7 ms·
‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-tech manifesto lives on
- xg15 3y ago> After the terrorist’s death was announced, the entrepreneur Elon Musk tweeted that Kaczynski “might not be wrong” in his diagnosis that technology had been a disaster for humanity, one of a list of Silicon Valley figures who have praised the clarity of the bomber’s reasoning (while condemning his violent acts). I play both sides, so I always come out on top!
- Melting_Harps 3y ago> I play both sides, so I always come out on top! How anyone thinks this guy has the time to be chief engineer at SpaceX when all he does is shitpost on twitter all day is the real grift. I'm a big proponent of Musk corps, solely because of the team within them and entirely despite of Elon (though he did serve a purpose); but the former channer in me also likes seeing how sage level trolling has not only made him immensely wealthy but also functions as a sort of psyop to gauge to how effective social media really is/remains in the collective psyche. It's like the more advanced version of, 'stick your smartphone in the microwave for full charge' kind of thing: perverse and diabolical in a way but also necessary to put a finger on the pulse of the collective IQ of the modern internet sort of thing.
- ahartmetz 3y agoBetter than some "we just want to make the world a better place" true believer.
- leobg 3y agoDude. Read the tweet in context [1]. He was responding to this headline: “The Industrial Revolution and its consequences have been a disaster for the human race." Most likely, he was thinking of the dangers of AI (hence “might” - because we still don’t know). [1] https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1667627403089268739?s=46&t=ghYP4pErsBkf1PjNJzkt7w https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1667627403089268739?s=46...
- xg15 3y agoIf that's the case, it's still hypocritical - he was one of the early investors in OpenAI: https://www.businessinsider.com/elon-musk-openai-reason-exists-artificial-intelligence-ai-microsoft-2023-5?op=1 https://www.businessinsider.com/elon-musk-openai-reason-exis...
- leobg 3y agoYou haven’t followed the story at all, have you? He founded OpenAI to prevent an outcome where AGI is developed closed source by a single corporation - which he thought would likely be Google. Elon founding OpenAI actually led to him falling out with Larry Page, who used to be a good friend of Elon (but who didn’t share these concerns about AI). It is ironic that it’s now OpenAI that partnered with Microsoft and runs GPT-3/4/x on a closed source basis. This is the opposite of what Elon wanted to achieve, and what he had in mind when he named the venture “OpenAI”. Elon (who left OpenAI in 2018) has criticized OpenAI for this many times over the last months. He says OpenAI has taken donations as a non profit and then turned around and made themselves into a closed source for-profit.
- speak_plainly 3y agoI never found his argument convincing. The main tension in his manifesto is motivated by an underlying assumption that isn’t accurate. He sees technology as being a distinct force in opposition to humanity rather than an extension of humanity and that is the source of his fears. There are a lot of reasons to believe that technology is not an opposing force, like the idea of embedded cognition and embedded action. I think technology is better understand as something connected to human intention and we can evaluate technology by how well it maps on to our unique quirks and needs. So for example when you look at a bee hive do you see it as a diabolical prison made by bees for bees or a complicated construction connected to a set of intentions that fulfill the needs of bees?
- aero-deck 3y agoTech can start out as an extension, but what people fail to understand is that it can become slowly become autonomous over time, kinda like how a party gets out of control and people start putting holes in walls. I think technologists rarely, if ever, talk about this because a lot of what enables our blind pursuit of technology is to say that technology must be an extension of humans and so it can never become autonomous. When ppl talk about AGI and paperclip maximizers, I think it's a way of pushing the problem far into the horizon and ignoring that the boundary is fluid and pushing. Imagine if all the people at Google and Facebook stopped thinking that they're making the world a better place?
