4 ms·
> Talk to any homeless person in a tent city in the US and they will confirm most if not all of them are heavy drug abusers. I don't think self reporting is us
by seanmcdirmid 3y ago
> Talk to any homeless person in a tent city in the US and they will confirm most if not all of them are heavy drug abusers.
I don't think self reporting is useful here. Ask the guy who is smoking fent in the back of the bus (smells like burnt peanut butter) if he is a drug addict, and he will confirm that he has never even tried them before.
More to the point, most homeless are only homeless for a week or two. They usually aren't abusing drugs and find themselves back on their feet relatively quickly (or at least can get help and haven't burned all bridges with their family). However, among the chronic homeless, the ones that are the most visible to everyone, substance abuse and/or mental illness is a common problem (with fent, permanent mental illness results pretty quickly).
I really think we should be dumping our resources into easy cases (people who just need some financial support/housing) because if they fall into hard cases (people abusing drugs), it is very expensive to impossible to solve their problems. I don't even think force will work very well, unless you can apply it at the beginning of addiction, most of them will never be productive again and will, humanely, require some kind of assisted living for the rest of their lives.
- starttoaster 3y agoDon’t mistake my comment for a lack of compassion. Having been homeless myself for almost a year when I was younger, camping out in a local forest preserve and packing out each and every day in the midwest, I do have quite a lot of compassion for homeless people. While I was working my way out of the hole I was in, many of my coworkers were also homeless, I got to know many of them and their individual struggles quite well. However, I’m curious about the cost of assisted living for every drug abusing homeless person in the United States, the ones that don’t work and likely never will, and how the rest of society could shoulder that burden with tax dollars when a huge portion of society barely understands how they will afford to retire when they become too old to work blue collar jobs themselves. I don’t see that being a realistic goal, but I’m interested in hearing more about that if I’m somehow wrong.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoI was homeless for a couple of weeks when I was young. It wasn't really that bad for me though, since I was working, and was eventually given a couch in a friend's house. Finland's method of dealing with chronic homeless should provide a model for an assisted living solution. It comes out to be cheaper than providing services they would consume on the street. A small apartment and a (more well payed than in the states) social worker for every 10 or so residents to make sure they don't burn down the place they are being given by the government. But we need to provide it nationally rather than at the state or local level. This would give us the opportunity to house them in less expensive locations and would prevent the current "tragedy of the commons" situation we have now.
- starttoaster 3y agoWorth pointing out that Finland has a much more sparse population density than the United States, with the United States having about 35 people per square kilometer, to Finland's 16. This might enable them to create even cheaper buildings in less desirable parts of their country, though on the flip side, I don't know that all of Finland's land is considered "liveable", basically being in the North Pole. Looking at their homelessness statistics, they've been on a downward trend for homelessness since 1989, having about 17,000 homeless individuals. So assuming that's around the time they started working to put homeless people in houses, I'll use that as their baseline. I'm not sure how accurate the census is on the homeless population in the US, but according to the following link we have about 582,000: https://endhomelessness.org/homelessness-in-america/homelessness-statistics/state-of-homelessness/ https://endhomelessness.org/homelessness-in-america/homeless... I guess the question here is: does Finland's assisted living solution scale to the size of the United States' homeless problem? And I truly don't have that answer, but while I think it's valuable to point out the patterns that other countries have done to course correct their issues, I think it's also fair to say not every pattern that smaller countries use will work at scale, or even work with our current economic and social systems.
- pfannkuchen 3y ago> Ask the guy who is smoking fent in the back of the bus (smells like burnt peanut butter) if he is a drug addict, and he will confirm that he has never even tried them before. This feels like a reverse Bloom filter situation. Positive means positive, negative means maybe.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoThat is true. But surely there is a better way to get a handle on this problem than just via self reporting. The issue is also that there are many different kinds of homeless that really aren’t very related to each other. You can’t use the same methodology to even count them.