8 ms·
Westfield’s San Francisco centre mall lost 46% of its stores since 2020
- andrewstuart 3y agoThey should remake “Escape from New York” in San Francisco.
- Ankaios 3y agoNobody's going to want to watch two hours of Snake Plissken searching around town for the President, only to find him sitting in a coffee shop eating avocado toast.
- balaji1 3y agoIKEA was supposed to open in SF. Somehow I thought it was supposed to be coming up in Westfield, but its somewhere else: https://sf.eater.com/2023/5/19/23729883/ikea-livat-mall-market-steet-food-hall-delayed https://sf.eater.com/2023/5/19/23729883/ikea-livat-mall-mark... Anyway, a big blow for SF to lose Westfield.
- vlovich123 3y agoIs it? I feel like it’s mostly tourist traffic. I don’t know if natives shop there all that much. In terms of revenue and tax basis maybe.
- 49erfangoniners 3y agoYeah this mall is terribl
- JoeyBananas 3y ago"Nobody wants to visit our town anymore because it is no longer worth visiting, but it's OK because that doesn't effect the locals."
- whalesalad 3y agoIKEA tenderloin? That is a horror movie and I need to see it.
- delfinom 3y agoI wonder if they'll be smart and not put fake toilets in the mockups....
- mc32 3y agoThey have to put something similar to pigeon spikes on all furniture which would kind of defeat the purpose of having floor samples. The only way this could work is if they charged people a refundable entrance fee of like $1000 or something. Otherwise I could see it turning into a squatted living space with druggies hanging out getting in the way of potential customers. Or posing health risks to customers (needles in cushions, unsanitary personal hygiene, etc.)
- simoncion 3y ago> The only way this could work is if they charged people a refundable entrance fee of like $1000 or something. I guess you'll be shocked to hear that shops with furnishings inside of them (including, but not limited to the Macy's department store) have been operating for decades without installing anti-homeless spikes on the floor samples, _or_ charging an entrance fee. Having a human posted at the entrance whose job is to bounce away hobos is (based on my personal, first-hand observations) more than sufficiently effective.
- mc32 3y agoNordstrom's is moving out, so is Anthropologie... but that's beside the point. IKEA's layouts are notoriously labyrinthine, the perfect kind where "associates" cannot scan to see what's going on a whole floor with a glance.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoYa, the IKEA near an art university in Beijing China used to have a problem with art students using it for nude photo shoots.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 3y agoGiving it 18 months before it gets shut down, but if it doesn't, I'd be curious to see how they pull it off.
- breadwinner 3y agoHow much of this is due to crime, versus WFH causing downtown to be less busy?
- rr808 3y ago13.4% due to crime, and 46.2% due to reduced traffic and 34.1% some combination and 6.3% unknown.
- abhayhegde 3y agoWhat's your source?
- estebank 3y agoLook at the previous to last chart at https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/westfield-charts-18148893.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/westfield-charts... That's a drop of foot traffic of more than half in the area.
- mlyle 3y agoThe problem is, this doesn't show causation. Obviously foot traffic is important to retail success, but retail success is important to vibrance. And crime is important to both retail success and foot traffic.
- dehrmann 3y agoThese are linked. Most of Downtown SF's desirability was you can work there and make a lot of money. When you could suddenly work other places for the same money, the main reason to go was gone. SF's pandemic policies exacerbated this by further driving certain people away from the city. Without office workers to put pressure on the city to keep the area safe-ish (or at least hide what's going on), the TL spread. And now, even if people return to the office, there's no reason for it to be in SF.
- givemeethekeys 3y agoThe area near the mall was pretty uninviting even before the guidelines to ignore theft under $1000 came into effect. Aggressive people high on drugs, exposed needles, and human feces were pretty much the norm, despite all the wealth that flowed into SF due to its growth. Everyone either was or personally knew at least one victim of a car break-in or bicycle theft. The government ignored all those issues because it didn't stop people from visiting SF, setting up businesses there and buying real estate there. Things got worse during the pandemic. City turned into a ghost town. The shoplifting went into high gear, and the density of tents around downtown went up even more. Still the city didn't do anything. I bet they thought, "oh, this pandemic will be over soon and all the working from home will end along with it".
