6 ms·
The comment by Yuval Noah Harari seemed insightful to me. If you argue against a bot about a political matter, not knowing it’s a bot - you always lose on a lon
by Havoc 3y ago
The comment by Yuval Noah Harari seemed insightful to me. If you argue against a bot about a political matter, not knowing it’s a bot - you always lose on a long enough timeline. ie you can never pursuade the bot but it can wear you down / eventually find an argument that works.
The only winning move is not to play. So I could see this having a chilling effect on all discourse
Aside from the whole skynet thing the above is what spooks me the most
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoFrom a Bayesian perspective, the only way to play and not lose is to not update your priors, at all, forever. (I suppose that "not playing" winds up much the same - you don't have any input on which to falsely update your priors.) But people who absolutely will not update their priors is not likely to work out well in the long run...
- x86x87 3y ago[flagged]
- civilized 3y agoThere are plenty of pushy humans who are prepared to talk you into submission. Check out your local Scientology or Lyndon LaRouche movement office. Would you talk interminably with a pushy human? How is the AI any different?
- mandmandam 3y agoThe differences that jump out at me are in cost, scale and accountability. It's work recruiting people to your cause. It's expensive, and takes time and attention and resources. People have consciences that might flare up, they have loose lips, they need training and guidance and oversight. Letting a bot loose for your cause costs pennies. It can be updated with a few clicks. You can reverse course or fine tune with a few sentences; you can even tailor it to the vulnerabilities of your victims with just a few data points. The brainwashing inflicted on people by advertising and the like has had a tremendous cost to society, and the planet; absolutely incalculable. It would be prudent to be alert to the danger of all that being exacerbated 100- or 1,000-fold.
- red-iron-pine 3y agoit's not just cheaper, its eminently more reactive. your human recruiter is going to have their own biases, could be tired, may not know how to deal with personality X or Y, they may not learn. the bots can track how they do by upvote, react quickly, won't get tired or annoyed, and can use existing data to filter and target those who are extremely vulnerable. hell, with real-time analysis by data mining companies (cough cough FB, reddit) they could even figure out if/when a normally stable-ish person is in crisis or has a bad week, and hit them at their most susceptible. 99% of the year they might be able to see through the BS, but this week things are hard and what they're seeing in their feed just feels right, for once...
- mandmandam 3y agoInteresting point.. I wonder how we could test to see if they are already doing this...
- throwaway22032 3y agoBots or no bots, that'w why arguing on the Internet is pointless. I could argue with you, "Havoc", for a while, and perhaps convince you that there are 2/3/7 genders, or whatever, and then as sure as the sun rises, along comes another user. Or infinite set of. Most social media is "man yells at cloud", quite literally.
- tikhonj 3y agoVery much unlike pre-AI political arguments with real people on the internet.
- b1n 3y agoYou may not ever be able to persuade a bot, but you can identify if it is capable of repudiating your points or not. You can ascertain if it is arguing in good faith and chose to end an argument if it isn’t. When you say “find an argument that works” isn’t this just saying that they’ve said something you find persuasive? What’s wrong with this? How is this different to any other argument in good faith?
- cvoss 3y agoBecause we have to assume not everyone can ascertain what are bad faith or dishonest arguments, or even good faith but illogical arguments. People are fallable and can be persuaded by bad arguments. So the point is, given enough time, the person will make a mistake and fall for a bad argument.
- imtringued 3y agoAs someone struggling to destroy some of my own beliefs, due to their potential to waste a lot of my time. I have failed to do so. The perceptions of other disagreeing people ended up just being one more way to validate them because you end up seeing the same pattern of mistakes over and over again.
- Aerbil313 3y ago> you can identify if it is capable of repudiating your points or not. Wait until GPT5. Or don’t, because a vast amount of people are already incapable of that.
- aero-deck 3y agoThe chilling effect may actually be a good thing, given that discourse these days is overheated. There's a weird magic trick that social media companies have played on people to convince them that the text and images consumed on their websites are socially/culturally/politically relevant. Once it becomes clear how easy it is to fake that text people will come to understand how cheap and irrelevant "opinion" has become and this magic trick will become weakened.
- uoaei 3y agoThe entire thesis of TFA is that human psychological traits on societal scales are not prepared to handle an arena of discourse where that's true, that people will either be duped or completely check out of discourse per se, not limited to online social media. You hold the opposite position. Why?
- aero-deck 3y agoBecause there are actually multiple "arenas of discourse" and people will simply switch the "marketplace" they're using. It's technocratic hubris to think that there is just a single such arena and that all the others are illegitimate/dangerous.
