10 ms·
They’re gonna be left with bottom of the barrel mods. It’s a thankless task to begin with - a marginal proposition at best. Add some threats as a thank you for
by Havoc 3y ago
They’re gonna be left with bottom of the barrel mods. It’s a thankless task to begin with - a marginal proposition at best. Add some threats as a thank you for the unpaid work and it becomes downright abusive
Who the hell is going to want to mod in that context?
- swalsh 3y ago[flagged]
- colpabar 3y agocan't wait to see u/BrooklynDadDefiant as the new powermod of the top 500 subs
- yieldcrv 3y agoMods that were pushed out by other mods in the past People with vendettas and power vacuum opportunists People that want a different narrative on a subreddit There are tons of people that have other causes and interests than API tooling or company drama You know, this is all quite ignorable
- slipheen 3y agoThat's not exactly a list of people who are likely to do a good job. I think that's part of Reddit's problem - They can replace the mods with random people if they want, but the likelihood that those people will put in the work and do a good job is not high.
- yieldcrv 3y ago> That's not exactly a list of people who are likely to do a good job. based on what? is the control group the current mods because that's already a laughable set of people. there is no criteria before and there will be no criteria after.
- stcroixx 3y agoYou forgot people that don't want any narrative and would prefer to see all the content as long as it doesn't violate site wide rules.
- revscat 3y agoThis was my thought as well. To answer your question, though, I imagine bad faith actors of various flavors will be flocking the site: 1. Corporate marketing departments 2. Unpopular political/religious factions seeking to surreptitiously "move the needle" 3. Those who wanted to become mods before but didn't make the cut for completely valid reasons. Now they have an opportunity, only the quality will decrease as a result
- civilitty 3y agoFinally, I can fulfill my destiny of taking over r/television and banning anyone who says anything positive about a show with a laugh track. It should never have been allowed to begin with.
- mountainb 3y agoI support you in your quest.
- zzzeek 3y agosame, but for r/music for praising songs that have fade out endings
- sickcodebruh 3y agoAdd drum mixes panned from the audience perspective instead of drummer perspective and you’ve got my vote.
- alexjplant 3y agoI always mix audience perspective because I usually stand in front of the drum kit when I see bands live. Do most people stand behind them? Am I doing something wrong?
- relaxing 3y agoI'm assuming OP is themselves a drummer.
- anthonypasq 3y agoeveryone always says this yet getting a mod to relinquish their position is nearly impossible. Reddit mods desperately want to be mods and will do everything in their power to hold on to it. I know its a stereotype, but for many it is literally the only semblance of power/control they have over their life.
- Havoc 3y ago>everyone always says this yet getting a mod to relinquish their position is nearly impossible. There are certainly those, but not sure it is accurate to generalize to mods as a whole.
- TMWNN 3y ago> There are certainly those, but not sure it is accurate to generalize to mods as a whole. There are powermods who "moderate" hundreds of subreddits. This is not an exaggeration. Hundreds. When questioned, they invariably say that they "just watch the incoming queue" or something, and the other mods "do all the work". While likely true in the literal sense (again, hundreds), such answers of course completely evade of the question.
- TMWNN 3y ago>Reddit mods desperately want to be mods and will do everything in their power to hold on to it. I know its a stereotype, but for many it is literally the only semblance of power/control they have over their life. Remember, "Most of What You Read on the Internet is Written by Insane People". <https://np.reddit.com/r/slatestarcodex/comments/9rvroo/most_of_what_you_read_on_the_internet_is_written/ https://np.reddit.com/r/slatestarcodex/comments/9rvroo/most_...>. This also applies to powermods, assuming they're not being paid on the side to push some ideology.
- SanderNL 3y agoWouldn’t a properly prompted LLM be an OK mod?
- SSLy 3y agoIt would, but spez doesn't have OPEX for the GPU hours it'd require. Both for fine-tuning for per-subreddit rules, and running the model itself.
- HWR_14 3y agoI don't see why he wouldn't. Top of the line hardware is in the tens-of-thousands of dollars. He should have the OPEX-budget to buy enough cards to distort the market.