- micromacrofoot 3y agohard to imagine any mall doing particularly well these days
- byhemechi 3y agoThey seem to be doing pretty well in Europe and Australia
- zmgsabst 3y agoAlso in Asia.
- zitsarethecure 3y agoOut here in the "new" hotness, Columbus Ohio, entire malls are not just losing stores, but shutting down. https://www.dispatch.com/story/news/local/2022/12/28/eastland-mall-in-columbus-ohio-to-close-this-week-ending-54-year-run/69762335007/ https://www.dispatch.com/story/news/local/2022/12/28/eastlan...
- tlogan 3y agoApperently, Westfield mall in Silicon Valley is doing very well: https://www.siliconvalley.com/2023/03/21/san-jose-westfield-valley-fair-retail-restaurant-covid-real-estate/amp/ https://www.siliconvalley.com/2023/03/21/san-jose-westfield-...
- tehrob 3y agoValley Fair is doing "well enough" to have customers pay for parking after 2 hours, and charging employees to park there as well at the rate of ~$10 a day.
- zgluck 3y agoMy first time in SF was when I attended JavaOne 2007, because Java was still kind of exciting back then. Did what I'm used to in new cities - walk in a random direction to find something interesting. Two minutes later I felt like I was in The Wire. In subsequent visits I didn't wander about. And then I hear that things have gotten worse....
- dehrmann 3y agoSomeone said the TL is basically Hamsterdam.
- canucker2016 3y agoTL=Tenderloin, right? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenderloin,_San_Francisco https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenderloin,_San_Francisco
- zgluck 3y agoYes, and that was indeed the area I wandered into.
- simoncion 3y agoAye, it totally is. And it has the benefits that were illustrated in the show. People are going to buy and sell drugs, sex, & etc. It's better to have that out in the open where police can keep an eye on and discourage violence.
- zgluck 3y ago> It's better to have that out in the open where police can keep an eye on and discourage violence. I didn't see any police presence there. Do you have any scientifically researched reason for this claim or is it just a hunch?
- simoncion 3y ago> I didn't see any police presence there. How long did you stick around? A few minutes? In my personal experience, as someone who has lived here for more than a decade, I see regular auto patrols going through the neighborhoods, as well as occasional foot patrols whose purpose seems to be to talk to some of the folks in the area and get a sense of what has been going on lately. This isn't shit you're going to see if you're just passing through... you've gotta stick around and pay attention.
- George83728 3y agoIn related news, an ABC reporter for Good Morning America recently revealed on air that he was told not to report live from the location of this mall because it wouldn't be safe. "But it is worth mentioning that we are not at Union Square or the Westfield Mall this morning because we have been advised it is simply too dangerous to be there at this hour"
- bbor 3y agoThat seems insane, it’s not a dangerous neighborhood?? Unhoused people are (sometimes) mentally ill, not murderers. And why would they attack a news crew?? Baseless fear mongering
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoNot to split hairs, but the murder of a pregnant (Asian) woman in Seattle’s Belltown by a mentally ill unhoused person indicates that they can be murderers as well. We are pretty shocked as a community, there is a protest going on right now actually.
- simoncion 3y agoAnyone can be a murderer, so yeah, I'd (respectfully) say that your rebuttal is splitting hairs.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoYes, the guy was well known to act violently but was mostly harmless until he wasn’t (the police dealt with him many times, but didn’t make an arrest until he killed someone p). This is the same area where that poor girl who worked at Amazon got her head bashed in a coupe of years ago by some crazy guy in supportive housing. The streets aren’t really safe these days, and it isn’t just “fear mongering”. Sorry, emotions are running pretty high right now. If you made this comment at her vigil, it wouldn’t have ended well I think.
- asylteltine 3y agoSF is simply a failed city. Anyone who supports it right now is delusional from living there or has never actually been there. I was there many years ago and felt unsafe with the literal tent encampments on a normal street, human feces everywhere, needles, etc. can’t imagine how bad it is now
- deviantbit 3y agoI was in SF two weeks ago, it had been about 5 years since I was there last. I can say I was shocked. I stayed at the Ritz Carlton, and there were homeless drug addicts out front around the clock. Not just one or two, but a lot. You could walk the sidewalk and more cars than you could count had the windows broken out of them from thieves. We had dinner at Brenda's French Soul Food where we witnessed an armed robbery. We called 911 a dozen times. The police never showed up. One in my party was told by the dispatcher unless there is an injury, they may not come. I'm not going back until this is fixed. I'm not sure how it gets fixed.
