7 ms·
Political Polarization Comes for Marriage Prospects
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agohttps://archive.is/7XwMP https://archive.is/7XwMP
- more_corn 3y agoI don’t see a problem with this. That’s are about a dozen things people need to align on if they’re going to get married. Politics seems sort of critical.
- dcsommer 3y agoAlignment is of course still critical for marriage. The increasing difficulty or low probability of alignment is the problem.
- wilg 3y agoOnly a problem if you are trying to maximize marriages, which does not seem like a good metric to maximize.
- dcsommer 3y agoThe same trend applies to all forms of close relationship. So no, it is a problem if you want to maximize any form of social cohesion.
- wilg 3y ago> The same trend applies to all forms of close relationship. Does it?
- HDThoreaun 3y agoThe rise of single parent households does seem like a legitimate issue to me. If the non marrieds aren't having kids fine, but if they end up having kids and then hating each other thats not.
- wjholden 3y agoI agree, seems like a really fundamental conflict you'd want to pre-solve before having children.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoI think the percentage of Americans who are politically ingrained is larger than at any time in memory, perhaps since reconstruction. It's made us more susceptible to a mindset of being under threat. And while politicians have long been addicted to pushing a threat mindset on the population - I can't personally recall a time where a primary goal was to turn citizens against each other.
- partitioned 3y agoThe early 1900s and the push to give black Americans more rights is a good parallel to current times. The demonization of the “negro” and the “negro”lover. This was a time of a lot of political pushback in the south against white people starting to side with blacks. There’s lots of fun old timey propaganda posters equating black people with the devil.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoI do a fair amount of genealogy and I keep finding parallels between today and early 20th century. Housing is one. I think we're transitioning to a period that necessitates birth families living together longer - except that we lack the housing for it.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoMmm, maybe George Washington was right and a two party system was a bad idea?
- notfromhere 3y agoThe founders were wrong about a lot of things, they also failed to account for the fact that political parties were naturally going to emerge. Constitution as a frame for government worked well if you just want a land owning elite to run things, it works pretty poorly when you want to have a functioning democratic republic. It doesn't account for political parties, the checks and balances are weak and mainly depend on a gentleman's agreement, and a federal legislature that's biased towards land-based apportionment also functions poorly. Political polarization in the US is more potent than elsewhere because our voting system ensures that there are only two parties and that purists take over said parties. A parliamentary system that's reflective of the actual popular vote would be much more functional and responsive to what people actually want out of their government. GOP had a bunch of extremists take over and how they run half of the political system and look to Orban and Fidesz as a model of how to slowly smother democracy in its sleep.
- partitioned 3y agoA logical consequence of the increasing divide between the political tribes. As the opinions diverge the room for compromise gets smaller.
- rsynnott 3y agoWell, I think it’s more that the divide in the US (and some other places, but not everywhere) has become so much about _rights_. It’s very personal. I could (and have) relate to someone who has quite different views on _economic_ issues, but someone who wants to ban people from marrying or to ban abortion or what have you, yeah, not so much. In Ireland we have significant political divide, across multiple parties, but it’s largely not about rights on a party level. No party with elected representatives is campaigning on banning abortion or restricting LGBT rights or similar. And conversely when the abortion and equal marriage legalisation referendums were held, they had all-party support. Many _individuals_, of course, will have views that people might find abhorrent, but it’s less a case of “they vote for X so they must be a bad person”. EDIT: To be clear, there are _problems_ with this consensus-forming approach, where social progress kind of has to wait until everyone gets in line; in Ireland the abortion legalisation referendum passed by 67%, which would imply that it could have been held long before and since passed, of instance. I don't think it would work for the US case anyway; the US has a party actively trying to remove _existing_ rights, which is a very different sort of thing.
- lapcat 3y agoRelated: The Never Married, a New Normal https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36103297 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36103297 (21 days ago, 439 comments)
- AlexandrB 3y agoIt's funny, there's a small contingent of people who want to eliminate things like "no fault divorce". Ostensibly because they value the institution of marriage so much. It seems extremely counterproductive because if they get their way I suspect the number of people getting married will drop even more.
- leodler 3y agoThe proportion of them both previously and currently being left by their wife says all you need to know about their motivations and how serious they are as human beings.
- csomar 3y agoLet's create modern day slavery by forcing you for life into a relationship... These people know what they want. > I suspect the number of people getting married will drop even more. Marriage used to happen when you were 20. You don't think it through at that age. These same people want you to do just that: Do a decision at 20 and stick for it for the rest of your life regardless of anything else. But, in my opinion, they are correct this will improve the number of married people (you only need to do it once).
