8 ms·
BlackCat claims they hacked Reddit and will leak the data
- skilled 3y agoThe crazy thing is that this data probably doesn't have all that much value beyond emails/passwords, which are probably decently hashed anyway. Reddit might collect data, but it doesn't enforce an algorithm. And I think mod tools (the automated ones) are also third-party only? --- EDIT: I forgot that Reddit has private messaging and chat, so maybe that does have some value.
- sschueller 3y agoInternal communication between CEO etc. would probably be more interesting.
- ta1243 3y agoEspecially anything from his old days of modding jailbait
- NullPrefix 3y agomodding jailbait?
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoThere was a literal subreddit. I think that he was added as a prank by the head mod but some are using it as an example of his immorality.
- plagiarist 3y agoYeah the mod thing is baseless. However I do think letting pedophiles hang out on your website doing pedophile stuff without taking an action about it is maybe immoral. I also think allowing white supremacists or other bigots to hang out and spread bigotry is immoral.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoYeah, I'm not arguing he is moral, just that the one argument is bad but, as you've pointed out, there are certainly better.
- gambiting 3y agoReddit's CEO was a mod of a jailbait subreddit in the early days - the problem here is that it's impossible to prove whether he joined by himself or whether other mods have added him without his knowledge. As a mod you can add other users as mods and they don't need to agree to it.
- Semaphor 3y agoNot for a long time. I believe that it used to be possible (it actually is on Lemmy, though you need to have posted there first), but nowadays on reddit, it sends a mod request.
- veave 3y agoIt happened when it didn't ask for permission. He could've removed himself (and I suppose he eventually did) but I imagine that, as a joke, he was probably added as mod to thousands of subs, and couldn't be arsed to remove himself from all of them.
- dathos 3y agoHe could have removed himself, he’s not a random user but the CEO. I feel like that kinda removes the argument of ‘someone could have added him without his consent’.
- gambiting 3y agoThat implies he was even aware that it happened, and again, we have no way of knowing that. If someone makes you a mod all that used to happen was that you get a message in your inbox, and he must receive thousands of messages all the time as he's being tagged in things non stop. Also he was literally a mod on thousands of subreddits, unlikely he added himself to all of them, or that he even reviewed the list.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- s9w 3y ago[dead]
- skilled 3y agoAh, you're right. Reddit does have private messaging, forgot about it.
- raverbashing 3y agoIf that is part of the data, of course Not sure how much the internal messaging system is used on Reddit (personally never used the chat, DMS are very rare)
- paxys 3y agoInternal communication between employees doesn't happen on Reddit chat.
- _8j50 3y agoPrivate messages, especially involving admins and mods would be interesting but I'd imagine a lot of people, including famous personalities might have said sensitive stuff in private messages.
- veave 3y agoA list of user names -> emails is extremely juicy.
- ImaCake 3y agoI'm pretty sure they do have an algorithm. Not sure how fancy it is, but my feed would prioritise subreddits i interacted with regardless of upvotes for a while. It was one of the things that made me slowly stop using the site beyond specific subreddits.
- goykasi 3y ago> doesn't have all that much value beyond emails/passwords I would bet that it has even lower value than that. They were only able to get 80gigs of data -- basically nothing compared to reddit's actual dataset. This means they probably didnt get anywhere close to any high value databases (or even low value). Also, the fact that they dont even describe what type of data they managed to get a hold of tells me its probably not that meaningful. Reddit should definitely not be paying these extortionists regardless of what was swiped.
- ninjinxo 3y agoIf I were the hacker, I'd edit maxwellhill to have email address ghislainemaxwell@gmail.com just for the shitstorm it'd create, context: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29838084 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29838084 Aside from that, email addresses to usernames might be valuable - you could identify high-value targets from finance, crypto, or luxury item subs. Or you could just make lists of people who post on specific subs for targeted harrassment.
- monero-xmr 3y agoWhat brave extortionists - $4.5 million for themselves and also the api changes. Like a modern day Robin Hood, their honor is unassailable.
- Semaphor 3y agoWell, there was a limited time offer for just the 4.5 million! What a steal that would have been!
- _8j50 3y agoThe common thing they say these days is that they "helped" you find a vulnerability by breaking in and that's their pentest fee.
- Aaargh20318 3y agoThey didn't steal the data, it was a surprise off-site backup.