- cammikebrown 3y agoMarket Street is really bad. Tons of other areas of SF feel totally fine most of the time.
- deviantbit 3y agoI had no idea it was that bad. Why do people park down there if their windows are just going to get smashed in?
- nikanj 3y agoSF is big enough to have a steady supply of fresh out-of-towners
- seanp2k2 3y agoPartially because some of the lots in the area are flat-rate $30-50 and street parking is free or much much lower cost. IMO governments shouldn’t allow private companies to ruin parking downtown like this — cities need to operate their own parking garages with the same rates as street parking in my opinion.
- bbor 3y agoYou called 911 a dozen times? Why? Also “more cars than you could count” actively had broken windows? Not saying you’re lying, buttttt… that would be highly unusual. This comment reads like you googled SF from 2000mi away and brought up the hot topics
- panarky 3y ago25% of America's roughly 1,000 malls have closed over the last ten years. The pandemic accelerated a demise that was already underway. But it's fun to take a larger trend that's been happening for many years in many cities, and pretend it's a uniquely SF disease.
- MrBuddyCasino 3y ago„Hotel rates are up across the US, but not in San Francisco. The city's politicians can blame remote work & Covid all they want - but the numbers don't lie. San Francisco is uniquely in trouble - and it's due to policy decisions & poor leadership.“ https://twitter.com/michelletandler/status/1670069172976463872 https://twitter.com/michelletandler/status/16700691729764638...
- dehrmann 3y agoHere's a quote from another article: > In that same period, Westfield Valley Fair in San Jose has seen a 66% increase in sales, the company said.
- tdehnel 3y agoPlease knock it off. Your logic doesn’t even make sense. Covid happened everywhere, yet SF has had among the worst recoveries: https://www.cbsnews.com/amp/sanfrancisco/news/sf-covid-19-pandemic-recovery-among-worst-in-nation-bay-area-council-study/ https://www.cbsnews.com/amp/sanfrancisco/news/sf-covid-19-pa... In other parts of the country, they are actually building new malls. Go down to Palo Alto or San Jose, or even Stonestown. Those malls are thriving. https://montco.today/2023/01/triple-five-group-florida-king-of-prussia-mall/ https://montco.today/2023/01/triple-five-group-florida-king-...
- tssva 3y agoI live in the county with the highest median household income in the country. 3 out of 5 anchor store locations at the local mall sit empty and national retailers are continuously leaving. Some are being replaced by lower end stores which could never have afforded a mall location 10 or even 5 years ago, but many locations remain empty. The mall is slowly dying and the owner is looking to redevelop it.
- mnd999 3y agoIf you buy everything online, this is what happens. Maybe it’s what people want, maybe it’s unconscious.
- Animats 3y agoWestfield Mall lost business when Sony gave up on the Metreon and that was converted to a Target store in 2012. Target was just more useful, although rather bleak. Westfield has a Bloomingdales, which was mostly used as a walk-through route between the parking garage on Mission and the rest of the mall. Bloomingdales was a traditional downtown department store, with fine china and such, stuff nobody goes downtown to buy any more. Certainly not since the pandemic. "Designer clothing, shoes, handbags, and more" says their web site.
- nl_jaded 3y ago[flagged]
- canucker2016 3y agoArticle title is slightly misleading. Later in the article: "An analysis by The Standard shows that 45 stores, or 46% of the mall’s 97 pre-pandemic retailers, have closed since 2020. While 21 new stores have opened in the past three years." So -46 existing stores and +21 new stores for total of -25 stores (down about 25% from pre-pandemic). Losing Nordstrom doesn't help. The property managers are walking away from the mall, so there doesn't seem to be much confidence wrt profitability of the mall, esp. given rising interest rates.
- activiation 3y agoI've seen some malls around Atlanta with only a couple stores still open