3 ms·
> This, combined with the 512b vectors that are the "-512" part, quadruples the amount of architectural FP/SIMD state, which is one of the main reasons we _don'
by bee_rider 3y ago
> This, combined with the 512b vectors that are the "-512" part, quadruples the amount of architectural FP/SIMD state, which is one of the main reasons we _don't_ get any AVX-512 in the "small" cores.
That’s an interesting point. Does anyone know—the Knights Landing Phi had AVX-512 and was based on Atom cores. Did they bolt on all these extra registers?
- moonchild 3y agoYes. Phi was a massive vector processor bolted onto a tiny scalar processor. This seems to have worked pretty well, for what it was. But it wouldn't be suitable for the applications where intel is using gracemont, because client workloads tend not to use avx512.
- Dylan16807 3y agoNote that quadrupling the architectural state doesn't mean quadrupling the actual state. In fact, it looks like Haswell and Skylake-X had the same number of physical registers, 168. So that's a straightforward doubling from 256x168 to 512x168. But further into the thread it looks like the first gen E cores had about 200 128-bit register lines, so trying to fit 512x32 would have been very tight. To put some of that a different way: The vector design headed for E cores was 128 bits stretching to 256 bits. If it had been 256 bits all the way through, it's likely they would have added AVX-512 support, even if they couldn't increase the size of the register file at all.
- namibj 3y agoThey actually separated architectural registers from physical ones, due to being SMT4. There's a chips and cheese article on this.
- detaro 3y agoAll variants of Phi were quite small/simple cores (I think the early ones were derivatives of early Pentium designs(!), just lots of them in more modern processes) with massive vector units strapped to the side. Which was fine for that purpose, since they really only were intended to feed the vector units and not expected to be any good at general-purpose computing tasks.