- ransomwarebtxh 3y ago[flagged]
- chii 3y agoI mean, if you're gonna extort somebody, you might as well force them to do some good as well.
- lr4444lr 3y agoDon't you think they perhaps just considered that making a pro forma altruistic sounding demand on top of the venal one would put public pressure on their target to comply and make themselves merely look like Robin Hood?
- ImaCake 3y agoYes, that's pretty much the point of the demand for rollback of the API changes. Its pretty transparent that they want the money, but they clearly have thought of your line too.
- spacephysics 3y agoGiven what’s been found with Twitters censorship and governmental collusion, curious if the data they have is in the same vein and how people will react to it - if what they say is true
- RandomLensman 3y agoLooks to me most people didn't care about any of that in relation to Twitter.
- logicchains 3y ago[flagged]
- RandomLensman 3y agoI would have guessed not more than 10% of the population care either way - but happy to be proven wrong.
- threeseed 3y ago> Twitters censorship and governmental collusion Also known as complying with local laws. It's always amusing when Americans realise that most of the world doesn't ascribe to their views on free speech. And in fact governments with broad support from their citizens want social media companies to be regulated.
- tyingq 3y ago>Also known as complying with local laws That's one form of "censorship and governmental collusion". There are others. Parts of government collude with companies outside of actual law too.
- yonaguska 3y agoSuppressing news stories and users at the behest of the FBI has nothing to do with complying with local laws. Let's not forget that Twitter was actively becoming a host for child porn at the same time, and not addressing that issue simultaneously.
- Ecstatify 3y agoThe mismanagement of Reddit is crazy. I wonder will they fire Huffman. His blatant lying is insane when people have emails to back up their claims against him. Seems like he’s on a media blitz to try and change the narrative. You know when you’re doing interviews with The Verge you’re in bother.
- themitigating 3y agoWhat did he lie about?
- ramraj07 3y agoMisrepresented and made up discussions with Apollo app creator. Then caught red handed when the creator released recordings of those calls.
- JshWright 3y agoThat's only the most recent incident... A few years back he was caught silently editing users posts that were critical of him.
- quitit 3y agoSteve Huffman, aka Spez, falsely claimed that Apollo creator (Christian Selig) had threatened and blackmailed Reddit for $10M. The facts are that no threat nor blackmail attempt was made and Spez had entirely invented and spread the false claims as an attempt to discredit Selig. In response to the false claims, Christian Selig released a recording of the phone call that disproved the claim and cleared his name. As Selig is in Canada, he was legally entitled to record and release the phone call. Huffman took umbrage at this action because it revealed Huffman's deceptive conduct. Later in a Reddit "AMA", Huffman continued stating falsehoods about interactions with Selig, in spite of the evidence. https://techcrunch.com/2023/06/09/reddit-ceo-doubles-down-on-attack-on-apollo-developer-in-drama-filled-ama/?guccounter=1 https://techcrunch.com/2023/06/09/reddit-ceo-doubles-down-on...
- 3y ago
- 99112000 3y agoTypical extortionist behavior. Their first attempt failed, so they just try and piggy back on this media hype wrt to api changes eve tho they dont give a damn, just to blow up this supposed breach and add fuel to the existing fire.
- lr4444lr 3y agoI don't know what's at stake, but I hope Reddit refuses to negotiate with these extortionists, which will only embolden future ones. If and when the criminals are found, may they be punished to the fullest extent of the law!
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoIt really depends to me - are they about to leak corporate or user data. If it's MY data that's about to be leaked because Reddit was hacked I'm not a fan of the the high principled moral high ground - they should (literally) pay for it because they failed to protect my data.
- paxys 3y agoSo basically – cybercrime and extortion is perfectly fine as long as it doesn't affect me. If it does, everyone must be held accountable.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 3y agoI think that is basically the human condition. That said, we are at a point, at least in US, where information about people has been released several times over. The sheer amount of free monitoring I have received over the past 2 years alone would likely last me at least through my lifetime and I am not sure I am exaggerating much. If that is the case: fuck it. Lets make it miserable for everyone until the pain is felt to an extent that necessitates changes.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoI didn't say the crime was fine. I don't think that in either scenario it shouldn't be investigated. Reddit failed to keep that information safe, and if it's an user's information they need to do what they can to keep it safe. They don't get to make the choice if it's someone else's information. If it's theirs, go hard, let it leak if they want.