- erehweb 3y agoThe article points out that there are a lot of "surplus" liberal women and conservative men, but I'm not sure what the author wants to happen. Should people be settling for subpar marriages with a spouse who doesn't share their core beliefs? Author quotes research saying these are less happy on average.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoMy wife and I worked it out for 25 years. We had disagreements but it wasn't necessary to adopt the other's position. However, the recent political trends that directly seek to turn everyone against each other - I think it poisons accommodations like we had.
- heavenlyblue 3y agoWas she conaervative and you liberal?
- true_religion 3y agoNot the original poster, but I’ve been married 13 years. My spouse is liberal, and I was originally conservative. I feel like back in the day, the political spectrum was more narrow and although there were disagreements it was more on how to apply the law, not on if a law should exist at all. Roe v Wade for example is from 1973. This law was established in my childhood, and as a nominal conservative I support it. Removing it is a radical change, leading to an alien landscape where people are fleeing newly antiabortion states and refusing job offers on the basis of what laws they have to live under. Life, death, and medical care are too fundamental to be left to the states. If you do, then do you really have a strongly knit country? I’ve digressed a bit, but I think the stakes have changed so people on both sides of the spectrum share little common ground.
- rsynnott 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rsynnott 3y ago> This is a sizable decline in just four years, albeit the two results cannot be directly compared. Hersh and Ghitza’s finding was based on a database of voter registration records. They focused on voters in 30 states and did not have direct data to define married couples. In contrast, the American Family Survey was based on a national sample of 3,000 American adults, and I looked at married adults and compared respondents’ party identification with their spouses’. (From their main source article on the claim that marriages across party lines are falling.) One of the more irritating habits of the media is to present two studies whose methods make any comparison, especially with a rather small change in numbers, fraught, explicitly acknowledge this problem, _and then proceed to compare them anyway_.
- ucm_edge 3y agoCouple questions on the data here. The graphs are showing people who are distinctly a political position. But first how distinct is distinct? Are we taking extreme activist or just pretty committed? Second how much of the potential mate pool remains closer to political center. Seems like 30 to 35% potentially given the graph. Because if distinct is not that extreme and you have a decently sized center pool, then your say slightly left of center males can marry the distinctly left females and have reasonable overlap on value. At least to the point political views are not a negative and shared values in other areas can be the foundation of the relationship. The lack of a centrist pool or unwillingness of the distinct individuals to shop for mates in that pool would signal a problem, but I don’t see the article build a case for either condition.
- lapcat 3y agoA big issue is that sexual politics have become partisan. There used to be pro-life Democrats and pro-choice Republicans, but those are practically extinct now, and support for birth control seems to depend on your political party. Since the 1980s or so there's been a kind of religious revival where certain Christian groups have asserted themselves politically and come to dominate the Republican party, bringing their personal conservative social values into politics and even lawmaking, especially with regard to the appropriateness of sexual behavior and the role of women in society and the economy. Naturally, many (though not all) women find this push for a return to tradition to be abhorrent; they don't want to go back to the past. It's not just a theoretical, academic political disagreement. These issues are personal, they strike home.
- pessimizer 3y agoThe contemporary Democratic party version of liberalism has introduced a new, very intense sexual orthodoxy, and the deep desire to encode it into law, by violence if necessary. Religious conservatives and liberal centrists are having a sex war. It's not one-sided.
- lapcat 3y ago> encode it into law, by violence if necessary I'm afraid to ask, but what does this mean exactly? I would note that the Democratic party has consistently neglected to encode abortion rights into law when it had full control of the legislative branches of the federal government at the beginning of the Biden, Obama, and Clinton administrations.
- lumb63 3y agoNot GP so I can’t comment on what they’re referring to. The point you make is one I’ve thought about over the last year and I’m curious to hear other theories and thoughts on why Democratic legislatures haven’t passed any federal-level abortion legislation. My inclination is to believe that some Democratic strategist(s) predicted that their party would get more votes by campaigning on “they’re taking away your rights” rather than “we’re guaranteeing your rights”.
- bbatha 3y agoThe truth is because of the history OP points to Democrats have likely never had the votes for federal abortion legislation. Nor did they need it because it was a constitutional right. The last true democratic trifecta was in the army Obama years where there were still plenty of “blue dog” and pro-life democrats. There were many more democrats like Biden who were personally pro life, due to his catholic background, but content with it as a constitutional right. The Hyde amendment which prohibits Medicare funds for abortions is ample evidence of this artifact of older political lines. This leaves the 2020-22 congress to shore up abortion rights. However those congresses had the narrowest of majorities and much larger fish to fry (pandemic recovery and inflation, etc etc). It’s only been a strong and unifying rallying by cry for the party since the post roe era and even that wasn’t obvious until after the 2022 mid terms.