- aeternum 3y agoI think you really nailed the ultimately question: Can technology have agency? If not, then it's just another tool for humans. We are excellent tool users, and leverage everything we can to expand our senses and abilities. We already successfully wield tools of unimaginable power. If technology itself can have agency, then it truly is a paradigm shift for the millennia. There has never been an entity that is better at tool-use than us humans. All bets are off.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoI think this is all a red herring. At least until we crack GAI, at which point paperclip maximizers and other lethal agents of pure technology come knocking. Point being: technology, so far, has never been autonomous. But technology also doesn't grow on trees, nor does it stick out from the ground like a valuable rock. Technology is actively invented, and requires costly reproduction and maintenance. It only sticks around if enough people deem it worthy to have enough resources allocated to birth and propagate some piece of technology. In other words: there is always someone commissioning the technology. Someone with use for it. When considering the gains and ills of progress, it is IMO wrong to focus on technology itself. Especially when talking ills, it's a good way for the actual cause of suffering to remain hidden. Every technology that ever harmed anyone was commissioned and deployed by somebody. Perhaps commissioned with ill intent from the start, or perhaps only repurposed for evil. But it's not technology that does the damage, but people - and these days, organizations, which is both government branches and businesses. Going back to agency and autonomy - technology doesn't have agency, but people do, and importantly, large organizations seem to have separate agency of their own. Sans of GAI, no tech will turn on all humans on its own - but a corporation might, and corporations wield the most powerful of technologies.
- LatteLazy 3y agoI feel very sympathetic to his complaints about society. But he offers no solutions that would not embarrass a 4 year old. He wanted people, all people everywhere to give up tech. And he never bothered to address either of the obvious issues with this: (a) that whoever didn't would have a huge military advantage over those that did and would soon be in charge and (b) that we can only stay alive in the numbers we currently have because of modern agriculture so we'd need to starve a lot of people to death. It's sad that he could so well summarise the problem AND offer no, even remotely workable, solution.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- HPsquared 3y agoA bit like Marx in that regard.
- ahartmetz 3y agoOr anarchists or whatever other ideology you have. Great problem descriptions, unworkable solutions. So far, no one has created a well working social order from first principles.
- secstate 3y ago... and is unlikely to ever create one, either. First principles assume ability to understand. I'm not sure humans understand (or have the ability to understand in the future) emerging behavior in groups of humans. And the hubris to believe we can often results in violence because it's one of the simpler AND effective ways to make someone do what you think they should do.
- red-iron-pine 3y agoI would have said Libertarians
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- euix 3y agoGetting a faculty job at 25 is extremely impressive, the mistake he made was using violence to spread his message - in his manifesto he even states that he uses it to make sure message heard - but if he had just held on, resisted the urge and played the long game he could have had a much bigger voice in the world - even if he never became an academic, outside of the system as a pundit, youtuber, hacker, etc. The world was gotten more technologically authoritarian but the tools and means to live outside or even in opposition to it also has vastly increased. The point being, if you want to fight and be a rebel, it's better to do it from a position of liberty..
- WeylandYutani 3y agoHe lacked any normal social skills. If you work in the tech industry it's easy to forget how important those are to influence anyone who doesn't spend all their lives in front of a screen.
- x3874 3y agoTruer words couldn't have been said. Life isn't just using some API and then automatically get something done or delivered.
- adamrezich 3y ago> but if he had just held on, resisted the urge and played the long game I don't think everyone having wireless devices that connect to a global information network in their pockets at all times is something one could've really foreseen in 1978. and, even so, it's not as though it's really feasible to make any sort of shock-to-the-system sentiment widely and broadly heard, today, while abstaining from violence—even our modern societies are still trying to grapple with the question of, how much violence and destruction is justified in order to make a point about something, as seen in the last few years. had Kaczynski chosen peaceful decades-later contemporary Internet discourse as his means of promoting his ideas, he'd simply be tarred and feathered as an "alt-right" nutjob, just like everyone else with views that contradict the present Western civilization status quo. The System has gotten extremely efficient in perpetuating itself, and silencing anything resembling Actual Dissent.
- terryliveson 3y agoI would need to read his second book and is elucidated on his thoughts more, but I think a theme that he made without trying was on centralized technologies. It has been a bit, but there was a part regarding power plants where he points out the centralized nature of it. Further, technology is good and an extension of ourselves, but when we go from a nice tool to have to mandatory, I think we should be cautious.