- greggsy 3y ago
- sandworm101 3y agoI do not believe the claim. At the moment there is a war between reddit users and reddit managment. The managment is looking to IPO and so is trying to demonstrate its ability to wrench profits. The users are reacting through demonstrations of thier power to impact shareholder value. This hacking claim falls squarely into the later: it threatens shareholder value by introducing uncertainty. I will need to see solid evidence to be convinced.
- adaml_623 3y agoNo there is a war between Reddit management and a number of Reddit users. A certain proportion of users do not care about the API at all.
- Gualdrapo 3y agoThey won't care until the effects affect them.
- guraf 3y agoBarely anyone will be affected. Redditors are being used as pawns by the third party devs in their fight to maintain their free loading existence. Which was easy, social media is good at riling up people for made up reasons. Reddit has several hundred million users, and even more anonymous visitors. The two biggest third party apps have 1.5M users combined.
- _a9 3y agoI would bet on it being real. ALPHV/BlackCat is a known group. They hacked Western Digital back in March. https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/tag/blackcat/ https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/tag/blackcat/
- kramerger 3y agoI don't care about your stupid DMs. But I would very much want to see the IP addresses each account used last time, to identify people with many alt accounts
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bequanna 3y agoHash of the IP would be sufficient for that purpose and would keep location anonymous.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Seattle3503 3y agoIPv4 isn't that big. You could compute the hashes of all addresses on consumer hardware. You would want to add a private salt.
- zo1 3y agoIf you add a private salt, you won't be able to do "grouping" or identifying duplicates, which is what this thread was discussing. If it was me, and I wanted "independent" researchers to highlight clusters or duplicates I would do the following as a first-pass solution: Store an internal mapping of IP->unique sequential number, likewise do the same for usernames. The goal is that it's random and not based on any hash or ordering. So people with either the IP, username or username + IP, can't identify the unique internal numbers. Then release those. Though tbf, if I was part of any sort of "bot prevention" or "sock puppet identification" team at Reddit, I'd be doing this already. But we all know the dirty secret is to not actually track down such abuse, but to appear like you are doing so, so that you can inflate your user count with plausible deniability.
- kramerger 3y ago
- phneutral26 3y agoIf this turns out to be true it would be crazy. Reddit is hanging off the cliff, soon to be never seen again.
- nubinetwork 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36375544 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36375544
- seydor 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- csomar 3y ago> along with our money or we will leak it It's interesting that they think it's "their" money. Also, we have an interesting situation here: 1. Either the data is practically worthless - because reddit didn't bother with them; or 2. The data is critical and Reddit is truly mismanaged. Guess only time will clear this one out. Wait and see.
- 100721 3y agoI think there's some wiggle room between "worthless" and "critical"...
- rchaud 3y agoNot to defend Reddit (there's no way I'm using that godforsaken official app), but: who cares? There is very little in the way of genuinely sensitive data I can imagine them having. So little commerce is done on Reddit that the risk of there being hundreds of thousands of CC numbers and home addresses is almost nil. User passwords? Half of Reddit is creating burner accounts every 3 months to dodge suspensions and bans.
- el_nahual 3y agoA usernames -> hashed ip table would be enough to doxx anyone that accessed both burners and pseudonymous accounts from the same computer.
- 100721 3y agoI understand what you're trying to say. However, this is not technically correct, and people who are not technically inclined may believe this to be correct. The truth is that you can use the same computer across many different networks, or even on the same network with a refreshed dynamic IP address, and such a table wouldn't allow the cross referencing you're suggesting. For a username -> ip address table to provide this functionality, the users would need to access the site from the same IP address, not the same computer. It's worth noting that the table would become polluted by things like public wifi, shared home internet, VPNs, etc. as well
- heavenlyblue 3y agoThere will be enough accounts where that statement would be true though.
- SnorkelTan 3y agoThere was a link posted a while ago on hn: https://stylometry.net/ https://stylometry.net/ Methods like stylometry make ip correlation largely unnecessary for finding alts.
- 3y ago
- lost_tourist 3y agoA lot of CS people use reddit including blackhat hackers, I was wondering if something like this might happen after reddit pisses them off by attacking their fellow CS people via going from beloved place to BS to a full capitalist menace.
- klipklop 3y agoHopefully we find out who the user “maxwellhill” really was. Can’t believe we never found out who one of the most influential Reddit users of time was.