The university administration openly admit this too. What I mean is the racism accusation is a total charade as long as the majority of those purporting to call attention to the problem in one place are actually in support in another. None of the authors have protested the systematic racism in the institution they work for. None of them have resigned in protest to support all the Asian students that are discriminated against. They're completely silent on the issue. The study you linked has nothing to do with Stanford's discrimination against students either. I'm not American but if I understand it correctly their supreme court might soon force the universities to end racial discrimination. Which will also mean that it's sadly unlikely the majority of students and staff will ever come to their own conclusion about how and why racism is categorically wrong. They really should know better.
- TMWNN 3y agoProducer Dick Wolf's five Law & Order shows similarly taught us over two decades that the "wealthy CEO" or "high-powered corporate lawyer" is always guilty, and the large companies they own/work for are just as crooked. The only upscale demographic that is never the criminal is the famous TV-show producer.
- balderdash 3y agoBy that logic, sounds like the EITC needs to be altered as it’s disproportionally benefitting black people, then the problem is solved. I’m being flippant, but sometimes people’s logic baffles me.
- wendyshu 3y agoI think the article is saying that the decision whether or not to audit is not a function of race, but black people are more likely to file certain kinds of returns (eg with earned-income tax credit) and those kinds of returns are more likely to get audited because they're more likely to contain mistakes. I wouldn't call this "racial bias" at all.
- hnburnsy 3y agoDo those complaint about the racial bais in the way the IRS set up their systems propose changing the set up? For EITC I would imagine the IRS does simple date, math, and duplicate checking. Should the IRS turn these checks off for equity reasons? These are rhe common reasons for EITC denial... Your Child Doesn’t Qualify More than One Person Claimed the Child Social Security Number or Last Name Don’t Match Married and Filed as Single Head of Household Over or Underreporting Your Income or Expenses
- vidarh 3y agoThere's too little info to go on in the article. If it is true, as they might possibly seem to imply, that they triggered more audits but didn't find cheating at an elevated rate over other subsets, then the first step to do would be to look at what assumptions were made about how EITC correlates with cheating or ucaught errors that'd justify an audit, and whether there's data to support those assumptions.