- prirun 3y agoPeople are becoming more extreme, both left and right, to the point that I think an extreme and middle would have a hard time being a couple, let alone opposite extremes. I know a couple where the guy is extreme right and the wife is middle. The wife had to prohibit all discussion of politics, in private or with company, because they usually got out of control. This is also a problem between generations. I know a lady, leaning right but not what I'd call extreme, who no longer is speaking to her daughter who is extreme left. It's crazy to me that politics is being given this much power in some people's lives. Here's a clue to everyone: politicians don't care about us, at all! They only want to keep us divided and fighting amongst ourselves so we don't unite and fight against them.
- atoav 3y agoThe US has no real left. Your "left" is basically: - Biology of sex is complicated (true), Sociology of gender is complicated (also true), therefore we should give people some slack here and protect them of bigots want to punish them for something they have been born into. - Sexuality is complex and consenting adults should be allowed to do what they want - Sexuality is complex and people should be able to marry other people regaedless of sex and gender Given the fact that these are all well researched topics I am not sure how a liberal position like that could be considered extreme. Extreme would be something like demanding that gay people are ahot on the streets or that kids genitalia are checked at school.
- GloomyBoots 3y agoThe US has no left in the same sense that it has no right. It’s just different tribes of liberals arguing over which is more fascist.
- atoav 3y agoDo me a favour and list the policy promises of each side (be it implicit or explicit ones) and then we check what political ideology they stem from. Example: Banning books or drag shows, for others because you don't like them is not what I would call "liberal". But hey, in certain political circles words have lost all connection to their meaning, so knock yourself out. As a European I don't like the Democrats either, but pretending both sides are the same is a spwcial kind of mental gymnastics.
- MrDunham 3y ago> the rising difficulty many young people have finding a partner who meets all of their requirements—emotional, physical, financial, and political Admittedly, I do many things wrong. But this is one I've done well and could be helpful for those struggling with the above ("meets ALL of their criteria") My wife and I are far apart politically... and our marriage is something I (and I think, we) cherish. When dating I struggled with finding someone who met ALL my criteria. In the course of it someone taught me to sit down and select your three (and ONLY three) "must-have" criteria. All other things are then negotiable. For me, I wanted someone who was smart, who shared my religious beliefs, and who was supportive of my entrepreneurial plans/journey. (Side note, I cheated and said I also wanted to be physically attracted to them.) Fast forward to me meeting my wife. There are a good deal of things we disagree on — politics being towards the top. Had I let that get in the way and looked for a laundry list of must-haves I would never have married her, would never have had our two incredible children , and might possibly either still be looking or have given up on my criteria and settled. This trick (pick 3 "non negotiables", let the rest be negotiable) served me extremely well in finding a dog after meeting ~100 (before having criteria), in my wedding (open bar, all my friends can come, no shoehorning of food by the venue), and a few other cases. I can only speculate on why it works so well. It likely works because it forced me to really list what was crucial and to be more flexible on things I'd otherwise list as crucial. Either way, if this helps one person to simplify, focus, and be flexible enough to find a mate theme it was worth it. Hope it helps you. And happy Father's Day to all you other fathers out there.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoI'd say the issue is that most people have "generally treats other people with respect" as one of their non negotiable traits. High information society combined with extreme siloization has brought us to a point where a significant portion of society believes that those who vote for the other party do not generally treat others with respect. It's an extremely difficult thing to look past in a partner. It comes down to the most basic understanding of what respect is and unfortunately I do not think it's a trick, Trump voters generally do not treat minorities with the respect that democrats deeply believe they deserve. Dem voters generally do not treat trump supporters with the respect trump supporters deeply believe they deserve. I don't see any solution.
- lumb63 3y agoI wonder what areas this impacts most. Since the dating market is highly local (most people don’t consider “the whole nation” their dating pool), areas with more ideological divide are more likely to be impacted, but the authors don’t seem to look at this very much. For example, if the female ideological shift left is occurring mostly in blue states, it may matter most to blue states; if it is homogenous across the board, a different conclusion is to be drawn.
- Kye 3y agoThere's no such thing as a blue state or a red state. Supporters of both parties are about evenly distributed through the country. Most states are marginally one way or the other. The stark differences happen at county and municipal levels.
- minerva23 3y agoFor men, "political disagreement" means arguments at home. For women, "political disagreement" means risking their lives.