- djyaz1200 3y agoKaczynski was a loser. He couldn't manage to turn a Harvard degree into a productive role in society so he waged a cowardly war on people who did nothing to harm him. The detailed list of specific injuries to victims here is sad... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ted_Kaczynski https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ted_Kaczynski
- ok123456 3y agoHe did less damage than a Harvard grad who went on to run a hedge fund, or went on to work in private equity, or work for McKinsey, or become a lobbyist. Where's the detailed list of victims of globalization and finance?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- infamouscow 3y agoOr invading another country and killing somewhere on the order of 100K-1M innocent civilians. If we're going to make a rank order list of genocidal maniacs, Ted Kaczynski isn't anywhere near the top.
- wellthisisgreat 3y agothat's some rich whataboutism
- ok123456 3y agoIt's not "whataboutism." It's proportionality and universality.
- infamouscow 3y agoWhataboutism is slang for not having a coherent argument.
- anm89 3y agoYou can always tell weak thinkers when they need to throw out pre-labeled idea placeholders instead of making their point
- Minor49er 3y agoThe manifesto itself isn't dangerous, but the way that Kaczynski drove attention towards it certainly was
- drewcoo 3y agoTechnically he got it published buy promising to stop bombing. He drew attention to it by stopping terrorism. Not trying to excuse anything. Just sayin'.
- renewiltord 3y agoThe quest for novelty finds itself in the "but what if the bad guy were right" thing very often. I can tell you that I enjoy stories where I'm the bad guy - either accidentally or through some discovery of harm (video games do this in a fun way). But in the end, it's just fantasy. This guy couldn't separate real life from a poor model of the world. In the end, intelligence is a composite measure and he lacked it in sufficient form. Pity.
- nier 3y agoMost of the article seems to be based on an interview with a certain Sean Fleming. He’s a research fellow at the University of Nottingham, who is writing the first book-length study of the Unabomber’s ideology. From the article: «If Kaczynski did raise valid points, Fleming says, it is because he took them from others, including the French sociologist Jacques Ellul, whose 1954 text, The Technological Society, electrified the bomber as a young man.»
- joshuaheard 3y agoI watched a TV show about the Unabomber a while back that was really good. I remember one of the detectives investigating him became sympathetic after reading his manifesto. I don't think the Unabomber was as much anti-tech as he was against tech controlling our lives. A valid concern in the AI era. I'll never forget the one scene where the detective was driving an empty road late at night and came up to a red light at an intersection where there was no other cars in sight. We have all had this experience. You can see that the detective was slowly realizing the Unabomber's point as he waited a long time for the piece of technology, that had complete control over him at that moment, to allow him to proceed.
- ms512 3y agoThe referenced TV show is likely the first season of Manhunt [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manhunt_(2017_TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manhunt_(2017_TV_series)
- atestu 3y agoManhunt: Unabomber https://reelgood.com/show/manhunt-unabomber-2017 https://reelgood.com/show/manhunt-unabomber-2017 I loved it too. It used to be on Netflix but they took it down.
- recursivedoubts 3y agotwo things can be true at the same time: - his ideas were interesting & worthy of consideration - his actions were deplorable
- calf 3y agoI'm a Marxian leftist, but the one time I tried reading his essay I found it incomprehensible, ramblings of an ill person. It could've been about any topic, the style was redundant overconfident rambling. So, I never cared for the overanalysis of this, the media obsession and spectacle is pretending he had anything comprehensible to say at all. I.e., his ideas resonate for people who have not actually read leftist writing. Or maybe they resonate for accelerationists, tankies, and the like.
- awaythrow483 3y ago[flagged]
- dang 3y agoWe've banned this account for repeatedly breaking the site guidelines. In this case you did it with ideological flamewar, but there were plenty of other cases of unsubstantive/flamebait comments, including personal attacks, so no we're not Marxians. Please don't create accounts to break HN's rules with. It will eventually get your main account banned as well. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- waboremo 3y agoCouldn't agree more. Which makes sense, he only experienced life through books in near total isolation. You can't really provide anything of value about life or society that way, you're just stuck in your own mental projection of the world.
