11 ms·
Afraid of Your Child's Math Textbook? You Should Be.
- kiba 15y agoOne might thought that people incremental revise previous editions rather than publishing whole new content, but it doesn't seem to be the case. At that point, we might as well just use khanacademy math lecture and show them according to a teacher's lesson plan.
- droithomme 15y agoIn most states math education is completely fad driven. Textbook selection committees are usually staffed with people who do not understand the subject, and when domain experts are asked to donate their time to evaluate materials, their feedback is ignored as the only purpose of having them aboard was to apply to the dog and pony show evaluation proceedings a sheen of legitimacy. Textbook publishers spend millions each year wining and dining members of committees, providing them with gifts and trips and sometimes even setting them up with speaking fees that are a masked form of bribery and kickbacks. It's a well known problem and has been going on for decades. It's very similar to the way the pharmaceutical rep industry works. I strongly recommend everyone read "Judging Books by Their Covers" by Richard Feynman for his experience in the process, which remains the standard modus operandi to this day: http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm As the editor's postscript to that article summarizes: "As a rule, however, state agencies don't want legitimate evaluations of the textbooks that publishers submit for adoption, because the agencies are allied with the publishers. The adoption proceedings staged by these agencies are not designed to help school districts, to protect students, or to serve the interests of taxpayers. Rather, they are designed to serve the interests of the publishers, to generate approvals and certifications for the publishers' books, and to help the publishers sell those books to local schools." These dynamics are part of why I strongly oppose calls for national standardization, the streamlining and centralization of would lead to a much larger and more difficult to combat corruption as greasy palm edu-bureaucrats rake in the dough for selling out the country.
- r00fus 15y agoFad driven, or politics/corruption driven? The textbook "industry" is one of the most pernicious, that really should be put out of business... in today's world, even if we were doing dead-tree based knowledge devices, they could be tailored to the individual and printed on demand. Of course, things like tablet-based (eInk or LCD) reading and khan academy are the future of learning.
- droithomme 15y agoThere's two separate phenomenon. Pedagogical approaches follow fads rather than solid principles known to work. Textbook selection is corrupt. Both are problems that have not been solved at least since Feynman's experience in the 1960s despite much effort and an awareness of the problem.
- tokenadult 15y agoEarlier Hacker News submission about teachers in Minnesota writing their own textbook to state curriculum standards, by forking an appropriately licensed online textbook series: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3203857 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3203857
- greenyoda 15y agoThe link to that newspaper article says "story no longer available".
- tokenadult 15y agoThanks for letting me know. This http://minnesota.publicradio.org/display/web/2011/11/06/online-textbooks/ http://minnesota.publicradio.org/display/web/2011/11/06/onli... appears to be a working link, from a website better about keeping links alive, to the same AP news story.
- spindritf 15y ago> That math homework you're trying to help your child muddle through might include problems with no possible solution. It could be that key information or steps are missing, that the problem involves a concept your child hasn’t yet been introduced to, or that the math problem is structurally unsound for a host of other reasons. That sounds an awful lot like reality. Not that I think it's a great way to teach maths (though maybe it is a great way to teach problem solving) but an educated adult should have little trouble spotting the missing information or contradictions and either guessing, pointing out, or assuming them away. I realize that it wasn't intentional on the part of the authors (neither are real problems), and that it's not the point of the article but merely a hook.
- gatlin 15y agoOpen-ended questions and problems are awesome. However, typically book work is intended to be rote practice of an algorithm. Already it is not a simulation of the real world - typically the real world open ended problems are cross-disciplinary and much larger in scope than a context-free simple arithmetic algorithm. That is not the point of book work, and when students go in expecting problems to be internally consistent, sound, solvable, and to behave the way the teacher told them, it can hamper learning as they have had the proverbial rug pulled.