- ribosometronome 3y agoI wonder what dang thinks about that for HN? I'm not sure how you would properly prompted LLM change moderating standards based on community feedback? Sticky threads for popular topics? Have the understanding of things like local politics or a newly released game in 2023 to be able to separate out bad faith discussion from real? Reddit isn't twitter where the main thing the mods do is remove abusive replies. They're community crafters and maintainers.
- SanderNL 3y agoAlright, I see. Reddit is not my thing, but I can see how this gets complex (and costly) fast.
- seanhunter 3y agoMy understanding is Reddit the company actually already uses openai's moderation api[1]. Not sure they expose that to anyone (even mods) outside the company. It's not an LLM I don't think though, it's just a set of classifiers to give a probability that something violates various categories of their TOS. [1] https://platform.openai.com/docs/guides/moderation https://platform.openai.com/docs/guides/moderation
- hbn 3y agoI have a feeling they won't have a hard time finding deranged weirdos who want to mod and will remove anything that could in any way raise an eyebrow of advertisers/payment processors/etc The worst mods for the community will be the best mods for reddit's bottom line. The power-tripping is payment in itself for those types.
- ramesh31 3y ago>The power-tripping is payment in itself for those types. As if the current mods are any different? Honestly I don't mind this at all. The big subreddits have become so ossified in their power structures, that each community is its' own little fiefdom now. There is massive friction to being able to post anywhere. Reddit would be objectively better with a less heavy handed approach to moderation, and some kind of site-wide formal appeals process that neuters the ability of any individual mod from going on a power trip.
- LordDragonfang 3y ago>There is massive friction to being able to post anywhere. Reddit would be objectively better with a less heavy handed approach to moderation Whenever I see this sentiment I'm honestly stumped as to how anyone's experience can be so different from mine. What exactly is it that you're trying to post that's so difficult? because from what I see in nearly every sub, they'd be improved by more moderation, since nearly all of them get stuffed with off-topic and low-effort content, often actively breaking the community rules in the sidebar.
- ipaddr 3y agoDifferent subs have different rules and different formats on what they expect. Casually posting as you would in one thread might get you banned in another. Here is a good example. As a new user signed up for an account and posted in a sub got a lot of replies but didn't come back for a few months. Tried replying and was forbidden because of low karma points. Never came back.. The reason why you as a long term reddit user are stumped is because your experience is different.
- doxeddaily 3y ago[flagged]
- JohnMakin 3y agoYea this is a surefire way to end up with greedy, power-hungry moderators that have no interest in making the community better.
- ahepp 3y agoIf mods on Reddit really believed they were irreplaceable, wouldn’t it make more sense to protest by quitting?
- rpearl 3y agoBut that's not why the protest is happening...?
- revscat 3y agoNo one is claiming to be irreplaceable, although if you have evidence to the contrary you're welcome to provide it.
- Havoc 3y ago>If mods on Reddit really believed they were irreplaceable I was going more for "very hard, especially in bulk and on short notice" than irreplaceable there. >wouldn’t it make more sense to protest by quitting? Already did a while back...used to mod some big-ish subs. Going private seems like a reasonable intermediate step though. A bit like workers holding a strike instead of straight to mass resignation
- bnralt 3y ago8 years ago a bunch of Reddits went dark to protest the firing of Victoria Taylor. The AMA sub claimed that they wouldn't be able to continue without Victoria's help. Eventually the sub opened back up and things continued as they had before; the average user noticed no difference. If you told people today that Reddit AMA's hadn't been working for the past 8 years because the company fired an employee then, they'd probably laugh.
- sharkweek 3y agoI still use Reddit and I get that beloved people get fired for any number of reasons, but AMAs have been noticeably worse since Victoria’s time running them. I actually can’t think of more than a handful of examples of great AMAs the last few years. At one point it was a press stop for almost anyone famous doing a tour, and that doesn’t seem to be true anymore.
