7 ms·
The history and future of workplace automation (2015)
- ggm 3y agoA socialist economic perspective raised in the UK in the 70s and 80s was that robotics were going to be a huge contradiction to Labour theory of Value because the value is inherent to human labour, and so the robot either reduces the value to zero, or infinite: Retaining the humans means that you can quantify the labour inputs to cost of production and in that theoretical model assign value to the goods made accordingly. I suspect classical economists don't see value in this theory. But that said, the underlying point is that cost, price and value are really odd concepts and in some ways, "all made by machines" confuses the hell out of people who thought they had a sense of value in a product which is now made by .. whom exactly? I mean why do I even pay more than the capital depreciation, the input costs and some low margin? Objects like resistors or pills reflect the sunk costs much more than the labour costs. Are electronics production lines and pill factories totally devoid of humans? No. They moved roles. They supervise machines, or they perform tasks where the costs of (mobile) robots or robots adaptive to contextual demand is still too high. I have a friend who supervised a totally automated clarified butter (Ghee) factory in Queensland Australia. It operates in a very narrow temperature band: too high and the Ghee tastes burnt. Too low and it gums up the flow. He's like the man in Kurt Vonnegut's "Player Piano" keeping the robot working, which makes the Ghee. There's a driver or two, and some payroll staff, and cleaners, and finance/economics and advertising staff. It's hardly "nobody works here" but they don't employ people on the factory floor as much as they did. Robot slaughter houses (there's a thought...) are using smart cutting devices to move highly skilled labour to the places they can add value. There are 4 important cuts on a side of beef which have to be made "just right" to extract maximum value in all the subsequent jointing. That demands a skill which goes beyond the normal, you have to sense where the muscle and bone points are on this specific carcase right then and there. 4 cuts, which ruin the value if you get them wrong. Sheep shearers are highly paid. Robot sheep shearing has been a long time "in development" It is also worth noting that if you don't have a workforce, you don't have people earning money, and thus don't have people buying your goods. This is not a problem for a Bottega making handbags to sell to Melania Trump and her friends, because you aren't selling them to your local workforce. It's a huge problem if you make milk, or tin pineapples, and expect to sell produce locally: if you don't pay people, they can't buy your product.
- eli_gottlieb 3y ago>I mean why do I even pay more than the capital depreciation, the input costs and some low margin? If the neoclassical theory of price converging to marginal cost actually holds, then this is exactly what we should be paying! > Objects like resistors or pills reflect the sunk costs much more than the labour costs. You mean up-front capital expenditures? Sounds about right, but then there's the problem that somewhere back in that chain, high-skilled professional labor was expended to design the machines (that design the machines?). So you do then have present marginal costs paying for past inputs, capex, and labor as well as present inputs and depreciation. Except you're not really paying the past labor directly, but instead via the firm that owns the trade-secrets and IP created by the past labor. So there's labor in there eventually, but alienated through enough layers of indirection that the same employer gets paid a bunch of times over for one design's work of actual work. Meanwhile, the guy who did the actual work is probably hunting for a new job because he doesn't get paid for use of his old work. Hmm... we need IP reform.
- Noumenon72 3y ago> if you don't pay people, they can't buy your product. I've never seen any value in this argument. If I make Bugattis, I gain nothing by paying my employees enough to buy a Bugatti. In a two-person one-good economy, yes, I can't hire you to milk the cow for $1 and then charge you $2 for the milk, but this isn't going to lead to you starving among spoiling milk. The market will clear, the prices of labor and milk will equalize, because $2 is more than the market will bear. With robots the price of the milk will go very low because it's so easy to make, meaning I will be willing to sell it for very little in return. You can get a near worthless job like collecting pretty rocks and buy milk with that.
- pixl97 3y ago>With robots the price of the milk will go very low because it's so easy to make This is making a huge amount of dangerous assumptions. With robots the price of milk might skyrocket, for example, if land becomes more desirable for other purposes that robots unlock driving up feedstock costs. We are already seeing farmland costs increase significantly. As long as land/homes are a good investment expect costs to increase.
- chii 3y agoFor those who don't like downloading a pdf and viewing it outside of the browser: https://docs.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=https://www.aeaweb.org/articles/pdf/doi/10.1257/jep.29.3.3 https://docs.google.com/viewerng/viewer?url=https://www.aeaw...
- ajcp 3y agohttps://pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/jep.29.3.3 https://pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/jep.29.3.3
- system2 3y agoI use the extension, helps. https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/pdf-viewer/oemmndcbldboiebfnladdacbdfmadadm https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/pdf-viewer/oemmndc...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Hextinium 3y agoAnecdotally I see this transition to higher production yield per person happening in real time, we are closing down some old factories and trying to re-train people to work in the new one being built in its place and it's very hard. A significant number of floor staff only have highschool degrees and are being speedrun through an associate's to stay with the company on a higher staff grade. Others are doing months of on the job training to be brought up to the level that they can still be employed. I know some just can't hack it and are quietly being let go. I know we are already asking our youth to mortgage their lives to get higher education, but what about a 50 year old woman who has been working for 30 years and still has 15 to go, but their job is completely gone? Do we send them back to college? This is already happening en mass in Japan, elderly are working entry level jobs because their old jobs are replaced. I think the college and retraining argument are only going to become more entwined in the next 20 years.