- spindritf 15y ago> However, typically book work is intended to be rote practice of an algorithm. I see your point, I see the article's point and you're both right -- a maths textbook probably shouldn't look like that. It's a mistake, an oversight, a bug, and, as someone noted in the comments, it would be great if books were being improved instead of written anew every few years. It's why I can run the most current Linux kernel and actually have a better experience than with a stable one -- it was improved, not rewritten. What I didn't like was this idea that a parent could be scared because of some imperfection in the way a homework problem is framed, pandering to this light version of maths anxiety many people seem to have that actually prevents them from learning maths. If the problem is poorly stated, reframe it, point out the problem, guess or find the missing information, assume whatever needs to be assumed to get some sort of workable solution (which you can then improve upon :) There is no reason to panic, be afraid, or even really bothered by that. Again, I know, it was just a hook but it bothered me enough to post these two comments.
- Tycho 15y agoWhy do we need more maths textbooks in the first place? I can't imagine there's new branches of maths that we need to teach school kids about. (and same goes for a lot of other subjects)
- mceachen 15y agoAt least in California, it's due to our state-mandated course curricula being a continuously moving target. I was a software engineer at an educational software startup, and we were continually "course correcting" to meet these mandates (and yes, they did seem arbitrary and "change for change sake").
- yummyfajitas 15y agoWe don't. In my sophomore year of college, I discovered there were massive price disparities between old and new textbooks. Thermodynamics, 1'st edition (~1970) - $10, Thermodynamics, 7'th edition (~2000) - $120. I used the old editions, and it didn't hurt me much (I lost a few points due to renumbering of homework problems). All they did was renumber the chapters and problems, no new material was added, most of the time the text was identical.
- mceachen 15y agoThis is true for college textbooks. Not so for K-12 textbooks. In this space, wholesale churn is rampant. Math series only have a several year shelf life, before old-and-broken is replaced with new-hotness. My wife and mother and sisters are all elementary school teachers, and they haven't ever stayed with a math series for more than 5 years. In our district, they are required to change them every 7. K-12 level mathematics, compared to college level curricula, is much more "how" to teach than "what" to teach, and much more subjective. There were knock-down drag-out fights about the use of math manipulatives (which is the use of physical elements to show arithmetic operations).
- yummyfajitas 15y agoSo basically, we need new textbooks because the law demands change for it's own sake. Good to know what the real problem is. But why is the author of the submission complaining about textbook publishers rather than state legislatures and school administrators?
- meemo 15y agoI was the only person my cousin could turn to for help when he was taking math in high school. When he asked me for help, my first instinct was to help him find the relevant information in his textbook. But the textbook wasn't helpful at all. First, he was often working with things that weren't indexed; even though his homework was from the textbook's supplemental materials. Then, the text was hard to understand. It just wasn't written very well. Finally, the whole thing was just too busy, with many different fonts, all sorts of margin notes, many footnotes, and colored boxes surrounding text. This made finding information harder and just gave me a headache.
- MBCook 15y agoI had the same experience. My little sister just finished HS a year or two ago, and I helped her with her homework quite a few times. The books were useless. It was nearly impossible to find concepts in it, and when you did the description was often relatively short, relying on an example that was often poorly constructed. In the end, if the book didn't jog my memory I would have to Google the concept to find a better page. The book might as well have been nothing but problem sets. I never met any of her teachers. I got the impression that at least one of them wasn't qualified to teach math, but that was 2nd hand information through the lens of my sister, so I can't be sure how accurate it was.
- mceachen 15y agoI've seen the horribleness of my children's text books, and completely agree that they are not-good. But now what? Who should we be talking to who can affect change?
- autarch 15y agoIn the US, there's usually a local school board for the city that's in charge of buying textbooks. Of course, there's a lot of different factors that they have to account for, like state and federal standards, as well as the limitations of their own budgets.