- a2tech 3y agoActually this is a great example of wht they're going to get. AMA's used to be a GREAT use of Reddit when Victoria ran them. The questions were fresh and it was a very broad pool of people they interviewed. Since then they've either been 1) terrible 2) obviously pimping something or 3) a combination of both. They're not even worth reading and I stopped looking at them years ago.
- mlyle 3y agoI agree. I thought they'd be able to replace Victoria and it'd be no issue. But the magic of AMA, part of what drew me to reddit in the first place, was gone. I scarcely look at them now.
- sharkweek 3y agoYeah Victoria did a good job queueing up a high quality experience for readers and the AMA participant when celebrities did do their press tours. My guess is she trained the guests less familiar with Reddit on how to have a successful AMA (e.g., “don’t be Woody Harrelson”). And because they were so successful, publicists were probably more willing to allow them to happen.
- searealist 3y agoLot's of people would love to take over as the new mods. The current mods aren't quiting for a reason, they enjoy it.
- belter 3y agoSomebody told them AI can do it?
- bytesizedbitch 3y agoI used to moderate a support subreddit, we eventually moved to Discord and encouraged everyone to move there as well. Behaviour such as only supports our move.
- Siecje 3y agoI wish Discords were discoverable. Why do I need so many members to show up when search for servers? That means I need to have a community somewhere else.
- sophwood 3y agohttps://disboard.org/ https://disboard.org/
- nerdix 3y agoIronically, discord doesn't support use of third party clients and you risk an account ban if you use one of the many unofficial clients.
- llbeansandrice 3y agoIt’s obviously not really about the ability to use 3rd party clients. It’s because of the sudden change and the official app being flaming garbage. This wouldn’t be an issue at all if the official reddit app was even half as good as the worst of the 3rd party clients and reddit actually providing parity in mod tools across their own clients. I have to go to new reddit to do multiple mod actions.
- vicktour 3y agoI despise Discord, but Discord's app works well. Its kind of like the Yin to Reddit's UI Yang.
- nerdix 3y agoSome people don't like that its electron. And its fairly crappy on Linux if you use Wayland.
- jedberg 3y agoThe /r/science mods are all coming back on Monday, a decision they made a few days ago, before any threats were made. They are worried that if they got replaced, it would be with people who would destroy the community they worked so hard to build. I suspect a lot of communities, especially the smaller ones, feel the same way.
- jamaicahest 3y agoAnd thus, Reddit holds all the power. If the mods are so attached to their community, that Reddit can dictate whatever terms they want, then the mods have no leverage.
- Havoc 3y agoOn the one hand I can understand it...but also that is such a feeble stance. Mods that feel that strongly about protecting their community would do so much better in a federated context.
- fnovd 3y agoFederation works for Twitter, it doesn't work for Reddit. If my Mastodon instance federates with yours, I can see your posts, you can see mine, we're fully merged. If my lemmy instance federates with yours, we can browse each other's communities, but those communities themselves don't merge. The userbase merges but the communities do not, and the community is the base unit that gives Reddit value. Federated Reddits will never take off for this reason. You either have a bunch of fractured communities that are all worse because there is no network effect, or you have one instance (or one community) absorb all the traffic and become its own centralized fiefdom.
- calf 3y agoThat's actually bottom of the barrel reasoning in my book, to cave to the admins because Reddit admins would punish you. It's psychologically unhealthy, any therapist would tell you that.
- haunter 3y ago/r/science was already thrash too so biased it hurts, might as well be /r/politics2. Honestly nothing value would be lost with that sub. Current front page: >A new study has found that both Christian nationalism and biblical literalism are associated with a greater tendency to believe in conspiracy theories >Being female, liberal, intellectually humble, and having weak party identification are all positively associated with writing more persuasive political arguments >When house prices increase, homeowners are likely to strengthen their belief in meritocracy
- xyst 3y agoReddit management is delusional. The IPO money is blinding them. I really hope a mass migration to lemmy instances really sticks.
- aeternum 3y agoPeople want power, why wouldn't you want to be a mod of a popular subreddit?