- uoaei 3y agoNo, it's a feature of the human mind that truth is considered objective independent of the lens used to acquire it. "Post-truth" sources in some arenas will be conflated with "real-truth" sources in others, leading to a blanket demotion of the perceived value and quality of truth. The whole argument from TFA is about human psychology, not about specific offerings of "marketplaces" where truth may be more or less maligned.
- aero-deck 3y agodunno what "TFA" refers to here, but it seems like we're heading into a argument regarding epistemology, which is not a discussion that HN handles well. IMO "truth" is distraction here because what is at stake here are people's values, not their understanding of math and physics. When people worry about "post-truth", they're worried about liberal values no longer being the unquestioned default. It is absolutely a marketplace, and if people switching marketplaces en-masse makes it harder to launch rockets and develop vaccines, then it probably means those activities are making people net unhappy. People are a lot smarter than we give them credit for, even the dumb ones.
- itairall 3y agoIt is a straw man to pretend that political discussion looks like an Intelligence Squared debate when almost all the time it looks like a food fight about nonsense. The idea the world will be worst off with less flame wars is simply wrong IMO. I would already rate the discourse I have had with chatGPT4 as the best of my life. I win if I learn something. It strikes me as highly perverse to view that the only way to win is to not play the game because you can't brow beat the bot into submission. THAT is though what we mean by "political discussion". A bullshit pie throwing contest until one side quits. A twitter flame war. Yes, hopefully AI completely destroys that.
- bioemerl 3y agoI think you're mistaken at least with current AI. It's very easy to condition them into a new frame or mind if you speak to them in a certain way. They're also very prone to "trope" - where when your sprinkle a few hints of something that's common they'll fall right into line with behavior associated to it. We forget that AI becomes more human as it gets more intelligent. These are not computers programmed with a hard limitation anymore, they're actually more prone to being manipulated than other humans are.
- sfg 3y agoI talk about political matters for ideas, education, and stimulation (mine and the other person's), rather than to beat them into taking on my position. I'd certainly walk away from a conversation long before I'm worn down into taking on their views. I think this interchange of thought and sharing of ideas is the true essence of discourse. That other thing is more of a verbal tribal battle. I can see issues with bots swinging the political landscape in ways that cause harm, but I think there is good reason to think discourse might flourish. Fundamentally, if the competitive arguers are discouraged, whilst the curious and conversational are encouraged, or at least not hurt, then discourse itself wins.
- haxiomic 3y agoI don't think political swings are likely to happen from improving curious thoughtful discourse, these things are dwarfed by blunt evocative approaches that reach broad segments of voting society We might find discourse flourishes corners of discussion on the internet but the wider internet is much more at risk to these approaches
- dsego 3y agoSounds almost like arguing with a conservative and expecting to convince them with rational arguments. PS Intended as a lighthearted jab, please don't get offended.
- DantesKite 3y agoHumans are like that too.
- Animats 3y ago> If you argue against a bot about a political matter, not knowing it’s a bot - you always lose on a long enough timeline. i.e. you can never persuade the bot, but it can wear you down / eventually find an argument that works. That's a useful insight. The one on one wearing-down process came from theology. It's sometimes called Jesuitry. Members of the Society of Jesus were trained to do that sort of thing, and they got so good at it that the whole organization was suppressed in the 1700s.[1] There are still Jesuit-run schools in the US, and they do tend in that direction. "Never argue with a Jesuit", said Richard Nixon. Since mass media, large scale use of one on one convincing has gone out of fashion. It's not cost-effective. With large language models, it's back. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suppression_of_the_Society_of_Jesus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suppression_of_the_Society_of_...
- null0pointer 3y agoI've noticed some humans are willing to argue without giving up too. Sometimes online arguments follow a pattern where each response is longer than the last until one person decides it's not worth their time to continue the argument. In my head I've called this "argument by attrition".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- earthboundkid 3y agoThis is dumb idea from someone who does not use online forums. When someone keeps making stupid points against me online, I get only more dug in on my views. If anything, you would want to make a bot to say "Not X" so the pro-X side could feel better about how dumb the opposition to X is.
- afro88 3y agoI've yet to see an AI bot that is both realistic and intelligent enough to keep me engaged (GPT4), but also can't be convinced that 1 + 1 = 3 (also GPT4)
- systems_glitch 3y agoIDK having everyone check out on social media to interact with definite humans in meatspace probably is net positive.
- RealityVoid 3y agoA lot of times you don't argue with someone to prove to them you are right, but to prove to bystanders that there are different ways of looking at this. Refusing to engage will not make the world a better place if the only ones talking are idiots.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- HuhWhatMeansYou 3y ago[dead]
- gavanwilhite 3y agoWhile this sounds wise at first glance, this is just clearly not true to anyone who's used ChatGPT. The problem is usually the opposite (sycophancy)