- gmichnikov 15y agoI don't think change in this area is going to come from within (unless the reason for change is financial). If/when it happens, I think it will be the result of external pressure that comes from things like Khan Academy and open-source textbooks proving themselves to be better than paid textbooks. I've thought about working on a free site to help parents/students locate the best free online math resource that can help them with a specific question, worksheet, homework assignment, etc. As a tutor, I've frequently heard from parents that they know these types of things exist on the internet, but that they have no clue how to find the right Khan video that will help with tonight's homework. If anyone is interested in this sort of thing, please get in touch.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 15y agoI met a 10 year old child with Asperger's[1] who was trying to do some math homework. The book was wrong; they hadn't labelled a diagram but were asking for those labels in the answers. Maybe some children would have worked out to create their own key or to write in the book, but this boy just stopped. An activity that he's good[2] at, that he enjoys, is being slowly poisoned by poor quality materials. It's not just math books either. Where's the Feynman quote about the horse evolution? [1] Proper diagnosis from a set of real doctors. [2] Got a scholarship to a decent school partly based on his math ability.
- joelhooks 15y agoMy kids don't go to school, but we use the Saxon books for math here at home. They are so well put together. Incremental development. Enough consistent repetition of core concepts. All lessons back reference the fundamentals/foundations with a simple indexing system.
- joshkaufman 15y agoDo you use the original or homeschool edition? I'm planning to pick up a set soon.
- joelhooks 15y agoI always order the homeschool set, but I believe the actual textbook is the same. We just get tests/answers.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- nthj 15y agoAs a homeschool graduate who used Saxon through high school, I agree with your assessment. The one issue I took with Saxon is that the original example problems when introducing a new concept were too easy. I was able to grok how to solve the problems for the first 5-10 lessons, without actually understanding the principles behind them. When the problems grew harder and actually required applying the concepts, I'd have to backtrack a couple of weeks. A bit of a bugger, but all in all I liked Saxon a lot.
- pnathan 15y agoI thought Saxon badly needed to be broken apart into discrete subjects and accelerated. Other than that, it wasn't bad. Certainly parsecs ahead of the public school texts I saw at the time.
- droithomme 15y agoIt's silly to have churn in the publishing market with ever new approaches, all of which are known to be less effective than proven methods of learning math that have been known for hundreds of years. Just use the Singapore Math series for K-6 and be done with it. Sound pedagogy, known to work, has been debugged, no frivolous cutting edge theories from M.Eds who have never taught math successfully.
- Angostura 15y ago> all of which are known to be less effective than proven methods of learning math that have been known for hundreds of years. [Citation needed]. The methods my kids currently use, seem more effective that the ones I used at school. I am in my late 40s. edit: I'm based in the UK, however.
- droithomme 15y ago1. My personal experience as a teacher. 2. The average state of math knowledge of contemporary american high school graduates, coupled with statistics on needed remedial education for college entrants with high school diplomas. Teaching math is easy. I can teach any kid math. It's not a problem at all because we know how to do it. Many countries do it successfully. Observing what schools are doing, the textbooks, the approaches, and the level of math competency of elementary school teachers completely explains what is going wrong. It's not a mystery. Also explains why kids homeschooled by parents, even parents who were high school drop outs, end up with considerably better math skills than most public school graduates, and even many private school graduates. Typical high school graduates don't understand fractions, percentages or decimals. They can't do division. They don't understand algebra at all. We know this is true because of college placement tests. This is absurd. 100% of high school graduates should have passed differential and integral calculus. That should be the minimal acceptable standard. That it is not, and that graduates fail at even moderate arithmetic skills, shows the complete failure of the system. Downvote all you want while shouting "the dedicated teachers are not the problem, the students and their parents are!" That won't change a thing. Meanwhile, those who utilize proven approaches succeed and those who make excuses and follow fads fail.
- swang 15y agoCorruption in the "Text Book" industry is not new. Some of you may have read the article written by Richard Feynman about his experience reviewing math textbooks for California... in 1964. http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm
- joejohnson 15y agoOne math exercise in a chapter I was assigned called for students to use a math formula to calculate their level of attractiveness, using a mathematical ratio of 1:1.618 (otherwise known as phi or divine proportion), a formula scientists have devised to set standards of beauty. Math can be tough enough for some kids without having to learn that, on top of struggling to apply math formulas to their face, they are also inherently unattractive. Talk about installing math phobia! First, I think he meant instilling math phobia. And second, this "golden ration == attractiveness" myth is un-scientific and an urban legend perpetuated by Dan Brown and similar authors.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- edtechdev 15y agoThis guy knows a lot about the textbook industry, but I'm not sure he knows much about teaching and learning. How you design texts can make a difference (google "conceptual change texts" for example), but how much do textbooks really influence the quality of instruction? If a teacher is just blindly following a textbook (and not doing other things like supporting students, using interactive software, etc.), then there are bigger problems. Ironically, too, students would learn more from a textbook with mistakes in it if they were made aware of that fact and encouraged to find them. I know I learned the most in geometry where I had a teacher who couldn't even draw a circle and made mistakes every single day.
