5 ms·
I doubt they're anti-diversity, but bringing up this topic in context of RMS and FSF is a bit rich, given the high-profile character assassination attempt direc
by TeMPOraL 3y ago
I doubt they're anti-diversity, but bringing up this topic in context of RMS and FSF is a bit rich, given the high-profile character assassination attempt directed at RMS, in not so distant past. Free software ecosystem hasn't fully recovered from that yet.
- sneak 3y agoThe attacks on rms have been wholly based on what he actually said, not character assassination. rms seems to forget that people will read not the words you write, but what they interpret you to be driving at based on the words you write. They took this to mean he was defending pedophilia (when in fact he wrote no such thing, being both neurodivergent and precise). This is rms' fault for being bad at PR whilst being a public figure and leader.
- bombolo 3y agoHe said epstin is a serial rapist, but that wasn't really emphasized.
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> The attacks on rms have been wholly based on what he actually said, not character assassination. They weren't. The things he actually said played a minor role in that kerfuffle - it all started with a lot of smears thrown at RMS by a person with some grudge. Additional quotes came later, as people started fishing for them. > rms seems to forget that people will read not the words you write, but what they interpret you to be driving at based on the words you write. They took this to mean he was defending pedophilia (when in fact he wrote no such thing, being both neurodivergent and precise). Why exactly are you defending people being irrational or engaging in power plays? You note yourself what the facts were, so why justify mistaking them? > This is rms' fault for being bad at PR whilst being a public figure and leader. RMS was doing fine until someone decided to destroy him for personal gain. Do you expect every person doing something interesting in a niche community should behave like a Hollywood celebrity or a politician, having their communications managed by teams of spindoctors, on the off chance someone wants to destroy them and picks mass media as their weapon of choice?
- sneak 3y ago> RMS was doing fine until someone decided to destroy him for personal gain. He was not destroyed, literally or figuratively. If that is the basis of your claim, then everything else based upon that has no supporting evidence. Who do you assert yielded personal gain, and how? I saw nothing of the sort.
- RobotToaster 3y agoIt's interesting how people will claim to be pro diversity, then say it's someone's fault for communicating in an autistic way.
- cassianoleal 3y agoDiversity, but only the kind I'm comfortable with.
- sneak 3y agohttps://xkcd.com/1984/ https://xkcd.com/1984/ He's bad at communicating. It may be because he's autistic, but ultimately that part is not relevant. The way humans in bulk receive public communications is a fact of nature; it would be like someone swimming in the ocean and drowning and saying that it was bad that the ocean couldn't accept their style of swimming. He's a public figure and certain actions undertaken by public figures when communicating with millions of people are bad. He undertook those actions and suffered the negative consequences. It's ultimately not related to his neurodivergence; there are autistic people who don't make huge PR blunders.
- fullspectrumdev 3y ago> high-profile character assassination attempt people pointing out that what the man said and did was fucked is somehow a character assassination attempt? Literally none of the factual claims of “RMS said X” have been false, it’s pretty much all been on the record.
- mandmandam 3y agoVice put out one of the most blatantly false and disgusting smear jobs in recent history [0]. You're defending the indefensible - why? 0 - https://stallmansupport.org/debunking-false-accusations-against-richard-stallman.html https://stallmansupport.org/debunking-false-accusations-agai... (with links to primary sources throughout).
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> Literally none of the factual claims of “RMS said X” have been false, it’s pretty much all been on the record. On the contrary, literally every single claim about what RMS said or did was fabricated, or pulled out of context so badly you could still see the severed threads trailing behind. The original posts and subsequent press articles were one big patchwork of lies and manipulative statements; this was all trivial to verify and apparent to anyone except those who, for some reason, really wanted to believe it's true.
- Arnt 3y agoLiterally every single claim. That includes https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26708993 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26708993 then, so go on, tell all about how that was fabricated or pulled out of context.
- ryandrake 3y agoAnd even if it wasn't fabricated, it's still character assassination. Look, if you take any public figure, and spend enough time looking through all the things they ever written or said in their lives, you can probably find some terrible thing to paint them as a terrible person. Someone could be a role model, have a lifetime of charitable work and positive achievements, bbbbbbut years ago they once said they didn't like gay people (or whatever), all of a sudden none of their achievements matter and they're actually monsters! Any of us with a long posting history on the Internet probably at one time said something that wasn't nice. Cherry picking that one thing and holding it up as the summation of who we are, is character assassination.
- pyrale 3y ago> Free software ecosystem hasn't fully recovered from that yet. That's what happens when you put all your eggs into one basket, and then realize that basket had a hole. Maybe free software would be better off if the FSF had spent time building a resilient movement rather than a church to RMS.