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoIts unpopular but one option would be to tax the wealthy to pay for additional services for the poor and underemployed. This is not my preferred way to deal with social issues but it strikes me as absurd to expect the 50 year old woman whose job has been automated away to struggle when there are people who could make that go away without any appreciable suffering at all. We have to consider how historical inequity has led to the status quo (for example historical union busting leaves the 50 year old worker with less today that she would have had otherwise) and what we may do to right those historical wrongs in the present.
- ekianjo 3y ago> would be to tax the wealthy to pay for additional services for the poor and underemployed. There's not enough rich people to do that in the first place. You will end up taxing the whole middle class, which is effectively what politicians are increasingly doing, which brings everyone down
- ffgjgf1 3y ago> There's not enough rich people I’m not sure that’s true. There are more rich people than ever and taxes are at their lowest point since ~1940
- ajcp 3y agoThis is a very interesting study and as someone working in this space ("intelligent" automation) incredibly germane. I have not read this fully yet and may be repeating findings but did want to chime in on something I've noticed in regards to this "replacement theory of automation" that doesn't quite hold up: businesses are inherently efficient. I have yet to come across an organization that has the opportunity to eliminate a skilled role - that is a white collar, certified expert position (think accountant or financial analyst) - because I have automated one of their business processes. I have worked for small, medium, and very large enterprise organizations. In every instance there has been at least two or three other business processes that were and will be out of our automation capabilities that the team member simply could not do because they were spending the vast majority of their time doing a business process that could be automated. Automation simply frees that team member up to do what was previously seen as "value added" work but now can be considered business critical. The author of this study probably even touches on that by addressing how the meaning of work and a job role simply shifts upon the automation of previously executed business processes by moving to what are still considered "in role" processes.
- TheRoque 3y agoIncreasing amount of bullshit jobs, and overall time wasting on nonproductive tasks ?
- potatoman22 3y agoI wish this article weren't so long. I want to understand what it has to say, but don't want to invest the time to do so.
- Krisjohn 3y agoEven while businesses promote government policy that looks to treat workers as rich and businesses as poor, they understand (as can be seen by lots of product pricing policies) that businesses are rich and individuals are poor. How many products have you seen with a cheap (or free) personal or family option, then expensive business or enterprise option? This is how the economy should be structured. Businesses should fund the government budgets and individuals should have lots of stuff (like public transport, or basic housing) provided free.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoBusiness options usually are more expensive than private/personal ones, but that's because - for various reasons - they can be charged more. Sometimes they even subsidize the personal versions (and/or personal versions are seen as marketing vectors that help in securing B2B deals). So the structure you mention already exists in the economy - the money just doesn't seem to make its way towards funding public services.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoI noticed a pattern of college educated people starting artisanal businesses. I know a person with a legal degree that is baking pastries, for example. That's just one person of course but I think it's getting quite common. If you look around here in Berlin, there sure are a lot of very well educated expats running all sorts of small businesses making coffee, craft beer, donuts, sourdough bread, whatever. They've given up on the white collar careers they were trained for. It's not just a Berlin thing. It's happening all over the place. I bought some regional wine in the Netherlands when I visited my family there. In a small village from a tiny business that produces wine locally and sells it on local markets. I should add that the Netherlands is not known for its wine production. That's a completely new thing (thanks to global warming). This is far away from the big cities. The same market featured all sorts of local produce. In the US you'd call it a farmer's market. Expensive produce made by people with decent educations aimed at people with disposable income. What's an artisanal business, it's a business model where the added value is in something being done with a personal touch and craft. Mostly without a lot of automation. People pay extra for that sort of thing and the people doing this stuff tend to enjoy what they are doing. The whole point is quality, craft, and tradition. As volume production for highly automated/processed stuff scales, prices for that drop and demand for the artisanal stuff increases. Just an observation: automation is a race to the bottom and it merely serves to enhance the value of stuff that is harder to automate. We automate the boring, low value stuff first. That creates more capacity for doing the high value stuff. Which as the wording implies is great for economic growth. Related to this is the re-shoring of manufacturing jobs. Now that automation has lowered the price of doing things locally with fewer workers, it no longer makes economic sense to ship stuff half way across the planet. Plus people like the idea of locally produced stuff. Americans want US made cars and phones. Germans like their German cars. Etc. Yes, a lot of that manufacturing uses less people to produce vastly more goods. But that's just causing them to grow faster and employ more people. That's why there is a labor shortage instead of mass unemployment. Despite macro economic circumstances, a few years of lock down, etc. This stuff is just fueling economic growth. The whole economy is shifting to emphasize qualities such as being locally produced, sustainable, etc.