- vacri 15y agoOn the commission thing. one thing that's easy to overlook is that once an author has written the book, there's nothing more to do, in an ongoing day-to-day sense. Sit back and enjoy the royalties for years. Someone else does the selling, and the author's efforts don't scale with the number of sales. The salesperson has to sink effort into each sale, has to work it, or at the very least do the paperwork. Similarly the author gets royalties on all copies, but the salesperson only gets commission on the books they sell. A thousand books sold by four sales staff is 1000 books for royalty purposes, but only 250 books on average for commission purposes. There is some slight irony in assuming something is wrong with the number just because they don't appear superficially linearly correct, when criticising the quality of maths books...
- Luyt 15y agoSit back and enjoy the royalties for years. Apparently, that's not the case anymore for educational book writers. The article states: Today, royalties are a thing of the past for most writers and work-for-hire is the norm. ...and during the article this new state of affairs is mentioned quite a few times, and loathed.
- mattmcknight 15y agoI always find something a little ridiculous in these articles that blame the textbook for errors (or a statewide test), when the textbook has been through more review than an exercise that an individual teacher designs. That said, math textbooks are becoming an anachronism. Adaptive individualized content is already available up to high school level.
- rcthompson 15y agoDid you even read the article? The whole point is that the textbooks are written on an impossibly tight timeline by unqualified and underpaid writers and undergo little to no review, either by the publisher or the school districts buying them.
- mattmcknight 15y agoYour comment is not related to the subtext of my comment. The guy has an editor for his textbook contributions, but no editor for the material he gives his own class. Therefore, the textbook material gets more review than something he does on his own. To your point, if he is unqualified to write exercises for a textbook, he would also be unqualified to create these for his own class. If he is underpaid...that is largely irrelevant- if he were really underpaid, he wouldn't have taken the job. The article was of the anti-corporate bias perspective, which is why it was on Salon.com, that this is because of the "profit motive" of the publishers. However, that perspective is also nonsensical. The examples do not change that much from edition to edition- they are seldom created from whole cloth. Even in his tortured example of complaining about the golden ratio problem was one of textbook translation- pointing out that, as an author, he cared about things other than the effectiveness of the text. It is true that many textbooks are of low quality...but considering the bias of the writer, the whole article is a bit self-serving, while also being hypocritical. All points about the incompetence of textbook buyers stand though. They choose for the worst of reasons, with effectiveness almost never even on the table as a concept.
- rcthompson 15y agoI guess if you ever try to fix a problem by throwing money at it, there will always be someone there to intercept it. I think this has helped articulate for me exactly why "throwing money at a problem" is so bad: because it attracts the kind of people who chase after large sums of money, not the kind of people who fix problems. (People always deride others in debates and arguments for "throwing money at the problem", but they never stop to explain why it is a bad thing. Now I know.)
- nhaehnle 15y agoYou make a very good point. Although I would add that money does play an important role as well. The article mentions that qualified writers and educators are leaving the field because the pay is so ridiculously low. I suppose that what this shows is that simply "throwing money at the problem" is not a good thing. You have to throw money at people who are genuinely driven to solve the problem.
- rcthompson 15y agoYes the problem is when you "just" throw money at the problem without detailed oversight by someone who cares about the problem and can get the money to the right people.
- tsotha 15y agoHow much has grade school level math changed over the years? Do we really need new textbooks?
- WalterBright 15y agoLeft unexplained in the article is why math books need to be reinvented every year.