- GloomyBoots 3y agoI’m not in the “he was right” camp but I don’t see how you can call it incomprehensible. It’s certainly not well-written, but it lacks the opaque prose that leftists especially are so fond of, and is easy enough to follow.
- motohagiography 3y agoThis article is just agit prop trying to use the news peg of Kaczynsci's death to associate his ideas with The Guardian's political opponents like Musk and Carlson, to make them seem "dangerous," and justify some response to this new fictional danger. I'd insult the author and editors but kicking down at journalists only reinforces the spite that drives them to produce things like this. The conceit of Kaczynsci and other rebels is that they think forming sound criticisms absolves them from the responsibility to prevail. If you want to change the world, maybe try making something it wants. If you are frustrated because nobody wants to listen to you, maybe index on solving that problem instead of forcing people to listen to you with bizarre political acts and attacking prominent individuals so as to capture some of the reflected attention for your tedious opinions. While that advice is for journalists, it's perhaps also applicable to would-be immitators of Kaczynski as well.
- neilv 3y ago1. Person X wants attention to their manifesto. 2. Person X becomes a terrorist for that purpose. 3. People say "Y'know, because of all those terrible things X did, I took a look at their manifesto, and they have some interesting ideas." 4. Person Y sees this, and repeat. Suggestion: When people actually care about ideas, there are plenty of thinkers they could read and talk about, without encouraging future terrorists.
- RobotToaster 3y ago[flagged]
- awaythrow483 3y agoThe movie fight club is a direct editorialized adaption of the Manifesto
- mcint 3y agoPoints I would raise, from the article: If Kaczynski did raise valid points, he says, it is because he took them from others, including the French sociologist Jacques Ellul, whose 1954 text, The Technological Society, electrified the bomber as a young man. “Few of his arguments are actually original,” Fleming says. “He borrowed most of his ideas from fairly mainstream academic authors who would never have condoned his violence. And separation of ideas from the violence, counter to the premise of the article, which it mentions only once, late, in passing: “I don’t think we should read Kaczynski as a theorist or philosopher, and try to separate his ideas from his violence,” he says. “He’s a self-described terrorist, and revolutionary, and this is how I read him.” Well summarized elsewhere. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16850733 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16850733
- norir 3y agoKaczynski needs to be understood as much as a brilliant propagandist as a philosopher. Dismissing him as a philosopher because he drew his ideas from others misses the point. Regardless of what one thinks of the man, his ideas and actions (and I strongly disagree with many of his ideas and all of his violent actions), he has clearly been more influential than Ellul in the US by a wide margin.
- NoRelToEmber 3y agoI would urge everyone to read the manifesto directly, and not The Guardian's selective summary, that gives no hints the manifesto has chapters such as "The Psychology of Modern Leftism". https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/library/national/unabom-manifesto-1.html https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/library/national...
- red-iron-pine 3y ago[flagged]
- awaythrow483 3y agoIf you haven't read the manifesto, do yourself a favor and read it and come to your own conclusions. In my opinion it's a weird mix of extremely coherent and well reasoned points that come to a sort of nonsensensical conclusion but that doesn't deter from how good the good parts are and they are definitely worth reading If you strip out the call for revolution stuff which is very poorly argued anyway and I think just transparently will never happen, the remaining 80% of the manifesto is very well written
- red-iron-pine 3y agoWe had to read this in college, in a lit course on "dangerous discussions". Marx, Mein Kampf, SNCC manifestos, The Turner Diaries, chunks of the Koran and the Bible, a short look at Juche, some Ding Xiaoping Thought, etc. And among others, the Unibomber Manifesto. The professor had printouts that he gave to us so that we didn't have to search for it. True for a lot of the documents, actually. It felt uncomfortably prescient then, and more so now. He makes a lot of good points but doesn't tie them together well, IMO, and his conclusion is kind of weak. Still, his points sting when you look at how we're sliding to a cyberpunk future that we can all see coming but won't make changes to prevent.