7 ms·
"Percentage of students missing 5 or more days of school monthly has doubled since 2020" seems like it might have some explanatory powers. How can you miss a qu
by jeffbee 3y ago
"Percentage of students missing 5 or more days of school monthly has doubled since 2020" seems like it might have some explanatory powers. How can you miss a quarter of the school days and keep up?
- WalterBright 3y ago> How can you miss a quarter of the school days and keep up? Not a problem, as public schools move at a glacial pace. In 8th grade, the teachers were still going over the times tables with them. In high school "honors" class, the teacher spent an entire semester on the concept of "molar mass". My experience going through the bowels of the public school system was it was fun place to be with your friends. Any learning was incidental. Of course, the magnitude of this disaster made it very difficult for me to get my feet under me in college.
- jeffbee 3y agoYour experience from > 50 years ago may not be relevant.
- projektfu 3y agoI forget where you're from, but I know you're a little older than me. In my public school, 8th grade tracked some students into high-school math (New York Regents Course 1) and the others into math that they'd need for the next year. But in 7th grade, all students were solving some algebra problems, graphing and plotting, etc. basic geometry, some constructions, etc. 11th grade (Regents, not Honors) Chemistry had equilibrium problems, etc., although it was hit or miss whether the teacher could teach them. It was also not required, as only 2 years of science were required, and most students would have taken Earth Science/Geology and Biology. However, it shows that public schools can get teach it, and the standards can require it. I do wish people would give up on teaching Physics without Calculus. Kind of a wasted year for me, and everything made sense as soon as you added differentiation and integration. I think the two courses should be taught together in the same class. Presumably, the No Child Left Behind act and the Common Core curriculum are supposed to provide a baseline for the country that is well above "times tables in 8th grade". Common Core seems to me to suffer from a second-system effect, eschewing some of the tried-and-true for the experimental, but the motivation is a reasonable one. I never understood why they didn't take a successful state's curriculum and adapt it to all the states, but that's politics more than anything else. I'm pretty concerned though, now that I'll be having kids go through the system, that the parties involved (teachers, administration, politicians) will conspire to avoid doing work while avoiding responsibility. But that's local politics, not national.
- WalterBright 3y agoCalculus had this fearsome reputation in high school of being terribly difficult. When I finally learned the basics of it (in college) I thought "is that all?" Of course, it wasn't all at all, but the calculus needed for high school physics is pretty simple. I took every honors class in high school. Everything they had. I was terribly, woefully underprepared for college. It took a year and a half before I had my legs back under me. It was a wonder I didn't flunk out. But I had a great time in high school. I had little responsibilities, a little money, and lots of friends to hang with.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoFor certain kids, HS is pretty easy academically, even if you play it on hard mode. It comes as a huge shock when hitting university in how hard things can get, and how you weren't really being challenged with homework you could do in class the period before it was due. Washington state has the option for kids to take some college courses in HS. I hope my kid can take advantage of that (but he just graduated from Kindergarten, so we are a ways off from determining anything).
- WalterBright 3y agoYou can teach basic calculus to high school students in a couple hours, if they have a solid understanding of algebra.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoYa. And it really isn't that hard if you have a solid understanding of algebra. Linear algebra on the other hand...I wish I started earlier on that so I could really get all the cool stuff happening in ML today.
- kccqzy 3y agoThere's plenty of physics you can teach without calculus. I wish the curriculum here wouldn't start with kinematics. When I did physics without calculus, I was taught forces, force diagrams, torque, pulley systems, buoyancy, work and energy, and some basic electric circuits (including Kirchhoff's Rules). The only bit of kinematic was motion with constant velocity, which doesn't need any calculus.
- tallytarik 3y ago> In 8th grade, the teachers were still going over the times tables with them. > In high school "honors" class, the teacher spent an entire semester on the concept of "molar mass". This is not the case everywhere.
- WalterBright 3y agoBeing an Air Force brat, I attended 4 public schools in various locales. They were all the same. All ordinary, middle class schools. Average test scores seem to be about the same from then to now.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoA lot of this is mandated by the school: you have a cough? Go home, it might be COVID! It gets annoying as a parent: the kid wants to be in school, they aren't really sick (well, above the normal level of snifflies a kid has during much of the winter), but the system is ultra conservative right now.
- TheFreim 3y ago> the kid wants to be in school Really? When I was in school I always wanted to NOT be in school, same for all my friends. It's always weird now hearing people my age or older saying things like this when my personal experience was completely the opposite.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoMy sister was like you, she never wanted to be in school. I felt bored staying at home, so always wanted to go. My kid is just a Kindergartener and still likes to go meet up with his friends and play vs. not getting enough screen time while staying home. We don't make it a free Nintendo Switch/iPad day when he comes home sick. There are lots of kids who would rather be at school than home. It is not that they really liked school, just that being home watching soap operas isn't very fun at all (in my case, this is before the internet).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TheFreim 3y ago> How can you miss a quarter of the school days and keep up? In middle school I missed quite a bit of school, even more in high school (sometimes missed entire weeks at a time) . It's not really that difficult, most of the time was spent on fluff. I passed with nothing lower than a B if my memory serves me, got accepted to every school I applied to so I was definitely performing well enough.
- whatscooking 3y agoAs someone who graduated valedictorian but skipped more days than allowable to graduate (my parents had to fight with the district to let me graduate), there is no correlation between days attended and skill/aptitude.
- kubik369 3y agoSo you are saying that because you, a presumably exceptional student since you mention being valedictorian, could afford to skip days at school, the same applies to average or below-average students? Could you elaborate on how you came to that conclusion?
- BeFlatXIII 3y agoI’d argue that there is a correlation but it stops somewhere along the skill ladder.
- jgwil2 3y agoA single data point cannot establish or refute a correlation.
- HDThoreaun 3y ago> there is no correlation between days attended and skill/aptitude. This may be true, but there is absolutely a correlation between days attended and amount learned.
- Claude_Shannon 3y agoIn Poland it was a very common thing in high school for us to skip school and study for high school exam on our own, as that was more effective usage of time we felt.