5 ms·
15” MacBook Air Teardown
- manaskarekar 3y agoOff-topic - I love the fact that Apple takes care to make the insides look as nice as the outside. Everything from the layout to the boards looks so good.
- exitb 3y agoIt always looked good, but I’m honestly impressed how tetris-like their design has became. It truly feels like there’s no wasted volume in there. That being said, it’s all horrible from the repairability point of view.
- masklinn 3y agoApple is really inconsistent and more than a touch schizophrenic about this. The laptops get scores of 2~4 (the touchbar iterations were an amazing 1, you have to look for the Surface Laptop or an orange to get worse), meanwhile the iphone 14 debuted a new design which earned a 7.
- sudhirj 3y agoThey design to meet their internal (supply chain and exec decision) constraints and considerations. Sometimes those factors align with ifixit’s scores, but that’s more likely a coincidence.
- TMWNN 3y ago>Apple is really inconsistent and more than a touch schizophrenic about this. >The laptops get scores of 2~4 (the touchbar iterations were an amazing 1, you have to look for the Surface Laptop or an orange to get worse), meanwhile the iphone 14 debuted a new design which earned a 7. I'm more optimistic than sudhirj. There is a longstanding trend in Apple, going back to the Apple II versus Macintosh 128K, of alternating between open and sealed designs. As just one of many, many examples: The iBook G3 (not the clamshell)? Very sealed. iBook G4? Quite open, despite its exterior having very few changes.
- agumonkey 3y agoreminds me of some audiophile brands, the innards were so clean and symmetrical..
- ttfkam 3y agoDon't see how this is off-topic.
- kitsunesoba 3y agoIt's something they started focusing more on I want to say some point in the early-mid 2000s. The innards of the PowerMac G4 towers and PowerBook/iBook G4s weren't very nice looking, and the latter were an absolute nightmare to disassemble with 3x as many screws as seen in the video above. Where that changed was with the PowerMac G5 and iMac G5 on the desktop side of things and the unibody MacBooks on the portable side. The internals of the first couple revisions of 20" iMac G5 in particular were very nice both aesthetically and from a serviceability standpoint, which they unfortunately degraded with later revisions by making it necessary to remove the screen to access internals.
- nikau 3y agoThe early ibooks designs were outsourced, to asus I believe. I remember they were dangerous to repair as the screw lengths were all different and you could screw a long screw into a short hole which would cut into some pcb traces.
- kitsunesoba 3y agoInteresting, do you know if that applies to the fruit colored models or the later white ones? I disassembled a white iBook G4 ages ago and it was a real mess to take apart.
- nikau 3y agowas either the g3 or g4 ibook (my g3 was such a lemon it got replaced with a g4)
- 037 3y agoProbably you already know this, but it was a Steve Jobs thing: Growing up, Jobs once helped his father build a fence around their family home in Mountain View. While working, Paul shared a piece of advice with Jobs: “You’ve got to make the back of the fence, that nobody will see, just as good looking as the front of the fence. Even though nobody will see it, you will know, and that will show that you’re dedicated to making something perfect.” The idea stuck with Jobs. While at the helm of Apple, Jobs insisted that every element of the Macintosh computer be beautiful, down to the circuit boards inside. “Look at the memory chips. That’s ugly. The lines are too close together,” Jobs said of the circuits in Isaacson’s biography. […] https://www.cnbc.com/2018/05/10/how-steve-jobs-developed-his-design-philosophy-for-apple.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/05/10/how-steve-jobs-developed-his...
- ericpauley 3y agoWatching this video I just assumed the logic board removal was some aside, not necessary to replace the battery. Nope! Looking at their 13" guide this entire process is necessary to perform a battery replacement. Given everything else is solid state and will probably never fail it makes even less sense to block battery replacement behind them. The Air is an awesome device to use but wow... what a terrible design for battery replacement.
- chronicsonic 3y agoYeah bit strange with the future EU rules calling for user replaceable batteries.
- dagmx 3y agoThis would likely still pass muster under that ruling. They don’t specify that it has to be trivial, just that it has to be doable without specialty tools.
- woleium 3y ago... for replacement. Batteries have sensitive thermal requirements, so im sure there is a reason for the layout the wayy it is.
- nrp 3y agoThe reason is most likely just that there was no consideration in the design process for designing for serviceability. It’s surprisingly easy to design for repair without sacrificing other attributes if you include that in your design goals from the start.
- lozenge 3y agoOn what basis do you say easy to repair doesn't involve sacrificing other attributes? I've seen the Fairphone and it's a chunky one.
- woleium 3y agoEveryone loves to hate on Apple and their glue, but it's got to be hard to balance durability with repairability, especially at the volume that Apple ships.
- pzo 3y agoApple is not the biggest laptop producer - hp, lenovo, dell has been shipping each year more than apple. ThinkPads are actually durable and easily repairable and even upgradable and they sell much cheaper and with smaller margin. You would expect that apple with bigger R&D, bigger product price and much bigger margin would focus more on repairability by itself instead of waiting for EU to force it's hand.
- lozenge 3y agoTheir price and margin comes from the thinness, lightness and solidness, all of which reduce repairability.
- pzo 3y agoExcluding current m1 and m2 generations and going back 2-3 years back what did you get? Laptops that keyboards was breaking and to replace it you had to remove the whole top of laptop for like couple of hundreds of dollars. Hard drive soldered with price for 1TB around $1k with even backup port removed in case of failor. Battery glued. I used to have thinkpad x1 extreme gen 2 which price was $1.5k, 2x nmve slots, 2x removable ram up to 64gb ram. Battery removable with just a screws. Wifi module replaceable and could be upgraded. Display could be replaced and upgraded. Durable case from carbon fiber. Solid keyboard with even track point. And was still very lightweight - because carbon case.
- kitsunesoba 3y agoAs someone who owns both a MacBook and a ThinkPad, while the construction of ThinkPads (at least "real" ThinkPads, not in-brand-only models) is solid they often leave something desired in terms of case flex. I'm comfortable holding my 16" M1 Max MBP by its corner while it's open because it doesn't flex at all, while I'm more nervous doing that with my X1 Nano despite it being much more lightweight.