- seydor 3y agoEveryone. They are not asking a lot, just don't shut down the site in a hissy fit
- tbatchelli 3y agoMaybe we'll have paid mods, but not paid by Reddit, but paid with people and organizations with money, an agenda, and some societal changes in mind.
- galuvian 3y agoI'm pretty sure that's already happening in some cases, and not for the good of society.
- avereveard 3y agodo you have any evidence backing the statement that moderation quality correlates with sub closure?
- Havoc 3y ago> do you have any evidence backing the statement that moderation quality correlates with sub closure? I made no such statement.
- avereveard 3y ago> They’re gonna be left with bottom of the barrel mods. sorry for pharaprasing. do you have any evidence that there is a negative correlation between 'bottom of the barrel mods' and 'mods that are going to be outsted by the message about subs having be made private?'
- fluidcruft 3y agoDoes reddit care? Free labor that doesn't complain costs less.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- marcusverus 3y agoBased on a quick google search, only .004% of Reddit users are mods. I find it difficult to believe that reddit will have a hard time finding competent mods within the remaining 99.996% of its userbase.
- munificent 3y agoCounter-argument: 99.996% of Reddit users apparently don't want to be moderators or they already would be, so finding more will be very hard.
- jdminhbg 3y agoI really don't think that's the case. If you want to mod r/politics, you don't just raise your hand and then get mod powers. Moderators are a closed group.
- munificent 3y agoYou can create your own subreddit and be the sole moderator of it in about sixty seconds of effort.
- jdminhbg 3y agoSure. But that doesn't really have any bearing on whether Reddit can find volunteers to take over big subs.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 3y agoThis sounds distinctly different from one raising their proverbial hand to gain moderator powers on one of the most popular subreddits on the site. How many non-moderator users don't care about moderating a subreddit with 1 user but do care about moderating a subreddit with 1M users?
- munificent 3y agoIf someone wouldn't be willing to start and grow their own subreddit, should they really be entrusted with the keys to a big one?
- hackinthebochs 3y ago>Who the hell is going to want to mod in that context? Who would want to instantly have status over millions of people? Hmm, that's a hard one...
- irthomasthomas 3y ago/r/programming was predicted to remain open during the strike, due to it being modded by Reddit admins. But they also went dark when the top post was collecting examples of chatgpt generated anti-protest comments. https://web.archive.org/web/20230612074029/https://old.reddit.com/r/programming/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230612074029/https://old.reddi...
- TX81Z 3y agoI always savor the moment when people discover they are being led by morons.
- ilyt 3y agoPretty much, essentially ones that will be left are ones wanting the power rather than good of their community
- TX81Z 3y ago[flagged]
- winternett 3y agoEver since most of these social sites launched their advertising portals, moderation has basically become a practice in how to creatively subvert non-paying posters anyway. These sites need to ensure they deliver on numbers represented to paid advertisers, and now it's pretty much the only way to make it to top rankings, so how much one is willing to pay determines what's on the front page more than anything else now. The corporate mods are the ones that prevent harmful and deceptive things from staying at the top of the front page I bet, and they're not likely to be regular mod roles any time soon due to the power wielded. These massive social media sites all get corrupted after a while and then can never manage to come back. This may well be that point for Reddit.
- fho 3y agoIf I were reddit I would probably think "LLMs will moderate just fine".
- P_I_Staker 3y agoSo the mods will stay the same. Got it!
- nickfromseattle 3y ago> They’re gonna be left with bottom of the barrel mods. There are surprisingly few mods for how much engagement the subreddits have. There has to be mods that are just as good as the current batch, but haven't had a chance to shine. This of course assumes the selection process is built to identify and promote mods that are as good, or better than the old mods. Question for HN: If you were the Reddit admins, how would run the moderator selection process to get a great crew?
- stefantalpalaru 3y ago[dead]
- michaelcampbell 3y ago> Who the hell is going to want to mod in that context? The same type of people who want to be on the boards of HOA's. eg: the ones you least want doing it.